These don't have real tabs. The curtain "tabs" are actually thin thread that catches on the extension rod. They will not open and close smoothly on an extension rod. I don't know who would think this is a better option than a solid tab, but the listing photos only show the backing on a white curtain, so it is not evident by the listing photo. I don't think I can return these because Wayfair has connected me with the manufacturer rather than give an option to return. They were not made custom. The curtains shipped faster than the samples did.