From: mccomt@aix.rpi.edu (Todd M. Mccomb)
Subject: Scelsi piano music review
Organization: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY
Date: Sat, 29 Aug 1992 18:03:48 GMT


Giacinto Scelsi (1905-1988) wrote one of this century's largest sets
of piano music.  This pianistic output was concentrated into two
relatively brief periods: 1930-1941 and 1952-1956.  At that point,
Scelsi's compositional development forced him to largely abandon keyboard
instruments -- until then, the piano had been by far his most-used
vehicle for self-expression.  Scelsi was a virtuoso pianist, and even
his most experimental compositions in this genre show a marked pianistic
conception.  The place which this output will hold in the repertoire
remains to be seen -- Scelsi was basically 'discovered' in the 80s.
 
The first period of piano writing (1930-1941) occurred during Scelsi's
early compositional phase in which his language was largely traditional.
Here the greatest influences seem to be Scriabin, Berg & Bartok.  This
was also when Scelsi wrote his "rabbits" such as the extremely impressive
String Quartet No. 1 (1944) and the still un-recorded cantata La Nascita
del Verbo (1948).  The early piano output includes four sonatas as well
as the first seven suites.  Some of these are lost, and the others will
no doubt be recorded at some point.
 
After 1948, Scelsi abandoned composing for a few years only to emerge
with his new style in 1952.  The beginning of this period is again
concerned almost exclusively with the piano, the following pieces being
written at that time: Suite No. 8 (1952), Four Illustrations (1953),
Five Incantations (1953), Suite No. 9 (1953), Suite No. 10 (1954),
Action Music (1955), and Suite No. 11 (1956).  The intended purpose of
this article is as a review of Werner Bartschi's recording of Suites
Nos. 8 & 9 on Accord 200802.  Unfortunately, I have been largely
unsuccessful at obtaining scores of these pieces, so my knowledge is
not as large as I would hope.
 
The Suite No. 8 "Bot-Ba (Tibet)" is subtitled: "Evocation of Tibet
with its monasteries on high mountain summits - Tibetan rituals - Prayers
and Dances."  Though it is described as less(!) violent than the Suite
No. 6, the Suite No. 8 makes much use of toccata-style movements largely
based on clusters.  These alternate with slower meditative sections based
on slow chord ostinatos, with still a hint of Schoenberg in the connecting
sections.  This Suite is immediately attractive for any barbarians who
might like cluster toccatas and percussive devices, as it is still largely
concerned with aggressive motion, despite the title.  However, it is still
successful at evoking Tibet -- or at least the recorded Tibetan music
I have heard, which is more than a little dissonant.  The suite is in six
movements with the "center" in the third based on the golden section.
This is followed by an extremely dissonant movement, then the slowest
movement of the suite, and then the complex Bartokian finale.  Bartschi's
playing is admirable, particularly in the extremely virtuosic finale.
 
The Four Illustrations and Five Incantations are recorded by Suzanne
Fournier on Accord 200742.  These works are much shorter than the Suites
8 & 9, and the Four Illustrations in particular is more concentrated in
form.  This piece is in four movements describing four avatars of Vishnu,
and might be said to correspond roughly to a sonata -- in particular the
Four Illustrations occupy the same position in Scelsi's middle output with
respect to the piano sonata as does the massive orchestral work Aion with
respect to the symphony.  Both conclude with slow, fading resolutions.
The Four Illustrations is charged with a variety of ideas, and is a piece
I continue to find fascinating after more than a hundred hearings -- I
have little doubt that it is Scelsi's finest piano piece.  For the most part
it is a slow work based on murky passage-work in the middle registers and
subtle interactions between the movements; the violent Varaha Avatar (as
scherzo) is the exception.  The Four Illustrations begins Scelsi's
concentration on slow and static music.  The Five Incantations are much
simpler in conception -- though quite virtuosic pianistically, each is
basically independent with a clearly identifiable theme.  They might be
described as rhapsodies, or possibly etudes.
 
The Suite No. 9 "Ttai (Peace)" is subtitled: "A succession of episodes
which alternatively express Time - or more precisely, Time in motion,
and Man as symbolized by cathedrals or monasteries, with the sound of
the sacred Om," along with the comment: "This Suite should be listened to
and played with the greatest interior calm. Restless people should keep
away."  This rambling piece is in nine movement, all clearly restrained
and predominately quiet and slow.  Though Halbreich repeats his comparison
between Scelsi and Bruckner when discussing this piece in the CD notes,
it is particularly here that the limits of this comparison are seen.  I
find that there is always a sense of striving (an idea which is surely
inseparable from the 19th century) in Bruckner's music, and this Suite
of Scelsi's is nothing but arrival.  Scelsi returns more extremely to
ostinato-based movements, as well as simply slow repeated chords; it
took me several hearings to appreciate this suite, and it continues to
occupy something of a singular position -- perhaps a rock on which
Scelsi's further explorations during the 50s are levered.  There are
many moments of evocation of various world musics, in particular the
compressed southeast asian style polyphony of the fourth movement, which
is something of a resolution for the first part of the suite.  Another
high point is the eighth movement which is then followed by a slow finale.
In this eighth movement, Scelsi starts a polyphonic style which he was to
use later in his string writing.  I also hear something of the style of
Charles Tournemire in his Don Quixote/Vanity movements; whether Scelsi
knew Tournemire I do not know, though I think the comparison is apt as
this suite is one of Scelsi's most vain pieces.
 
The Suite No. 9 has also been recorded by Marianne Schroeder on Hat Hut
CD, along with the Suite No. 10 "Ka (Essence.)"  Though Schroeder's
performance is good, Bartschi's is better.  Not only does he bringer a
deeper sense to the music, but he plays it 10% faster (something which
doesn't hurt for this piece.)  The Suite No. 10 is not very successful,
in my opinion -- the bind in which Scelsi finds himself here might have
had something to do with his abandonment of the piano shortly afterward.
At the beginning, this suite offers something of an introduction to the
earlier piano music (and this is something Scelsi was to continue for
some years: an incredible new idea emerging like a boulder, followed
by somewhat easier pieces which function as something of an explanation
for the first; example: String Quartets Nos. 2 & 3.)  The first three
movements use more traditional western figurations in Scelsi's slow ostinato
style, followed by a fourth movement which combines these and then three
other movements which close the seven movement suite.  These last three
movements are largely based on quickly arpeggiated chords in the highest
register over slow recitatives in the lower ones.  Some of the new sound
ideas here do point toward Scelsi's later output, such as the highly
singular world of Pfhat (1974).
 
The Action Music and Suite No. 11 are not yet recorded, though I suspect
Accord will be coming out with them soon.  I expect that Action Music
returns to the cluster toccatas of Bot Ba, and that the Suite No. 11
develops further some of the later ideas in Ka -- though I would really
like to find out how Scelsi ends his piano output (not surprisingly at
the same time as he was writing Triphon for solo cello.)  In addition
to these pieces, there is a later piano piece Aitsi (1974) which uses
electronics to de-temper the decaying resonances.  This is similar to
Stockhausen's Mantra, though the effect is quite different.  The String
Quartet No. 5 is based on Aitsi, and the piano piece is arguably more
effective -- the contrast between attack and decay is much more extreme.
Here as in most of Scelsi's last music, the language is quite harsh
and largely eschews any traditional development.  Aitsi is one six-minute
movement, based on a chord expanded in a style similar to Indian
classical alap (though stacked vertically.)
 
T. M. McComb
 
Newsgroups: rec.music.classical