I went with this product after doing research on several similar products, and this had the most consistency of positive reviews across websites. It went on easy and adhered well. It darkened the patio pavers slightly, but it has a nice look. I only did one coat, and the instructions say you need to apply a second coat 24 hours later for a wet look. So, one coat did not provide the wet look, which I'm fine with. The only reason I gave a 3 for "water resistance" is because I don't know yet. Hoping it holds up.