I meannnn…. I'm not sure what you're looking for from a TP holder. I was kinda hoping for one that would make it as EASY AS HUMANLY POSSIBLE to change the toilet paper roll for EVERYONE in the house. While it performed no such feat, I do like it. The tray can be used to set down toy, phone, store flushable wipes, etc. Like it. If it had miraculously made everyone stop leaving the empty rolls for me, would have had 5 stars for SURE!! :)