I ordered 6 chairs. One of them came with a nick in the seat, and another came with a back that I couldn't attach because 2 out of 3 screws wouldn't catch. Wayfair is replacing both which is nice, but it's still kind of annoying that everything wasn't perfect out of the box. Overall, I like these chairs, but they aren't as nice as I wanted them to be and are a little creaky.

Updating this 2.5 years later: The seats to these chairs have yellowed over time. Bummer since buying 6 of them was a decent investment.