# 2014 Survey Results

Thanks to everyone who took the 2014 Less Wrong Census/Survey. Extra thanks to Ozy, who did a lot of the number crunching work.

This year's results are below. Some of them may make more sense in the context of the original survey questions, which [can be seen here](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1h4IisKq7p8CRRVT_UXMSiKW6RE5U5nl1PLT_MvpbX2I/viewform). Please do not try to take the survey as it is over and your results will not be counted.

**I. Population**
-----------------

There were 1503 respondents over 27 days. The last survey got 1636 people over 40 days. The last four full days of the survey saw nineteen, six, and four responses, for an average of about ten. If we assume the next thirteen days had also gotten an average of ten responses - which is generous, since responses tend to trail off with time - then we would have gotten about as many people as the last survey. There is no good evidence here of a decline in population, although it is perhaps compatible with a very small decline.

**II. Demographics**
--------------------

**Sex**  
Female: 179, 11.9%  
Male: 1311, 87.2%  
  
**Gender**  
F (cisgender): 150, 10.0%  
F (transgender MtF): 24, 1.6%  
M (cisgender): 1245, 82.8%  
M (transgender FtM): 5, 0.3%  
Other: 64, 4.3%  
  
**Sexual Orientation**  
Asexual: 59, 3.9%  
Bisexual: 216, 14.4%  
Heterosexual: 1133, 75.4%  
Homosexual: 47, 3.1%  
Other: 35, 2.3%  
  
_\[This question was poorly worded and should have acknowledged that people can both be asexual and have a specific orientation; as a result it probably vastly undercounted our asexual readers\]_  
  
**Relationship Style**  
Prefer monogamous: 778, 51.8%  
Prefer polyamorous: 227, 15.1%  
Uncertain/no preference: 464, 30.9%  
Other: 23, 1.5%  
  
**Number of Partners**  
0: 738, 49.1%  
1: 674, 44.8%  
2: 51, 3.4%  
3: 17, 1.1%  
4: 7, 0.5%  
5: 1, 0.1%  
Lots and lots: 3, 0.2%  
  
**Relationship Goals**  
Currently not looking for new partners: 648, 43.1%  
Open to new partners: 467, 31.1%  
Seeking more partners: 370, 24.6%  
_  
\[22.2% of people who don’t have a partner aren’t looking for one.\]_  
  
**Relationship Status**  
Married: 274, 18.2%  
Relationship: 424, 28.2%  
Single: 788, 52.4%  
  
_\[6.9% of single people have at least one partner; 1.8% have more than one.\]_  
  
**Living With**  
Alone: 345, 23.0%  
With parents and/or guardians: 303, 20.2%  
With partner and/or children: 411, 27.3%  
With roommates: 428, 28.5%  
  
**Children**  
0: 1317, 81.6%  
1: 66, 4.4%  
2: 78, 5.2%  
3: 17, 1.1%  
4: 6, 0.4%  
5: 3, 0.2%  
6: 1, 0.1%  
Lots and lots: 1, 0.1%  
  
**Want More Children?**  
Yes: 549, 36.1%  
Uncertain: 426, 28.3%  
No: 516, 34.3%  
  
_\[418 of the people who don’t have children don’t want any, suggesting that the LW community is 27.8% childfree.\]_  
  
**Country**  
United States, 822, 54.7%  
United Kingdom, 116, 7.7%  
Canada, 88, 5.9%  
Australia: 83, 5.5%  
Germany, 62, 4.1%  
Russia, 26, 1.7%  
Finland, 20, 1.3%  
New Zealand, 20, 1.3%  
India, 17, 1.1%  
Brazil: 15, 1.0%  
France, 15, 1.0%  
Israel, 15, 1.0%  
  
**Lesswrongers Per Capita**  
Finland: 1/271,950  
New Zealand: 1/223,550  
Australia: 1/278,674  
United States: 1/358,390  
Canada: 1/399,545  
Israel: 1/537,266  
United Kingdom: 1/552,586  
Germany: 1/1,290,323  
France: 1/ 4,402,000  
Russia: 1/ 5,519,231  
Brazil: 1/ 13,360,000  
India: 1/ 73,647,058  
  
**Race**  
Asian (East Asian): 59. 3.9%  
Asian (Indian subcontinent): 33, 2.2%  
Black: 12. 0.8%  
Hispanic: 32, 2.1%  
Middle Eastern: 9, 0.6%  
Other: 50, 3.3%  
White (non-Hispanic): 1294, 86.1%  
  
