I'll start by saying I was very nervous to order these chairs online.  I read, re-read and then read the reviews again before I ordered FOUR for my hearth room.  I ordered the Devon Pewter fabric which is a very soft charcoal flannel.  The chairs are very nice and sturdy.  The swivel mechanism is solid, not loose at all.  They are slightly bigger than I anticipated but that's my fault. They are very comfortable.  Other reviews talked about the back pillow.  I don't think it appears lumpy in person.  I was concerned about bulky seams and the fabric not looking tight but in person they are great.