While the glass votives were as expected, the tray was made of extremely thin wood and was rough and unfinished. While this may be the 'rustic' vibe the designer wanted, I felt that the price of $80. CA warranted a better quality base for the votives. (I lightly sanded the piece, painted it with milk paint and finished it with a shiny sealer. Finished look was much better!) The ordering and delivery process from Wayfair was excellent, as usual!