From: tanaka@sran79.sra.co.jp (TANAKA shin'ichiro)
Newsgroups: fj.soc.misc
Subject: Re: smokers & non-smokers ( Re: discussions on smoking )
Date: 15 Apr 92 04:11:55 GMT
Distribution: fj
Organization: Software Research Associates, Inc., Japan.
In-reply-to: ando@phys.hokudai.ac.jp's message of 13 Apr 92 11:31:03 GMT

$B#S#R#A$N$?$J$+$G$9!%(B

In article <ANDO.92Apr13203118@kotai.phys.hokudai.ac.jp> ando@phys.hokudai.ac.jp (Kazunori Ando) writes:

 >In article <TANAKA.92Apr13180255@sran79.sra.co.jp> tanaka@sran79.sra.co.jp
 >(TANAKA shin'ichiro) writes:
 >
 > $B!!!d$o$?$7$O!$(B
 > $B!!(B$B!d(B	     $B$@$+$i!$$_$s$J!J5J1l<T$HHs5J1l<T$H!K$G2?$H$+$7$J$$$H$$$1$J$$(B
 > $B!!!d$@$H;W$$$^$9!%(B
 >
 >$B0JA0$N(B$B5-;v$G=R$Y$?$H$*$j!";d$OA45J1l<T$NKPLG$r0U?^$7$F$$$k$o$1$G$O(B
 >$B$"$j$^$;$s$7!"4pK\E*$KA4$/$=$NDL$j$G$9(B$B!#(B

$B$3$3$d!$B>$N5-;v$G$O;d$HF1$8$3$H$r9M$($F$$$k$h$&$K$b;W$($k$N$G$9$,!$$I(B
$B$&$bJQ$G$9$M!$!%!%(B

--
 > $B!!!d62$/$F$$$($J$$$h$&$J>u67$H$$$&$N$O!$$b$7$"$k$H$7$F$b!$$=$l$O5J1l<T$@$1(B
 > $B!!!d$,9=@.$7$F$$$k$b$N$G(B$B$O$"$j$($^$;$s!%$?$^$?$^!$62$,$C$F$$$k?M$,Hs5J1l<T(B
 > $B!!!d$G!$62$,$i$l$F$$$kJ}$,5J1l<T$G$"$k$@$1$N>u67(B$B$r<h$j>e$2$F$$$k$K2a$.$^$;(B
 > $B!!!d$s!%5U$N>l9g$@$C$F$"$jF@$^$9$h$M!)(B
 >
 >$B5U$N>l9g!"2?$bLdBj$O5/$3$j$^(B$B$;$s!#(B $B5J1l<T$,$$$J$$$N$G$9$+$i!#(B:-)
 >

$B$=$&$G$9$M!%!V!XHs5J1l<T$,5J1l<T$KLBOG$r$+$1$i$l$k!Y$H$$$&Ld(B$BBj!W$O5/$3(B
$B$j$^$;$s$M!%$?$@$7$=$l$@$1$G$9!%0c$&LdBj$b$"$k$G$7$g$&!%(B

$B5J1l=j$K!X$H$F$b62$$?M!Y$,F~$C$F(B$B$-$F!$$3$3$G%?%P%3$r5[$&$J$HbK$s$G2s$C(B
$B$?$i$I$&$G$7$g$&!)!!!!$^$?Hs5J1l$NHH:a<T$O$$$J$$$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B$B!!$I$s$J(B
$BJ}K!$G$b!V%?%P%3LdBj$@$1!W$r2r7h$9$l$P$$$$$N$J$i!$$b$&$I$&$G$b$$$$$G$9!%(B

$B!X62$$?M!a%?%P%3$r(B$B$9$&$R$H!Y$H$$$&$N$O!J$HJ9$3$($k$$$$J}$O!K$b$&;_$a$F(B
$BM_$7$$!%!d$_$J$5$s!%(B

 >$B!t(B $B$3$NLdBj$O!J5J1l<T!&Hs(B$B5J1l<T!K$K$D$$$FL@$i$+$KBP>N$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B;d$O=*;O!$!VJL$J0UL#$G$NBP>N@-!W$r$$$C$F$$$^$9!%!XHs5J1l(B$B<T$,5J1l<T$K$+(B
$B$1$i$l$kLBOG!Y$,5J1l<T$HHs5J1l<T$K$H$C$FBP>N$J$o$1$O:G=i$+$i$"$j$^$;$s!%(B

