From: glenn@rightbrain.com (Glenn Reid)
Newsgroups: comp.sys.next.software
Subject: PasteUp vs PageMaker vs Quark (RTF)
Date: 3 Sep 92 06:36:15 GMT
Reply-To: glenn@rightbrain.com

While Glenn has been working hard to get the software out the door,  
others have been assembling this comparison.

If you'd like to know more, fire an email to reynolds@rightbrain.com  
because the reply address on this post is to Glenn's account, not  
mine.  He disabled my machine from posting (but was foolish enough to  
leave his machine logged in and unattended!).

jack

Feature Comparison

   Feature is available
    No feature or feature barely usable
	
Ease of use	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Takes advantage of NeXT platform: Display
PostScript, UNIX, true multitasking	 	 	 
Drag & drop Graphics: EPS, TIFF, Adobe
Illustrator , Adobe TouchType , FAX files	 	 	 
Drag & drop styles and color	 	 	 
Copy and paste attributes (scale, rotation, etc.)	 	  
	 
See-through graphics while positioning	 	 	 

Interface	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Multiple documents open at once	 	 	 
Unlimited undo and redo	 	 	 
View facing pages (spreads)	 	 	 
Size, position and scale items numerically	 	 	 
Color and style palettes	 	 	 
Document layout palette	 	 	 
Measurements palette	 	 	 
Magnify tool	 	 	 

Rulers, Units & Guides	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Measurements: picas, points, inches & metric	 	 	 
Master guides 	 	 	 
Snap-to guides	 	 	 
Snap-to ruler tickmarks	 	 	 
Fit in Window command centers page	 	 	 

Zooming & Scrolling	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Custom Zoom	 	 	 
Grabber hand	 	 	 
Zoom to marquee-dragged area	 	 	 
Center selection when zooming	 	 	 
Thumbnail views	 	 	 
Continuous redraw while scrolling	 	 	 

Graphic Objects	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Lines, boxes, ovals	 	 	 
Oval and polygonal graphic boxes	 	 	 
Arrowheads on lines	 	 	 
Custom arrowheads and dashes	 	 	 
Adjustable line weights,  lls, and tints	 	 	 
Custom line weights and percentage  lls	 	 	 
Assign different color/tint to line and  ll	 	 	 
Select items through placed graphics	 	 	 
See items while moving and scaling	 	 	 
Nudge items	  	 	 
Scale ovals and polygons proportionally	  	 	 
Alignment  and distribution	 	 	 
Grouping	 	 	 
Duplicate objects	  	 	 

Rotation, Skew & Scale	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Rotation	 	 	 
Skew	 	 	 
Rotate any object	 	 	 
Rotate to any degree	 	 	 
Directly edit rotated type	 	 	 
In-line graphics	 	 	 
Paragraph rules	 	 	 
Imported graphics	 	 	 
Color/grayscale image control	 	 	 

Color	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Spot-color separations	 	 	 
Process-color separations	 	 	 
Overprinting	 	 	 
Knockouts of EPS graphics	 	 	 
Automatic Trapping	 	 	 
Find and replace color	 	 	 

Document Construction	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Changes to master items on document pages	 	 	 
Insert and delete multiple pages	 	 	 
Text Flow and Autowrap	 	 	 
Multicolumn text boxes	 	 	 
Paragraph indents	 	 	 
Long documents (100+ pages)	 	 	 
Built-in management of imported  les	 	 	 

Text Handling	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Word processing	 	 	 
Find, change, and spell-check in layout view	 	 	 
Expand and collapse pages & page ranges	 	 	 
Spelling check	 	 	 
Built-in spell checking in multiple languages	 	 	 
User dictionaries editable as text	 	 	 
Same dictionary for spelling and hyphenation	 	 	 
Column layout and  ow	 	 	 
Column layout panel	 	 	 
Drag column links	 	 	 