**Work Status**  
Academic (teaching): 86, 5.7%  
For-profit work: 492, 32.7%  
Government work: 59, 3.9%  
Homemaker: 8, 0.5%  
Independently wealthy: 9, 0.6%  
Nonprofit work: 58, 3.9%  
Self-employed: 122, 5.8%  
Student: 553, 36.8%  
Unemployed: 103, 6.9%  
  
**Profession**  
Art: 22, 1.5%  
Biology: 29, 1.9%  
Business: 35, 4.0%  
Computers (AI): 42, 2.8%  
Computers (other academic): 106, 7.1%  
Computers (practical): 477, 31.7%  
Engineering: 104, 6.1%  
Finance/Economics: 71, 4.7%  
Law: 38, 2.5%  
Mathematics: 121, 8.1%  
Medicine: 32, 2.1%  
Neuroscience: 18, 1.2%  
Philosophy: 36, 2.4%  
Physics: 65, 4.3%  
Psychology: 31, 2.1%  
Other: 157, 10.2%  
Other “hard science”: 25, 1.7%  
Other “social science”: 34, 2.3%  
  
**Degree**  
None: 74, 4.9%  
High school: 347, 23.1%  
2 year degree: 64, 4.3%  
Bachelors: 555, 36.9%  
Masters: 278, 18.5%  
JD/MD/other professional degree: 44, 2.9%  
PhD: 105, 7.0%  
Other: 24, 1.4%

**III. Mental Illness**
-----------------------

535 answer “no” to all the mental illness questions. Upper bound: 64.4% of the LW population is mentally ill.  
393 answer “yes” to at least one mental illness question. Lower bound: 26.1% of the LW population is mentally ill. Gosh, we have a lot of self-diagnosers.  
  
**Depression**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 273, 18.2%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 383, 25.5%  
No: 759, 50.5%  
  
**OCD**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 30, 2.0%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 76, 5.1%  
No: 1306, 86.9%  
**  
Autism spectrum**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 98, 6.5%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 168, 11.2%  
No: 1143, 76.0%  
**  
Bipolar**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 33, 2.2%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 49, 3.3%  
No: 1327, 88.3%  
  
**Anxiety disorder**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 139, 9.2%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 237, 15.8%  
No: 1033, 68.7%  
  
**BPD**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 5, 0.3%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 19, 1.3%  
No: 1389, 92.4%  
  
_\[Ozy says: RATIONALIST BPDERS COME BE MY FRIEND\]_  
  
**Schizophrenia**  
Yes, I was formally diagnosed: 7, 0.5%  
Yes, I self-diagnosed: 7, 0.5%  
No: 1397, 92.9%

**IV. Politics, Religion, Ethics**
----------------------------------

**Politics**  
Communist: 9, 0.6%  
Conservative: 67, 4.5%  
Liberal: 416, 27.7%  
Libertarian: 379, 25.2%  
Social Democratic: 585, 38.9%  
  
_\[The big change this year was that we changed "Socialist" to "Social Democratic". Even though the description stayed the same, about eight points worth of Liberals switched to Social Democrats, apparently more willing to accept that label than "Socialist". The overall supergroups Libertarian vs. (Liberal, Social Democratic) vs. Conservative remain mostly unchanged.\]_  
  
**Politics (longform)**  
Anarchist: 40, 2.7%  
Communist: 9, 0.6%  
Conservative: 23, 1.9%  
Futarchist: 41, 2.7%  
Left-Libertarian: 192, 12.8%  
Libertarian: 164, 10.9%  
Moderate: 56, 3.7%  
Neoreactionary: 29, 1.9%  
Social Democrat: 162, 10.8%  
Socialist: 89, 5.9%  
_  
\[Amusing politics answers include anti-incumbentist, having-well-founded-opinions-is-hard-but-I’ve-come-to-recognize-the-pragmatism-of-socialism-I-don’t-know-ask-me-again-next-year, pirate, progressive social democratic environmental liberal isolationist freedom-fries loving pinko commie piece of shit, republic-ist aka read the federalist papers, romantic reconstructionist, social liberal fiscal agnostic, technoutopian anarchosocialist (with moderate snark), whatever it is that Scott is, and WHY ISN’T THERE AN OPTION FOR NONE SO I CAN SIGNAL MY OBVIOUS OBJECTIVITY WITH MINIMAL EFFORT. Ozy would like to point out to the authors of manifestos that no one will actually read their manifestos except zir, and they might want to consider posting them to their own blogs.\]_  
  