$B$G$9$,!$$=$l(B$B$r$b$C$F!V5J1l<T$,$3$&$3$&$9$l$P$=$l$G$$$$!W$H$$$&7kO@$r=P(B
$B$9$N$O$*$+$7$$$H$$$C$F$$$k$@$1$G$9!%$=$s$J(B$B$d$jJ}$G$3$N<j$NLdBj$r2r7h$7(B
$B$?$i!$@$$NCf$a$A$c$/$A$c$G$9!%(B

$B!t<V$K>h$kA0$K$O!$<V$,DL$j$=$&$J$H$3!$GS(B$B5$%,%9$,FO$-$=$&$J$H$3!$8e$+$i(B
$B!t$=$3$K8=$l$=$&$J?M!$$9$Y$F$K;vA0$KN;2r$r$H$C$F$+$i$G$J$1$l$P>h$C$F$O(B
$B!t$$$1$J$$$H<gD%$9$k?M$,=P$F$-$?$i!$$=$l$r$N$a$k$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

$B!t%,!<%j%C%/$N8z$$$?NAM}$O!$2s$j$N?M(B$B$K$OLBOG$J$@$1$@$+$i!$6X;_$9$Y$-$@(B
$B!t$H$$$&$N$,@5$7$$O@M}$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

----
 > $B!!!d$I$&$7$F!V62$/$F$$(B$B$($J$/$F$b$=$l$OEvA3!W$H$9$k$N$+:,5r$,J,$+$i$J$$$N$G(B
 > $B!!!d$9!%!JCfN,!K$"$^$jM}M3$,;W$$Ev$?$j$^$;$s!%(B$B$$$$$?$$$N$K$$$($J$$$N$O3N$+(B
 >   $B!d$K@5$7$$;Q$G$O$J$$$G$9$,!$!V@5O@!W$G$$$C$F$7$^$($P!$$=$l$O$$$($J$$(B$BJ}$,(B
 >$B!!(B $B!d$*$+$7$$$N$G$9!%(B
 >
 >$B!J$3$j$c$^$?$:$$$V$s$H6J$2$i$l$A$c$C$?$J$!!D!#(B(^_^;$B!K(B
 >$B0lHV<e$$?M$N(B$BN)>l$b9M$($:$K!V@5O@!W$J$IM-$jF@$J$$$H$$$&$N$,!"O@;]$G$9!#(B

$B<e$$?M$NN)>l$r9M$($k$N$O@5O@$G$O$"$j$^$;$s(B$B!%<e$$?M$r$J$/$9$k$N$,@5O@$G$9!%(B

$B!t$@$$$?$$!V$=$N?M$O$I$&$7$F$$$($J$$$N$+!)!W!V$=$N?M$,$$$($J$$M}M3$O(B$B$*(B
$B!t$+$7$/$J$$$+!)!W$rLd$&$F$$$k$N$G$9$h!)!!6J$2$F$$$k$D$b$j$O$J$$$G$9!%(B
$B!t$I$N$h$&$K6J$,$C$F$$$k$N$+(B$B65$($F2<$5$$!%J,$+$i$J$$$N$G!$!%!%(B


 > $B!!!d(B >$B!V62$/$F8@$($J$$!W$H8@$&?M$,$$$k8B$j!"!VA3$k$Y$-4D6-!W$H(B$B6;D%$C$F(B
 > $B!!!d(B >$B8@$($k>u67$G$O$J$$$N$G$O!)(B
 > $B!!!d$G$O!$$3$l$OC/$,0-$$$N$G$7$g$&$+!)!!%?%P%3$r5[$&?M(B$B$N@UG$$J$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B
 > $B!!!d;d$@$C$F!$!V62$/$F$$$($J$$!W$R$H$K$O!V62$/$F$$$($^$;$s!W!%62$$$+$i$$$o(B
 > $B!!!d$J$/$F$$$$$H$$$&$N$OHs5J1l<T$@$+$iG'$a$i$l$kFC8"$G$O$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!%(B
 >
 >$B!V62$$$+$i8@$o$J$/$F(B$B$$$$!W$H$O;d$O$I$3$K$b=q$$$F$$$^$;$s$h!#(B:-)
 >$B$=$&$G$O$J$/$F!"!V$I$&$7$?$i8@$($k$h$&$K$J$k$+!W$,%F!<%^(B$B$J$s$G$9!#(B
 >
 >$B!t(B $BC/$+$r0-<T$K$7$J$$$H5$$,:Q$^$J$$$s$G$7$g$&$+!)(B :-)