Typographic Controls	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Pairwise-kerning and tracking	 	 	 
Kerning and tracking editors	 	 	 
Baseline shifts, superscripts, subscripts	 	 	 
Horizontal scaling of type	 	 	 
Automatic drop caps	 	 	 
Hyphenation and justi cation	 	 	 
Save and load H&J settings	 	 	 
Suggests hyphenation points	 	 	 
Ranked dictionary hyphenation	 	 	 
Leading grids, vertical alignment & justi cation	 	  
	 
Align paragraphs to leading grid	 	 	 
Vertical alignment and justi cation	 	 	 
Tabs	 	 	 
Change tab positions numerically	 	 	 
Table editor	 	 	 
Breaking and nonbreaking spaces, characters	 	 	 
Automatic hanging punctuation	 	 	 
Automatic smart quotes	 	 	 
Automatic ligature substitution	 	 	 
Automatic em- and en-dash substitution	 	 	 

Style Sheets	PasteUp	PageMaker	Quark
Style sheets	 	 	 
Styles with local formatting	 	 	 
See style applied to current paragraph	 	 	 
Keyboard shortcuts for styles	 	 	 
Merge styles	 	 	 

-
-
Jack Reynolds, VP Sales
RightBrain Software, 132 Hamilton Avenue, Palo Alto, California USA   
94301
(415)326-2974 or(415)326-2977 Fax
reynolds@rightbrain.com