**American Parties**  
Democratic Party: 221, 14.7%  
Republican Party: 55, 3.7%  
Libertarian Party: 26, 1.7%  
Other party: 16, 1.1%  
No party: 415, 27.6%  
Non-Americans who really like clicking buttons: 415, 27.6%  
**  
Voting**  
Yes: 881, 58.6%  
No: 444, 29.5%  
My country doesn’t hold elections: 5, 0.3%  
**  
Religion**  
Atheist and not spiritual: 1054, 70.1%  
Atheist and spiritual: 150, 10.0%  
Agnostic: 156, 10.4%  
Lukewarm theist: 44, 2.9%  
Deist/pantheist/etc.: 22,, 1.5%  
Committed theist: 60, 4.0%  
  
**Religious Denomination**  
Christian (Protestant): 53, 3.5%  
Mixed/Other: 32, 2.1%  
Jewish: 31, 2.0%  
Buddhist: 30, 2.0%  
Christian (Catholic): 24, 1.6%  
Unitarian Universalist or similar: 23, 1.5%  
  
_\[Amusing denominations include anti-Molochist, CelestAI, cosmic engineers, Laziness, Thelema, Resimulation Theology, and Pythagorean. The Cultus Deorum Romanorum practitioner still needs to contact Ozy so they can be friends.\]_  
  
**Family Religion**  
Atheist and not spiritual: 213, 14.2%  
Atheist and spiritual: 74, 4.9%  
Agnostic: 154. 10.2%  
Lukewarm theist: 541, 36.0%  
Deist/Pantheist/etc.: 28, 1.9%  
Committed theist: 388, 25.8%  
  
**Religious Background**  
Christian (Protestant): 580, 38.6%  
Christian (Catholic): 378, 25.1%  
Jewish: 141, 9.4%  
Christian (other non-protestant): 88, 5.9%  
Mixed/Other: 68, 4.5%  
Unitarian Universalism or similar: 29, 1.9%  
Christian (Mormon): 28, 1.9%  
Hindu: 23, 1.5%’  
  
**Moral Views**  
Accept/lean towards consequentialism: 901, 60.0%  
Accept/lean towards deontology: 50, 3.3%  
Accept/lean towards natural law: 48, 3.2%  
Accept/lean towards virtue ethics: 150, 10.0%  
Accept/lean towards contractualism: 79, 5.3%  
Other/no answer: 239, 15.9%  
  
**Meta-ethics**  
Constructivism: 474, 31.5%  
Error theory: 60, 4.0%  
Non-cognitivism: 129, 8.6%  
Subjectivism: 324, 21.6%  
Substantive realism: 209, 13.9%

**V. Community Participation**
------------------------------

  
**Less Wrong Use**  
Lurker: 528, 35.1%  
I’ve registered an account: 221, 14.7%  
I’ve posted a comment: 419, 27.9%  
I’ve posted in Discussion: 207, 13.8%  
I’ve posted in Main: 102, 6.8%  
  
**Sequences**  
Never knew they existed until this moment: 106, 7.1%  
Knew they existed, but never looked at them: 42, 2.8%  
Some, but less than 25%: 270, 18.0%  
About 25%: 181, 12.0%  
About 50%: 209, 13.9%  
About 75%: 242, 16.1%  
All or almost all: 427, 28.4%  
  
**Meetups**  
Yes, regularly: 154, 10.2%  
Yes, once or a few times: 325, 21.6%  
No: 989, 65.8%  
**  
Community**  
Yes, all the time: 112, 7.5%  
Yes, sometimes: 191, 12.7%  
No: 1163, 77.4%  
  
**Romance**  
Yes: 82, 5.5%  
I didn’t meet them through the community but they’re part of the community now: 79, 5.3%  
No: 1310, 87.2%  
  
**CFAR Events**  
Yes, in 2014: 45, 3.0%  
Yes, in 2013: 60, 4.0%  
Both: 42, 2.8%  
No: 1321, 87.9%  
  
**CFAR Workshop**  
Yes: 109, 7.3%  
No: 1311, 87.2%  
  
_\[A couple percent more people answered 'yes' to each of meetups, physical interactions, CFAR attendance, and romance this time around, suggesting the community is very very gradually becoming more IRL. In particular, the number of people meeting romantic partners through the community increased by almost 50% over last year.\]_  
  
