From: neilb@scs.leeds.ac.uk (Neil Bowers)
Subject: 3rd CFV and VOTE ACK: rec.games.abstract
Followup-To: poster
Organization: The University of Leeds, School of Computer Studies
Date: Mon, 12 Oct 1992 15:07:44 GMT

This is the THIRD Call For Votes (CFV) on the creation of usenet newsgroup
rec.games.abstract.  During the 30 day discussion period there were
no serious objections to the group, or the proposed name.  I have
appended the charter.
A mass vote acknowledgement follows the charter, if you have already voted
please check that you appear in the list.

To cast your vote, send email to neilb@scs.leeds.ac.uk (you can reply
to this message).

To vote against the group, send a message containing the line:

        I vote NO for rec.games.abstract as proposed

To vote for the group, send a message containing the line:

        I vote YES for rec.games.abstract as proposed

The voting will close at midnight, 27th October.

Follow-ups directed to news.groups

Neil Bowers
neilb@scs.leeds.ac.uk

				---===---

Group Name
----------

	rec.games.abstract

Status
------

	Unmoderated

Rationale
---------

	Abstract Strategic and Tactical games are an acknowledged genre,
	but there is no obvious group for discussion of this topic.
	The more popular games (eg chess and go) have their own group,
	but these are not the correct place to discuss games such as
	reversi.  As rec.games.board has been accepted as a forum for
	war- and other commercial board games, discussion of the
	topics listed below would interrupt the flow of that group.

	rec.games.abstract would provide a focus for discussion which
	currently appears in a number of groups, often to the annoyance
	of readers.  It is not intended to replace or detract from any
	existing groups, but to complement them.

	The design and implementation of programs to play such games is
	another topic with no group.  rec.games.programmer is too general.
	The creation of rec.games.abstract  was partly prompted by the
	proposal for comp.games.research.

Charter
-------

	The newsgroup would be for discussion of abstract games where
	strategy, tactics and player skill are paramount.  This includes
	the major category of perfect information, pure-strategy
	(deterministic) games, i.e. those with no element of chance (e.g.
	no dice), and where all information is available (unlike card games
	and Scrabble, for example, where players' hands are hidden).  The
	games under consideration are characterised by a simple board and
	pieces, with a small number of rules.  The cliche `a minute to
	learn, a lifetime to master' is often applied.

	o	discussion of less mainstream abstract games,
		which do not warrant a group of their own.

	o	design and implementation issues for computer players.

	o	develop generic code for computer programs,
		such as board widgets, alpha-beta and other algorithms.

	o	introduce each other to new games, thus finding new
		opponents.

	o	discuss strategy & tactics for human players.

	o	what makes a {good,fun,hard,popular} abstract game?
		Will playing X be detrimental/beneficial to my Y playing? etc.

	o	ask `experts' for rule clarification.

	o	catalogue known abstract games, variations, genealogy,
		sources of equipment, literature, clubs.

	o	maintain a list of email opponents for various games.

	o	catalogue available computer programs for these games.

	o	maintain a FAQ, outriggers could be posted to other groups,
		get a mention in appropriate FAQs.

	o	propose and discuss new games or mechanisms

	o	puzzles for games other than chess et al.

	o	organise tournaments for various (obscure) games.

	o	organise an ftp archive, where useful information and games
		programs can be held.

	o	vote for the best and the worst abstract game of the year
		(or month or ever!)

