We got the one with the light top and really love it. Just what I have been looking for for months without success but much better than I had imagined for my purpose. 

Pros: Very well made. We are thrilled we found exactly what we needed & perfect size for our space. 
Cons: It does not have good instructions but my husband is an engineer which helped. The hint from another customer that the metal rods were not the same size was of immense help in getting it put together easily.