Four stars, for a fantastic sofa. Its not perfect, but pretty close 4.5 stars. Its a little wider that it looks in the photos. Im 6'5" 240lbs and it fits me perfect.  For the money its about as good as it gets. It is firm, and sits three comfortably. I strongly recommend it, we get compliments by everyone who comes over. We purchased this with the matching sofa and for the money we couldn't be happier. 

Pros: Great Value, easy to assemble, comfortably firm, and looks like we paid a lot more for it.
Cons: Its a little lighter than it looks and can slide around a little