-- NewsGrazer, a NeXTstep(tm) news reader, posting --
M>UQR=&8P7&%N<VE[7&9O;G1T8FQ<9C!<9FYI;"!4:6UE<RU2;VUA;CM<9C%<
M9G1E8V@@4WEM8F]L.UQF,EQF;6]D97)N($-O=7)I97([?0I<;6%R9VPQ,C`*
M7&UA<F=R,3(P"GM<8V]L;W)T8FQ<<F5D,%QG<F5E;C!<8FQU93`[?0I<<&%R
M9%QT>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@W.3(P7'1X.3,V,%QT
M>#$P,#@P7'1X,3`P.#!<='@Q,#,V,%QT>#$Q-3(P7&8P7&(P7&DP7'5L,%QF
M<S,V7&9C,"!7:&EL92!';&5N;B!H87,@8F5E;B!W;W)K:6YG(&AA<F0@=&\@
M9V5T('1H92!S;V9T=V%R92!O=70@=&AE(&1O;W(L(&]T:&5R<R!H879E(&)E
M96X@87-S96UB;&EN9R!T:&ES(&-O;7!A<FES;VXN7`I<"DEF('EO=2=D(&QI
M:V4@=&\@:VYO=R!M;W)E+"!F:7)E(&%N(&5M86EL('1O(')E>6YO;&1S0')I
M9VAT8G)A:6XN8V]M(&)E8V%U<V4@=&AE(')E<&QY(&%D9')E<W,@;VX@=&AI
M<R!P;W-T(&ES('1O($=L96YN)W,@86-C;W5N="P@;F]T(&UI;F4N("!(92!D
M:7-A8FQE9"!M>2!M86-H:6YE(&9R;VT@<&]S=&EN9R`H8G5T('=A<R!F;V]L
M:7-H(&5N;W5G:"!T;R!L96%V92!H:7,@;6%C:&EN92!L;V=G960@:6X@86YD
M('5N871T96YD960A*2Y<"EP*:F%C:PI<8EQI7&9S-#@@7`I<"D9E871U<F4@
M0V]M<&%R:7-O;EP*"EQF,5QB,%QI,%QF<S(P(%P*"EQF<S(T(*@*7&8P7&9S
M,C@@("`*7&D@1F5A='5R92!I<R!A=F%I;&%B;&4*7&DP(%P*"EQF,5QF<S(P
M(.`*7&8P7&9S,C@@("`@"EQI($YO(&9E871U<F4@;W(@9F5A='5R92!B87)E
M;'D@=7-A8FQE"EQI,"!<"@E<"@I<:5QF<S,V($5A<V4@;V8@=7-E"0I<9G,R
M,"!087-T955P"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!086=E36%K97(*7&DP7&9S
M,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%%U87)K"EQI,%QF<S(X(%P*5&%K97,@861V86YT86=E
M(&]F(`I<9G,R-"!."EQF<S(X(&4*7&9S,C0@6%0*7&9S,C@@('!L871F;W)M
M.B!$:7-P;&%Y7`I0;W-T4V-R:7!T+"`*7&9S,C0@54Y)6`I<9G,R."`L('1R
M=64@;75L=&ET87-K:6YG"EQF,5QF<S(P(`D*7&9S,C0@J`I<9G,R,"`)X`G@
M"EQF,%QF<S(X(%P*1')A9R`F(&1R;W`@1W)A<&AI8W,Z(`I<9G,R-"!%4%,*
M7&9S,C@@+"`*7&9S,C0@5$E&1@I<9G,R."`L($%D;V)E7`I);&QU<W1R871O
M<@I<9C%<9G,R-"#D"EQF,%QF<S(X("P@061O8F4@5&]U8VA4>7!E"EQF,5QF
M<S(T(.0*7&8P7&9S,C@@+"`*7&9S,C0@1D%8"EQF<S(X("!F:6QE<PD*7&8Q
M7&9S,C0@J`I<9G,R,B`)X`G@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($1R86<@)B!D
M<F]P('-T>6QE<R!A;F0@8V]L;W()"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S
M,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($-O<'D@86YD('!A<W1E
M(&%T=')I8G5T97,@*'-C86QE+"!R;W1A=&EO;BP@971C+BD)"EQF,5QF<S(T
M(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X
M(%-E92UT:')O=6=H(&=R87!H:6-S('=H:6QE('!O<VET:6]N:6YG"0I<9C%<
M9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"!<"@I<9C!<
M9G,R."!<"@I<:5QF<S,V($EN=&5R9F%C90I<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@
M4&%S=&55<`I<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@4&%G94UA:V5R"EQI,%QF<S(X
M(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!1=6%R:PI<:3!<9G,R."!<"DUU;'1I<&QE(&1O8W5M96YT
M<R!O<&5N(&%T(&]N8V4)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<
M9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%5N;&EM:71E9"!U;F1O(&%N9"!R
M961O"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R
M-"!<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!6:65W(&9A8VEN9R!P86=E<R`H<W!R96%D<RD)"EQF
M,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4VEZ92P@<&]S:71I;VX@86YD('-C
M86QE(&ET96US(&YU;65R:6-A;&QY"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF
M<S(X($-O;&]R(&%N9"!S='EL92!P86QE='1E<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<
M"@I<9C!<9G,R."!$;V-U;65N="!L87EO=70@<&%L971T90D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@
MJ`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($UE87-U<F5M96YT<R!P
M86QE='1E"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($UA9VYI9GD@=&]O
M;`D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%P*
M"EQI7&9S,S8@4G5L97)S+"!5;FET<R`F($=U:61E<PI<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI
M7&9S,C`@4&%S=&55<`I<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@4&%G94UA:V5R"EQI
M,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!1=6%R:PI<:3!<9G,R."!<"DUE87-U<F5M96YT
M<SH@<&EC87,L('!O:6YT<RP@:6YC:&5S("8@;65T<FEC"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H
M":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($UA<W1E<B!G=6ED97,@"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)
MJ%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%-N87`M=&\@9W5I9&5S"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)"EQF
M<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4VYA<"UT;R!R=6QE<B!T:6-K;6%R
M:W,)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"!<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!&
M:70@:6X@5VEN9&]W(&-O;6UA;F0@8V5N=&5R<R!P86=E"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H
M":@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@7`H*7&E<9G,S-B!:;V]M
M:6YG("8@4V-R;VQL:6YG"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!087-T955P"EQI
M,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!086=E36%K97(*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P
M(%%U87)K"EQI,%QF<S(X(%P*0W5S=&]M(%IO;VT)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF
M<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!'<F%B8F5R(&AA;F0)"EQF,5QF
M<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@6F]O;2!T;R!M87)Q=65E+61R86=G960@
M87)E80D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X
M($-E;G1E<B!S96QE8W1I;VX@=VAE;B!Z;V]M:6YG"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)
M"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@5&AU;6)N86EL('9I97=S"0I<
M9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@0V]N=&EN
M=6]U<R!R961R87<@=VAI;&4@<V-R;VQL:6YG"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R
M,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@7`H*7&E<9G,S-B!'<F%P:&EC($]B
M:F5C=',*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%!A<W1E57`*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<
M:5QF<S(P(%!A9V5-86ME<@I<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@475A<FL*7&DP
M7&9S,C@@7`I,:6YE<RP@8F]X97,L(&]V86QS"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*
M"EQF,%QF<S(X($]V86P@86YD('!O;'EG;VYA;"!G<F%P:&EC(&)O>&5S"0I<
M9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@07)R;W=H
M96%D<R!O;B!L:6YE<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*
M"EQF,%QF<S(X($-U<W1O;2!A<G)O=VAE861S(&%N9"!D87-H97,)"EQF,5QF
M<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF
M<S(X($%D:G5S=&%B;&4@;&EN92!W96EG:'1S+"`*7'!A<F1<='@Q,30P7'1X
M,C,P,%QT>#,T-#!<='@T-C`P7'1X-3<V,%QT>#8Y,#!<='@X,#8P7'1X.3(P
M,%QT>#$P,S8P7'1X,3$U,C!<9F,P(*X*7'!A<F1<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT
M>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-SDR,%QT>#DS-C!<='@Q,#`X,%QT>#$P,#@P7'1X
M,3`S-C!<='@Q,34R,%QF8S`@;&QS+"!A;F0@=&EN=',)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)
MJ`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@0W5S=&]M(&QI;F4@=V5I9VAT<R!A;F0@<&5R8V5N
M=&%G92`*7'!A<F1<='@Q,30P7'1X,C,P,%QT>#,T-#!<='@T-C`P7'1X-3<V
M,%QT>#8Y,#!<='@X,#8P7'1X.3(P,%QT>#$P,S8P7'1X,3$U,C!<9F,P(*X*
M7'!A<F1<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-SDR,%QT>#DS
M-C!<='@Q,#`X,%QT>#$P,#@P7'1X,3`S-C!<='@Q,34R,%QF8S`@;&QS"0I<
M9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@07-S:6=N
M(&1I9F9E<F5N="!C;VQO<B]T:6YT('1O(&QI;F4@86YD(`I<<&%R9%QT>#$Q
M-#!<='@R,S`P7'1X,S0T,%QT>#0V,#!<='@U-S8P7'1X-CDP,%QT>#@P-C!<
M='@Y,C`P7'1X,3`S-C!<='@Q,34R,%QF8S`@K@I<<&%R9%QT>#8T.#!<='@V