	o	generally have fun in a decent way

MASS VOTE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
" (Thomas Koller)" <tkoller@ch.ethz.vision>
"(Eckhard Bartscht)" <bartscht@de.dbp.uni-hannover.irb>
"Alec Habig" <ahabig@edu.indiana.astro.bigbang>
"BROOKS, M A (23)" <BROOKS@edu.ufl.ifas.icbr>
"David A. Wagner" <dawagner@EDU.Princeton.phoenix>
"David H. Thornley" <thornley@edu.umn.cs>
"Douglas Rusch" <drusch@edu.indiana.bio.sunflower>
"Eric J. Olson" <ejo@edu.alaska.gi.kaja>
"Garnet (x5738)" <GHARRIS@COM.HNS.LANDO>
"J. A. Durieux" <xerox@nl.vu.cs>
"John W. Boelter" <BOELTER3945@edu.uni.iscsvax>
"Jonathan R. Ferro" <jf41+@edu.cmu.andrew>
"Kathryn S. Weeks/Linguistics" <ksw3290@edu.utah.cc.u>
"Michael Tsuk, TDA/EPT/STT(OEM), MLO5-3/E35, DTN 223-0479 29-Sep-1992 0844" <tsuk@com.dec.enet.kelvin>
"Robert W. Spiker" <rws3n@EDU.Virginia.astro.astsun8>
"Sven M. Heinicke" <sven@edu.widener.cs>
AARONS%earn.EARLHAM@uk.ac.earn-relay
ALLEN SMITH <ALLENS%earn.EARLHAM@uk.ac.earn-relay>
Adam Meredith Logan <amlogan@EDU.Princeton.phoenix>
Amit Jayant Patel <amitp@edu.rice.owlnet>
Andreas Voelter <andi@de.uka.ira>
Android <benjie@us.ca.sac.quack>
Antti Karttunen <karttu@fi.mdata>
B.J. 29-Sep-1992 1214 <herbison@com.dec.enet.erlang>
BIRMINGH@GOV.FNAL.FNAL (Now we're both twits.)
Barney.Pell@uk.ac.cam.cl
Bill Newman <newman@EDU.Cornell.TC>
CHBRIN5@DE.UNI-KONSTANZ.NYX (Kai Hortmann)
COLORADO@GOV.NASA.GSFC.STARS
Chris Chisolm <chisolm@edu.unm.atlas>
Chris Gill <cpg@uk.ac.nott.maths>
Chris Seabrook <cds@com.ossi>
Chuck Carroll <cec35848@edu.uiuc.cso.uxa>
Clay Dresser <CDRESSER@EAGLE.WESLEYAN.EDU>
Clay Dresser <CDRESSER@EDU.WESLEYAN.EAGLE>
Colin Bell <crb11@uk.ac.cam.cus>
Court Demas <court+@edu.cmu>
DARKWING <U95_SSZABO@EDU.STEVENS-TECH.VAXC>
DCHATHAM@edu.utk.utkvx
DILCHER@de.desy.vxdesy
DJBAILEY@COM.HONEYWELL.MAVD.SKYLER
DNICOL@EDU.UMKC.VAX1
DWR2560@EDU.TAMU.ZEUS
Dan Pettersson <pson@SE.UU.DoCS.Tirana>
Darse Billings <darse@ca.ualberta.cs>
David Barr <barr@edu.psu.pop>
David Chalmers <dave@edu.indiana.cogsci>
David Cheng <drcheng@edu.nyu.stern.sales>
David Goldfarb <goldfarb@EDU.Berkeley.ocf>
David J. Fred <djf@edu.umich.itd.css>
David Reeve Sward <sward+@edu.cmu>
E Stephen-Smith <crunch@nz.ac.vuw.kauri>
E58992%earn.TRMETU@uk.ac.earn-relay
Edvard L|kketangen <edvardl@no.uio.ifi>
Frits Daalmans <asstud3@nl.kun.sci>
Greg Lindahl <gl8f@EDU.Virginia.clas.fermi>
Hoinitz-64045 114864 <hoinitz@su.dubna.jinr.main1>
J C Flack <julien@uk.ac.leeds.scs>
JOHN FISKIO-LASSETER <JOHNL%earn.EARLHAM@uk.ac.earn-relay>
JT <jmilhoan@edu.ohio-state.acs.magnus>
Jacob Butcher <jacob@com.tcs.tcsi> <jacob>
James Vincent Schultz <js3b+@edu.cmu.andrew>
Jens Wunderwa <wunderwa@de.tu-muenchen.informatik>
