On December 3, 2010, Nielsen SoundScan reported that there had so far been 162,000 paid digital downloads of the song in the United States.
" je Melissa Ruggieri iz revije "Richmond Times-Dispatch" komentirala: »K sreči vsebuje tudi dve majhni najstniški uspešnici, vključno s pesmijo Britney Spears ('My Only Wish Year') in pesmijo glasbene skupine 'N Sync ('You Don't Have to Be Alone Christmas')«.