This rocking chair pad set seems sturdy enough and the color and thickness are adequate.  The cushions are smaller than I expected.  The rocker pictured must be a small one.  The oddest thing was that the cushions were thrown into an empty box without any tags from the manufacturer, no plastic wrap to keep it clean, and no packing slip.  Nothing about how this product was shipped or received gave the impression that is was new or packed with any sort of consideration at all.  Its almost like they are reselling returned merchandise that other customers opened and cut the tags from.  Is this why the exact same product from JC Penny was twice the price? Because theirs isn't used?