$B$"$s$I!<$5$s$O!V62$/$F$$$($J$$(B$B>u67$r:n$C$F$$$k?M$,0-$$!W$H$$$C$F$$$k$N(B
$B$G$O$J$$$N$G$9$+!)!!$G!$$=$NO@D4$+$i$O!V5J1l<T$,5$$r;H$o$J$$(B$B$+$i0-$$!W(B
$B$HFI$a$^$7$?$,!$!%!%!!C/$b0-$/$J$$$N$K!VNI$/$J$$>u67$,H/@8$7$F$$$k!W$H(B
$B$$$&<gD%$J$N$G$9$+!)(B

$B!t62$/$F$$$($J$$?M$NB8:_$rG'$a$k$H$$$&$3$H$O!$$=$N?M$,62$,$k$@$1$N@5Ev(B
$B!t$J;vM3$r:n$C$F$$$k?M$,$$$k(B$B$H$$$&$3$H$G$9$h!)!!!V$$$o$J$/$F$b$$$$!W$H(B
$B!t$$$C$F$$$k$N$H$I$3$,0c$&$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

 >$B8=:_!"!V62$/$F(B$B8@$($J$$!W?M$,!V8@$($k!W$h$&$K$J$C$F!"$7$+$b$=$N?=$7=P$,(B
 >$B5J1l<T$K$9$s$J$j!V<u$1F~$l!W$i$l$J$1$l$P$J(B$B$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B$=$&$G$9$h!%$G$9$+$i$=$l$OC1$K!$!V$$$($J$$?M$,0-$/$F!W!V$$$C$F$bJ9$+$J(B
$B$$?M$,0-$$!W$N$G$"(B$B$C$F!$!V5J1l<T$,0-$/$F!W!VHs5J1l<T$O0-$/$J$$!W$G$O$J(B
$B$$$@$1$G$9!%(B


 >$B!V62$/$F8@$($J$$!W?M$K$?$@L5M}$K(B$B!V8@$o$;$k!W$@$1$G$OLdBj$N2r7hK!$H$7$F(B
 >$B2<$N2<$G$9$7!"5J1l<T$KLUL\E*$K!V8@$o$l$?$i$d$a$m!W$H8@$&$@$1(B$B$G$bBLL\$G$9!#(B

$B;d$,$$$C$F$$$k$N$O!$!X$@$+$i!$$I$&$d$C$F!)!Y$G$9!%(B

$B!t!V2<$N2<!W$H$$$&$+$i$K$OEz$($F$b(B$B$i$*$&!%!J$H$-$A$s$H<gD%$9$k;d!%(B:-)

$B$=$NItJ,$J$7$K!$!V5J1l<T$K$b$C$H9M$($m$HJ9$3$($k$$$$J}!W$r$9$k$3(B$B$H$K0U(B
$BL#$r46$8$^$;$s!%(B

 > $B!!!d$G$9$+$i!$(B
 > $B!!!d(B	     $B!V62$,$i$J$$$G$$$&$h$&$K4+$a$k!W$H$+!$!%!%(B
 > $B!!!d(B	     $B!V62$/$F$b$$$&$h$&$K$7$^$9!W$H$+!$!%!%(B
 > $B!!!d(B	     $B!V$$$C$F$$$k?M$,$$$?$i%U%)%m!<$7$F$"$2(B$B$h$&!W$H$+!$!%!%(B
 >
 >$B$9$Y$F!V$=$N>l!W$N;v$7$+9M$($F$$$^$;$s$M!#(B
 >$B2?EY$b8@$&$h$&$G$9$,!"!V%?%P%31sN8(B$B$7$F$$$?$@$1$^$;$s$+!W$,DLMQ$7$J$$(B
 >$B5J1l<T$H!V62$/$F8@$($J$$!W$H$$$&>u67$r$I$&$7$?$iKPLG$G$-$k$+$,Ld(B$BBj$G$9!#(B
 >$B$3$NLdBj$O$=$N>l$NIU$1>F$-?O$G2r7h$G$-$kLdBj$G$O$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B!V$=$N>l$N$3$H$r!W9M$($F(B$B$$$k$N$G$9!%(B