M-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@W.3(P7'1X.3,V,%QT>#$P,#@P7'1X,3`P
M.#!<='@Q,#,V,%QT>#$Q-3(P7&9C,"!L;`D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@
MX`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%-E;&5C="!I=&5M<R!T:')O=6=H('!L
M86-E9"!G<F%P:&EC<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*
M"EQF,%QF<S(X(%-E92!I=&5M<R!W:&EL92!M;W9I;F<@86YD('-C86QI;F<)
M"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"!<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!.=61G
M92!I=&5M<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J"`)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<
M9G,R."!38V%L92!O=F%L<R!A;F0@<&]L>6=O;G,@<')O<&]R=&EO;F%L;'D)
M"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@06QI
M9VYM96YT("!A;F0@9&ES=')I8G5T:6]N"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF
M,%QF<S(X($=R;W5P:6YG"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($1U
M<&QI8V%T92!O8FIE8W1S"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H(`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!<
M"@I<:5QF<S,V(%)O=&%T:6]N+"!3:V5W("8@4V-A;&4*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<
M:5QF<S(P(%!A<W1E57`*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%!A9V5-86ME<@I<
M:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@475A<FL*7&DP7&9S,C@@7`I2;W1A=&EO;@D*
M7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!3:V5W"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)
M"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4F]T871E(&%N>2!O8FIE8W0)
M"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*
M"EQF,%QF<S(X(%)O=&%T92!T;R!A;GD@9&5G<F5E"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<
M9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@1&ER96-T;'D@961I="!R;W1A
M=&5D('1Y<&4)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<
M9G,R."!);BUL:6YE(&=R87!H:6-S"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF
M<S(X(%!A<F%G<F%P:"!R=6QE<PI<9C%<9G,R-"`)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@
M":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($EM<&]R=&5D(&=R87!H:6-S"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H
M":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($-O;&]R+V=R87ES8V%L92!I;6%G92!C;VYT<F]L
M"0I<9C%<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!<"@I<:5QF<S,V
M($-O;&]R"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!087-T955P"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*
M7&E<9G,R,"!086=E36%K97(*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%%U87)K"EQI
M,%QF<S(X(%P*4W!O="UC;VQO<B!S97!A<F%T:6]N<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH
M":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!0<F]C97-S+6-O;&]R('-E<&%R871I;VYS"0I<9C%<
M9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@3W9E<G!R:6YT
M:6YG"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@
M2VYO8VMO=71S(&]F(`I<9G,R-"!%4%,*7&9S,C@@(&=R87!H:6-S"0I<9C%<
M9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@075T;VUA=&EC
M(%1R87!P:6YG"0I<9C%<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)
MJ%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($9I;F0@86YD(')E<&QA8V4@8V]L;W()"EQF,5QF<S(T
M(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X
M(%P*"EQI7&9S,S8@1&]C=6UE;G0@0V]N<W1R=6-T:6]N"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*
M7&E<9G,R,"!087-T955P"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!086=E36%K97(*
M7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%%U87)K"EQI,%QF<S(X(%P*0VAA;F=E<R!T
M;R!M87-T97(@:71E;7,@;VX@9&]C=6UE;G0@<&%G97,)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)
