From: debchat@vax2.concordia.ca (DEB CHATTERJEE)
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian
Subject: Re: Deb Chatterjee a "commie"? (was Re: West Bengal :
Date: 12 Aug 92 20:43:27 GMT

Summary:  
Date: 12 Aug 1992 16:47 -0500
Distribution: usa
Keywords:  
Organization: Concordia University
News-Software: VAX/VMS VNEWS 1.41    

In article <23418@alice.att.com>, amit@research.att.com (Amit Gupta) writes...
>This was an interesting email from "the commie-killer". Kinda neat that most of
>his recommendations/suggestions are what an average capitalist would expect 
>from
>a typical communist govt (like the ex-Soviet Union, or China).. keep reading.
> 
>comments welcome. flames will be ignored, as usual
> 
>-amit
>amit@research.att.com
> 
 I respond to Amit Gupta's rhetorics - "substitute Communism ====> Captitalism
 and then solve the resultant equation." I assert that Amit makes a lot of 
 mumbo-jumbo and his most stupid remarks go to show that he is ignorant as a 
 good "commie" of Bengal. 

 It is needless to say that when one sees that Communism surviving in a totally
 feudal country like India, then what is the `value' of communism ? Capitalism
 and Communism, themselves being `enemies' of each other, individually oppose a
 feudal system. Feudal system always has a multi-level/ multi-strata and the 
 very "divide-and-rule" approach in maintaining law-and-order/ justice in the
 system. People are classified according to race, or, any form distinction that
 is suitable to the feudal landlords/ merchants to oppress the poor. In Andhra,
 Vijaywada, one has to see CPI leaders - who are rich farmers :-). Moreover in
 another sense, if we look at the Communist rulers in West Bengal, we see a good
 number of them being Moslems. As I know, Al-Qur'an dictates very strictly that
 everybody Moslems, MUST submit to the Supreme Will of Allah (God). Now, I know
 that Mohd.Shahidullah (CPI(M) party member) is at the same time beilever in the
 Marxist theory, and, a devout Moslem. The two are contradictory. Marxism - as
 has been propounded by Engels and Marx abhors belief in the Order of Divinity.
 (Mao Tse Tung's Cultural Revolution - Great Leap Forward - is another example
 where Chairman Mao banned ALL religious organizations, teachings of Confucius,
 and Buddha. Goes to show that Communism really neglects the Order of Divinity.)
 Coming back to my original point, political figures like Shahidullah occur in
 communist parties, because the intellectual bankruptcy of the Communist party
 is BOUND TO OCCUR in a strong feudal country (India). These (basically anti-
 religion) parties, have often been strange bedfellows to staunch religious
 groups. The Communist parties have revised their stands so much that one will
 only laugh, when Joyti Basu attempts to justify the wrong-doings of all his
 party's goons based on `Marxist' theories ! Such trends are seen only in feudal
 societies. In the famous Shahbanu case, in 1985, CPI(M) started to support the
 Supreme Court's decision, but, due to `internal party pressure' from that great
 Kalimuddin Shams (Forward Bloc, MLA), it suddenly withdrew its stand. This was
 the effect of `democracy'. This `democratic' system must die. To do that one
 needs to keep the country (of 850 million) under a strict laws. I had proposed
 changes to the effect that `Lee of Singapore' type government be implemented.
 (I however do not know each and every detail of the government there, and, such
 details can readily be furnished by many other people.) 

 In fact Communist parties must be declared illegal in India, because, these 
 parties contribute nothing except to breed intellectual/ moral degradation and
 economic disaster. Looking back at what CPI(M) has done to West Bengal for the
 past 15 years, one can only do nothing but to support my comments on Communism.
 Amit Guptas must realize that their lukewarm approach towards capitalism is a
 significant result of the dishonesty amongst commis - particularly in India. As
 and example, Amit Guptas will be in U.S to get the western education, but, when
 their material needs are satisfied, they will start criticizing the U.S system
 (or a pro-Lee of Singapore system) without batting an eyelid. 

 Thus Communist parties must be banned for good. This is to say that the mode of
 attacking the enemy is best done by proceeding along the enemy's offensive.

> since you asked for flames..
> 
>* FLAME ON *
> Panchatantra: "a smart enemy is better than a foolish friend".
>* FLAME OFF*

 I admit that I am a fool, but, I shall never be your's or any IPSG's friend .

 - deb chatterjee
(a good samaritan)
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian