From: ph9991_manfr@rivers.acc.uwrf.edu
Newsgroups: rec.arts.drwho
Subject: The Valeyard Explained
Date: 10 Jan 93 16:20:05 -0600
Organization: University of Wisconsin - River Falls


If it seems I'm taking this Valeyard argument rather personally, it's
because his origins play a key role in the novel I'm developing for
Virgin's New Adventures novels.  
There is an explanation for the Valeyard that makes complete sense and
contradicts nothing on screen or nothing we can imagine.  If you think
of something as you read this, tell the net and let me know because I do
want to get this absolutely right.  I've been over this before on the Net,
and so far my theories seem pretty watertight.  

Before I plung in to this story, I'll say it one more time:  
the word was "incarnation."  

Right.


"THE TRIAL AND THE VALEYARD: EXPLAINED!"

Once upon a time there was an advanced civilization in the constellation
of Andromeda.  Someone there knew of the existence of Gallifrey, the Time
Lords, and of the Time Lords' vast repository of knowledge; an almost
ethereal information network called the Matrix.  
Someone there also knew there was much profit to be had from stealing 
information from the Matrix, so they decided to steal.

However, these someones also knew that eventually, the Time Lords would be
able to trace the leak from the Matrix, and so they decided to work from
another location other than Andromeda, in order to protect their home.
They chose Earth for reasons known only to them, and there appears to be
three principal persons who were nicking the information and data, known
henceforth as they were known in the Trial, the Three Sleepers.

Sure enough, the Time Lords do eventually trace the leak, and decide to
pull the Earth and its solar system (not to mention the entire constellation)
two light years off its original heading, causing a solar fireball that
nearly destroys the Earth.  Or rather, the High Council of the Time Lords
does this using the Magnetron.  This is not public knowledge, for it violates
every non-intervention rule the Time Lords have, not to mention near-genocide.
This was strictly covert and secret.  
The Sleepers, meanwhile, figure out a way to save some of their efforts
by setting up a survival chamber for themselves monitored by an L3 robot.
Unfortunately for them, the robot mission sent to recover them couldn't find
the Earth now it was off course, and thus the Sleepers were never picked up.
However, the secrets they stole from the Matrix were still intact in the
form of a memory tape, also guarded by the L3 robot.  
Various nefarious money-grubbers tried to steal the secrets over the next
500 years, none succeeding.  

Then one day, the Doctor arrived.
He and Peri stumble onto "The Mysterious Planet" and discover some of the
happenings there, such as the Earth being moved off course.  What they
don't find out is who did this and what was in a particular box that
Glitz and Dibber were interested in.  
However, the seeds of curiosity were planted in the Doctor....

...The Doctor's curiosity can be very dangerous to those in who the Doctor
is curious about.  The High Council of the Time Lords knows this very well
indeed.  The Doctor had stumbled on their secret handiwork, and although
he didn;t know the full story yet, there was too much of a chance that
he someday would, or that someone hearing of his visit someday would.  
Therefore, the Council decided to save themselves there and then before it
got any further out of hand.  
Simply killing the Doctor would be very conspicuous to any of this Council's
political enemies, so that was not done.  
The best way to handle him, they decided, was to discredit him and at the
same time tie his name to the whole Earth/Ravolox affair.  This way, should
anyone in the future look into what happened on Earth, they would hear
"well, the Doctor visited there a lot and was put on Trial for it," and 
probably end their investigations there.
As the Master would later say, they Council was making a scapegoat of the
Doctor to conceal their own involcement.  
The best way to discredit him was indeed to put him on Trial for breaking
the First Law of Time, the non-intervention directive, and get him convicted
and executed.  To make the Trial look even better, the Supreme Guardians
of the Law would try the case, i.e. the most upstanding Time Lords on
Gallifrey.  This way a guilty verdict could never be questioned.  

They still needed to convict him though.  They know from experience that
the Doctor is a rather formidable enemy, especially in purely intellectual
challenges, which is all a trial ever is, so they need to have someone
prosecuting the case who really knows his stuff, and who really knows the
Doctor inside and out, making him or her able to predict the Doctor's
reactions to certain strategies.  
Who better to prosecute the Doctor than the Doctor himself?

At this point, the Council did one of two things unexplained in the series:
1) they contacted the already existing Valeyard and dealed with him or
2) they actually constructed the Valeyard and dealed with him then.
I think the second option is the far more likely one  by a process of 
elimination, and also based on dialog the Master has.  
I eliminate the first possibility because it would constitute an interference
in history which is too dangerous to the Valeyard to risk. 
Many have asked the question, "Why was he going after the Doctor's 
regenerations?  He'd kill himself because the Doctor would never live to
number twelve."  I agree with this question.  It doesn't make sense.
Therefore the Valeyard is not *directly* from the Doctor's future.
But he still is in a way.  Arguments supporting reason two may help to 
understand this better.  
The Master has the following lines in "The Ultimate Foe":
from Part One:  "The Valeyard is an amalgamation of the darker sides of your
		nature, somewhere between your twelfth and final incarnation."
from Part Two:  "But the Valeyard, a distillation of all that is evil in you,
		a composite of your every dark thought is a different
		proposition."
The words "amalgamation," "distillation," and "composite" all indicate, to
me at least, that the Master means the Valeyard was created by someone, some
outside force.  The Valeyard is not a natural phenomena.
What I think he is is a prediction by the Matrix of the Doctor's "phased"
form between his Twelfth and Thirteenth selves.  The "phase" I speak of
is similar to the Watcher seen in "Logopolis," or of Cho-je in "Planet
of the Spiders."  Cho-je in particular, because although he was a projection
from K'Anpo's mind, he did seem to be able to operate quite independently
of K'Anpo, until the moment of regeneration of course.
I think the High Council chose to create a Doctor of their own to prosecute
this case.  They used the Matrix to envision what the Doctor would be like
between his Twelfth and Thirteenth selves, and then told it to distill out
all the good qualities, leaving only an evil Doctor.  
They chose the 12-13 phase because this Doctor would not have any
regenerations of his own, and thus that is something they could and did use
to bargain for his co-operation.  Also, a future phase had to be used
to prevent destabilizing the present Doctor.  There is also the great
side benefit of having the most experienced Doctor possible prosecuting
the case, i.e. this is the oldest one.  
Additionally, if the Valeyard is indeed a "child of the Matrix," then he
of all people would be best able to alter the evidence from the Matrix,
and this also explains why he was so easily able to set up his dreamscape
within it in "The Ultimate Foe."  
This also explains why he survived the Particle Diseminator in "Foe."
he is only a phased Doctor, a projection of the Matrix.  How do you kill
or diseminate something that doesn't really exist?  

