The star arrived quickly and in fair condition. It was a little smaller than I expected, but that's a good thing - we have a very low clearance above the tree, and I was concerned that it wouldn't fit. 

I like the look of it, and it did work, but given that I didn't order until after Christmas we didn't bother actually putting it on the tree, just confirmed it was working. One problem with that: one of the points was not attached, and I wasn't able to get it into place. I will try again in December, but it isn't really a big deal - I can either tape it into place, or just put that side to the back. Not ideal, but not a major issue either, just enough to take off one star.
I looked for a long time to find the right tree topper, and I think we'll be very happy with this.