"When I Think of You" was the 32nd biggest Hot 100 single of 1986, as well as the 47th biggest Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs single of 1986 and the 22nd biggest Hot Dance Club Play single of 1986.
"When I Think of You" стал 32-м самым успешным синглом 1986 года в чарте Billboard Hot 100, 47-м - в Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs и 22-м в Hot Dance Club Play.