**HPMOR**  
Yes: 897, 59.7%  
Started but not finished: 224, 14.9%  
No: 254, 16.9%  
  
**Referrals**  
Referred by a link: 464, 30.9%  
HPMOR: 385, 25.6%  
Been here since the Overcoming Bias days: 210, 14.0%  
Referred by a friend: 199, 13.2%  
Referred by a search engine: 114, 7.6%  
Referred by other fiction: 17, 1.1%  
  
_\[Amusing responses include “a rationalist that I follow on Tumblr”, “I’m a student of tribal cultishness”, and “It is difficult to recall details from the Before Time. Things were brighter, simpler, as in childhood or a dream. There has been much growth, change since then. But also loss. I can't remember where I found the link, is what I'm saying.”\]_  
  
**Blog Referrals**  
Slate Star Codex: 40, 2.6%  
Reddit: 25, 1.6%  
Common Sense Atheism: 21, 1.3%  
Hacker News: 20, 1.3%  
Gwern: 13, 1.0%

**VI. Other Categorical Data**
------------------------------

**Cryonics Status**  
Don’t understand/never thought about it: 62, 4.1%  
Don’t want to: 361, 24.0%  
Considering it: 551, 36.7%  
Haven’t gotten around to it: 272, 18.1%  
Unavailable in my area: 126, 8.4%  
Yes: 64, 4.3%  
  
**Type of Global Catastrophic Risk**  
Asteroid strike: 64, 4.3%  
Economic/political collapse: 151, 10.0%  
Environmental collapse: 218, 14.5%  
Nanotech/grey goo: 47, 3.1%  
Nuclear war: 239, 15.8%  
Pandemic (bioengineered): 310, 20.6%  
Pandemic (natural): 113. 7.5%  
Unfriendly AI: 244, 16.2%  
  
_\[Amusing answers include ennui/eaten by Internet, Friendly AI, “Greens so weaken the rich countries that barbarians conquer us”, and Tumblr.\]_  
  
**Effective Altruism** **(do you self-identify)**  
Yes: 422, 28.1%  
No: 758, 50.4%  
_  
\[Despite some impressive outreach by the EA community, numbers are largely the same as last year\]_  
  
**Effective Altruism (do you participate in community)**  
Yes: 191, 12.7%  
No: 987, 65.7%  
  
**Vegetarian**  
Vegan: 31, 2.1%  
Vegetarian: 114, 7.6%  
Other meat restriction: 252, 16.8%  
Omnivore: 848, 56.4%  
**  
Paleo Diet**  
Yes: 33, 2.2%  
Sometimes: 209, 13.9%  
No: 1111, 73.9%  
  
**Food Substitutes**  
Most of my calories: 8. 0.5%  
Sometimes: 101, 6.7%  
Tried: 196, 13.0%  
No: 1052, 70.0%  
  
**Gender Default**  
I only identify with my birth gender by default: 681, 45.3%  
I strongly identify with my birth gender: 586, 39.0%  
  
**Books**  
<5: 198, 13.2%  
5 - 10: 384, 25.5%  
10 - 20: 328, 21.8%  
20 - 50: 264, 17.6%  
50 - 100: 105, 7.0%  
\> 100: 49, 3.3%  
  
**Birth Month**  
Jan: 109, 7.3%  
Feb: 90, 6.0%  
Mar: 123, 8.2%  
Apr: 126, 8.4%  
Jun: 107, 7.1%  
Jul: 109, 7.3%  
Aug: 120, 8.0%  
Sep: 94, 6.3%  
Oct: 111, 7.4%  
Nov: 102, 6.8%  
Dec: 106, 7.1%  
  
_\[Despite my hope of something turning up here, these results don't deviate from chance\]_  
  
**Handedness**  
Right: 1170, 77.8%  
Left: 143, 9.5%  
Ambidextrous: 37, 2.5%  
Unsure: 12, 0.8%  
  
**Previous Surveys**  
Yes: 757, 50.7%  
No:  598, 39.8%  
  
**Favorite Less Wrong Posts (all > 5 listed)**  
An Alien God: 11  
Joy In The Merely Real: 7  
Dissolving Questions About Disease: 7  
Politics Is The Mind Killer: 6  
That Alien Message: 6  
A Fable Of Science And Politics: 6  
Belief In Belief: 5  
Generalizing From One Example: 5  
Schelling Fences On Slippery Slopes: 5  
Tsuyoku Naritai: 5

