From: debchat@vax2.concordia.ca (DEB CHATTERJEE)
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian
Subject: Re: Rapists on the payroll of CPI(M).
Keywords: Amit Gupta - traducer
Date: 26 Jul 92 19:58:00 GMT
Distribution: na
Organization: Concordia University
News-Software: VAX/VMS VNEWS 1.41

In article <23303@alice.att.com>, amit@alice.UUCP () writes... [in response to
Aditi Sen's and my previous postings]

 Note my `inflammatory' reply will only refer to points categorized by Amit.
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
>1. Guilt & Identity : Actually there should be no protection for rapists. In
    ================   
    Calcutta these rapists were definitely on the payroll of the CPI(M),because
    , dragging the woman by her hair and then raping her inside the Lake in 
    presence of her friend who was tied to a post, is ONLY possible if those 
    rapists had CPI(M) backing. The police should, in the ideal case, have 
    arrested them and put them behind bars. The question of judicial inquiry is
    irrelevant - because they are rapists. This incident is possible only in a
    Communist State. Cong(I) were rascals, but, the Bantala and the Rabindra 
    Sarobar incident are real examples of CPI(M) atrocities.

>2. Wife-sister-mother, woman, every cell in the body : Amit is really very 
    ==================================================
   insensitive here. He cannot face the gravity of the question posed by Aditi.
   Thus, he is obfuscating - avoiding the real issue. 

>3. Human rights of the victim : Obfuscating again ! Human beings at least in
    ===========================
    Calcutta, DO NOT simply call anybody rapist ! Thus the general public
    " teaching them a lesson "  seems most appropriate here - Bantala and the
    Rabindra Sarobar case. I would take away ALL human rights of a criminal -
    as rapist, once proven to be guilty.  

>4. Rocket scientist, hooligans, police protection etc etc : Looks like Amit
    =======================================================
    Gupta has only learnt how to lie. I am not sure, but, seems that Amit is
    one of those persons affected by RSS(*) virus. To explain my point, no
    hooligan/ lynchmob etc. CAN EXIST WITHOUT the support of the local political
    party. Thus Amit's statement is absolutely false and he knows it. What I
    have stated happened since the times of Dr.B.C.Roy till date. Thus, when a
    rape is committed, and, police officers of BOTH Lake and Tollygunge police
    stations REFUSE file a FIR, the onus is on the major ruling party - which is
    the CPI(M). The same happened with the Bantala incident.

>5. Debjani Basik, relevance of human rights to our society : In the Debjani 
    =========================================================
    Banik case, the Baniks murdered that poor woman, burnt her body, and, then
    got away with it because of the lawyer Somnath Chatterjee - CPI(M) member !
    The level of corruption spread by the CPI(M) in ALL forms of civic life is
    unthinkable.

>6. CPM, CongI, no alternatives : The privileges of democracy exist only for
    ============================
    civilized, right-thinking individuals. Not for societies where rapists are
    allowed to go scot-free in the name of `political amnesty'. The democratic
    rights conferred upon any individual demands that he/ she act in accord with
    the established norms in a civilized society. In short: live and let live.
    However, CPI(M) has established: Die and let rapists live. 

    My honest demand/ suggestion: LET CPI(M) GOVERNMENT BE DE-STABILIZED AND
                                  POWER BE RETURNED TO THE PRESIDENT, TILL
                                  CONDUCIVE CIRCUMSTANCES EXIST TO CALL IN FOR
                                  A FRESH ELECTION. LET ALSO, COMMUNIST PARTIES
                                  BE BANNED IN CONTESTING THE ELECTIONS.


> Well-reasoned follow-ups welcome. Flames will be ignored, as usual.
> 
> -amit
> Amit Gupta

 - deb chatterjee
(a good samaritan)