Jim Ault <aultj@edu.rpi>
Jonathan Welton <jonboy@org.sub.stgt.nadia>
Joshua Randall <randall-joshua@EDU.YALE>
Jud Kenney <pjk39593@edu.uiuc.cso.uxa>
Julian Richardson <julianr@uk.ac.ed.aisb>
Kai Ivo Quale <kai@no.uio.ifi>
Katie Boyle <kboyle@au.edu.monash.cc.yoyo>
Ken Fishkin <fishkin@com.xerox.parc>
LIPSCOJA@Edu.Vanderbilt.ctrvax
Magnus Holmberg <mho@se.kth.stacken>
Magnus Olsson <magnus@se.lu.thep>
Marc Moorcroft <smarry@org.guild.zooid>
Mark Joseph Delano <md4y+@edu.cmu.andrew>
Matt Crawford <crawdad@gov.fnal.fncent>
Melvin H. Nicholson YBH <nicholso@gov.nasa.arc.pioneer>
Michael Norrish <Michael.Norrish@nz.ac.vuw.comp>
Michael Schmahl <fsmgs@edu.alaska.acf-lab.camelot>
Michael Woodhams <woodhams@EDU.Princeton.phoenix>
Michel van der List <vanderlist@edu.fccc>
Mika Johnsson <JOHNSSON@fi.utu.cc.sara>
N D Silver <nik@uk.ac.leeds.scs>
NARAHT@EDU.CMU.CC.CLUB.DRYCAS
Nick Leverton <leveret@uk.co.demon.warren>
Noam Paz <aristo%earn.TECHUNIX@uk.ac.earn-relay>
Oliver Schoett <schoett@de.tu-muenchen.informatik>
PETERS%earn.EARLHAM@uk.ac.earn-relay
PMDF Mail Server <postmaster@EAGLE.WESLEYAN.EDU>
Patrick Tufts <zippy@edu.brandeis.cs.berry>
Paul Kinsler <kinsler@au.oz.uq.physics.newton>
Paul Palmer <palmerp@EDU.ORST.MATH>
Peter Lasersohn <plsr@edu.rochester.cc.troi>
Peter Nilsson <d90-pni@se.kth.nada>
R A Carson <tai-shu@nz.ac.vuw.kauri>
R J Williams <rodw@uk.ac.leeds.cbl>
Ralf Treinen <treinen@de.uni-sb.dfki>
Robert Vandeventer <S613012466@EDU.Cerritos>
Ronnie Simonds <nicholas@edu.umd.wam>
Sean Matthews <sean@de.mpg.mpi-sb>
Stefan Chakerian <schaker@edu.unm.atlas>
Steven Mathers <s.mathers@au.oz.trl>
Stig Hemmer <stig@no.unit.lise>
Thomas Kettenring <kring@de.uni-kl.physik>
Thomas Omar Smith <ts2a+@edu.cmu.andrew>
Tim Dunn <tdunn@edu.csuchico.ecst>
Tim Yao <tyao@edu.uiuc.cso.uxh>
Tom Fitzgerald <fitz@com.wang>
Toni Kotinurmi <gvbraun@fi.hut.vipunen>
Tor Iver Wilhelmsen <toriver@no.unit.pvv>
U2119737@AU.EDU.unsw.csd.csdvax
Vikram Dwarkadas <vvd6t@EDU.Virginia.astro.astsun7>
Virginia G Jelinek <vjelinek@edu.ohio-state.acs.magnus>
Wilhelm Mueller <ZMUELLER@edu.utk.utkvx>
a282244@de.lrz-muenchen.sysun (Helmut Richter)
acadams@mil.ncsc.afterlife (Arthur C. Adams)
adb@edu.bu.albert (Adam Bryant)
adray@edu.kent.mcs
ahahn@EDU.UCSD.sdcc13 (Qwyrx )
ahm@com.rent.spatula (Andreas Meyer)
alex@org.sub.nbg.venus
allis@NL.RULIMBURG.CS
andreas@no.uib.ifi (Andreas Opdahl)
anneke@nl.uva.fwi
arseno@ca.ulaval.phy
ask@com.att.cblph (Arthur S Kamlet)
austin@com.franklin (Austin G. Hastings)
baljeual@EDU.Calvin.uther (Alan Baljeu)
barry@edu.stanford.playfair (Barrett P. Eynon)
bas@NL.UVA.PHYS
beowulf@com.att.research (John A Foley)
