It has turned out not to be based on correct physics because it assumed the effects were caused by reflection and refraction of light rather than being caused by the scattering of light as Thomson proposed.
Ito ay gagawing out hindi na batay sa tamang physics dahil ito assumed ang mga epekto ay dulot ng pagninilay-nilay at repraksyon ng ilaw sa halip na sanhi ng scattering ng ilaw bilang Thomson iminungkahi.