I absolutely love the color of these lamps however, when we unboxed them, one of the lamps had a rattle on the inside like something was loose.  The top spins around and around and the other top does not.  They both work and I did not want the hassle of returning them so I just kept them so that is the reason for the 3 starts.  If the one lamp did not have the loose part, I would give them 5 stars.