First I will say the shelves are a high quality wood and great value. I gave only 4 stars for 2 reasons. Out of the box they had a very strong odor of wood stain, so strong I’d recommend opening them outdoors. I allowed several days on the covered porch before bringing them in. Additionally I was annoyed by the fact that I had to download an app for installation instructions. I even contacted the manufacturers for a printed version to be emailed and they refused. I figured it out, but directions should come in the box in my opinion. Paint is SW Sea Salt. Hope this helps