The colors were beautiful. Unfortunately one arrived defective and the replacement arrived damaged. I only gave 3 stars as the carpet wasn't as thick, or as soft as I hoped (personal preference), and the quality seemed to be lacking in the edge stitching and general manufacture for the price point. Oriental Weavers usually have quality carpets, so I was a little surprised and am chalking it up to a quality control person who must have called in sick that day. Wayfair customer service however, was excellent as usual.