bernhard pfahringer <bernhard@at.ac.univie.ai.oefai>
bethmo@com.microsoft
billones@com.grebyn (Jeremy Billones)
bjackson@edu.purdue.cc.mentor (Ben Jackson)
boutell@org.cshl.isis (Tom Boutell)
breaker@org.fidonet.pdnfido
breuker@NL.RULIMBURG.CS
c164-aa@edu.berkeley.po (Paul DuBois)
carlton%apollo.hp.com@uk.co.hp.hpl
carmel@IL.AC.Technion.cs (david carmel)
cep@com.taligent.blowfish (Christophe Pettus)
chan@jp.ac.tut.tutics.imaisun (Chan Namkiu)
chisnall@nz.ac.canterbury.cosc (The Technicolour Throw-up)
christopher k farrell <farrell@edu.ohio-state.cis>
clarka@com.netcom (Andrew Clark)
cs000gij@edu.umt.selway (Gary I Jeppesen)
cs021045@edu.brown.cs (Andrew Brecher)
csjjlay@edu.mtsu.knuth (JJ Lay)
d89-eek@se.kth.nada
daniel@uk.ac.leeds.scs
dave boll <boll@EDU.ColoState.CS>
davids@EDU.Berkeley.ICSI (David Petrie Stoutamire)
djoyce@edu.clarku.black (Dave Joyce)
doane@EDU.UCSC.lick (Jay Doane)
dpt@edu.berkeley.math (Dylan Paul Thurston)
drosera@edu.mit.ai.gnu
dubach1@edu.harvard.husc
dvc@com.att.hr.eagle (45255-Dave Van Cleef(HOxxx)BIN)
eisen@edu.jhu.cs.server
elandal <elandal@fi.nullnet.tower.archtwr>
emcguire@com.intellection.mama3
eychaner@EDU.CALTECH.BBSO.SUNCUB (Another casualty of applied metaphysics.)
fab9452@edu.tamu.nigel (Allan Bailey)
fau@Edu.CWRU.po (Francis A. Uy)
ferguson@edu.uiuc.ncsa (Jim Ferguson)
fiji@EDU.WPI.wpi (Ben Bennett)
foxx@com.ingr.b17a.foxxjac (TheFoxx "AJ")
gil@de.sel.us-es
greg@uk.ac.leeds.scs
hart@edu.andrews.cs.susan (Kevin Hart)
hde@EDU.CMU.CS.THEORY.MORIARTY
heinz@de.uni-freiburg.ruf.sun8 (Alois Heinz)
hendrix@mil.navy.dt.oasys (Dane Hendrix)
herbert@at.ac.tuwien.complang.mips (Herbert Pohlai)
hmasum@ca.carleton.ccs (Hassan Masum)
hougaard@dk.aau.daimi
hpk@de.han.prim (Holger Krekel)
hship@com.stratus.sw.teton (Howard Ship)
hsieh@edu.toronto.math
irilyth@EDU.CLAREMONT.FENRIS (Josh Smith)
james@com.ricoh.crc (James Allen)
jbrewer@com.wri
jeff@edu.nwu.acns.casbah (Jeff Williamson)
jhart@edu.caltech.ugcs (John M. Hart)
johne@sg.gov.iti (Dr. John S. Eickemeyer)
jorfra@se.foa.lin.fenix (J|rgen Fransson)
jt@pl.edu.fuw
jtol@fi.oulu.rieska (Jouni Tolonen)
jwhit@com.xerox.wbst845e (Jeff Whitmire)
kaba@de.north.freeside.wintermute (Kai Bartels)
kanderso@edu.reed (Karl Anderson)
kirk@edu.cornell.tn.alchemy (Kirk Gunsallus)
kking@edu.uah.cs (Ken King)
klocek@edu.msu.cps
kmc@com.netcom (Kevin McCarty)
kosinski@edu.andrews.cs.susan (James Kosinski)
larry@COM.logsysv (Laurence Sigmond)
lunatic@com.netcom (Lunatic E'Sex)
m89jol@se.uu.tdb.bellatrix (Jan Olsson)
m91kgh@se.uu.tdb.bellatrix (Karl-Gunnar Hultland)
malloy@mil.navy.nprdc (Sean Malloy)
marms%sandia@edu.unm.cs.unmvax (Mike Arms)
martin@de.uni-ulm.mathematik (Martin Hasch)