$B;d$O!$$3$NJ}K!0J30$K$=$&$$$&<R2q$r$D$/$j=P$9J}K!$O$J$$$H;W$C$F$$$k$N$G!$(B
$B7+$jJV$7$$$C$F(B$B$$$^$9!%$3$l$,!VIU$1>F$-?O!W$@$H$$$&$N$J$i!$$b$C$H$$$$J}(B
$BK!$r<($7$F2<$5$$!%(B

$B!tLdBj$O:G=i$+$iL@$i$+$K(B$B$5$l$F$$$k$H;W$$$^$9!%J}K!$rL@<($7$F2<$5$$!%(B

--
 >$B!t(B $B0UCO0-$G$9$,!"!V8@$($J$$?M$N!v0-$$!vItJ,!W$C$F$I(B$B$3$i$X$s$J$s$G$7$g!)(B
 >$B!t(B $B!V8@$o$J$$?M!W$G$O$J$/!V8@$($J$$?M!W$G$9$+$i$M!#(B
 >$B!t(B $B%a!<%k$K$h$k$*Ez$($r$*(B$BBT$A$7$^$9!#(B:-)

$B$I$3$,0UCO0-$J$N$+J,$+$j$^$;$s$,!$%a%$%k$K$9$k$HLLE]$J$N$G!$$3$3$G$*Ez(B
$B$($7$^$9!%(B

$B$b(B$B$7$+$9$k$HK\Ev$K$=$l$,J,$+$i$J$$$N$G$7$g$&$+!)!!6C$-$G$9!*!*(B

$B!t!V0-!W$G$O$J$/!V9%$^$7$/$J$$!W!V$=$&$G(B$B$"$C$F$O$$$($J$$!W$G$9$,!$!%!%(B

$B!V$$$o$J$/$F$O$$$1$J$$$3$H$r!X$$$($J$$!Y!W$N$O!V;EJ}$,$J$$$3$H!W$G$O$"(B$B$C(B
$B$F$b!$K\<AE*$K$O?d>)$b5vMF$b$5$l$F$O$$$1$J$$$3$H$G$9!%$&$^$/5!G=$7$F$$(B
$B$k$+$I$&$+$OJL$H$7$F!$!V$*8_(B$B$$$K<+J,$N<gD%$r$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F$*8_$$$NMx(B
$B1W$rD4@0$79g$&!W$H$$$&%k!<%k$N$b$H$K2f!9$O$$$-$F$$$^$9!%(B

$B!V$$$($J$$?M$N$3$H$r9M$($J$1$l$P$$$1$J$$!W$H$$$&$N$O!V%^%J!<!W$G$O$"$k(B
$B$+$bCN$l$^$;$s$,!$!V%k!<%k!W$G(B$B$O$"$j$^$;$s!%!V%k!<%k!W$O!V<+J,$N$9$Y$-(B
$B$3$H$O%-%A%s$H$9$k!W$G$9!%(B

$B$b$7$$$($J$$?M$N$3$H$r$^$:9M$($k(B$B$3$H$,%k!<%k$G$"$k$H$7$^$7$g$&!%(B

$B#1#0?M$N?M4V$,$$$F!$$=$N$&$A$N0l?M$/$i$$$,$=$&$$$&?M$@$C$?$i!$;D$j$N(B$B$_(B
$B$s$J$G9M$($F$"$2$l$P$^$"!$2?$H$+$J$j$^$9$M!%$G$b!$7rA4$J;Q$G$O$J$$$G$9!%(B

