From: kitagawa@will.ntt.jp (Masahiro Kitagawa)
Newsgroups: fj.news.group
Subject: Re: Objection [CFD/CFA fj.life.in-japan]
Date: 12 Aug 92 17:55:04 GMT
	<1992Aug10.022739.14354@etl.go.jp>
	<TOZAKI.92Aug11135505@sapphire.math.keio.ac.jp>
	<MAD.92Aug12213213@lettuce.math.keio.ac.jp>
Distribution: fj
Organization: NTT Basic Research Labs., Tokyo, Japan

$@KM$b(J, $@$+$J$j6a$$(J$@$3$H$r=q$-$+$1$F$$$^$7$?!#$3$N(JNG$@$NCf?4E*$J%H%T%C%/%9$,(J
$@309q?M$K4X78$9$kOCBj$G$"$k$3$H$K4X$7$F$O(J, $@C/$b(J$@0[O@$,$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

($@7{>O$,$=$l$K9g$C$F$$$J$$$H$$$&0U8+$,=P$F$b$*$+$7$/$J$$$N$@$,(J, $@=P$^$;(J
$@$s$M!<!#(J)

$@$=$l$G(J, $@%0%l!<%>!<%s$NItJ,$@$1$,AhE@$K$J$C$F(J, $@2a>j$K%/%m!<%:%"%C%W$5$l(J
$@$F$$$^$9!#A0ED$5$s$,(J, $@NI$$Ld(J$@Bj$r=P$7$F$/$l$?$N$G(J, $@;d$N0U8+$r$^$H$a$5$;(J
$@$FD:$-$^$9!#(J($@8M:j$5$s$b(J, $@IMED$5$s$b(J, $@$3$N7o$K4X$7$F$O$3$l$,(J$@:G8e$@$+$i(J,
$@$^$"(J, $@FI$s$G$d$C$F2<$5$$!#(J)

In article <MAD.92Aug12213213@lettuce.math.keio.ac.jp> mad@math.keio.ac.jp (MAEDA Atusi) writes:

 |    (1) $@FbMF$H$7$F$OB>$N%K%e!<%9%0%k!<%W(J(fj.rec.food$@$d(Jfj.rec.movies$@$J(J
 |	  $@$I(J)$@$KEj9F$7$F$b$*$+$7$/$J$$$b$N$,(J($@$=$l$i$N%K%e!<%9%0%k!<%W$H$N(J
 |	  $@%/%m%9%]%9%H$H$7$F(J?)$@Ej9F$5$l$k!#(J
 |
 |    (2) (1)$@$N$h$&$J5-;v$O:G=i$+$i(Jfj.rec.*$@$@$1$KEj9F$5$l$k!#(J

 |$@$^$?>.J}$5$sB>!"$O$d(J$@$/%K%e!<%9%0%k!<%W$r:n$m$&$H9M$($F$*$i$l$kJ}!9$O!"(J
 |    (a) $@!V(J(1)$@$O2aEOE*$J>uBV$G!"$f$/$f$/$O(J(2)$@$,K>(J$@$^$7$$!W$N$+!#(J
 |    (b1)$@!V(J(1)$@$,1J5W$KB3$$$F$b9=$o$J$$!W$"$k$$$O$`$7$m(J
 |    (b2)$@!V(J(1)$@$,1J5W$KB3$/$Y$-(J$@$@!W$J$N$+!#(J
 |$@$I$A$i$G$7$g$&$+!#(J

$@KM$O(J, (1) $@$K$J$k$+(J (2) $@$K$J$k$+$O(J, fj $@A4BN$N>u67$dB>$N(JNG$@$N>u67$K$h(J$@$C$F(J
$@<+$:$+$i7h$^$k$H$$$&0U8+$r4{$KEj9F$7$F$$$^$9!#(J

$@8=:_$N>u67$G$O(J, $@$*$=$i$/(J (1) $@$K6a$$$G$7$g$&!#$3$N(J$@>uBV$GC1=c$K(J (1) $@$rH](J
$@Dj$7$F(J (2) $@$r6/MW$9$k$H(J, (i) $@Ej9F0UM_$,$=$,$l$k(J, (ii) fj $@$O8+<N$F$F(J 
soc.culture.japan $@Ey$KN.$l$k(J, (iii) fj $@$X$N:_F|309q?M$N;22C$,$$$D$^$G(J
$@$bA}$($J$$(J, $@Ey$N0-1F6A$,$"$k$H;W$$$^$9!#$3(J$@$s$J$3$H$O(J, $@C/$bK>$s$G$$$J$$(J
$@$G$7$g$&!#(J

