From: phen@volga.bcl.t.u-tokyo.ac.jp (Masaki OSHIKAWA)
Newsgroups: fj.news.policy
Subject: Re: Why the committee is better than anarchy
Date: 12 Dec 92 12:59:55 GMT
	<1992Dec10.033752.26335@nntp.csl.sony.co.jp>
	<ANDO.92Dec11174700@kotai.phys.hokudai.ac.jp>
Reply-To: OSHIKAWA@tkyvax.phys.s.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Distribution: fj
Organization: Institute for Solid State Physics , University of Tokyo

$@2!@n!wJ*@-8&(J$@$G$9!#(J
$@$O$8$a$^$7$F!#(J

In article <ANDO.92Dec11174700@kotai.phys.hokudai.ac.jp> ando@phys.hokudai.ac.jp (Kazunori ANDO) writes:
>------------------------
>$@#N#G:n@.!&GQ;_EjI<=$@50F(J
>
>$@0J2<$N<jB3$-$r2OLn0F(J$@$N(J CFV $@$HCV$-49$($k!#(J
>
>$@!Z<jB3$-![(J
>CFV(1)--$@:FEjI<@A5a<u$1IU$1(J--$@@bF@$*$h$SEjI<8F$S$+$14|4V(J--CFV(2)
>$@"((J $@#C#F#V$r9T$&$3$H$rDs0F$7$?B&$r;?@.B&$HDj5A$9$k!#(J
>CFV(1):
>$@!}@.N)>r7o!'#2#0#0I<0J>e(J
>$@!}H=Dj>r7o!';?(J$@@.2aH>?t$G2D7h!#F1;~$KH?BPB&$K:FEjI<@A5a$N8"Mx$rM?$($k!#(J
>	     $@:FEjI<@A5a4|4VFb$K@A5a$N$J$+$C$?>l9g$O(J$@$=$N$^$^2D7h$9$k!#(J
>	     $@;?@.$,2aH>?t$KC#$7$J$$>l9g!">x$7JV$7#3%v7n%k!<%k$rE,MQ$7$F(J
>	     $@Gr;fE12s!#(J
>
>CFV(2):
>$@!}@.N)>r7o!'(JCFV(1)$@$NEjI<?t0J>e$NEjI<$,$"$k$3$H!#(J
>$@!}H=Dj>r7o!'(JCFV(1)$@$+$i$NF@I<?t$NA}J,$r(J$@I>2A$9$k!#(J
>	     $@;?@.GI$NA}J,$h$jH?BPGI$NA}J,$,B?$$>l9g!">x$7JV$7#3%v7n%k!<%k$r(J
>	     $@E,MQ$7$FGr;fE1(J$@2s!#;?@.GI$NA}J,$NJ}$,B?$$>l9g$O2D7h!#(J
>
>$@!Z=$@5$N0U?^![(J
>
>$@#1!%(JCFV(1)$@$O%"%s%1!<%HE*MWAG$,6/$/!"=>Mh$N(J$@2OLnDs0F$K$*$1$kEjI<$KAjEv$9$k!#(J
>    $@$5$i$K>/?t0U8+$N5_:Q$N$?$a$K:FEjI<@A5a$N8"Mx$rM?$($k!#(J
>
>$@#2!%(JCFV(2)$@$O!"@bF@!&EjI<8F$S$+$14|4VFb$K0lJ}$,B>J}$r@bF@$9$k$+!"EjI<(J
>    $@?t$rA}$d$9$+$7$J$$8B$j0F7o$,@.N)(J$@$7$J$$!#$=$N$?$a!"3hH/$J5DO@$H(J
>    $@L@3N$JO@5r$,MW5a$5$l$k!#(J
>   $@!JEj9F<B@S$,$=$NO@5r$K$J$jF@$k$3$H$O(J$@9g0U$5$l$F$$$k$H9M$($i$l$k!K(J
>
>$@#3!%#1H/EjI<$HHf3S$7$F!"$h$jB?$/$NEjI<$r0z=P$9$3$H$,MW5a$5$l$k!#(J
>
>$@#4(J$@!%7k2LE*$KH=CG$,0BA4B&$X?6$i$l$k!#(J

$@$"$s$I!<$5$s$N0U?^$O$o$+$i$J$/$b$J$$$G$9$,!"<B:]$K$3$NJ}K!$G<A$N9b(J$@$$9g(J
$@0U$,F@$i$l$k$+$I$&$+$O5?Ld$G$9!#(J

[$@Nc#1(J]

$@H?BPGI$,!"(JCFV(2)$@$G$NH]7h$rL\;X$7$F!"(JCFV(1)$@$G$O8N0U$KH?(J$@BPI<$r>/$J$/$7$F(J
$@$*$/!#H?BPGI$,$3$N$h$&$J@o=Q$r<h$k$H!"5DO@$N<A$K4X$o$j$J$/5D0F$rAr$k$3(J
$@$H$,$G$-$k!#(J

