Other unidentified writers are often quoted throughout the Internet for many contradicting stories about Kalantiaw. (See: Postscript.) Some maintain that he was not only the third ruler of Panay, but that he was also the third in a dynasty of rulers named Kalantiaw. His father was not Rajah Gulah but King Kalantiaw I who captured the town of Batan in 1399 with Chinese adventurers.
May mga nagsasabing siya ay hindi lamang pangatlong pinuno ng Panay kundi pangatlo sa isang dinastiya ng mga haring may pangalang Kalantiaw. Ang ama niya, ayon sa iba, ay hindi si Rajah Gulah kundi si Haring Kalantiaw I, ang sumakop sa bayan ng Batan sa tulong ng mga Tsinong tulisan noong taong 1399.