From: kachun@astro.as.arizona.edu (Ka Chun Yu)
Newsgroups: sci.skeptic
Subject: Re: n
Date: 30 Jul 92 21:22:51 GMT
Organization: University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ

Since my joke posting on the Weekly World News's handling of UFOs, I've
received an extremely long mailing from a UFO addict .  It consists
of a list of must read books for those who wish "to join the debate
about the reality of the saucers."  A quick perusal of the list can
give one an idea of where this person's beliefs lie.

However I'd like to see the sci.skeptic gurus comment on these works,
specifically if many of these tomes have been debunked and where.  

>
>UFO Books -- The Serious Literature
>Compiled by [name deleted]
>[Please pass this list along intact to anyone who wants a copy.]
[stuff deleted]
>
>Berlitz, Charles and William L. Moore. The Roswell Incident. New 
>York: Grosset & Dunlap, 1980. 168pp. ISBN 0-448-21199-8.  The 
>facts about the crash of a saucer in the summer of 1947 in New 
>Mexico and how the US government covered it up.
>
>Bowen, Charles, ed.  The Humanoids. Chicago: Henry Regnery, 1969. 
>256pp.  LC 77-126142. Good summary of the evidence compiled from 
>material published in the British Flying Saucer Review magazine.
>
>Blum, Howard.  Out There: The GovernmentUs Secret Quest for 
>Extraterrestrials. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1990. 300pp.  ISBN 
>0-671-66260-0.  An important book since it is written by a former 
>NY Times reporter who has written two other influential books -- 
>one about Nazi intelligence officers brought to America illegally 
>after WWII and the other about the Walker spy case.  However, 
>BlumUs UFO book was apparently hastily done and, thus, somewhat of 
>a disappointment in the UFO research community.
>
>Bullard, Thomas Edward.  UFO Abductions: The Measure of a Mystery. 
>Vol. 1: Comparative Study of Abduction Reports.  (Bloomington, IND): 
>Fund for UFO Research, 1987. 402pp.  This study by a PhD folklorist 
>is must reading for anyone wanting to understand the depth and 
>breadth of the abduction enigma. Bullard concludes UFO abduction 
>stories are much too internally consistent down to small details to 
>be classed as traditional folklore or typical dream material.
>
>Butler, Brenda, Dot Street, and Jenny Randles.  Sky Crash: A Cosmic 
>Conspiracy. Sudbury, Great Britain: Neville Spearman, 1984. 283pp.  
>ISBN 85435-155-8. Review and analysis of the facts in the British 
>Bentwaters-Rendlesham RAFB case.
>
>Clark, Jerome. The UFO Encyclopedia, Volume 1: UFOs in the 1980s. 
>Detroit, MI: Apogee Books, 1990. 234pp.  ISBN 1-55888-301-0. This 
>encyclopedia is mostly the author's tour de force, but still delivers 
>valuable information not easily available elsewhere.  Libraries 
>should have this.
>
>Clark, Jerome.  The UFO Encyclopedia, Volume 2: The Emergence of a 
>Phenomenon: UFOs from the Beginning through 1959. Detroit, MI: 
>Omnigraphics, 1992. 433pp.  ISBN 1-55888-301-0.  The second 
>volume of this fine work is must reading for those desiring real 
>understanding of UFOs.
>
>Colombo, John Robert.  UFOs Over Canada: Personal Accounts of 
>Sightings and Close Encounters. Willowdale, Ontario, Canada: 
>Hounslow Press, 1991. 221pp.  ISBN 0-88882-138-7.  A nice book by a
>famous Canadian compiler of Canadiana of short UFO accounts mostly 
>in the words of the witnesses themselves.
