The cushion and material is fine on the two that arrived and they should get a five.  However, the wrong cushions were sent on the third, and getting the replacement has been extremely difficult and time consuming and I still don't have it.  I sent back the other cushions weeks ago so I don't understand why there is such difficulty.  I was not going to write a bad review because I like the cushions, but because the problem is still not resolved, it appears this is the only way to have anyone pay attention to it.