M"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!);G-E<G0@86YD(&1E;&5T
M92!M=6QT:7!L92!P86=E<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!4
M97AT($9L;W<@86YD($%U=&]W<F%P"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF
M<S(X($UU;'1I8V]L=6UN('1E>'0@8F]X97,)"EQF,5QF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@
M"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4&%R86=R87!H(&EN9&5N
M=',)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@3&]N9R!D;V-U;65N=',@
M*#$P,"L@<&%G97,I"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($)U:6QT
M+6EN(&UA;F%G96UE;G0@;V8@:6UP;W)T960@"EQP87)D7'1X,3$T,%QT>#(S
M,#!<='@S-#0P7'1X-#8P,%QT>#4W-C!<='@V.3`P7'1X.#`V,%QT>#DR,#!<
M='@Q,#,V,%QT>#$Q-3(P7&9C,""N"EQP87)D7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@V
M-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#<Y,C!<='@Y,S8P7'1X,3`P.#!<='@Q,#`X,%QT>#$P
M,S8P7'1X,3$U,C!<9F,P(&QE<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R
M."!<"@I<:5QF<S,V(%1E>'0@2&%N9&QI;F<*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P
M(%!A<W1E57`*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%!A9V5-86ME<@I<:3!<9G,R
M."`)"EQI7&9S,C`@475A<FL*7&DP7&9S,C@@7`I7;W)D('!R;V-E<W-I;F<)
M"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@1FEN9"P@8VAA;F=E+"!A;F0@
M<W!E;&PM8VAE8VL@:6X@;&%Y;W5T('9I97<)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R
M(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!%>'!A;F0@86YD(&-O;&QA<'-E('!A
M9V5S("8@<&%G92!R86YG97,)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@
M"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%-P96QL:6YG(&-H96-K"0I<
M9C%<9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($)U:6QT+6EN('-P96QL(&-H96-K
M:6YG(&EN(&UU;'1I<&QE(&QA;F=U86=E<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@
MX`I<9G,R-"`)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@57-E<B!D:6-T
M:6]N87)I97,@961I=&%B;&4@87,@=&5X=`D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@
MX`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%-A;64@9&EC=&EO;F%R>2!F;W(@<W!E
M;&QI;F<@86YD(&AY<&AE;F%T:6]N"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H":@)"EQF<S(R(.`*
M7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@0V]L=6UN(&QA>6]U="!A;F0@KV]W"0I<9C%<
M9G,R-""H":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($-O;'5M;B!L87EO=70@<&%N96P)"EQF
M,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@1')A9R!C;VQU;6X@;&EN:W,)"EQF
M,5QF<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!<"@I<:5QF
M<S,V(%1Y<&]G<F%P:&EC($-O;G1R;VQS"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!0
M87-T955P"EQI,%QF<S(X(`D*7&E<9G,R,"!086=E36%K97(*7&DP7&9S,C@@
M"0I<:5QF<S(P(%%U87)K"EQI,%QF<S(X(%P*4&%I<G=I<V4M:V5R;FEN9R!A
M;F0@=')A8VMI;F<)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@2V5R;FEN
M9R!A;F0@=')A8VMI;F<@961I=&]R<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)"EQF
M<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!"87-E;&EN92!S:&EF=',L('-U
M<&5R<V-R:7!T<RP@<W5B<V-R:7!T<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<
M9G,R."!(;W)I>F]N=&%L('-C86QI;F<@;V8@='EP90D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH
M":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!!=71O;6%T:6,@9')O<"!C87!S"0I<9C%<9G,R,B#@
M"EQF<S(T(`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($AY<&AE;F%T
M:6]N(&%N9"!J=7-T:0I<<&%R9%QT>#$Q-#!<='@R,S`P7'1X,S0T,%QT>#0V
M,#!<='@U-S8P7'1X-CDP,%QT>#@P-C!<='@Y,C`P7'1X,3`S-C!<='@Q,34R
M,%QF8S`@K@I<<&%R9%QT>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@W
M.3(P7'1X.3,V,%QT>#$P,#@P7'1X,3`P.#!<='@Q,#,V,%QT>#$Q-3(P7&9C
