So the low rating comes from a couple of things I didn't love about it. Number one, all the shelves have to be located at the bottom due to the pole construction. Each shelf does secure tightly and holds alot but the pole itself needs rubber ends to keep it from slipping, especially where it comes together with the tub. The spots where I thought I could hang my razors, is impossible to get a razor in and out of. And with a three year old, I'm not a hundred percent confident in it staying up, because of the spring and twist construction. It did replace two shower caddies, if it holds up.