"Beautiful Eyes" was later performed as part of Swift's set for Stripped on August 5, 2008; she wore a black, one-shoulder dress and performed with a back-up band while playing a rhinestoned acoustic guitar.
Prvič je s pesmijo »Beautiful Eyes« nastopila 23. januarja 2005 na NAMM Show iz leta 2005, letni glasbeni prireditvi v Anaheimu, Kalifornija v centru Anaheim Convention Center.