From: hiraoka@snoopy.ohsaki.meidensha.co.jp (Josuke Hiraoka)
Newsgroups: fj.soc.misc
Subject: Re: Economics and Marx
Date: 5 Oct 92 12:09:54 GMT
	<YASHI.92Sep20103758@ritsuko.cs.titech.ac.jp>
	<MASAITOH.92Sep22110833@econsun1.e.u-tokyo.ac.jp>
	<INF31E.92Sep22172743@elena.ling.flab.fujitsu.co.jp>
	<SATO.92Sep28224033@cs21.atr-sw.atr.co.jp> <YONEMU-T.92Se
Followup-To: fj.soc.misc
Distribution: fj.soc.misc
Organization: MEIDENSHA CORPORATION, Tokyo, Japan
In-reply-to: sato@atr-sw.atr.co.jp's message of 3 Oct 92 07:35:09 GMT

$@J?2,!wL@EE<K$G$9(J

In article <SATO.92Oct3163509@cs21.atr-sw.atr.co.jp> sato@atr-sw.atr.co.jp ($@:4F#$5$s(J) writes:

>  In article <HIRAOKA.92Oct2193834@snoopy.ohsaki.meidensha.co.jp> hiraoka@snoopy.ohsaki.meidensha.co.jp ($@;d(J) writes:

>   |$@%^%k%/%9$,M=4|$7$?$h$j$b!";qK\<g5A$,6/pW$G$"$C$?$N$O3N$+$G$7$g$&!#(J
>   |$@$7$+$7!"<+M3$J;T>l7P:Q$N%a%+%K%:%`$O!"7h$7$F0BDjE*$J<R2q$r<B8=$7(J
>   |$@$^$;$s$G$7$?!#$=$l$r>/$7$G$b0BDjE*$J$b$N$K$7$h$&$H$7$F!"$$$m$$$m(J
>   |$@$J@)EY$,9M$(=P$5$l$F$$$kLu$G$9$h$M!#(J

>  $@$=$&$=$&!"%1%$%s%8%"%s$N9M$(J}$G$9$M!#;T>l$rF0$+$7$F$$$k$N$O(J
>  $@46>p$r;}$C$??M4V$G$9$+$i!";~@^$j!"Hs>o$K6KC<$J5sF0$r<($9$3$H(J
>  $@$,$"$j$^$9!#IT67$K$J$k$H3'$,Ej;q$r95$($F$^$9$^$9IT67$,?<9o$K(J
>  $@$J$k$H$+!#$=$l$rKI$0$?$a!"8x6&Ej;q$J$I$N@/I\$K$h$k;T>l$X$N2p(J
>  $@F~$,I,MW$K$J$k$o$1$G$9!#(J

$@$O$$!#$=$&$J$s$G$9$,!"$?$@!"$3$l$r!"!V;~@^$j!W$H$$$C$F:Q$^$;(J
$@$FNI$$$N$+$I$&$+!#$3$l$r;qK\<g5A$N;}$DK\<AE*$J7g4Y$H9M$($k$N(J
$@$,!"@5$7$$$N$G$O$J$$$+!#$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#8=$K!"$3$l$@$1H/E8$7(J
$@$F$-$?8=:_$N7P:Q$G$b!"IT67$NGH$O7c$7$$$G$9$+$i!#(J

>  $@$?$@!"$3$l$O$"$/$^$G$b;T>l%a%+%K%:%`$r0BDj$K5!G=$5$;$k$?$a$N(J
>  $@6[5^HrFqE*$JA<CV$G$"$k$3$H$rK:$l$F$O$$$1$^$;$s!#2aEY$N;T>l2p(J
>  $@F~$O7k6I7P:Q$N3hNO$r$=$.!"<R2q<g5A$N<:GT$r7+$jJV$9$3$H$K$J$j(J
>  $@$^$9$+$i!#JF:nG@6H$J$s$F$N$OE57?E*$J;vNc$G$9$M!#(J

$@7+$jJV$7$K$J$j$^$9$,!"!V6[5^HrFqE*$JA<CV!W$G:Q$^$;$i$l$J$$K\<A(J
$@E*$JLdBj$r4^$s$G$$$k$H9M$($k$o$1$G$9!#$J$K$;!"IT67$NEY$K!"@83h(J
$@$r6<$+$5$l$k$N$O=nL1$G$9$+$i!#!JAH9g$,6/$1$l$POC$OJQ$o$k$1$I!K(J