(1) $@$+$i(J $@B>$N(JNG$@$K%/%m%9%]%9%H$5$l$k$+$I$&$+$O(J, $@$=$N%/%m%9%]%9(J$@%H$,Ej9F(J
$@<T$K$H$C$FM-1W$G$"$C$?$+$I$&$+$H$$$&$3$H$K$h$C$F7hDj$5$l$k$H;W$$$^$9!#(J
$@%/%m%9%]%9%H$7$F$b(J, $@$=(J$@$A$i$+$i$NH?1~$,$J$1$l$P(J, $@Ej9F<T$O(J, $@$=$N%/%m%9%](J
$@%9%H$OM-1W$GL5$+$C$?$HH=CG$9$k$G$7$g$&!#$=$&$$$&$3$H(J$@$,B3$1$P(J, $@=y!9$K%/(J
$@%m%9%]%9%H$O$5$l$J$/$J$k$G$7$g$&!#5U$K(J, $@!V(Jfj.somewhere $@$GFI$s$@$N$G!W(J
$@$H$$$&MM$J%U(J$@%)%m!<$,$"$l$P(J, $@Ej9F<T$O%/%m%9%]%9%H$,M-1W$G$"$k$HH=CG$7(J, 
$@@Q6KE*$K9T$J$&$h$&$K$J$k$G$7$g$&!#$I$A$i$K(J$@$J$k$+$O(J, $@%/%m%9%]%9%H@h$N(JNG
$@$NFI<T$N?t(J, $@6=L#(J, $@309q8l$N%9%-%k(J, $@%"%/%F%#%S%F%#!<Ey$G:81&$5$l$k$G$7$g(J
$@$&(J$@!#=>$C$F(J, $@%/%m%9%]%9%H$5$l$k$+$I$&$+$O(J, $@Ej9F<T$,<+J,$NMx1W$r(Jmaximize
$@$7$h$&$H$9$k%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$N7k2L(J$@$H$7$F(J, fj $@$NB>$N(JNG$@$N>u67$rH?1G$7$?$b(J
$@$N$K$J$C$F9T$/$G$7$g$&!#%U%)%m!<$7$J$$%5%$%l%s%H!&%j%9%J!<$,$$$?(J$@$H$7$F(J
$@$b(J, $@$=$l$OEj9F<T$K$O$o$+$j$^$;$s$+$i(J, $@%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$N30$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(J

$@F1$8$3$H$,(J, (2) $@$K$D(J$@$$$F$b8@$($^$9!#Ej9F$9$k(JNG$@$rA*Br$9$k:]$N(J, $@:G$b:,8;(J
$@E*$J4p=`$O(J, $@!V:G$bNI$/FI$^$l!?%U%)%m!<$5$l$k$G$"$m(J$@$&!W$3$H$G$7$g$&!#B((J
$@$AFI<TAX$K$h$kA*Br$G$9!#$3$l$O(J, $@C1=c$KOCBj$NJ,N`$H$O0c$$$^$9!#OCBj$,6&(J
$@DL$7$F$$$F(J$@$b(J, $@8@8l$,M}2r$G$-$J$1$l$PFI$s$G$b$i$($J$$$7(J, $@%P%C%/%0%i%&%s(J
$@%I$,0[$J$l$PM}2r$7$F$b$i$($J$$$3$H$b$"$j(J$@$^$9!#$D$^$j(J,$@!VOCBj!W!V8@8l!W(J
$@!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!WEy$rAm9gE*$KH=CG$7$F(J, $@FI<TAX$rA[Dj$7$F(JNG$@$rA*$V$o$1(J
$@$G$9!#(Jfj $@$NKX$I$OF|K\$K=;$s$G$$$kF|K\?M$GF|K\8l$r;H$C$F$$$^$9$+$i(J, 
$@!V8@8l!W$d!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!W$r?4(J$@G[$;$:$K(J, $@!VOCBj!W$@$1$G(JNG$@$rA*Br$9$l(J
$@$P==J,$@$C$?$o$1$G$9!#$3$l$O9,$$$K$7$F$=$&$J$@$1$G$"$C$F(J, $@$=$l$,(J$@M#0l@d(J
$@BP$NA*Br4p=`$G$"$k$H4*0c$$$7$F(J, $@?M$K2!$7$D$1$k$h$&$J$3$H$,$"$C$F$O$$$1(J
$@$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

