From: debchat@vax2.concordia.ca (DEB CHATTERJEE)
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian
Subject: Re: Deb Chatterjee a "commie"? (was Re: West Bengal : Taking the Bull
Date: 13 Aug 92 23:44:42 GMT

Summary:  
Date: 13 Aug 1992 19:48 -0500
Distribution: usa
Keywords:  
Organization: Concordia University
News-Software: VAX/VMS VNEWS 1.41    

In article <SHUBU.92Aug11145242@oporto.cs.utexas.edu>, shubu@cs.utexas.edu 
(Shubhendu Sekhar Mukherjee) writes...
>>>>>> In article <BssD3q.9nG@news.udel.edu>, cobra@chopin.udel.edu 
(Jay Bhartkumar Patel) writes: ...... [deleted] .......
>.........[deleted] .......
>I might have missed something on this intelligence service.  Mr.Chatterjee
>- are you implying a secret service police force?  If so, then ...

 Yessir ! I DID ascribe to a stronger RAW than now. There are several valid
 reasons for that. Moreover, I must add that Communism is the worst menace to
 any society. Aside the diatribes and `cat-callings' of a group of obfuscating
 `proletariats', and, who are proselytes of a lesser god called Dr.Karl Marx,I
 strongly opine that Communist parties must be `kept' under survellaince for
 6-7 years. (I have replied why it should be so to one Mr.Amit Gupta who said
 that I was a communist ! Anyway, I think that Mr.Gupta has learnt the tactics
 from the defunct Gang of Four (China, 1973 ?) - to falsely accuse people.) 

 Since the worst philosophy (theoretical and implementation) that have filled
 the pages of the libraries of Columbia, Yale, Harvard, Stanford, Princeton, MIT
 and Cambridge (U.K) was written by an educated guy called Dr.Karl Marx (no more
 intelligent than Joachim Carlo Santos Martillo Ajami), I think that all the
 proponents of that stupid philosophy must chill out ! Dr.Engels had also been
 no better; actually the latter conjured it up with his bearded drinking-buddy
 Dr.Karl Marx to propose an incomplete, moronic theory which based on wrong
 mathematical economic models yields a mode to justify the oppression of humans
 throughout the world. I did not propose anything along that line. In fact, as I
 still maintain, something along the line of Lee of Singapore must be 
 implemented soon enough to end the feudal system in India. The impact of this
 stupid philosophy (Communism) has been what I saw in Vijaywada. Rich Kammas and
 Reddys (NO OFFENCE PLEASE !) are STAUNCH members of the CPI ! What a joke ! 
 This bullshit, fucked up philosophy must be trashed once for all, and, the book
 " Dialectics of Nature " -- Freddie Engels (with notes by J.B.S Haldane) should
 serve as an example of how a morally corrupt, opportunist `philosopher' like
 Freddie Engels, after consuming bottles of Deutsch beer, could write. There has
 been several immoral acts in this world. The worst is the case of Rasputin and
 another one of them is the formulation of a nicely packaged garbage called the
 " Dialectics of Nature ". From a completely theoretical level, one can argue
 following Schrodinger's arguments, place of man in society and his relations
 to science, that Engels's Dialectics was purposely never revised - under the 
                                          =========
 directions of Josef Stalin. 

 In a feudal system, as in India, Communist parties have ALWAYS been revisionist
 and the reports of Bhatinda (CPI) and Vijaywada (CPI(M)) congresses reveal this
 fact. In the Vijaywada congress (CPI(M)) politburo members Harkishen Singh
 Surjeet and B.T.Randive both acknowledged that Indira Gandhi (a reactionary as
 according to Pramode Dasgupta) as a possible model who could be taken as a
 `friend' of the party ! Many commis will give a sheepish grin when being
 reminded of this. Thus, a politically immoral and incompetent party should be
 declared illegal right away ! What's wrong with that ?? In West Bengal whatever
 logic some people like Deepak Srivastava may give, NO PROGRESS HAS BEEN SEEN.
 It is 15 years since 1977, and, I think that these red-ants are going to enter
 their fort (Alimuddin Street) right away even in the next election. Why ? (The
 Cong(I) party in W.B is no better, because Subrata Mukherjee (INTUC leader) is
 on the payroll of the CPI(M)). In view of parties like Cong(I), CPI(M), Janata
 etc., I propose an end to ALL democratic system in this country (INDIA) for 20
 years, and, implement a Lee of Singapore type rule. Let present P.V. Rao and
 his chosen ones takeover, what's so catastrophic about it ?

 My main point: WHY PROSTITUTE WITH DEMOCRACY WHEN PEOPLE ARE NOT WORTH IT ?

 My question: WHY COMMUNISM IS CONSIDERED AS A VIABLE ALTERNATIVE - WHEN IT IS
              BASED ON BANKRUPT PRINCIPLES - THAT DO NOT WORK ?

 My hypothesis: RAW (Research Analytical Wing) must be given more power to 
                improve the law-and-order situation in India, and, keep a good
                watch on the separatist and Communist parties/ organizations. It
                WILL improve the conditions within the country. 


   Am I proposing something unfair ? Is the general consensus is that India be
   divided and broken up into pieces - just as you break a bottle of baby oil ?

> 
>Luck!
>-Shubu

- FLAMES from immoral commis of the U.S ?

          deb chatterjee
        (a good samaritan)
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian