When we remodeled our kitchen there was a mirror and shelf just inside our back door.  Both  were made of wood and painted white, and had worked well for many years.  I had planned to give them a fresh coat of paint and reinstall them, though they also needed some patching and the shelf needed to be reinforced, Still we had not wanted to spend more money on an already expense remodel.  While looking for a bedroom mirror, I came across this one with the shelf attached, clean lines, a great smooth finish and, as a one piece unit, would be easier to hang than our old pieces.  Ready to hang and the price made it very affordable too AND it was delivered so quickly the wall paint had barely dried when we hung it!

Pros: Sturdy, easy to mount to the wall, great price.
Cons: Shelf is a bit narrow, but still a great key catcher.