From: aburto@nosc.mil (Alfred A. Aburto)
Subject: SPECfp89 results 
Organization: Naval Ocean Systems Center, San Diego
Distribution: comp.benchmarks 
Date: Sat, 26 Sep 1992 02:37:52 GMT
Expires: Fri, 16 Oct 1992 07:00:00 GMT

-------
SPECratio89 and SPECfp89 results are listed below for 75 different
systems (including compiler).

These results and all other results I have are available via anonymous
ftp from 'marlin.nosc.mil' in directory '/pub/aburto'. The host number 
for 'marlin' is: '128.49.16.4'. Some people have had troubles getting 
files using the 'get' command (with 'permission denied' the result) 
while others have not. I'm not sure why. Someone suggested using the
'put' command but I'm no expert with ftp.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------*
SPECratio and SPECfp89 for a number of systems referenced to program run *
times on a VAX 11/780: 23951.4 sec for SPICE2G6, 1863.0 sec for DUDOC,   *
20093.1 sec for NASA7, 4525.1 sec for MATRIX300, 3038.4 sec for FPPPP,   *
and 2648.6 sec for TOMCATV. The SPECratio is obtained by dividing the    *
program run time into the VAX 11/780 run time. SPECfp89 is the geometric *
mean of the SPECratio's. Results are all single CPU/FPU results.         *
                                                                         *
                                           SPECratio                     *
System                    -----------------------------------------   SPEC
                          SPICE2  DODUC  NASA7 MATRIX  FPPPP TOMCAT   fp89
--- --------------------- ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------
001 VAX 11/780               1.0    1.0    1.0    1.0    1.0    1.0    1.0
002 HP 9000/340              1.8    1.1    1.2    1.0    1.0    0.9    1.1
003 HP 9000/370              3.4    3.2    3.6    2.8    3.3    3.5    3.3
004 Sun 4/260                4.8    3.4    3.4    9.3    2.9    4.2    4.3
005 Motorola 8864DP          6.6    6.0    5.7    7.6    5.7    4.9    6.0
006 Motorola 8608            7.1    6.3    6.3    8.7    6.2    5.2    6.6
007 Motorola 8864SP          7.3    6.4    6.3    8.3    6.0    5.4    6.6
008 Intel 486/25             8.8    5.8    5.8    9.5    7.0    4.3    6.6
009 Sun SPARCstation SLC     7.1    4.3    8.8    9.5    6.7    5.2    6.7
010 DEC 6000/410             6.2    6.9    8.2    6.5    7.5    7.4    7.1
011 Sun SPARCstation 1       8.3    5.0    8.7   11.1    7.9    5.6    7.5
012 Sun SPARCstation 1       8.2    5.0   10.2   11.0    7.8    6.0    7.8
013 DECstation 2100          7.0    8.3    9.7    7.2    8.9    7.3    8.0
014 MIPS RC2030              8.8    9.8   12.0    5.7    4.7   10.7    8.2
015 DG Aviion 410            8.2    6.7    8.9   10.3    8.0    8.0    8.3
016 DG Aviion 310            8.3    6.9    9.3   10.9    8.3    8.3    8.6
017 DG Aviion 5010           8.7    7.1    9.5   11.1    8.7    8.9    8.9
018 HP 9000/834              8.7    8.7    9.1   10.5    9.0    8.5    9.1
019 MIPS RX2030              9.0    9.9   13.3    9.6    4.9   11.0    9.2
020 Sun SPARCstation 1+     10.0    6.1   12.1   12.8    9.5    7.1    9.3
021 DECstation 3100          9.6    9.0   12.2    6.0   10.4   10.2    9.4
022 NeXTstation 040/25       9.6    7.9   11.8   10.6   11.1    9.4   10.0
023 Sun SPARCstation 330    11.1    8.3   11.2   14.4    9.4    7.5   10.1
024 MIPS M/120-5             9.9   11.0   12.8    5.9   12.2   11.1   10.2
025 HP 425t                 11.8    7.7   11.5   10.8   12.1    8.4   10.2
026 DEC DS5810               8.3   14.6    9.8    8.3   14.1    9.1   10.4
027 Motorola 8864SP         10.0    8.1   12.2   14.7   11.7    9.3   10.8
