Evaluating Text Creativity across Diverse Domains: A Dataset and Large
  Language Model Evaluator
Authors: name: Qian Cao; name: Xiting Wang; name: Yuzhuo Yuan; name: Yahui Liu; name: Fang Luo; name: Ruihua Song
Published: 2025-05-25 17:25:23

Abstract: Creativity evaluation remains a challenging frontier for large language
models (LLMs). Current evaluations heavily rely on inefficient and costly human
judgments, hindering progress in enhancing machine creativity. While automated
methods exist, ranging from psychological testing to heuristic- or
prompting-based approaches, they often lack generalizability or alignment with
human judgment. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose a novel
pairwise-comparison framework for assessing textual creativity, leveraging
shared contextual instructions to improve evaluation consistency. We introduce
CreataSet, a large-scale dataset with 100K+ human-level and 1M+ synthetic
creative instruction-response pairs spanning diverse open-domain tasks. Through
training on CreataSet, we develop an LLM-based evaluator named CrEval. CrEval
demonstrates remarkable superiority over existing methods in alignment with
human judgments. Experimental results underscore the indispensable significance
of integrating both human-generated and synthetic data in training highly
robust evaluators, and showcase the practical utility of CrEval in boosting the
creativity of LLMs. We will release all data, code, and models publicly soon to
support further research.