$@Nc$($P(J, $@;d$O(J Australia $@$N(J network $@;v>p$K$D$$$F$I$&$7$F$bCN$j$?$$$3$H$,(J
$@$"$C$F(J, soc.culture.australian $@$KEj9F(J$@$7$?$3$H$,$"$j$^$9$,(J, $@$3$N;~$NA*(J
$@Br4p=`$O(J, $@!V%*!<%9%H%i%j%"$G(J network $@$r;H$C$F$$$k?M!W$H$$$&!V%P%C%/%0(J
$@%i%&%s%I!W$G$"$C$F(J, $@!VOCBj!W$G$O$"$j$^$;$s$G$7$?!#3N$+$K(J, $@$=$NOCBj$O%*!<(J
$@%9%H%i%j%"$NJ82=$H$O$"$^$j4X(J$@$o$j$N$J$$$3$H$G$7$?$,(J, $@?F@Z$J(J mail $@$r$$$/(J
$@$D$+D:$$$F(J, $@LdBj$OL5;v2r7h$7$^$7$?!#$3$l$O$"$^$jNI$$Nc$G$O(J$@$J$+$C$?$+$b(J
$@$7$l$^$;$s!#;d$O(J, $@$=$N(JNG$@$KAj1~$7$/$J$$OCBj$G$9$,(J, $@$HA0CV$-$7$?$h$&$J5$(J
$@$b$7$^$9!#$7$+$7(J, soc.culture.japan $@$G$b(J, $@!VF|K\?M$"$k$$$OF|K\$K=;$s$G(J
$@$$$k(J/$@$$$??M!W$H$$$&!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!W$H!V1Q8l(J$@!W$H$$$&!V8@8l!W$r4|BT(J
$@$7$FEj9F$5$l$k(J, $@!VF|K\$NJ82=!W$H$$$&!VOCBj!W$H$O4X78$N$J$$5-;v$,(J, $@$+$J(J
$@$j$NNL$r(J$@@j$a$F$$$^$9!#B>$N(J soc.culture.* $@$b;w$?$j$h$C$?$j$N$h$&$G$9!#(J

$@JL$NNc$r5s$2$^$7$g$&!#!V9b<~GH2sO)!W$N(J$@OCBj$O(J, $@Nc$(!V%"%^%A%e%"L5@~!W$N(J
$@OCBj$G$J$/$H$b(J fj.sci.misc $@$h$j$O(J fj.rec.ham $@$KEj9F$9$k$N$,M-8z$@$H9M(J
$@$($k?M$OB?$$$G$7$g$&!#$=$l$O(J, $@!V%"%^%A%e%"L5@~2H!W$H$$$&!V%P%C%/%0%i%&(J
$@%s%I!W$r;}$C$?FI<TAX$O(J, $@9b<~GH(J$@$K$b>\$7$$$G$"$m$&$H4|BT$7$F$$$k$+$i$G$9!#(J
$@2>$K(J sci.microwave $@$H$$$&$N$,$"$C$?$H$7$F$b(J($@$J$$$1$I(J), $@!VF|(J$@K\8l!W$H$$(J
$@$&!V8@8l!W$r4|BT$9$l$P(J, $@$=$3$K$OEj9F$7$J$$$G$7$g$&!#(J

$@309q?M$NOCBj$K4X$9$k(JNG$@$K$D$$$F$bF1$8(J$@$3$H$,8@$($^$9!#$^$:(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$K$O(J, 
$@!V309q?M$K4X78$9$k!W!VOCBj!W$N5-;v$,Ej9F$5$l$k$3$H$,4|BT$5$l$^$9!#(J($@FI(J
$@<T$,$=$&4|BT$9$k!#(J) $@=>$C$F(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$K$O!V309q?M$K4X78$9$kOCBj!W$K6=L#$r(J
$@$b$C$F$$$kFI<TAX$,$$$k$o$1(J$@$G$9!#$=$NFI<TAX$K$O(J, $@I,A3E*$K!VF|K\$K=;$s$G(J
$@$$$k309q?M!W$H$$$&!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!W$r;}$C$??M$,B?$/4^(J$@$^$l$F$$$k$3$H(J
$@$,4|BT$5$l$^$9!#$^$?(J, $@309q?M$+F|K\?M$+$rLd$o$:(J, $@!VF|K\8l0J30!W$N!V8@8l!W(J
$@$rM}2r$9$k?M$,(J$@B?$/4^$^$l$F$$$k$3$H$b4|BT$5$l$^$9!#$=$N$h$&$K(J, $@Ej9F<T$,(J
$@M=A[$9$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(J

$@F|K\?M$+$i8+$l$P(J, $@!V309q?M$K4X78$9$k!W$H$$$&!VOCBj!W0J30$NM}M3$G$3$N(JNG
$@$KEj9F$9$kI,MW@-$O$"$^$j46$8$i$l$J$$$+$b$7$l$^$;(J$@$s!#$7$+$7(J, $@$@$+$i$H$$$C(J
$@$F(J, $@309q?M$b$=$&$G$"$k$Y$-$@$H$$$&$3$H$K$O$J$j$^$;$s!#$3$N(JNG$@$KEj9F$5$l(J
$@$kF05!(J$@$H$7$F$O(J, $@!VOCBj!W(J, $@!V8@8l!W(J, $@!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!WEy$,$"$jF@$^$9!#(J

$@!V8@8l!W$K4X$7$F$O(J, $@B>$N(JNG$@$KEj9F$7(J$@$F$b==J,$J8z2L$,F@$i$l$k$3$H$,J,$+$l(J
$@$P(J, $@=y!9$K$3$N(JNG$@$rA*Br$9$k:]$N4p=`$H$7$F$O<e$/$J$C$F$f$/$G$7$g$&(J$@!#5U$K(J, 
$@B>$N(JNG$@$KEj9F$7$F$b8z2L$,F@$i$l$J$1$l$P(J, $@A*BrF05!$H$7$F$O6/$/$J$C$F$f$/(J
$@$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#$3$l$O(J, $@B>$N(JNG$@$N>u67<!Bh$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#$3$N(JNG$@$N@'Hs$N(J
$@LdBj$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(J

$@!V%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I!W$K4X$7$F$O(J, $@!VF|K\$K=;$s$G$$$k309q?M!W$,(J fj $@>e$G%^(J
$@%$%N%j%F%#!<$G$"$k8B$j(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$NA*BrF05!$H$7$F$O=EMW$J0UL#$r(J$@;}$AB3$1$^(J
$@$9!#5U$K(J, fj $@>e$K!V309q?M!W$,B?$/$J$C$F9T$1$P(J, $@<+A3$KHf=E$O7Z$/$J$j$^(J
$@$9!#(J

$@2>$K(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$K(J$@!V309q?M!W$,0n$l$k$h$&$J$3$H$K$J$l$P(J, $@H`$i<+?H$N4V$K(J S/N 
$@$r9b$a$?$$$H$$$&M_5a$,I,A3E*$K=P$F$-$F(J, $@!VOC(J$@Bj!W$K$h$kA*Br$NHf=E$,=E$?(J
$@$/$J$j(J, $@$h$j<~JUE*$JOCBj$O(J, $@B>$N(JNG$@$K0n$l=P$7$F$f$/$G$7$g$&!#(J[$@Cm(J1] $@$=$l(J
$@$/$i(J$@$$309q?M$,A}$($F$$$l$P(J, $@B>$N(JNG$@$G$b==J,8z2L$,F@$i$l$k>u67$K$J$C$F$$(J
$@$k$O$:$G$9$+$i!#(J

[$@Cm(J1] $@;w$?$h$&$J(J$@$3$H$O(J, mailing list $@$G$h$/7P83$7$^$9!#%a%s%P$,>/$J$$(J
$@$&$A$O(J, $@$I$s$J%a!<%k$G$bMh$J$$$h$j4r$7$$$N$G$9$,(J, $@%a%s%P$,A}$($FMh$k$H(J
$@$&$k$5$/$J$C$F(J, $@$"$^$j4X78$N$J$$OCBj$ON.$7$FM_$7$/$J$$$H;W$&$h$&$K$J$j(J
$@$^$9$7(J, $@FbMF$K$b87$7$/$J$j$^$9!#(J

$@$b$&0lEY3NG'$7$^$9!#$3$N(JNG$@$,$I$NMM$K;H$o$l$k$+$O(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$r;H$&?M$d309q(J
$@?M$N(J$@0U<1$@$1$G7h$^$C$F$f$/$N$G$O$J$/$F(J, $@$`$7$m(J, fj $@$NB>$N(JNG$@$NFI<T$N0U(J
$@<1$d(Jfj$@A4BN$N>u67$r<+A3$KH?1G$7$?$b$N(J$@$K$J$j$^$9!#=>$C$F(J, $@$3$N(JNG$@$N;H$$J}(J
$@$rF|K\?M$NN)>l$+$i$"$l$3$l:Y$+$/5DO@$7$?$j7h$a$?$j$7$F$b(J, $@$"$^$j0U(J$@L#$O(J
$@$J$/$F(J, $@A4$F$O(J fj $@$N>u67<!Bh$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(J

$@0J>e(J, $@%K%e!<%9$K$*$1$k;T>l86M}$H%^%/%m7P:Q3X$G$7$?(J$@!#KM$O(J, $@9T@/;XF3$h$j(J
$@$b$j$b<+M3;T>l$N7rA4$J%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$r?.$8$F$$$^$9!#(J
--
MaSa					*--- **** ***-- *--* *-* *-*
Masahiro Kitagawa			$@KL@n(J $@>!9@(J	NTT$@4pAC8&5f=j(J
NTT Basic Research Labs.		kitagawa@will.NTT.JP
Newsgroups: fj.news.group