Once they conjured up the Valeyard, they had to make a deal with him
because he does have free will of his own.  They offered him the remainder
of the Doctor's regenerations and evidence-adjustment help in return for
prosecuting the Doctor in the Trial.
The Valeyard accepted, but for his own reasons, not the Council's.
The Valeyard did not trust the Council to honor their side of the bargain
and made preparation to cement his own existence himself.  
When the Trial collapsed (thanks to the Master), the Valeyard abandoned
his previous plans and cut right to the chase to get the Doctor's
regenerations by ring him into his Matrix dreamscape.
He gets the Doctor to sign the paper that will surrender the regenerations,
and then must convince the Doctor WHILE HE'S INSIDE THE MATRIX that he's
dead.  If you can convince someone they're dead while they are only 
existing in mind, then they are indeed dead.  Thus, the reason for the
quicksand bit at the end of Part One of "Foe," and for the bogus Trial
in Part Two of "Foe."  
I think the previous plan would have involved the point before execution
where the Doctor's memories would have been dumped into the Matrix, as is
done with all near-deceased Time Lords, but would have been easier for
the Valeyard to win because the Doctor would have been really due to die.
AS it was , the Valeyard needed to kill the Doctor within the Matrix in
order to inherit the remaining lives of the Sixth Doctor.  
The Valeyard also wants the Doctor destroyed to unfetter himself from the
Doctor's side of his existence.
If you still don't believe all this, listen to the Valeyard's words himself:
The Doctor asks the Valeyard why he wants the Doctor dead, and the Valeyard
replies:
"Come now Doctor, how else can I obtain my freedom?  Operate as a complete
entity?.... Only by ridding myself of you can I be free."
And as I've said before, this freedom was going to include the six unused
lives of the Doctor.  
And not only that, but it was also going to include control of Gallifrey!
And here's how...
The Valeyard was going to blow the whistle on the Council right after the
Trial, neatly arranging their deposement.  At the same time, he would sick
the Diseminator on the assembled Trial jurors, taking out all the good guys
on Gallifrey and the Keeper of the Matrix.  This would leave no one left
with control over the Matrix, except for the Valeyard himself since the
Doctor is already at one with the Matrix after "The Invasion of Time."
(something not forgotten in another story too, "Arc of Infinity.")
He would then reclaim his title to the Presidency, and with his control
of the Matrix, the Time Lords would have to agree to his demands.

The Master threw a spanner in the works, which in a way saved the Valeyard
some work.  He already got the Council deposed for him, leaving only the
Trialists and the Doctor to deal with.  The Master's ambitions were easily
put out of the way with a boobytrap in the form of the Limbo Atrophier  

A further spanner was thrown in the works when the Valeyard found the 
Doctor to be a bit more difficult to trick into suicide than he had originally
thought, in both the case of the quicksand and the fake Trial.  
He also didn't anticipate the Doctor spotting the Popplewick disguise. 
And he didn't think the Doctor could unravel the Diseminator.

The Valeyard had been doing quite a number and pulling all the right strings
during the Trial (such as the faked death of Peri, getting the Doctor to
explode into outbursts, not to mentioning altering the evidence), but
he hadn't prepared adaquately for when the Doctor was able to do the same
in the Matrix.

However, the Valeyard survived the Diseminator, simply because of the
nature of his incomplete existence.  He somehow escaped the Matrix, killed
the Keeper, and took his clothes as a disguise until he could get off
the station.

What he's up to these days is anyone's guess.  I imagine he might have
tried to stop the Inquisitor's election to the Presidency.  It's also
dangerous to think about what he might be doing with the Hand of Omega
and/or the Silver Nemesis now that the Doctor has sent them back to Gallifrey.
The Valeyard would be able to "remember" where on Gallifrey they had been
sent...

However, I believe his unsatisfactory existence is his number one priority.
He still wants to be complete, and indeed his continued existence may be
threatened if the new High Council ever figures out how to make the Matrix
"cancel" its prediction of his existence.   
I'll stop here, and hopefully if my book ever gets published (or even
finished for that matter), you'll find out how I think he'd go about it.
Suffice it to say that I truly want to make him the Ultimate Foe.
...he's going to be very, very nasty....



Steven.K.Manfred
 




Newsgroups: rec.arts.drwho