I got two of these for our home office about a week ago. They are quite comfortable and sturdy and accurate to the details listed here. Overall I'm quite satisfied with these and hopefully they hold up over time. One of the chairs was shipped to us with a small tear in the back mesh but the damage is minimal enough that I'm not bothering to return it. Hopefully I'm just unlucky but I'm rating this 4 stars because one was shipped with minor damage. Otherwise I'm very satisfied with these and would recommend them.