The first fixture I received arrived in a heavily damaged box and one side was bent as a result.  Upon notification, Wayfair promptly sent a replacement fixture.  The replacement fixture had two minor scratches but you can't see them from where the fixture is hanging so we kept it.  Aside from the damage, the fixture is exactly what I expected and I am pleased with the product.  This fixture is large and we had a large space to accommodate it so it's perfect. It is also very light weight which made installation easier than expected.