**VII. Numeric Data**
---------------------

Age: 27.67 + 8.679 (22, 26, 31) \[1490\]  
IQ: 138.25 + 15.936 (130.25, 139, 146) \[472\]  
SAT out of 1600: 1470.74 + 113.114 (1410, 1490, 1560) \[395\]  
SAT out of 2400: 2210.75 + 188.94 (2140, 2250, 2320) \[310\]  
ACT out of 36: 32.56 + 2.483 (31, 33, 35) \[244\]  
Time in Community: 2010.97 + 2.174 (2010, 2011, 2013) \[1317\]  
Time on LW: 15.73 + 95.75 (2, 5, 15) \[1366\]  
Karma Score: 555.73 + 2181.791 (0, 0, 155) \[1335\]  
  
P Many Worlds: 47.64 + 30.132 (20, 50, 75) \[1261\]  
P Aliens: 71.52 + 34.364 (50, 90, 99) \[1393\]  
P Aliens (Galaxy): 41.2 + 38.405 (2, 30, 80) \[1379\]  
P Supernatural: 6.68 + 20.271 (0, 0, 1) \[1386\]  
P God: 8.26 + 21.088 (0, 0.01, 3) \[1376\]  
P Religion: 4.99 + 18.068 (0, 0, 0.5) \[1384\]  
P Cryonics: 22.34 + 27.274 (2, 10, 30) \[1399\]  
P Anti-Agathics: 24.63 + 29.569 (1, 10, 40) \[1390\]  
P Simulation 24.31 + 28.2 (1, 10, 50) \[1320\]  
P Warming 81.73 + 24.224 (80, 90, 98) \[1394\]  
P Global Catastrophic Risk 72.14 + 25.620 (55, 80, 90) \[1394\]  
Singularity: 2143.44 + 356.643 (2060, 2090, 2150) \[1177\]  
_  
\[The mean for this question is almost entirely dependent on which stupid responses we choose to delete as outliers; the median practically never changes\]_  
  
Abortion: 4.38 + 1.032 (4, 5, 5) \[1341\]  
Immigration: 4 + 1.078 (3, 4, 5) \[1310\]  
Taxes : 3.14 + 1.212 (2, 3, 4) \[1410\] (from 1 - should be lower to 5 - should be higher)  
Minimum Wage: 3.21 + 1.359 (2, 3, 4) \[1298\] (from 1 - should be lower to 5 - should be higher)  
Feminism: 3.67 + 1.221 (3, 4, 5) \[1332\]  
Social Justice: 3.15 + 1.385 (2, 3, 4) \[1309\]  
Human Biodiversity: 2.93 + 1.201 (2, 3, 4) \[1321\]  
Basic Income: 3.94 + 1.087 (3, 4, 5) \[1314\]  
Great Stagnation: 2.33 + .959 (2, 2, 3) \[1302\]  
MIRI Mission: 3.90 + 1.062 (3, 4, 5) \[1412\]  
MIRI Effectiveness: 3.23 + .897 (3, 3, 4) \[1336\]  
  
_\[Remember, all of these are asking you to rate your belief in/agreement with the concept on a scale of 1 (bad) to 5 (great)\]_  
  
Income: 54129.37 + 66818.904 (10,000, 30,800, 80,000) \[923\]  
Charity: 1996.76 + 9492.71 (0, 100, 800) \[1009\]  
MIRI/CFAR: 511.61 + 5516.608 (0, 0, 0) \[1011\]  
XRisk: 62.50 + 575.260 (0, 0, 0) \[980\]  
Older siblings: 0.51 + .914 (0, 0, 1) \[1332\]  
Younger siblings: 1.08 + 1.127 (0, 1, 1) \[1349\]  
Height: 178.06 + 11.767 (173, 179, 184) \[1236\]  
Hours Online: 43.44 + 25.452 (25, 40, 60) \[1221\]  
Bem Sex Role Masculinity: 42.54 + 9.670 (36, 42, 49) \[1032\]  
Bem Sex Role Femininity: 42.68 + 9.754 (36, 43, 50) \[1031\]  
Right Hand: .97 + 0.67 (.94, .97, 1.00)  
Left Hand: .97 + .048 (.94, .97, 1.00)

**VIII. Fishing Expedition**s
-----------------------------

_\[correlations, in descending order\]_  
  
SAT Scores out of 1600/SAT Scores out of 2400 .844 (59)  
P Supernatural/P God .697 (1365)  
Feminism/Social Justice .671 (1299)  
P God/P Religion .669 (1367)  
P Supernatural/P Religion .631 (1372)  
Charity Donations/MIRI and CFAR Donations .619 (985)  
P Aliens/P Aliens 2 .607 (1376)  
Taxes/Minimum Wage .587 (1287)  
SAT Score out of 2400/ACT Score .575 (89)  
Age/Number of Children .506 (1480)  
P Cryonics/P Anti-Agathics .484 (1385)  
SAT Score out of 1600/ACT Score .480 (81)  
Minimum Wage/Social Justice .456 (1267)  
Taxes/Social Justice .427 (1281)  
Taxes/Feminism .414 (1299)  
MIRI Mission/MIRI Effectiveness .395 (1331)  
P Warming/Taxes .385 (1261)  
Taxes/Basic Income .383 (1285)  
Minimum Wage/Feminism .378 (1286)  
P God/Abortion -.378 (1266)  
Immigration/Feminism .365 (1296)  
P Supernatural/Abortion -.362 (1276)  
Feminism/Human Biodiversity -.360 (1306)  
MIRI and CFAR Donations/Other XRisk Charity Donations .345 (973)  
Social Justice/Human Biodiversity -.341 (1288)  
P Religion/Abortion -.326 (1275)  
P Warming/Minimum Wage .324 (1248)  
Minimum Wage/Basic Income .312 (1276)  
P Warming/Basic Income .306 (1260)  
Immigration/Social Justice .294 (1278)  
P Anti-Agathics/MIRI Mission .293 (1351)  
P Warming/Feminism .285 (1281)  
P Many Worlds/P Anti-Agathics .276 (1245)  
Social Justice/Femininity .267 (990)  
Minimum Wage/Human Biodiversity -.264 (1274)  
Immigration/Human Biodiversity -.263 (1286)  
P Many Worlds/MIRI Mission .263 (1233)  
P Aliens/P Warming .262 (1365)  
P Warming/Social Justice .257 (1262)  
Taxes/Human Biodiversity -.252 (1291)  
Social Justice/Basic Income .251 (1281)  
Feminism/Femininity .250 (1003)  
Older Siblings/Younger Siblings -.243 (1321)  
Charity Donations/Other XRisk Charity Donations .240 (957  
P Anti-Agathics/P Simulation .238 (1312)  
Abortion/Minimum Wage .229 (1293)  
Feminism/Basic Income .227 (1297)  
Abortion/Feminism .226 (1321)  
P Cryonics/MIRI Mission .223 (1360)  
Immigration/Basic Income .208 (1279)  
P Many Worlds/P Cryonics .202 (1251)  
Number of Current Partners/Femininity: .202 (1029)  
P Warming/Immigration .202 (1260)  
P Warming/Abortion .201 (1289)  
Abortion/Taxes .198 (1304)  
Age/P Simulation .197 (1313)  
Political Interest/Masculinity .194 (1011)  
P Cryonics/MIRI Effectiveness .191 (1285)  
Abortion/Social Justice .191 (1301)  
P Simulation/MIRI Mission .188 (1290)  
P Many Worlds/P Warming .188 (1240)  
Age/Number of Current Partners .184 (1480)  
P Anti-Agathics/MIRI Effectiveness .183 (1277)  
P Many Worlds/P Simulation .181 (1211)  
Abortion/Immigration .181 (1304)  
Number of Current Partners/Number of Children .180 (1484)  
P Cryonics/P Simulation .174 (1315)  
P Global Catastrophic Risk/MIRI Mission -.174 (1359)  
Minimum Wage/Femininity .171 (981)  
Abortion/Basic Income .170 (1302)  
Age/P Cryonics -.165 (1391)  
Immigration/Taxes .165 (1293)  
P Warming/Human Biodiversity -.163 (1271)  
