In 2005, Cyrus expanded his acting career in a stage production of "Annie Get Your Gun" in Toronto, appearing in the role of Frank Butler.
Imel je tudi manjšo vlogo v filmu Davida Lyncha iz leta 2001, "Mulholland Drive", kjer je igral Genea, čistilca bazenov, ki je imel afero z ženo Adama Kesherja (Justin Theroux).