>   |$@!V<R2q$,<+M3$K$J$k$K$D$l!W$H$$$&$N$O!V<+M3!W$N0UL#$N2r<a$,$h$/(J
>   |$@H=$j$^$;$s$,!"O+F/AH9g$NH/E8$H$+!"FH@j6X;_K!$H$+$b;X$7$F$$$k$H(J
>   |$@8@$&$3$H$G$7$g$&$+!#(J

>  $@$=$&8@$&0UL#$G$O$J$/$F!">pJs$,$$$-EO$k$?$a$KC/$b$,;T>l$K;22C(J
>  $@$9$k$?$a$NCN<1$rF@$d$9$/$J$C$F$$$k!"$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#$J$s$;!"(J
>  TV $@%?%l%s%H$@$C$F2q<R:n$C$A$c$&@$$NCf$G$9$+$i!#(J

$@$=$&$G$9$M!#$3$NJU$,!"Fq$7$$=j$G$9$,!#(J
$@3N$+$K$*$C$7$c$k$h$&$JB&LL$b$"$j$^$9$,!"5U$K!"<+M3$K$J$C$?$h$&$K(J
$@8+$($F$b!"7k6I!";qK\NO$N$"$k<T$,!">pJs$rFH@j$7$F$7$^$&!#$H$$$&;v(J
$@$K$O$J$i$J$$$G$7$g$&$+!#D94|E*$K8+$l$P!#(J

>   |$@$3$N%a%+%K%:%`$,F/$/$H!"<e$$2q<R$,DY$l$F$$$C$F!">/?t$N6/$$2q<R(J
>   |$@$,!"@8$-;D$k$o$1$G$9$M!#6/$$!"<e$$$O!"O+F/<T$KJ'$&DB6b$H!"@=IJ(J
>   |$@$NCMCJ$@$1$G$O7h$^$j$^$;$s$+$i!#7P1D<T$N9M$(J}$H$+$b$"$j$^$9$,!"(J
>   |$@FC$K5;=QNO$,7hDjE*$K8z$$$F$/$k$N$,:#$N7P:Q<R2q$NFCD'$G$9$h$M!#(J
>   |$@$G$9$+$i!"$=$N7k2L$H$7$F!"2I@j2=$,?J$_!"FH@j2=$,@8$8$^$9!#$=$&(J
>   |$@$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$O!"$[$s$N0lIt$N?M4V$,!"$"$^$j$K$bBg$-$J1F6ANO$r(J
>   |$@9T;H$9$k$3$H$N=PMh$k<R2q$K$J$C$F$7$^$$$^$9!#(J
>   |$@;d$b7P:Q$,@lLg$G$O$J$$$N$G!"$7$+$H$7$?;v$O8@$($^$;$s$,!"%l!<%K(J
>   |$@%s$"$?$j$O!"$=$N5"7k$H$7$F$N6bM;;:6H!J!)!K$K$h$kFH@j;qK\<g5A$r(J
>   |$@O@$8$?$O$:$G$9!#(J

>  $@$^$:!"<e$$2q<R$,DY$l$F$$$/$N$O$"$kDxEY;EJ}$N$J$$$3$H$G$9!#<e(J
>  $@$$2q<R$,DY$l$J$$!J$D$^$j6%Ah86M}$NF/$+$J$$!K<R2q$OIT7rA4$G!"(J
>  $@$=$N$7$o4s$;$O$+$J$i$:B>$NItJ,$XGH5Z$9$k$3$H$K$J$k$G$7$g$&!#(J

>  $@$?$@!"$=$N7k2L$H$7$F2I@j2=$,6KC<$K?J$`$H8@$&$3$H$O<+M3$J<R2q(J
>  $@$G$O$^$:$"$jF@$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#4k6H$,2I@j2=$rL\;X$9$N$O;T>l$K(J
>  $@$*$1$k2A3J$N7hDj8"$rF@$F$h$jM-Mx$J2A3J$G@=IJ$rGd$k$?$a$G$9$,!"(J
>  $@$=$N$h$&$J9b<}1W$N>&Gd$K$OI,$:%i%$%P%k2q<R$,8=$l$k$b$N$G$9!#(J

