Fan voting was reinstated in 1970 and has continued ever since, including Internet voting in recent years.
Tovrstno glasovanje je bilo začasno ukinjeno po škandalu leta 1957 v Cincinnatiju, ko je sedem od osmih izglasovanih igralcev bilo članov domače ekipe Cincinnati Reds (dva izmed njih sta kasneje zamenjala Willie Mays in Hank Aaron) .