"Max Payne 2" was the recipient of several industry awards, including Outstanding Art Direction at the Golden Satellite Awards 2004; Editors' Choice Awards from "GamePro", IGN, GameSpy, and GameSpot; and Game of the Month from "Game Informer".
Игра получила несколько наград, в том числе «Outstanding Art Direction» на Golden Satellite Awards 2004; «Editors' Choice Awards» от GamePro, IGN, GameSpy, и GameSpot; и «Game of the Month» от Game Informer.