I would give them 4.5 if I could, because overall I really love them and the fabric quality is delicate but beautiful. The linen like weave is soft, and flows nicely, making them hang just about perfectly. I ordered plum, which is a muted ashy purple, not a bright reddish 'royal purple.' The color is just about exactly as it appeared on my monitor. The only thing I was disappointed in was that once hung with the window light flowing through, this collection is very nice where the white is moving into the purple, but the purple portion pretty much stays the same. I believe they could have compensated for this issue by making them a bit deeper purple towards the bottom. I'm going to be hanging them on a double rod with another white sheer behind them though, and I think that may help enhance the purple so this collection may continue down a bit further into the purple. I'll keep my fingers crossed on that, but still, I love them anyway.