From: gmeltzne@jarthur.claremont.edu (Manu)
Subject: Re: Rebel attack kills 5 Israeli soldiers, wounds 5 more
Organization: Harvey Mudd College, Claremont, CA 91711
Date: Thu, 12 Nov 1992 03:46:55 GMT

In article <1992Nov11.140022.18749@ncsu.edu> hernlem@chess.ncsu.EDU (Brad Hernlem) writes:
>In article <1992Nov11.065002.16028@muddcs.claremont.edu>,
>gmeltzne@jarthur.claremont.edu (Manu) writes:
>> In article <Nov.10.21.37.51.1992.22601@caip.rutgers.edu>
>marwang@caip.rutgers.edu (Marwan Gharaybeh) writes:
>> >eyad@ecst.csuchico.edu (Eyad M. Alnuweiri) writes:
>> >
>> >>In article <1992Oct26.180255.28508@dazixco.ingr.com> naftaly writes:
>> >
>> >>When an Israeli soldier (or any occupation soldier) is in an occupied land
>> >>(West Bank, Gaza, South Lebanon), and he/she dies in any type of resistence
>> >>action, then he/she died in duty for the ideas of the state they represent.
>> >>They  are "soldiers" and this is their "paid job", so that is expected to
>> >>some extent from him/her, from the family, and from the Israeli government.
>> >
>> >The answer is simple and could be extracted from recent history ... In the
>> >late 1930's/early 1940's a country called germany was run by a group of
>> >NAZI's ... the Nazis used this very same procedure that you have just
>> >outlined namely; when a nazi soldier is killed in a country that they
>> >brutally occupied (France as an example) by the resistance hero's they
>> >used to get a group of the resisdents of the nearby village (women/children
>> >included) and execute them with there blood-thirsty/black-hatred rifles.
>> >
>> >Israel is using this same procedure again ... Now.
>> 
>> 	I would like you to citye an example of when Israel rounded up
>> 	the residents of a village and executed them.  Until then, your
>> 	post is pure BS.
>> 
>> 
>>
>   I believe that Marwan was drawing a comparison between these actions
>and, for example, the shelling of and bulldozing of the South Lebanese
>villages of Yater and Kafra by the IDF following the Isreali
>assasination of Sheikh Abbas Mosavi, his wife and young son by incineration.
>
>Admittedly not completely identical actions but both decidedly
>despicable and certainly both aimed at crushing opposition to occupation.

	I'm unfamiliar with the two examples that you cited and would
	appreciate it if you or anyone else elaborated on them.  (I mean
	the villages, I know about Musawi, for whom I have no compassion.
	However the fate of is family is tragic.)

	Geoff
>Brad Hernlem (hernlem@chess.ncsu.EDU)
>
>
> 							Manu
>> >
>>
>>______________________________________________________________________________
>> >                                                                     
>_
>> >Marwan Gharaybeh:                         ||                         
>_(_ 
>> >                                          ||               | |       
>|
>> >Better Known as ...                       ||    ()         | |       
>|
>> >                                          ||           _   | |     
>.-     | |
>> >Hadi el-gossah gossat hamdah ...          ||      \___/ \__/ |     
>(_|____/ |
>> >Hamdah, el-rimsh elly yitehaddah ...      ||       |  \_/    |       
>|      |
>> >galat mareedak ...                        ||  \___/      /   |  
>\___/    *  |
>> >mareedak, lo tethbahnee be`eedak mareedak.||            /
>>
>>=======================================================================
>=========
>> 
>> 
>> -- 
>> Email: gmeltzne@jarthur.claremont.edu            
>> 
>> A .sig?  A .sig? We don't need no stinkin' .sigs!
>


-- 
Email: gmeltzne@jarthur.claremont.edu            

A .sig?  A .sig? We don't need no stinkin' .sigs!