Have not had these more than a few days but the packaging was fine and there was no damage upon arrival to any of the 4 we ordered.

Assembly on the first stool did take longer than expected due to the different sizes of bolts (5 I believe), washers (2) and lock washers (2), but after the first was done it was fine.  I used a ratchet to speed up the process rather than the provided allen wrenches. If you are handy it is not a big deal but a first timer may have some problems assembling, all depends on the person.

Stools are very comfortable and seem sturdy so far.  Each leg has an adjustable foot base to help if you have an uneven surface.  

Again, have only had them for a couple days and we will see how they hold up.  Definitely like them so far!

Pros: Comfortable and look good
Cons: Directions could be a bit more detailed