>
>Condon, Edward U. and Daniel S. Gillmor (ed.).  Final Report of the 
>Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects (Conducted by the 
>University of Colorado Under Contract to the United States Air 
>Force). New York: Bantam Books, 1968. 965pp.  After close, 
>competent study of over 100 UFO sighting reports, 30% couldn't be 
>identified!  Read Condon's prejudiced introduction only after you 
>have looked through the rest of the study.  The National Academy of 
>Sciences rubber-stamped Condon's recommendations that no public 
>funds be devoted to the study of UFOs.
>
>Conroy, Ed.  Report on Communion: An Independent Investigation of 
>and Commentary on Whitley Strieber's Communion. New York: 
>Morrow, 1989. 427pp.  ISBN 0-688-08864-3.  This journalist was a 
>boyhood acquaintance of Strieber. When Strieber published 
>Communion, Conroy decided to see if his story would hold up under 
>an investigative journalist's scrutiny. Conroy says yes.
>
>Crystall, Ellen.  Silent Invasion: The Shocking Discoveries of a UFO 
>Researcher. New York: Paragon House, 1991. 190pp.  ISBN 1-55778-
>493-0.  A UFO researcher uses her psychic abilities to locate UFOs in 
>the field. Interesting for showing how a scientifically naive person 
>still understands that scientific and scholarly proof is what is 
>needed in the end. Many hard to interpret photos accompany the text.
>
>Curran, Douglas.  In Advance of the Landing: Folk Concepts of Outer 
>Space. New York: Abbeville Press, 1985. 132pp.  ISBN 0-89659-523-
>4.  Valuable photographic presentation of UFO folklore.
>
>Deardorff, James W. Celestial Teachings: The Emergence of the True 
>Testament of Jmmanuel (Jesus). Tigard, OR: Wild Flower Press, 
>1990. 323pp.  ISBN 0-926524-11-9. An analysis of some of the 
>collateral material from the extensive Billy Meier contact case.
>
>Delgado, Pat and Colin Andrews.  Circular Evidence: A Detailed 
>Investigation of the Flattened Swirled Crops Phenomenon. London: 
>Bloomsbury, 1989. 190pp.  ISBN 0-7475-0357-5.  The first of the 
>picture books about crop "circles".  It's a very good presentation of 
>the facts and their investigative methods. Some investigators 
>believe UFOs may produce the "circles".
>
>Druffel, Ann and D. Scott Rogo.  The Tujunga Canyon Contacts. 
>Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1980. 264pp.  ISBN 0-13-
>932541-7.  Good book about abduction/contact experiences.
>
>Eberhart, George M.  UFOs and the Extraterrestrial Contact Movement: 
>a bibliography. Metuchen, NJ: Scarecrow Press, 1986. 1298pp.  ISBN 
>0-8108-1919-8.  An outstanding listing of books, articles, movies, 
>TV appearances, dissertations, conferences, etc., about UFOs and 
>related phenomena.  No library in America should be without it.  Ask 
>your public library to get a copy today!!
>
>Emenegger, Robert.  UFO's: Past, Present and Future. New York: 
>Ballantine Books, 1974. 180pp.  ISBN 345-24189-4-150.  Good 
>general book.  Emenegger produced a film documentary of the same 
>name.  The US government hinted that it would give him some "real" 
>flying saucer footage for inclusion in his film.  This didn't happen.
>
>Evans, Hilary and John Spencer (eds.).  UFOs: 1947-1987 -- The 40-
>Year Search for an Explanation. London: Fortean Tomes, 1987. 384pp.  
>ISBN 1-870021-02-9.  Similar to the other book by Spencer and 
>Evans, but more extensive. A must read for dedicated ufologists.
>
>Fawcett, Lawrence and Barry J. Greenwood.  Clear Intent: The 
>Government Coverup of the UFO Experience. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: 
>Prentice-Hall, 1984. 259pp.  ISBN 0-13-136656-4.  Very important 
>book summarizing what ufologists know from studying the thousands 
>of FOIA-released government UFO documents.  Everything but proof 
>of crashed flying saucers is here, and it's all from FOIA-released 
>documents!
