I’ve never had a Sherpa body pillow cover, but now that I have there is no going back! I bought this for my teenage daughter as she is a big cuddler (lol) but I’m going to steal this. It is SO soft and even though one tiny bit of the material came off, I still love it. To get this cover on the pillow with damaging either, I smooch’d the Sherpa cover at the bottom of the body pillow and then worked the cover down the pillow. Now to figure out how to ninja move it out of her room )