I don't know how to rate this nightstand. It is very attractive, but there were a few problems. There was a small but noticeable paint imperfection, and a staple holding the plastic leg support was improperly placed.  I wrote to Wayfair, and they immediately offered to replace the nightstand. The second one is perfect. If not for the original problems, I would probably rate the nightstand 4 stars. Wayfair, for their excellent service, easily gets 5 stars.