>
>Flammonde, Paris.  UFO Exist! New York: Putnam, 1976. 406pp.  ISBN 
>399-11538-2.  Fine history of the subject from a radio 
>producer/journalist. The book details the US government's 
>involvement.
>
>Fowler, Raymond E.  The Andreasson Affair. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: 
>Prentice-Hall, 1979. 239pp.  ISBN 0-13-036608-0. First book about 
>a now famous abductee, Betty Andreasson Luca.
>
>Good, Timothy.  Above Top Secret: The Worldwide UFO Cover-Up. New 
>York: William Morrow, 1988. 592pp.  ISBN 0-688-07860-5.  The most 
>important book about the on-going government cover-up.  
>
>Good, Timothy.  Alien Liaison: The Ultimate Secret. London: Century, 
>1991. 242pp.  ISBN 0-7126-2194-6.  A reliable introduction to the 
>wilder tales circulating in the UFO subculture in the 70s, 80s, and 
>90s. The bizarre nature of what is known makes a prudent 
>investigator reluctant to throw out any information. Some of this 
>will turn out to be true after it is put through the academic mill in 
>the 1990s and beyond. Not for the timid or intellectually rigid.
>
>Haines, Richard F., ed.  UFO Phenomena and the Behavioral Scientist. 
>Metuchen, N.J.: The Scarecrow Press, 1979. 450pp.  ISBN 0-8108-
>1228-2.  Scholarly book of papers on how eyewitnesses report UFOs 
>and what cultural factors influence UFO reports.
>
>Haines, Richard F. Advanced Aerial Devices Reported During the 
>Korean War. Los Altos, CA: LDA Press, 1990. 75pp.  ISBN 0-9618082-
>1-7. An important study of early military UFO sightings.
>
>Haines, Richard F.  Melbourne Episode: Case Study of a Missing Pilot. 
>Los Altos, CA: L. D. A. Press, 1987. 275pp.  ISBN 0-88229-540-3.  
>Detailed review and analysis of the Australian Valentich airplane 
>abduction case.
>
>Haines, Richard F.  Observing UFOs: An Investigative Handbook. 
>Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1980. 300pp.  ISBN 0-88229-540-3.  
>Exceedingly cautious scientific study of mostly night lights and 
>daylight discs categories of UFOs.
>
>Hall, Richard.  Uninvited Guests: A Documented History of UFO 
>Sightings, Alien Encounters & Coverups. Santa Fe, NM: Aurora Press, 
>1988. 381pp.  ISBN 0-943358-32-9.  A very good summary of the 
>whole field of ufology. Highly recommended as a place to start.
>
>Hendry, Allan. The UFO Handbook: A Guide to Investigating, 
>Evaluating, and Reporting UFO Sightings. Garden City, NY: Doubleday 
>(Dolphin), 1979. 297pp. ISBN 0-385-14348-6.  The best study of the 
>subject.  About 1300 UFO reports, all happening within the year and a half of 
>the study's duration, are dissected.  8.6% fall into the genuine UFOs 
>category, that is, essentially flying saucers, whatever they are!
>
>Hopkins, Budd.  Intruders: The Incredible Visitations at Copley 
>Woods. New York: Random House, 1987. 223pp.  ISBN 0-394-56076-0. 
>HopkinsU second book.  He says it is likely that aliens are mixing our 
>genes with theirs, and this is a major purpose of the abductions.
>
>Hopkins, Budd. Missing Time: A Documented Study of UFO Abductions. 
>New York: Richard Marek, 1981. 258pp. ISBN 0-399-90102-7.  
>Hopkins' first book about abductions.
>
>Howe, Linda Moulton.  An Alien Harvest: Further Evidence Linking 
>Animal Mutilations and Human Abductions to Alien Life Forms. 
>Littleton, CO: Linda Moulton Howe Productions, 1989. 455pp.  ISBN 0-
>9620570-1-0.  Best book of surprisingly few considering the 25 
>year history of animal mutilations.
>
>Holroyd, Stuart.  Alien Intelligence.  New York: Everest House, 1979. 
>231pp.  ISBN 0-89696-040-4.  An excellent book by a student of the 
>paranormal that compares the different kinds of intelligence, 
>including ET intelligence and "disembodied" intelligence.
>
>Hynek, J. Allen, Philip J. Imbrogno, and Bob Pratt.  Night Siege: The 
>Hudson Valley UFO Sightings. New York: Ballantine Books, 1987. 
>208pp.  ISBN 0-345-34213-5.  About the early 1980s boomerang UFO 
>flap involving thousands of sightings.
>
>Hynek, J. Allen.  The UFO Experience: A Scientific Inquiry. New York: 
>Ballantine Books, 1972. 309pp.  ISBN 345-23953-9-150.  The father 
>of modern ufology writes a solid book about the subject.
>
>Jacobs, David Michael.  Secret Life: Firsthand Accounts of UFO 
>Abductions. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1992. 336pp.  ISBN 0-671-
>74857-2.  The most important book on UFO abductions so far. Start 
>here because the presentation is a just the facts, ma'am, blow by 
>blow account of what Jacobs believes is happening. He says 
>essential aspects of all abductions are absolutely real in ordinary 
>perceptual and space-time reality. However, there are definite 
>perceptual and space-time anomalies too. When people report that 
>they had a missing time experience of two hours, Jacobs says they 
>are actually bodily missing from planet Earth, or at least human 
>beings cannot find them on Earth! A warning to  extreme skeptics and 
>debunkers: this book may be hazardous to your mental health!
>
>Jacobs, David Michael.  The UFO Controversy in America. 
>Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1975. 362pp.  ISBN 0-
>253-19006-1.  A historian's review of ufology up to the date of 
>publication.
>
>Keyhoe, Donald E.  Aliens from Space: The Real Story of Unidentified 
>Flying Objects. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1973. 322pp.  Keyhoe says 
>the US government has crashed saucers and alien bodies.  He's 
>probably right. The last of Keyhoe's five books about UFOs.
>
>Kinder, Gary.  Light Years: An Investigation into the Extraterrestrial 
>Experiences of Eduard Meier. New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 1987. 
>265pp.  ISBN 0-87113-139-0.  Easy introduction to the complex 
>Billy Meier case.  The case is noted for outstanding photos and film 
>of UFOs and extensive contact notes.
>
>Knight, David C.  UFOs: A Pictorial History From Antiquity to the 
>Present. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1979. 192pp.  ISBN 0-07-035103-1. 
>UFO photos galore.
>
>Lindemann, Michael.  UFOs and the Alien Presence: Six Viewpoints. 
>Santa Barbara, CA: The 2020 Group, 1991. 233pp.  ISBN 0-9630104-
>0-9.  Oh, what to do with all the disparate UFO evidence! Learn here 
>how UFO luminaries Stanton Friedman, Budd Hopkins, Linda Howe, 
>Don Ware, Bob Lazar, and an anonymous probable abductee make 
>sense of it all, well, some small portion, anyway.
>
>Lorenzen, Coral and Jim Lorenzen.  Flying Saucer Occupants. New 
>York: New American Library (Signet), 1967. 215pp.  One of many 
>important books by longtime UFO researchers and directors of the 
>UFO investigative organization, APRO. Both deceased today, but not 
>forgotten for their lasting contribution to ufology.
>
>McCambell, James M.  UFOLOGY: A Major Breakthrough in the 
>Scientific Understanding of Unidentified Flying Objects. Millbrae, 
>CA: Celestial Arts, 1976. 184pp.  ISBN 0-89087-144-2.  
>Straightforward analysis of probable physics of UFO phenomena.
>
>Noyes, Ralph, ed.  The Crop Circle Enigma: Grounding the Phenomenon 
>in Science, Culture and Metaphysics. Bath, UK: Gateway Books, 1990. 
>192pp.  ISBN 0-946551-66-9. More facts and speculation about the 
>"agriglyphs".
>
>Randle, Kevin D. and Donald R. Schmitt.  UFO Crash at Roswell. New 
>York: Avon, 1991. 327pp.  ISBN 0-380-76196-3. The authors don't 
>back down. They say they have proved beyond a reasonable doubt that 
>a flying saucer -- not a UFO -- crashed in NM in the summer of 1947.
>Get off your duff.  Prove them wrong!
>
>Randles, Jenny. Abduction: Over 200 Documented UFO Kidnappings 
>Investigated. London: Robert Hale, 1988. 240pp.  ISBN 0-7090-3276-
>5. A British UFO researcher does a book about abductions. It is 
>important for showing that abductions are not just a North (or 
>South) American  phenomenon.
>
>Randles, Jenny.  From Out of the Blue: The Incredible UFO Cover-up at 
>Bentwaters NATO Air Base. New Brunswick, NJ: Global 
>Communications, 1991. 192pp.  ISBN 0-938294-08-3.  Randles 
>treats us to the latest, updated information on the Bentwaters RAFB, 
>Great Britain, landing of December 1980.
>
>Randles, Jenny.  The UFO Conspiracy: The First Forty Years. New York: 
>Blanford Press, 1987. 224pp.  ISBN 0-7137-1972-9.  Excellent 
>summary of the worldwide coverup of UFO information.
>
>Randles, Jenny. UFO Reality: A Critical Look at the Physical Evidence. 
>London: Robert Hale, 1983. 248pp.  ISBN 0-7090-1080-X.  Very good 
>presentation of the range of evidence for genuine UFO reality.
>
>Randles, Jenny and Peter Warrington.  Science and the UFOs. Oxford, 
>U.K.: Basil Blackwell, 1985. 215pp.  ISBN 0-631-13563-4.  Why the 
>science establishment doesn't recognize and study UFOs.
>
>Ruppelt, Edward J. The Report of Unidentified Flying Objects.  Garden 
>City, NY: Doubleday, 1956. 277pp. Written by a former head of the 
>AF's Project Blue Book public relations UFO effort. "Brand New 
>Enlarged Edition Latest, Up-to-the-minute Facts on UFO!" on dust 
>jacket.  No indication whatsoever inside the new edition that it 
>differs from the earlier edition by the addition of three extra 
>(debunking) chapters.  Without the dust jacket you would never know 
>there are two distinct editions of this classic UFO book.  Some UFO 
>researchers speculate that the Air Force/CIA was displeased enough 
>with Ruppelt's pro-UFO first edition that they made him include the 
>last three chapters in the "new edition"! 
>
>Sagan, Carl and Thorton Page, eds.  UFO's -- A Scientific Debate. New 
>York: Norton, 1972. 310pp.  ISBN 0-393-00739-1.  Appeared shortly 
>after the Condon Committee Report said once again that saucers 
>don't exist so they won't be studied by science.  UFO proponents, 
>debunkers, and honest skeptics have their say here.
>
>Salisbury, Frank B. The Utah UFO Display: A Biologist's Report.  Old 
>Greenwich, CN: Devin-Adair, 1974. 286pp.  ISBN 0-8159-7000-5.  
>Straightforward recounting of UFO events in Utah 1966-1973 with 
>some intelligent speculation about what it might mean.
>
>Saunders, David R. and R. Roger Harkins.  UFOs? Yes! Where the 
>Condon Committee Went Wrong. New York: World Publishing, 1968. 
>256pp.  LC 68-59202.  This book was written by a scientist 
>(Saunders) fired by Condon when he leaked a confidential department 
>memo that made it clear that the Condon UFO Study was a sham.
>
>Schwarz, Berthold E.  UFO Dynamics: Psychiatric and Psychic Aspects 
>of the UFO Syndrome. Moore Haven, FL: Rainbow Books, 1988. 560pp.  