$B$b$7$$$($J$$?M$,#5?M$/$i(B$B$$$$$F!$$5$i$K;D$j$N#4?M$,!V<+J,$N<gD%$/$i$$$O(B
$B$$$($kDxEY$N9TF0NO$r;}$D!W?M$@$C$?$H$7$?$i!$$I$&$G$7$g(B$B$&!)!!;D$j$N0l?M(B
$B$,$9$Y$F$N$3$H$r$9$Y$F$N?M$K$$$$$h$&$K=hM}$9$k@UG$$rIi$&$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B
$B$=$l$,@5$7$$<R(B$B2q$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

$B$b$&$$$A$I@h$NNc$G!%$$$($J$$0l?M$O$_$s$J$+$i5$$r;H$C$F$b$i$&$N$,EvA3$G!$(B
$B2?$b$$$o$J$/(B$B$F$b:$$C$?$3$H$K$O$J$j$^$;$s!%$b$7!$JL$N0l?M$,!V$=$NJ}$,3Z(B
$B$@!W$H9M$($F$=$NCg4V$$$j$r$7$?$H$7$?$i!$$I(B$B$&$G$7$g$&!)!!!V$$$o$J$$?M!W(B
$B$H!V$$$($J$$?M!W$O$I$&6hJL$D$1$k$N$G$7$g$&!)!!$^$7$F!V$$$($k$h$&$K$J$k(B
$BEX(B$BNO$r$7$J$+$C$??M!W$O$I$&$G$7$g$&!)!!$=$s$J?M$P$+$j$K$J$C$?$i!$<R2q$O(B
$BC/$,1?1D$7$F$$$/$N$G$7$g$&!)(B

$B!V(B$B$$$($J$$?M!W$H$$$&$N$O!V2s$j$K5$$r;H$o$J$$?M!W0J>e$K0-$$$N$G$9!%$=$l(B
$B$r5vMF$9$k<R2q$OBLL\$G$9!%(B


$B$b$&(B$B0lEY@bL@$7$^$9!%!$2s$j$K5$$r;H$&!J$($k!K?M$H!$2s$j$K5$$r;H$o$J$$(B
$B!J$($J$$!K?M$,$$$k$H$7$^$9!%(B

$B!t$b$7(B$B$d!$!V$$$($J$$?M!W$O2?$b0-$/$J$$$,!$!V5$$r;H$($J$$?M!W$O!V0-?M!W(B
$B!t$@$H$O$$$o$J$$$G$9$h$M!)(B

$B$?$H$(5$(B$B$r;H$o$J$$?M$I$*$7$G$b!$$*8_$$$K$-$A$s$H<gD%$r$79g$($PD4@0$r$D(B
$B$1$k$3$H$OM}O@>e2DG=$G$9!%(B

$B<gD%$7$J$$(B$B!J=PMh$J$$?M$O$7$J$/$F$b$$$$!K$3$H$,A0Ds$N<R2q$O$I$&$G$7$g$&!)(B
$B5$$r;H$&?M$,$$$o$J$$$rI,;`$G%U%)%m!<$7(B$B!$5$$r;H$o$J$$!J$($J$$!K?M$O;H$o(B
$B$J$$$N$G>!<j$K$d$j!$$$$o$J$$?M$O$"$k;~$O2?$b$7$J$$$G9,$;$G$$$i$l!$$"(B$B$k(B
$B;~$O4X78$J$$$H$3$m$G6rCT$r$$$C$F!$<+J,$G$O2?$NEXNO$b$7$J$$!$!%!%$H$$$&(B
$B$h$&$J>u67$K$J$k$@$1$@$H;W$$(B$B$^$9!%(B

$B!t:#$=$C$/$j$G$9$M!%(B:-)

$B$3$3$G!$5$$r;H$o$J$$?M$,0-$$$H$$$&$H$I$&$J$k$G$7$g$&!)(B

$B5$$r;H$o$J$$(B$B!J$($J$$!K?M$O5$$r;H$o$J$$$N$G!$2?$bJQ$o$j$^$;$s!%(B
$B$$$o$J$$?M$O$=$&$@$=$&$@$H;W$C$F$$$F!$2?$bJQ$o$j$^(B$B$;$s!%(B
$B7k6I5$$r;H$C$F$$$??M$,!$!V$b$C$H5$$r;H$(!W$H$$$o$l$F$$$k$@$1$N$3$H$K$J(B
$B$j$+$M$^$;$s!%(B

