So far this is exactly what we thought it would be. We are using the top container for treats and bones and the bottom for food. I like the inner container lids and how they can snap up for easy access. It fits nicely off to the side of our kitchen nook and doesnt look cheap or like we should hide it in the pantry! I actually feel like the food scoop that came with it is unnecessary but a nice addition anyway. If I needed it, Id buy this again.