>ISBN 0-935834-64-8.  A psychiatrist deals with the psychic 
>components of the UFO phenomena.
>
>Scully, Frank.  Behind the Flying Saucers. New York: Henry Holt, 1950. 
>230pp.  The first book in English about UFOs.  Hollywood reporter 
>talks about crashed discs that have only become plausible to 
>mainstream investigators again in the 1980s.
>
>Sitchin, Zecharia.  The 12th Planet.  New York: Avon, 1978. 436pp.  
>ISBN 0-380-39362-X. This lay scholar/journalist presents the best 
>documented ancient astronaut evidence in his series of books -- this 
>being the first one.
>
>Spencer, John and Hilary Evans, eds.  Phenomenon: Forty Years of 
>Flying Saucers. New York: Avon Books, 1988. 413pp.  ISBN 0-380-
>70654-7.  Essays about ufology from prominent ufologists in 
>America and Europe.  Good for seeing that UFOs are a worldwide 
>phenomenon.
>
>Story, Ronald, ed. The Encyclopedia of UFOs. Garden City, NY: 
>Doubleday (Dolphin Books), 1980. 440pp. ISBN 0-385-11681-0.  The 
>best of the encyclopedic books on UFOs.  Don't miss this.  Get your 
>local library to buy a copy.
>
>Strieber, Whitley.  Communion: A True Story. New York: William 
>Morrow, 1987. 299pp.  ISBN 0-688-07086-8.  Bestselling book by 
>previously bestselling author.  It's about his probable abductions.
>
>Thompson, Keith.  Angels and Aliens: UFOs and the Mythic 
>Imagination. New York: Addison-Wesley, 1991. 283pp.  ISBN 0-201-
>55084-9.  A minor lay scholar of the Jungian school takes on the 
>UFO. His history of the field should be read by all UFO investigators. 
>He suspects there might be a "real" component to UFOs, but his 
>emphasis is on the mythic aspects, which may be more important in 
>the final analysis anyway. 
>
>Vallee, Jacques.  Confrontations: A Scientist's Search for Alien 
>Contact. New York: Ballantine Books, 1990. 263pp.  ISBN 0-345-
>36453-8. Vallee is back to presenting "hard evidence" again instead 
>of speculation. Some Brazilian peasants were killed in apparent 
>encounters with UFOs.
>
>Vallee, Jacques.  Dimensions: A Casebook of Alien Contact. New York: 
>Contemporary Books, 1988. 304pp.  ISBN 0-8092-4586-8. The best 
>statement of Vallee's thesis -- UFOs are a manifestation of a time 
>immemorial alien control system.  
>
>Vallee, Jacques.  Messengers of Deception: UFO Contacts and Cults. 
>Berkeley, CA: And/Or Press, 1979. 243pp.  ISBN 0-915904-38-1. Just
>what the title says. Vallee adds to our understanding of the cultural 
>effects of UFOs.
>
>Vallee, Jacques.  Passport to Magonia: From Folklore to Flying 
>Saucers. Chicago: Henry Regnery, 1969. 372pp.  ISBN 0-8092-8330-1. 
>A study of the surprising parallels between fairy lore and modern 
>accounts of UFO beings.
>
>Vallee, Jacques.  UFO Chronicles of the Soviet Union: A Cosmic 
>Samizdat. New York: Ballantine Books, 1992. 212pp.  ISBN 0-345-
>37396-0.  Vallee turns away from excessive American ufologist bashing to 
>give us a reasonable rundown on the latest in Russian UFOs and 
>ufology. It's been as bad over there as it has been elsewhere. The 
>aliens seem to be equal opportunity abusers the world over.
>
>
>
--
*Ka Chun Yu                 * "Deputy dog dog a ding dang depa depa deputy     *
*kachun@as.arizona.edu      *  dog dog a ding dang depa depa . . ."            *
*                           *                         --"Don't Let's Start"    *