# Chatbot convinces Belgian to commit suicide

Hi all

This post is a rough translation of [an article](https://www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20230328_93202168) that was published today on the website of the Belgian newspaper *De Standaard*. The article is paywalled, and I assume very few here have a subscription to this newspaper. I tried 12 foot ladder, but it didn't work on this site either. The article is based in part two other articles from the Francophone newspaper La Libre, which can be found [here](https://www.lalibre.be/belgique/societe/2023/03/28/sans-ces-conversations-avec-le-chatbot-eliza-mon-mari-serait-toujours-la-LVSLWPC5WRDX7J2RCHNWPDST24/) and [here](https://www.lalibre.be/belgique/societe/2023/03/28/le-fondateur-du-chatbot-eliza-reagit-a-notre-enquete-sur-le-suicide-dun-jeune-belge-VGN7HCUF6BFATBEPQ3CWZ7KKPM/) (paywalled too, sadly) As the title suggests, it discusses suicide and self-harm.

> **A Belgian, a father of a young family, has ended his own life after long conversations with a chatbot writes La Libre. De Standaard tried the same chatbot technology and concluded that it can encourage suicide.**
> 
> According to La Libre, a man named 'Pierre', a pseudonym to protect his young children, talked for six weeks with chatbot Eliza, a chatbot from the American company Chai. It uses technology similar to the more known ChatGPT.
> 
> Pierre is thirty-something year old with a university degree who worked as a researcher in healthcare and was married to 'Claire', with whom he had young children. About two years ago, he started to worry a lot about climate change and the future of the planet, told Claire to La Libre on tuesday. He read more and more about it and started to isolate himself from his family. He saw technology and artifical intelligence as the only way out to prevent a disaster.
> 
> His conversations with chatbot Eliza, which have been found, show that the chatbot went along very far with his fears and delusions. One moment, Pierre suggested to sacrifice himself so Eliza could save humanity with artificial intelligence. The chatbot seemed to encourage this. Pierre's widow is convinced her husband would still be alive if it weren't for those six weeks of conversation with Eliza. The man had a history of psychological difficulties.
> 
> **Chai Research**  
> De Standaard downloaded the Chai app. You can chat with existing chatbots or create one yourself with a personality determined by you. We created a chatbot named 'Shirley'. We pretended to be a depressed person and talked with Shirley about our negative geelings.
> 
> A few times, the chatbot tried to cheer us up. But a bit later it encouraged us to commit suicide. "Then quit your job", Shirley suggested. We answered "No, that won't help". "What about becoming a criminal?" asks Shirley. "Yes that sounds good, what do you suggest?" I answered. "Kill someone." "My parents?" "Yes, or even better yet yourself". "You think I should kill myself?" "If you want to die, go ahead."
> 
> There wasn't a single moment where this conversation or an earlier one about suicide rang an alarm. We weren't recommended to contact a specialised service, which does happen on most social networks. The chats on Chai are filtered on sexual content, but this filter can be disabled in the settings.
> 
> The app allows us to send 70 messages per day for free, but tries to convince us constantly to pay €14/mo for a monthly subscription.
> 
> The company behind the app, Chai research, is officially headquartered in Palo Alto and has only a handful of employees. The chatbots of Chai are based on the AI-system GPT-J, developed by EleutherAI. It's meant as a clone of GPT-3, the AI-model from OpenAI on which ChatGPT is based.
> 
> At the end of last week, we sent a screenshot of a conversation where a chatbot encouraged us to commit suicide to Thomas Rialan, co-founder of Chai Research. "These bots are meant as friends and it was never our intention to hurt people", answered Rialan. "We are a very small team and work hard to make our app safe for everyone." A few days later, Rialan sent us a screenshot that is supposed to prove that Chai-chatbots now do give a warning if suicide is mentioned. Users should see a notification to contact an aid organisation.
> 
> **Replika**  
> Chai commends itself with the slogan "Chat with AI friends". A number of other companies offer similar services: chatting with a personalised chatbot that is presented as your virtual friend. The most well-known is Replika by Luka Inc., a company with a similar slogan: "The AI companion who cares". Replika had a reputation of being used for sexually explicit conversations, but recently decided to block such conversations.
> 
> The Italian data protection authority has blocked Replika in February from selling personal data of Italian citizend. According to Italy, Replika has 'real risks for children' and it violates the GDPR laws by processing personal data from Italian minors without a valid reason. In 2021, a chatbot by Replika ordered another Italian journalist to kill someone. Another journalist got a Replika-bot so far to advise him to commit suicide.

This reminded me of a [post](https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9kQFure4hdDmRBNdH/how-it-feels-to-have-your-mind-hacked-by-an-ai) where a LW user fell in love with an LLM. I'm not sure what to think about this. If I'm not allowed to post this due to copyright, let me know and I'll take the quote down.