Great quality chairs (we ordered two sets). Super sturdy. We're very happy with them. The seat cushions are comfy. I would have rated it a five, but the screw hole in one of the chairs wasn't matching up with the screw so we had to leave the screw halfway installed. It doesn't seem to have compromised the integrity of the assembly, though time will tell. The assembly on the other three chairs were fine. I would definitely order these chairs again.