From: ts@uwasa.fi (Timo Salmi)
Subject: Re: Another PKZIP 2.04C bug...  WITH bug test file
Organization: University of Vaasa, Finland
Date: Tue, 12 Jan 1993 05:48:07 GMT

Here we go again.  I understand the special circumstances, but I
still don't think this was a good idea. 

In article <16B5314890.NETOPRWA@ncsuvm.cc.ncsu.edu> NETOPRWA@ncsuvm.cc.ncsu.edu (Wayne Aiken) writes:
>begin 644 samedate.zip
>M4$L#!`D````!``1?FQA\TKE-?P(````$```'````4D5!1"Y-12`")C$#(L~;0

-Subject: Do not post binaries directly
-From: garbo.uwasa.fi:/pc/ts/tsfaq31.zip Frequently Asked Questions
-Date: Sat 19 Dec 00:00:12 1992

13. *****
 Q: May I just go ahead and post binaries to discussion newsgroups?

 A1: First of all this should not be taken as a recrimination
against any individual poster of binaries to a discussion newsgroup,
but rather as a reminder to all of us of the potential problems
involved. Because this information is at the same time intended to
help the well-meaning posters of binaries, there are pointers at the
end of this item on how to make your binary available in the proper
way.
   If someone sees these things differently, ok, but please note
that I would rather not get flaming, indignant arguments crashing in
over this issue. I'd prefer not to waste the time with the
bickering. (All civilized views are naturally always welcome).
   Also please note that it does not make a decisive difference
whether these posting in fact just contain sources and no
executables. The problems are similar whatever (binary posting or
something else) we decide call this method of distribution. The same
applies whether the binary posting is a short or a long one. This is
not just a simple question of "band width" (a term some users are in
love with :-).
   I know and understand that most of who do this mean well, and
wish to contribute to the general usefulness of the news. We all
appreciate that. Nevertheless, I would strongly advise against
posting binaries to unmoderated discussion newsgroups.  On top of
that the net rules don't like it, let's look at this from a purely
practical point of view. If other netters follow suit and start
posting binaries to discussion newsgroups not meant for this
purpose, there are several potential problems:
    1) The traffic will soon explode, since it is bound to be more
       or less haphazard. This is bound to invoke action sooner or
       later from the systems along the feed and/or net
       administration.
    2) There are no guarantees against trojans and other nasties.
       (This does not mean that the other methods are absolutely
       safe, but the likelihood is smaller by far.)
    3) The probability of commercial material being posted over the
       net increases, with all the consequent repercussions.
    4) The idea is very wasteful of net resources. Remember that
       there are over 80000 readers in eg comp.binaries.ibm.pc.d.
       Much better to put/get stuff into/from the orderly moderated
       groups, or use anonymous ftp, mail servers, or good BBSes.
    5) Even should the binary posting be just a short minor one, it
       may easily snowball by invoking others. Even if a single
       binary posting need not be harmful in any way per se, the
       danger of the snowballing effect must be kept in mind.
Now what to do if you have a useful binary you want to distribute. A
much better avenue than posting it, is telling where the utility is
available.  Or if it is not yet available anywhere on the net, first
upload it to a suitable ftp site, or send it to the relevant
moderator of the binary postings (provided there is a suitable
binary group on the net). If you wish to have the instructions for
submitting material to the garbo.uwasa.fi MsDos & Windows archives
I'll be happy to send you our upload instructions if you email me
for them. Or if you wish to FTP the instructions directly, they are
available as garbo.uwasa.fi:/pc/UPLOAD.INF.

 A2: If you have read an earlier version of this FAQ collection
please note that I gave errorneous information about the nature of
the alt.sources newsgroup.  It is definitely not for distributing
binaries but for source code only.
--------------------------------------------------------------------

   All the best, Timo

..................................................................
Prof. Timo Salmi      Co-moderator of comp.archives.msdos.announce
Moderating at garbo.uwasa.fi anonymous FTP archives 128.214.87.1
Faculty of Accounting & Industrial Management; University of Vaasa
Internet: ts@uwasa.fi Bitnet: salmi@finfun   ; SF-65101, Finland