So far so good.  This was a replacement of a unit that failed.  We like not having any ice or water on the surface of the door and with this unit the ice is shaped the way that you'd expect cubed ice to be shaped...in a cube, versus the splinters of ice we got out of the other unit.  It is also great with grandkids, no handles for them to pull themselves up with.  Another plus is not having a ice maker taking up space in the refrig.