$@$3$3$NItJ,$O$"$^$j@bF@NO$,$"$j$^$;$s$M!#(J
$@;d$bM>$j6qBNE*$J;qNA$K$O>\$7$/$"$j$^$;$s$,!"(J
$@%h!<%m%C%Q$G$O!"E49]$d<+F0<V$dEE5$$d2=3X$H$$$C$?;:6H$,!"8+;v$K(J
$@2I@j2=$5$l$F$$$k$N$G$O$"$j$^$;$s$+!#F10l6H<o$G9q:]E*$KBg4k6H$H(J
$@8@$($k$N$O!"JR<j$G?t$($k$[$I$J$N$G$O!)(J
$@%"%a%j%+$G$b<+F0<V$O%S%C%0%9%j!<!"EE5$$O#G#E!"#W#H$H$+!#(J

>  $@5;=Q$NFH@j$b!"5;=Q$,H/E8$7$?$j8x3+$5$l$F$$$k<R2q$G$O$J$+$J$+(J
>  $@Fq$7$$$G$7$g$&$M!#8=$K(J IBM $@$OB-85$,$0$i$D$$$F$$$k$G$7$g!#(J

$@$O$$$O$$!#$3$N!"2I@j2=$NLdBj$rO@$8$k$H$-$K%-!<$H$J$k$N$O!"$=$N;:(J
$@6H$,$I$NDxEY5;=QE*$K@.=O$7$F$$$k$+!"$G$7$g$&!#@8;:8zN($dIJ<A$,!"(J
$@5;=QE*$J8B3&$KMh$F$$$k$H8@$($k$[$I$K@.=O$7$F$$$l$P!"2I@j2=$,?J$_!"(J
$@$=$&$G$J$$$J$i$P!"?75,;2F~$b2DG=$G$7$g$&!#F|K\$J$i(J
$@$+$J$j@.=O$7$F$$$kE49]$O!"Bg<j#5<R!#(J
$@CfDxEY$N<+F0<V$G!"%H%h%?!"F|;:!"K\ED!";0I)!"%^%D%@$H$+$b$&>/$7!#(J
$@EE5$$O=EEE$J$i!"Am9g;0<R%W%i%9>/!9!#(J
$@2HEE$d>pJs$O5;=QE*$K1d$S@9$j$G$9$+$i!"$^$@2I@j2=$O0BDj$7$F$$$^$;$s!#(J

$@$D$^$j!"$[$C$F$*$1$P!"!JBg$-$JIT67$J$I$,%H%j%,$H$J$C$F!KI,$:2I@j2=(J
$@$,?J$`!"$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

>   |$@6d9T$d>Z7t$,7P:Q$NCf3K$r5m<*$k$h$&$K$J$C$?%P%V%k4|$NF|K\$J$s$F!"(J
>   |$@$^$5$K!"E*Cf$J$s$8$c$J$$$G$7$g$&$+!#(J

>  $@F|K\$K$*$1$k7P:Q%7%9%F%`$NLdBjE@$O!"6H<o$K$h$C$F;T>l;2F~$N>c(J
>  $@JI$K$+$J$j$N:9$,$"$k$3$H$G$9$M!#@=B$6H$,2aEv6%Ah$KSC$$$G$$$k(J
>  $@$N$K6d9T$,9b<}1WBN<A$r0];}$G$-$k$N$O!"6bM;6H$,BgB">J$N5vG'2D(J
>  $@6HL3$G?75,;2F~$,;v<B>eIT2DG=$K$J$C$F$$$k$+$i$G$9!#$=$l$K2C$((J
>  $@$F$$$6$H$J$l$P@/I\$,2?$H$+$7$F$/$l$k!"@dBPDY$l$k$3$H$O$J$$$H(J
>  $@$$$&4E$($,$"$k$b$N$@$+$i%j%9%/4IM}$,4E$/$`$A$c$JB_$7=P$7$r$7(J
>  $@$F%P%V%k$r@z$C$?$o$1!#K\Mh$J$i!"$3$N$h$&$J$^$H$b$J7P1DH=CG$N(J
>  $@$G$-$J$$6d9T$K$ODY$l$F$b$i$C$?J}$,@$$NCf$N$?$a$J$s$G$9$,!#(J

