The first order of shelves arrived with numerous dings and damage although there was no damage to the boxes and each shelf was individually wrapped in plastic which also showed no damage so I have to assume they shelves were shipped out that way.  
I contacted Wayfair and they quickly replaced the damaged shelves.  The new shelves arrived without any significant damage and were installed.  They look great but the the finish is extremely delicate and even the slightest item sliding across the surface will leave a mark.  If you are using these for display only and won't be moving or adjusting items often they should work fine.