Her successful role on "Beverly Hills, 90210" opened the door to several lead roles in made-for-TV films in the 1990s, including "Danielle Steel's Star" (1993), "Without Consent" (1994), "Lies of the Heart: The Story of Laurie Kellogg" (1994), "Falling for You" (1995), and "An Unfinished Affair" (1996).
Jennie Garth prikaže izjemno razumevanje do likovih vzponov in padcev in je upodobila Kelly na nežen način, zaradi česar je postala ena izmed najbolj razvitih in najpopularnejših likov v seriji.