From: yadallee@ersys.edmonton.ab.ca (Dave Shariff Yadallee)
Newsgroups: can.politics,soc.culture.british,soc.culture.australian
Subject: Re: Do we really need the monarchy?
Date: Sat, 12 Dec 92 07:36:36 MST
Organization: Edmonton Remote Systems #1, Edmonton, AB, Canada

WARNING !! NUCLEAR EXCHANGES BETWEEN MONARCHISTS AND REPO RE?PUBLICANS HIGH
PROBABLE IN THE NEXT FEW DAYS!!!

Andy <2893684@QUCDN.QueensU.CA> writes:

- In article <gPBmVB4w165w@ersys.edmonton.ab.ca>, yadallee@ersys.edmonton.ab.ca
- (Dave Shariff Yadallee) says:
- >
- >Andy <2893684@QUCDN.QueensU.CA> writes:
- >
- >
- >  Excuse me, but do you want to end like the USA?  The monarchy is NOT
- >anachronistic!!  If you ever hear of the Ismailis, they have a monarchy of
- >its own, nemevolent in nature, philanthropic and very nice people!!
-
- Is this the best you can do? We should keep a British Queen as not to be
- american. Personally, I think official bilingualism does a lot more to
- distinguish us from the Yanks than paying allegiance to a foreign soverign

  Froeign Sovereign?  I BEG YOUR PARDON.  Since when did Canada's indigenous
population were made up of white-people?  And on on whose model of government
has Canada based itself on?  THE BRITISH !!  You seem to ignore the fact that
Canada's government culture in BASED ON THE BRITISH parliament.  Canada was in
fact the Loyalist answer to a Nation in North America!! You are forgetting what
is historically and fundamental Canada.

-
-
-
- >-
- >   Easy, there is TOO MUCH power in the hands of the government, but then
- >again
- >Conservatives parties have been under the 'guidance' of the USA, hence must
-
- How is this relevant to the UK government not consulting the commonwealth?

  Excuse me, but are you aware that Margaret Thatcher, Brian Mulroney and other
Commonwealth Conservative leaders seemed to dance to a pied piper by the name
of Ronald Reagan?

- >our disasters can be attributed to that! Time and time again, I have propose
- >a
- >representative government that would be directly responible to God, Queen an
- >country on a VERY LARGE SCALE! It is time to consider who our friends are!!
-
- I'm sorry, you aren't answering the question at all, you are responding to
- an argument which has not only not been made but is completely irrelevent to
- the issue of commonwealth consultation. Again, if she is OUR Queen as much as
- she is Britain's, why do Canadians have no say on the succession?

  Try this one.  the reason the British Empire fell was that only England,
Scotalnd, Wales and Ireland, when it was part of GB, were the only ones
represented in Parliament.  No Canadian, Australian, India, Zealander sat in
Westminister, which I take issue with!!
  In case you missed it, Canadians, Australians, anybody who has Her Majesty
as Head of State, IS consulted! That was definitely the case 56 years age when
Edward 8th abdicated the throne.  IT depends on whether or not Parliament OR
the Privy Council addreses it and if the media CARES to report this!!

Andy, I suggest you go back and re-read what is Canada, or even British north
America before posting again!!

Rosemary Waigh, I said God, Queen and country, NOT JUST God and Queen!! you can
not seperate 2 from the 3rd element.  In other words, these are mutually
INCLUSIVE!

- >
- >REMOVE REPUBLICANISM FULLY !!
- >
- >Dave Shariff Yadallee (B. Sc. (Econ/Math) (U of Alberta 1990) )
- > (yadallee@ersys.edmonton.ab.ca, userLIBE@mts.ucs.ualberta.ca)
- >God Save the Queen, God Bless us All! Remember! Jesus Saves!!
- >Happy Christmas and Merry New Year to One and All - John Lennon

  That still stands.

Addressing the issue of Henry 8.  He as founder of the Church of england did
permit divorce.  Even there, I do believe that a divorce king should not be at
issue.

Addressing furthur the issue of Edward 8.  It was KNOWN in circle that none of
the British upper echelon would want him as king!  German sympathizer the
politicos said, unreligious the CofE said, hence he WAS secretly put away as
cleanly as possible.

Au Quebecois, la REine Elisabeth II peut parler bien le francais.  On l'a vu
pendant la fete du Canada.

Dave Shariff Yadallee (B. Sc. (Econ/Math) (U of Alberta 1990) )
 (yadallee@ersys.edmonton.ab.ca, userLIBE@mts.ucs.ualberta.ca)
God Save the Queen, God Bless us All! Remember! Jesus Saves!!
Happy Christmas and Merry New Year to One and All - John Lennon