$@F1$8@o=Q$O;?@.GI$b:NMQ$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k$,!"(JCFV(1)$@$G2aH>?t$r<h$k$H8@$&@)(J
$@Ls$,$"$k$N$G!"B?>/ITMx$+$J!)(J

$@7k6I!"I<FI$_$H@o=Q$H1?$K$h$C$F7k2L$,$+$J$j:81&$5$l$F$7$^$&!#(J

[$@Nc#2(J]

[$@Nc#1(J]$@$N$h$&$JH\61$J(J(?)$@@o=Q$rN>(J$@<T$H$b$H$i$J$$$H2>Dj$7$^$9!#(J
$@$=$l$G$b!"6KC<$JOC(J

  CFV(1) $@$G(J $@;?@.(J 200	$@H?BP(J 1
$@$N8e:FEjI<$N@A5a$,$"$j!"(J$@3hH/$J5DO@$,9T$J$o$l$?!#(J
  CFV(2) $@$G(J $@;?@.(J 199    $@H?BP(J 2
$@$G$"$C$?(J

$@>l9g$r9M$($^$7$g$&!#$"$s$I!<$5$s$NJ}(J$@<0$@$HH]7h$5$l$F$7$^$&$o$1$G$9$h$M!#(J

$@3N$+$K!";?@.GI$N0l?M$,H?BP$N5DO@$K@bF@$5$l$?$H8@$&;v<B$O$"$j$^$9(J$@$,!"(J
199$@?M$,3hH/$J5DO@$r7P$?8e$G$b$d$O$j;?@.$@$C$?$H8@$&;v<B$b$"$j$^$9!#(J

$@$3$N$H$-!"H?BP0U8+$NJ}$,<A$,(J$@9b$$$H$OI,$:$7$b8@$($J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

$@!t!t!t!t!t(J

$@$b$A$m$s!"5DO@$OFbMF$G9T$J$&$Y$-$G$"$j!"B??tGI$@$+$i(J$@@5$7$$$H$O8B$j$^$;(J
$@$s!#$G$b!">/?tGI$@$+$i@5$7$$$H$b8B$i$J$$$o$1$G$9!#(J
$@!JEjI<?t$,A}$($?J}$,@5$7$$$H$b8B(J$@$i$J$$(J :-p $@!K(J

$@M}A[O@$H$7$F$O!"5DO@$N7k2LA40w$N0U8+$,0lCW$9$k$3$H$,K>$^$7$$$o$1$G$9$,!"(J
$@<B:]$K$=$s$J$3(J$@$H$K$O$J$i$J$$>l9g$NJ}$,B?$$$G$7$g$&!#(J

$@$=$s$J$H$-$K!"$H$K$+$/$I$A$i$+7kO@$r=P$9$N$KEjI<$K$h$kB??t7h$O(J$@:G$b8x@5(J
$@$JJ}K!$@$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

$@$"$s$I!<$5$s$O!"B??t7h$O!INL!I$NO@M}$@$H8@$$$J$,$i!"7k6I5DO@$N!I<A!I$r(J
$@H=Dj$9$k$N$K!"EjI<?t$NA}8:$H8@$&!INL!I$KMj$i$6$k$rF@$J$$$o$1$G$9$h$M!#(J
$@EjI<?t$NA}8:!"$H$$$&NL$h$j$OEj(J$@I<?t$=$N$b$N$NJ}$,$^$@?.Mj$,$*$1$k$H;W$$(J
$@$^$9$1$I!#(J

$@!t!t!t!t!t(J

$@3N$+$K!"EjI<$H$$$&$N$OB??t$N2#K=$K$J(J$@$C$F$7$^$&4m81@-$O$"$j$^$9$,!"B>$N(J
$@J}K!$K$O$=$l0J>e$NLdBjE@$,$"$k$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

$@7k6I!"EjI<$NA0$K==J,5D(J$@O@$G$-$k$h$&$J%7%9%F%`$K$7$F$*$/$N$,%Y%9%H$@$H;W(J
$@$$$^$9$,!#(J
$@$H$$$&$o$1$G!"2OLn$5$s$NDs0F$K;?@.$G$9!#(J

$@!t!t!t!t!t(J

$@$?$@!"%7%9%F%`$r:n$k$@$1$8$c$J$/$F!"EjI<$K;22C$9$k3F?M$,!"5DO@$N<A$r9b(J
$@$a!"<A$NNI$$0U8+$K(J$@;?@.$7$F$$$/$H$$$&BVEY$r;}$C$F$$$J$$$H!"$"$s$I!<$5$s(J
$@$N7|G0$NDL$j$K$J$C$F$7$^$&$H;W$$$^$9$,!#(J

$@!J$=$&(J$@8@$&0UL#$G$O!"$"$s$I!<$5$s$KBP$7$FC1$K?t$NO@M}$GGw$k$N$O!"$"$^$j(J
$@NI$/$J$$$H;W$&!#!#!#(J $@!K(J

--
                        OSHIKAWA , Masaki
                        OSHIKAWA@tkyvax.phys.s.u-tokyo.ac.jp		
                        Kohmoto Group at ISSP, Univ. of Tokyo