028 DECstation 3100          9.5   11.3   13.2    9.8   12.5    9.9   10.9
029 HP 425s                 13.1    8.1   12.1   11.5   13.4    9.1   11.0
030 CDC 920B-450            10.6   11.1   12.6    9.9   12.2   10.7   11.1
031 SGI 4D/25S              10.6   11.1   12.6    9.9   12.2   10.7   11.1
032 DEC DS5400               9.1   12.8   12.8   10.4   13.4    9.9   11.3
033 DG Aviion 6200          11.0    9.2   11.9   14.1   10.9   11.0   11.3
034 Sun SPARCstation 330    11.4    9.5   14.0   14.7   13.1    8.2   11.6
035 CDC 910B-621            10.0   14.7   14.4    9.7   16.1   10.8   12.4
036 SGI 4D/210S             10.0   14.7   14.4    9.7   16.1   10.8   12.4
037 Motorola 8864SP         12.5   10.1   15.2   18.4   14.7   11.6   13.5
038 MIPS M/2000             12.0   17.6   16.8    8.4   20.1   16.8   14.7
039 MIPS RC3240             12.1   15.9   18.1   13.8   17.7   13.9   15.1
040 CDC 4340                13.6   15.8   18.1   13.6   17.5   14.2   15.3
041 Solbourne 5/801         14.9   11.6   16.1   22.6   17.9   11.8   15.4
042 Harris Night Hawk       13.4   11.9   16.2   21.4   18.6   14.6   15.7
043 Motorola 8612           14.8   12.2   17.5   21.5   15.3   14.9   15.8
044 Intel 486 50DX2         16.9   11.5   17.0   25.0   13.1   14.6   15.9
045 MIPS RC3260             12.0   17.3   18.2   13.1   20.0   17.3   16.0
046 MIPS M/2000             12.1   17.6   18.4   13.3   20.4   17.7   16.3
047 CDC 4360                13.5   17.1   18.4   13.3   20.0   16.9   16.3
048 CDC 4380                13.5   17.4   18.4   13.4   20.1   17.1   16.5
049 MIPS RX3230             14.2   16.9   21.0   15.4   15.8   18.5   16.8
050 Sun SPARCstation 490    16.4   14.0   19.9   22.5   18.8   12.3   17.0
051 SGI 4D/320S             15.3   19.8   18.2   13.3   24.7   16.5   17.6
052 DEC DS5000/200          13.7   18.1   22.6   17.0   22.0   17.3   18.2
053 Sun SPARCstation 2      16.5   14.1   23.4   23.7   18.2   15.6   18.2
054 Intel 486 50DX          20.8   12.2   21.1   29.0   14.7   16.5   18.3
055 Apollo DN10010           7.7   23.0   20.4   21.8   32.0   19.9   19.2
056 Sun SPARCstation 2      16.5   18.0   23.4   23.7   22.1   15.6   19.6
057 HP DN10010              11.9   23.0   20.5   22.0   32.0   19.9   20.7
058 Sun SPARCstation 2      16.5   18.0   27.1   27.8   22.1   16.9   20.9
059 Intel 486 66DX2         22.6   15.4   22.7   33.7   17.5   19.5   21.2
060 Sun SPARCstation 2      16.8   18.4   27.4   28.1   23.6   17.8   21.5
061 Intel STAR860           14.8   15.7   45.0   21.5   21.9   35.8   23.7
062 Sun SPARCstation 2      16.5   18.2   29.1   82.6   23.8   24.9   27.4
063 IBM RS6000/520          19.8   21.4   26.7   17.5   42.8   56.4   27.9
064 IBM RS6000/320          19.8   21.7   26.6   17.5   42.8   56.4   28.0
065 Alacron AL860           18.1   17.1   57.2   28.1   26.0   43.4   28.7
066 IBM RS6000/530          27.6   27.8   35.5   21.8   54.3   75.7   36.7
067 IBM RS6000/930          27.6   27.8   35.5   21.8   54.3   75.7   36.7
068 IBM RS6000/730          27.6   27.8   36.6   22.4   54.3   75.7   37.0
069 Stardent 3010           14.7   19.6   63.0  107.7   29.2   61.6   39.0
070 CDC 4680 (beta)         37.7   38.0   39.6   52.6   52.4   36.8   42.3
071 MIPS 6280 (beta)        37.7   38.0   39.6   52.6   52.4   36.8   42.3
072 IBM RS6000/540          33.2   33.3   43.4   26.5   66.1   91.3   44.4
073 HP 9000/720             46.9   48.6   58.0  210.0   81.4   52.9   70.2
074 HP 9000/730             58.3   66.5   78.7  407.7  105.9   83.6  101.6
075 IBM RS6000/550          47.2   49.4  144.4  729.8   86.8  138.0  119.7