P Aliens 2/Warming .160 (1353)  
Abortion/Younger Siblings -.155 (1292)  
P Religion/Meditate .155 (1189)  
Feminism/Masculinity -.155 (1004)  
Immigration/Femininity .155 (988)  
P Supernatural/Basic Income -.153 (1246)  
P Supernatural/P Warming -.152 (1361)  
Number of Current Partners/Karma Score .152 (1332)  
P Many Worlds/MIRI Effectiveness .152 (1181)  
Age/MIRI Mission -.150 (1404)  
P Religion/P Warming -.150 (1358)  
P Religion/Basic Income -.146 (1245)  
P God/Basic Income -.146 (1237)  
Human Biodiversity/Femininity -.145 (999)  
P God/P Warming -.144 (1351)  
Taxes/Femininity .142 (987)  
Number of Children/Younger Siblings .138 (1343)  
Number of Current Partners/Masculinity: .137 (1030)  
P Many Worlds/P God -.137 (1232)  
Age/Charity Donations .133 (1002)  
P Anti-Agathics/P Global Catastrophic Risk -.132 (1373)  
P Warming/Masculinity -.132 (992)  
P Global Catastrophic Risk/MIRI and CFAR Donations -.132 (982)  
P Supernatural/Singularity .131 (1148)  
God/Taxes -.130 (1240)  
Age/P Anti-Agathics -.128 (1382)  
P Aliens/Taxes .127(1258)  
Feminism/Great Stagnation -.127 (1287)  
P Many Worlds/P Supernatural -.127 (1241)  
P Aliens/Abortion .126 (1284)  
P Anti-Agathics/Great Stagnation -.126 (1248)  
P Anti-Agathics/P Warming .125 (1370)  
Age/P Aliens .124 (1386)  
P Aliens/Minimum Wage .124 (1245)  
P Aliens/P Global Catastrophic Risk .122 (1363)  
Age/MIRI Effectiveness -.122 (1328)  
Age/P Supernatural .120 (1370)  
P Supernatural/MIRI Mission -.119 (1345)  
P Many Worlds/P Religion -.119 (1238)  
P Religion/MIRI Mission -.118 (1344)  
Political Interest/Social Justice .118 (1304)  
P Anti-Agathics/MIRI and CFAR Donations .118 (976)  
Human Biodiversity/Basic Income -.115 (1262)  
P Many Worlds/Abortion .115 (1166)  
Age/Karma Score .114 (1327)  
P Aliens/Feminism .114 (1277)  
P Many Worlds/P Global Catastrophic Risk -.114 (1243)  
Political Interest/Femininity .113 (1010)  
Number of Children/P Simulation -.112 (1317)  
P Religion/Younger Siblings .112 (1275)  
P Supernatural/Taxes -.112 (1248)  
Age/Masculinity .112 (1027)  
Political Interest/Taxes .111 (1305)  
P God/P Simulation .110 (1296)  
P Many Worlds/Basic Income .110 (1139)  
P Supernatural/Younger Siblings .109 (1274)  
P Simulation/Basic Income .109 (1195)  
Age/P Aliens 2 .107 (1371)  
MIRI Mission/Basic Income .107 (1279)  
Age/Great Stagnation .107 (1295)  
P Many Worlds/P Aliens .107 (1253)  
Number of Current Partners/Social Justice .106 (1304)  
Human Biodiversity/Great Stagnation .105 (1285)  
Number of Children/Abortion -.104 (1337)  
Number of Current Partners/P Cryonics -.102 (1396)  
MIRI Mission/Abortion .102 (1305)  
Immigration/Great Stagnation -.101 (1269)  
Age/Political Interest .100 (1339)  
P Global Catastrophic Risk/Political Interest .099 (1295)  
P Aliens/P Religion -.099 (1357)  
P God/MIRI Mission -.098 (1335)  
P Aliens/P Simulation .098 (1308)  
Number of Current Partners/Immigration .098 (1305)  
P God/Political Interest .098 (1274)  
P Warming/P Global Catastrophic Risk .096 (1377)  
  
