This pattern and material are a poor match for the original Williamsburg Garden Images, so the comforter would not work as a replacement. The colors are much darker and drabber than the original; for example, brown-burgundy for what was originally bright red, olive green for what was originally kelly green. The background "parchment" is tan, not ivory. The fabric is also much heavier than the original Waverly fabric. It would work for a New England winter, but not in a Virginia summer.