LINEAR CORRELATION OF:

SPICE2G6 to SPICE2G6:    -----
SPICE2G6 to DUDOC:       0.943 *
SPICE2G6 to NASA7:       0.816
SPICE2G6 to MATRIX300:   0.691
SPICE2G6 to FPPPP:       0.945 *
SPICE2G6 to TOMCATV:     0.816
SPICE2G6 to SPECfp89:    0.926 *

DUDOC to SPICE2G6:       0.943 *
DUDOC to DUDOC:          -----
DUDOC to NASA7:          0.817
DUDOC to MATRIX300:      0.686
DUDOC to FPPPP:          0.970 *
DUDOC to TOMCATV:        0.813
DUDOC to SPECfp89:       0.926 *

NASA7 to SPICE2G6:       0.816
NASA7 to DUDOC:          0.817
NASA7 to NASA7:          -----
NASA7 to MATRIX300:      0.873
NASA7 to FPPPP:          0.829
NASA7 to TOMCATV:        0.885
NASA7 to SPECfp89:       0.948 *

MATRIX300 to SPICE2G6:   0.691
MATRIX300 to DUDOC:      0.686
MATRIX300 to NASA7:      0.873
MATRIX300 to MATRIX300:  -----
MATRIX300 to FPPPP:      0.689
MATRIX300 to TOMCATV:    0.700
MATRIX300 to SPECfp89:   0.884

FPPPP to SPICE2G6:       0.945 *
FPPPP to DUDOC:          0.970 *
FPPPP to NASA7:          0.829
FPPPP to MATRIX300:      0.689
FPPPP to FPPPP:          -----
FPPPP to TOMCATV:        0.895
FPPPP to SPECfp89:       0.937 *

TOMCATV to SPICE2G6:     0.816
TOMCATV to DUDOC:        0.813
TOMCATV to NASA7:        0.885
TOMCATV to MATRIX300:    0.700
TOMCATV to FPPPP:        0.895
TOMCATV to TOMCATV:      -----
TOMCATV to SPECfp89:     0.889

SPICE2G6, DUDOC, FPPPP, and SPECfp89 all show reasonably strong
correlations with one another. The correlations start to go to pot
with NASA7, then TOMCATV, and finally MATRIX300 which shows the
poorest correlation to the rest of the programs. These last three
programs appear to be the most sensitive to optimization. SPICE2G6
and DUDOC appear to be the most 'stable' programs (so far anyway).

Starting with system 061 the Arithmetic Mean starts to deviate
widely from the Geometric Mean and the Standard Deviation grows 
from +/-11 for system 061 up to +/-240 for system 075. It is with
these systems that the fluctuation in performance becomes most
erratic and hence the ability to predict performance differences a 
bit more fuzzy.

Al Aburto
aburto@marlin.nosc.mil

-------

Newsgroups: comp.benchmarks