In addition to the Left/Right factor we had last year, this data seems to me to have an Agrees with the Sequences Factor-- the same people tend to believe in many-worlds, cryo, atheism, simulationism, MIRI’s mission and effectiveness, anti-agathics, etc. Weirdly, belief in global catastrophic risk is negatively correlated with most of the Agrees with Sequences things. Someone who actually knows how to do statistics should run a factor analysis on this data.

**IX. Digit Ratios**
--------------------

After sanitizing the digit ratio numbers, the following correlations came up:  
  
Digit ratio R hand was correlated with masculinity at a level of -0.180 p < 0.01  
Digit ratio L hand was correlated with masculinity at a level of -0.181 p < 0.01  
Digit ratio R hand was slightly correlated with femininity at a level of +0.116 p < 0.05  
  
Holy #@!$ the feminism thing ACTUALLY HELD UP. There is a 0.144 correlation between right-handed digit ratio and feminism, p < 0.01. And an 0.112 correlation between left-handed digit ratio and feminism, p < 0.05.  
  
The only other political position that correlates with digit ratio is immigration. There is a 0.138 correlation between left-handed digit ratio and believe in open borders p < 0.01, and an 0.111 correlation between right-handed digit ratio and belief in open borders, p < 0.05.  
  
No digit correlation with abortion, taxes, minimum wage, social justice, human biodiversity, basic income, or great stagnation.  
  
Okay, need to rule out that this is all confounded by gender. I ran a few analyses on men and women separately.  
  
On men alone, the connection to masculinity holds up. Restricting sample size to men, left-handed digit ratio corresponds to masculinity with at -0.157, p < 0.01. Left handed at -0.134, p < 0.05. Right-handed correlates with femininity at 0.120, p < 0.05. The feminism correlation holds up. Restricting sample size to men, right-handed digit ratio correlates with feminism at a level of 0.149, p < 0.01. Left handed just barely fails to correlate. Both right and left correlate with immigration at 0.135, p < 0.05.  
  
On women alone, the Bem masculinity correlation is the highest correlation we're going to get in this entire study. Right hand is -0.433, p < 0.01. Left hand is -0.299, p < 0.05. Femininity trends toward significance but doesn't get there. The feminism correlation trends toward significance but doesn't get there. In general there was too small a sample size of women to pick up anything but the most whopping effects.  
  
Since digit ratio is related to testosterone and testosterone sometimes affects risk-taking, I wondered if it would correlate with any of the calibration answers. I selected people who had answered Calibration Question 5 incorrectly and ran an analysis to see if digit ratio was correlated with tendency to be more confident in the incorrect answer. No effect was found.  
  
Other things that didn't correlate with digit ratio: IQ, SAT, number of current partners, tendency to work in mathematical professions.  
  
...I still can't believe this actually worked. The finger-length/feminism connection ACTUALLY WORKED. What a world. What a world. Someone may want to double-check these results before I get _too_ excited.  

**X. Calibration**
------------------

  
There were ten calibration questions on this year's survey. Along with answers, they were:  
  
1\. What is the largest bone in the body? Femur  
2\. What state was President Obama born in? Hawaii  
3\. Off the coast of what country was the battle of Trafalgar fought? Spain  
4\. What Norse God was called the All-Father? Odin  
5\. Who won the 1936 Nobel Prize for his work in quantum physics? Heisenberg  
6\. Which planet has the highest density? Earth  
7\. Which Bible character was married to Rachel and Leah? Jacob  
8\. What organelle is called "the powerhouse of the cell"? Mitochondria  
9\. What country has the fourth-highest population? Indonesia  
10\. What is the best-selling computer game? Minecraft  
  
I ran calibration scores for everybody based on how well they did on the ten calibration questions. These failed to correlate with IQ, SAT, LW karma, or any of the things you might expect to be measures of either intelligence or previous training in calibration; they didn't differ by gender, correlates of community membership, or any mental illness \[deleted section about correlating with MWI and MIRI, this was an artifact\].  
  
Your answers looked like this:  
  
![](http://slatestarcodex.com/Stuff/calibration2014.png)  
  
The red line represents perfect calibration. Where answers dip below the line, it means you were overconfident; when they go above, it means you were underconfident.  
  
It looks to me like everyone was horrendously underconfident on all the easy questions, and horrendously overconfident on all the hard questions. To give an example of how horrendous, people who were 50% sure of their answers to question 10 got it right only 13% of the time; people who were 100% sure only got it right 44% of the time. Obviously those numbers should be 50% and 100% respectively.  
  
This builds upon results from previous surveys in which your calibration was also horrible. This is not a human universal - people who put even a small amount of training into calibration can become very well calibrated very quickly. This is a sign that most Less Wrongers continue to neglect the very basics of rationality and are incapable of judging how much evidence they have on a given issue. Veterans of the site do no better than newbies on this measure.

**XI. Wrapping Up**
-------------------

To show my appreciation for everyone completing this survey, including the arduous digit ratio measurements, I have randomly chosen a person to receive a $30 monetary prize. That person is...the person using the public key "The World Is Quiet Here". If that person tells me their private key, I will give them $30.  
  
I have removed 73 people who wished to remain private, deleted the Private Keys, and sanitized a very small amount of data. Aside from that, here are the raw survey results for your viewing and analyzing pleasure:  
  
[(as Excel)](http://slatestarcodex.com/Stuff/2014forpublic.xlsx)

[(as SPSS)](http://slatestarcodex.com/Stuff/2014forpublic.sav)

[(as CSV)](http://slatestarcodex.com/Stuff/2014forpublic.csv)