I think 3.5 stars is probably the better assessment of these chairs. Five stars for looks and comfort once assembled. Taking off a half star as I am not convinced the quality is going to hold up over time the finish seems like it is going to scratch easily and once that happens it will be rust central. Taking off a giant star for assembly. Use your own tools, the ones that come with it are terrible. Also, you'll need two people, one to do the assembling and one to keep the person assembling calm by chanting soothing words and bringing beers. At some point mid-assembly, you will seriously consider throwing the entire chair through a window. But once complete, you will sit in your cute new chair and think, eh, that wasn't so bad, I can assemble three more of these without going crazy. 

Pros: Good looking and comfortable
Cons: Obnoxious to assemble