M,"!C871I;VX)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4V%V92!A;F0@
M;&]A9"!()DH@<V5T=&EN9W,)"EQF,5QF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@
M"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4W5G9V5S=',@:'EP:&5N871I;VX@<&]I
M;G1S"0I<9C%<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!286YK960@
M9&EC=&EO;F%R>2!H>7!H96YA=&EO;@D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH"0I<9G,R,B#@
M"EQF<S(T(%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X($QE861I;F<@9W)I9',L('9E<G1I8V%L(&%L
M:6=N;65N="`F(&IU<W1I"EQP87)D7'1X,3$T,%QT>#(S,#!<='@S-#0P7'1X
M-#8P,%QT>#4W-C!<='@V.3`P7'1X.#`V,%QT>#DR,#!<='@Q,#,V,%QT>#$Q
M-3(P7&9C,""N"EQP87)D7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT
M>#<Y,C!<='@Y,S8P7'1X,3`P.#!<='@Q,#`X,%QT>#$P,S8P7'1X,3$U,C!<
M9F,P(&-A=&EO;@D*7&8Q7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@
M06QI9VX@<&%R86=R87!H<R!T;R!L96%D:6YG(&=R:60)"EQF,5QF<S(R(.`*
M7&9S,C0@":@)J%P*"EQF,%QF<S(X(%9E<G1I8V%L(&%L:6=N;65N="!A;F0@
M:G5S=&D*7'!A<F1<='@Q,30P7'1X,C,P,%QT>#,T-#!<='@T-C`P7'1X-3<V
M,%QT>#8Y,#!<='@X,#8P7'1X.3(P,%QT>#$P,S8P7'1X,3$U,C!<9F,P(*X*
M7'!A<F1<='@V-#@P7'1X-C0X,%QT>#8T.#!<='@V-#@P7'1X-SDR,%QT>#DS
M-C!<='@Q,#`X,%QT>#$P,#@P7'1X,3`S-C!<='@Q,34R,%QF8S`@8V%T:6]N
M"0I<9C%<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)J%P*"EQF,%QF
M<S(X(%1A8G,)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@0VAA;F=E('1A
M8B!P;W-I=&EO;G,@;G5M97)I8V%L;'D)"EQF,5QF<S(T(*@)J`D*7&9S,C(@
MX`I<9G,R-"!<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!486)L92!E9&ET;W()"EQF,5QF<S(R(.`*
M7&9S,C0@":@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@0G)E86MI;F<@
M86YD(&YO;F)R96%K:6YG('-P86-E<RP@8VAA<F%C=&5R<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@
MJ`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!!=71O;6%T:6,@:&%N9VEN9R!P=6YC='5A=&EO
M;@D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`D*7&9S,C(@X`I<9G,R-"`)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@
M7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@075T;VUA=&EC('-M87)T('%U;W1E<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@
MJ`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!!=71O;6%T:6,@;&EG871U<F4@<W5B<W1I='5T
M:6]N"0I<9C%<9G,R-""H"0I<9G,R,B#@"EQF<S(T(`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@
M075T;VUA=&EC(&5M+2!A;F0@96XM9&%S:"!S=6)S=&ET=71I;VX)"EQF,5QF
M<S(T(*@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@"0I<9G,R,B#@7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@7`H*
M7&E<9G,S-B!3='EL92!3:&5E=',*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%!A<W1E
M57`*7&DP7&9S,C@@"0I<:5QF<S(P(%!A9V5-86ME<@I<:3!<9G,R."`)"EQI
M7&9S,C`@475A<FL*7&DP7&9S,C@@7`I3='EL92!S:&5E=',)"EQF,5QF<S(T
M(*@)J`FH7`H*7&8P7&9S,C@@4W1Y;&5S('=I=&@@;&]C86P@9F]R;6%T=&EN
M9PD*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!3964@<W1Y;&4@87!P;&EE
M9"!T;R!C=7)R96YT('!A<F%G<F%P:`D*7&8Q7&9S,C0@J`FH":A<"@I<9C!<
M9G,R."!+97EB;V%R9"!S:&]R=&-U=',@9F]R('-T>6QE<PD*7&8Q7&9S,C(@
MX`I<9G,R-"`)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":A<"@I<9C!<9G,R."!-97)G92!S
M='EL97,)"EQF,5QF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@":@)"EQF<S(R(.`*7&9S,C0@7`H*
M7&8P7&9S,C@@7`H*7'!A<F1<='@Q-S(X7'1X,S0U-EQT>#4Q.#1<='@V.3$R
M7'1X.#8T,%QT>#$P,S8X7'1X,3(P.35<='@Q,S@R-%QT>#$U-34R7'1X,3<R
M.#!<9C)<9G,S-EQF8S`@+5P*+5P*2F%C:R!297EN;VQD<RP@5E`@4V%L97-<
M"E)I9VAT0G)A:6X@4V]F='=A<F4L(#$S,B!(86UI;'1O;B!!=F5N=64L(%!A
M;&\@06QT;RP@0V%L:69O<FYI82!54T$@(#DT,S`Q7`HH-#$U*3,R-BTR.3<T
M(&]R*#0Q-2DS,C8M,CDW-R!&87A<"G)E>6YO;&1S0')I9VAT8G)A:6XN8V]M
#"GT*
`
Newsgroups: comp.sys.next.software