I like these chairs a lot for my casual dining room. They feel pretty solid and are comfortable, plus they have that iconic Windsor styling I was looking for. My only complaint is that the finish on the seat varies. Some of my six chairs have a very smooth finish and some have a slightly rougher feel to them (they feel matte). I don't think it's too noticeable when just looking at them, but they definitely feel different if you run your hand over the surface.