I am giving it 5 stars but haven't used it yet, it needs to be seasoned and the process takes 2 days (because you have to do one step, and then wait and do the other the next day). For that reason, I'm not finding time to season it and start using it, BUT, the quality looks very good, it is heavy enough to be of decent quality, but not too heavy to be hard to handle, and it came in a beautiful box. If I face any issue after using it I'll update my review. Otherwise, if my review remains unchanged, it means it did deserve the 5 stars!