By the time the magazine hit newsstands, Simpson had already had her nose job, and some "Marie Claire" readers complained that this was hypocritical.
V sredi leta 2006 je revija "Marie Claire" objavila intervju z Ashlee Simpson, v katerem je Ashlee Simpson dejala, da "ima Hollywood zelo različen vidik o ženski lepoti" in da je ona sama pravzaprav del skupine nepriviligiranih deklet z šole v Los Angelesu, Green Dot Public School.