Some came with broken corners. Very flexible (not rigid as they claim) and easy to chip. A few pieces had dents and on one piece the very thin top veneer was scratched off at the edge. The middle of a couple of the planks were dimpled/dented so I am worried that a piece of furniture setting on a plank will mar or dent it. The tiles don’t seem like they will really stay down well. Easy to pull up after placing down so that makes me think they are not very permanent.  (But to be fair, my subfloor is not totally even and has paint on it. They are right. Subfloor must be completely level!)