Practically perfect in every way! 
Ill keep it short and sweet... 
The rockers arrived super fast. Based on several reviews, I was concerned about the packaging being sub par. Not an issue. They were wrapped and cradled all snug in the box. Assembly was very easy, although I would recommend 2 people. 
I am so happy with these rockers! Just what I wanted! The quality of the wood and finish is really nice... Smooth no rough edges. 
My only frownie face is that the footrests, which tuck up underneath the seat, are a bit difficult to maneuver. If you pull them out before attempting to sit, its difficult to get in it without straddling the whole thing. (Im short, so theres that). If you sit and then attempt to pull the footrest out, it wont fully engage. Not an issue for me, as Im not going to sweat that. For others tho, it may be something to consider. 
I still give them 5 stars. Looking forward  to at least 5 tolerable days here in Florida to use them.