Those that appeared were praised by John Wilson in "Blackwood's Magazine" and the last of the three particularly by Sir James Stephen in the "Edinburgh Review" (April 1840).
Те работы, которые вышли в свет, хвалил Джон Уилсон в журнале Blackwood's Magazine, а последние три отметил сэр Джеймс Стивен в Edinburgh Review (апрель, 1840).