I would give the finished chair a 5 star, I really do love these chairs. The only reason I gave a 4 star was because they were so difficult to put together. I read all of the reviews beforehand and I wish I would’ve taken everyone else’s warning more seriously. Its assembly is going to prevent me from buying a chair I have to put together again. Although worth it in the end, be prepared to have an all day project of frustration putting these together! The manufacturer didn’t make it easy!