These Country Cottage 8.5" Salad plates are nice, but they are not all shaped exactly the same.  Our 42-plus-year-old set nested perfectly.  These seem to be out of round some or not completely flat.  It's not a deal killer, though, and we like the service for 12 we purchased.  The pattern is simple, the product seems useful.  But I had to remove a star because they're not quite as well-made as our old Corelle set.