$B?M4V$O<+(B$BJ,$N9,$;$N$?$a$KEXNO$9$Y$-$G$9!%?M$N$3$H$K5$$r;H$&$N$K@lG0$5$;(B
$B$i$l$?$$$H;W$C$F$$$k?M$O>/$J$$$G$7$g$&(B$B!%$=$7$F$=$NEXNO$,$_$s$J$N9,$;$K(B
$BDL$8$k$N$,$h$j9%$^$7$$$N$G$9!%(B

$B$*8_$$$K<+J,$N<gD%$r$-$A$s$H$$$($P!$(B$B?M$N$3$H$K5$$r;H$&EXNO$rB?>/$J$j$H(B
$B$b7Z8:$G$-$k$3$H$K$J$C$F$$$^$9!%$G$9$+$i!$$=$l$3$=!V$$$($J$$?M$,$$(B$B$J$1(B
$B$l$P!$$$$($J$$?M$K5$$r2s$9$3$H$O$J$$!W$N$G$9!%!V5J1l<T$,$$$J$1$l$P7y1l(B
$B<T$O2?$b:$$i$J$$!W$HF1$8O@(B$BM}$G$9!%0c$&$N$O<R2q4pHW$r;Y$($k4pK\86M}$G$"(B
$B$k$H$3$m$G$9!%(B

$B<+J,$N<gD%$r<+J,$G$$$($J$$?M$,$$$k$3$H$O(B$B!$;EJ}$,$J$$$3$H$G$O$"$j$^$9$,!$(B
$B$b$N$9$4$/LBOG$J$3$H$G$9!%(B

$B?M$KLBOG$r$+$1$k$J$H$$$&<gD%$G!$$$$($J$$(B$B?M$r!VI,MW0J>e$K!WM\8n$9$k$N$O(B
$B4V0c$C$F$$$k$H9M$($^$9!%(B

$B!t62$=$&$@$+$i$$$($J$$$J$s$F$($N$,@5$7$+$C$?(B$B$i!$62$=$&$@$C$?$+$i;&$7$A$c$C(B
$B!t$?$H$$$o$l$F$bJ86g$,$$$($J$$!$!%!%(B:-)

--
 >$BNI$$>u67$K;}$C$F9T$3$&$H(B$B$9$kJ}K!$,!"!vD>@\E*!v$G$J$$$@$1$G$9!#(B
 >$BEXNO$9$k2ACM$,$"$k$H;W$&$+$i$3$=5-;v$K$7$F$$$^$9!#(B:-)

$B;d$K$O(B$B!V$"$s$I!<$5$s$N$$$o$l$k4V@\E*<jK!!W$,6qBNE*$K2?$J$N$+$,M}2r$G$-(B
$B$^$;$s!%!V(Bxxx$B$,NI$/$J$l$PNI$/$J$k!W$H(B$B$$$&<gD%$O!$2?2s$bJ9$/2ACM$r46$8(B
$B$^$;$s!%!VD>@\E*!W$G2?$,$$$1$J$$$N$+@bL@$7$F2<$5$$!%$I$s$J32$,$"$k$N(B$B$G(B
$B$9$+!)!!$=$&$G$J$1$l$P!$$-$A$s$H8z2L$N$"$kJ}K!$rL@<($7$F2<$5$$!%(B

$BD9$/$J$C$F$9$_$^$;$s!%(B

$B!t$b$&9_(B$B$j$h$&$H;W$C$F$?$s$@$1$I!$$D$$!$!%!%(B
--
$B")#1#6#0!!El5~ET?7=I6h;MC+#3CzL\#1#2HVCO!!4]@5%S%k#5#F!!(B
$B!!!!(B$B!!!!!!!J3t!K#S#R#A(B	$B%=%U%H%&%'%"9)3X8&5f=j!!!!EDCf!!?50lO:(B
      TEL: 03-3357-9361 (ex. 3133)$B!!!!(BFAX: 03-3351-0880