I really love this shelf and would have given it five stars, except the item came in a very damaged box, it had obviously been re-taped a couple of times and when I opened the box I expected the shelf to be quite damaged.  It only had a minor crack on one side of the back part where you hang it, and being that it's supposed to look weathered anyway it didn't make sense to return it.  This is the first time I've received an item with the packaging looking like it had been through a wrestling match.  Fortunately the item wasn't too damaged.  Better attention needs to be paid to packaging and sealing items, for sure.