I like the set even more than I thought I would.  The color is warm and matches our other furniture which has a similar color (also Ashley).  The chairs are comfortable and a nice height to get onto and off of easily.  

Would have rated 5 stars but one of the chairs arrived wobbly; something they should have caught before it left the manufacturing floor.  We were able to fix it by applying a pad to the bottom of the shorter leg, but still, it should not have arrived uneven :-)