I got the muted green rocker. It is perfect for my small frame and the nook I had for it. The wood in the arm cushions is squared off and the padding doesn't keep the edges from irritating the elbows. The rocker was a little ratchety on my wood floor and sluggish on a rug. I got some thick stick-on felt pads, 3.5 x 6", from WalMart and cut them lengthwise with a utility knife. Applied them to the entire bottom of each rocker. Now the rocking action is smooth and full in range. If the arm edges were smoother or better padded, I'd give the chair a 5 rating.