matwood%bullion@edu.utah.cs (Mark Atwood)
mbgordy@EDU.MIT.Athena
mcmanus@EDU.WPI.wpi (Pat McManus)
mdobbins@com.unisys.tredydev.asns (Michael Dobbins)
mem10@edu.CWRU.po (Milton E. Moskowitz)
mhpower@EDU.MIT.Athena
michael@com.afs
mike@de.GUN.mroh (Michael Rohleder)
minnotte@edu.rice.stat0 (Michael Minnotte)
mjn@uucp.pseudo (Murray Nesbitt)
mk11@edu.cornell
mkernig1@edu.swarthmore.cc
mmorg@edu.rice.ruf (Matt Morgan)
mox@us.il.chi.vpnet (William Moxley)
mxb8@Edu.CWRU.po (Matthew Bakaitis)
nates@edu.mit.ll (nate smith)
neilb@uk.ac.leeds.scs
nelson@edu.reed (Nelson Minar)
nick@ca.uwaterloo.sunburn (Nick Fitzpatrick)
norm@uucp.sdc (Norm Nithman)
nsmith@com.ti.micro.tms390 (Neal Smith)
nv89-nun@se.kth.nada
pete@EDU.UCSD.chem (Peter Wotruba)
peterb@uk.ac.qmw.dcs
peters@ca.ubc.physics (Dan Peters)
philip@ca.usask.spr (Tim Philip)
phipps@COM.Sun.Eng.calcite (Geoffrey Phipps)
phygod72@edu.gac.nic (Philip Miesle)
pjb4288@edu.rit.isc.ultb (Pete - Toonatic - Boulay)
rdoo@edu.utexas.cs (Raymond Doo)
rdubbs@edu.tamu.cs (Roger B. Dubbs III)
rendell@au.edu.monash.cs.bruce (Robert Paige Rendell)
richard@com.pegasus (Richard Foulk)
rick@edu.tmc.bcm.ssctr.crick (Richard H. Miller)
ridgway@EDU.UCSD.SDPHU1 (Douglas T Ridgway)
rivera@de.uni-bielefeld.techfak
rnlee@EDU.UCSD.sdcc3 (Profess'nal Agitator)
rob@edu.ohio-state.eng.ee (Rob Carriere)
rohm@EDU.BU.BUCRF17 (Ryan Rohm)
ruman@edu.uci.eng.maemaster (ruman)
s861022@AU.OZ.rmit.xx.minyos (Harry the Dirty Dog)
sandeep%etnibsd%uunet.uu.net@uk.ac.uknet (Sandeep Pathak)
sarel@za.ac.up.ee.ford (Sarel Lugtenburg)
schraudo@EDU.UCSD.cs (Nici Schraudolph)
scott@com.techbook (Scott Huddleston)
scotts@com.mentorg.sjc
sergray@edu.nmt.jupiter (Arthur Cressy III)
shaun@uk.ac.leeds.scs
shippert@edu.caltech.cco (Tim Shippert)
sls%romulus.cray.com@uk.ac.uknet (Steve Scott x1532)
smith@au.edu.anu.pell (Michael Smith)
spm2d@EDU.Virginia.cs.ash
stephen@uk.ac.leeds.scs
steve@org.cam.jetslag (Steve Perkins)
swalter@edu.du.cs.nyx (DreamWeaver)
sy_bodenmann%trzcl3.dnet@srzts100
tcasey@com.adobe.us.mv (Tim Casey)
tim@uk.co.canon.crash (Tim F O'Donoghue)
tjj@fi.helsinki.rolf (Timo Jokitalo)
tkoppel@edu.du.cair.cassandra (Ted Koppel)
tlin@EDU.Berkeley.stat (Tony Lin)
tmoody%sjuphil@com.psi.uu (T. Moody)
tobac@jp.co.ubspd (Bach Frederic)
tomas@se.gu.ling (Tomas By)
urbin@com.interlan.interlan (Mark Urbin)
wapembe@mil.ncsc.afterlife (William Pemberton)
watsonb@edu.purdue.ecn (Bradley S Watson)
wchang@org.cshl (William Chang at Cold Spring Harbor Lab)
wft@nz.ac.canterbury.math (Bill Taylor)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.misc,comp.mail.misc,comp.programming,comp.protocols.misc,comp.os.misc,comp.std.misc,comp.std.internat