Their second offering, 'Insomniatic,' with this as the lead single seems to have kept the staccato and the venom but added more layers of pop, to create something that sounds like My Chemical Romance going through a blender with some soft-hearted Angry Girl Music.
Fraser McAlpine iz BBC Radio je napisal: »Prejšnji album Aly & AJ je bil rock-pop, pogosto v stilu jeznega popa, vendar še vedno zagotovo pop.