I really liked the stain, the size and the overall quality of the piece but it arrived with a very noticeable scratch in a very noticeable place.  The scratch was deep enough that it revealed some while color which of course made it stand out even more.  Yes I could have sent it back but the weight of the item coupled with trying to repackage it would have been a nightmare.  I am very happy that All Modern gave me a $25 credit, but there absolutely needs to be better quality control when buying and shipping furniture on line.  I may expect (and really shouldn't frankly) some defects when ordering from Target or some other discounter, but not here.