$@F|K\$N6d9T$N;}$DLdBj$O!"3N$+$K$=$N$H$*$j$G$9!#$3$l$+$i!"5,@)$,(J
$@4KOB$5$l$k$H!":FJT@.$,?J$_!"$5$i$K2I@j2=$5$l$k$3$H$G$7$g$&!#(J

>  $@$D$^$j!"!V;qK\<g5A$N9T$-$D$/@h$N2I@j2=!W$J$I$G$O$J$/!"<R2q<g(J
>  $@5AE*$J%7%9%F%`$,29B8$5$l$F$$$k$?$a$KIY$_$NJ,G[$,IT8xJ?$K$J$C(J
>  $@$F$$$k$H$$$&0l8+L7=b$7$?8=>]$,@8$8$F$$$k$N$,8=>u$G$7$g$&!#$3(J
>  $@$l$rNc$($P@/I\$N5,@)$K$h$C$F6d9T$NB_$7=P$7$r@)8B$7%P%V%k$N:F(J
>  $@G3$rKI$4$&$J$I$H$9$k$N$O!"K\KvE>E]$G$9!#2f!9$O$h$j<+M3$J<R2q(J
>  $@$r<B8=$9$k$?$a$K@/I\$N5,@)4KOB$r$3$=5a$a$k$Y$-$J$N$G$9$h!#(J

$@$U!<$`!#>e$K=q$+$l$F$$$k!"8=>uG'<1$O$I$&$bM}2r$7$+$M$^$9!#Hs>o$K(J
$@FC<l$JLdBj$r$3$H$5$iBg$-$/<h$j>e$2$F$O$$$^$;$s$+!)(J
$@<+M3$J<R2q$r<B8=$9$k$?$a$K@/I\$N5,@)4KOB$r5a$a$k$3$H$O!"Bg6Z$N(J
$@0lHLO@$H$7$F$O;?@.$7$^$9!#8D!9$K8+$F$$$/$H!"=D3d$j9T@/$NJ@32$G(J
$@?oJ,GO</$J5,@)$b$"$k$i$7$$$G$9$+$i$M!#(J
$@$G$9$,!":4F#$5$s$N$*$C$7$c$k!"K\KvE>E]$NItJ,$,!"K\KvE>E]$K;W$($^$9!#(J

>  100$@Jb>y$l$P!"%^%k%/%9$,;XE&$7$?;qK\<g5A$NLdBjE@$,!"%1%$%s%:(J
>  $@$K1F6A$rM?$($?$H$O8@$($k$+$bCN$l$^$;$s$,!#(J

$@$I$&$$$?$7$^$7$F!#(J:-)

>  $@$=$l$K$7$F$b!"<R2q<g5A$,?MN`$KM?$($?:R2R$O2a5n$NG!2?$J$k@oAh(J
>  $@$bN?2o$9$k$b$N$G$7$?$+$i$M$'!#$^$"!"$3$l$O%^%k%/%90l?M$N@UG$(J
>  $@$G$O$J$$$s$@$1$I!#(J
$@$O!<!)$3$j$c$A$g$C$H8@$$2a$.$G$O!)(J
$@$I$C$A$K$7$F$b%^%k%/%9$N@UG$$JLu$,$J$$!#(J

>   |$@!!0UL#$H9=J8!"J*M}$H?t3X!"G'<1$H8@MU!"2ACM$H2_J>!"!"!"(J
>   |  $@!!!V8e<T!W$,!VA0<T!W$rI=8=$7$F$$$k$h$&$K8+$($^$9$,!"(J
>   |$@!!!!!!!!!VA0<T!W$N<B:_@-$dG!2?$K!)(J

>  $@6(F188A[(J :-)
$@$d$C$Q$j$=$&$G$7$g$&$+$M!#>iCL$8$c$J$/!#(J
--
$@L@EE<K(J $@Am9g8&(J $@J?2,>f2p!!!!!!(Jhiraoka@ohsaki.meidensha.co.jp 
$@!!0UL#$H9=J8!"J*M}$H?t3X!"G'<1$H8@MU!"2ACM$H2_J>!"!"!"(J
  $@!!!V8e<T!W$,!VA0<T!W$rI=8=$7$F$$$k$h$&$K8+$($^$9$,!"(J
$@!!!!!!!!!VA0<T!W$N<B:_@-$dG!2?$K!)(J