I have to admit this is my first Ice Cream Maker so I can't really compare but I just love that my KitchenAid Mixer can do so many things. It is such a staple in our household and we always recommend to everyone.  I also probably would not have bought another appliance just to make ice cream. This ice cream maker did not disappoint! Came with the high quality you would expect with kitchenaid. Beautiful product that made delicious ice cream! Now, we've just got to get more creative with recipes.