From: indu@iss700.Columbia.NCR.COM ()
Subject: Re: KASHMIR CAMPAIGN ( AKHAND BHARAT )
Originator: indu@iss700
Organization: NCR Corp, E&M-Columbia, Columbia, SC
Date: Wed, 09 Sep 92 17:44:34 GMT

 The following is reply to Samit Banerjee's email. As these are also 
 the present day questions, I am posting it on the NET.

> Hi Indu!
> Thanks for replying to my post. But I remain unconvinced by your arguments.
> India was divided because the Cong.leaders wanted a taste of power as much as 
> the Muslim League. It started out as a communal issue, but somewhere down the
> road that issue got blurred.
   True! THAT IS WHERE THE PEOPLES WILL WAS NOT REFLECTED. It is just a 
   Bunch of leaders trying to achive their selfish motives, succeded in 
   creating these problems. And we  people are also not blameless. WE HAVE 
   IN TURN GIVEN THEM, THE CHANCE TO RULE US (whatever the reasons are).
   AND WHAT IS THAT WE HAVE ACHIEVED, OTHER THAN CHEATING OUR SELVES 
   AND LAGGING BEHIND in every front? 
  
> More importantly your proposal for an Akhand Bharat seems premature at this

   True! Akhand Bharat may be slightly farther goal, nevertheless it 
   still remains our goal. We cannot forget the OBJECTIVE  of a Project 
   when involved in fixing a syntax error.

> point in our history and given the communal sentiments prevalent all over the

    WHAT YOU SAY IS TOTALLY AGREEABLE! AND THAT IS THE ONLY REASON WHY WE SHOULD
   remind ouselves this this issue of AKHAND BHARAT.  

   Who have created these communal sentiments? 
   Muslim-League! And we all know its ideology and what it gains out of it.
   Muslims have been misguided thru out the history that way. WHEN THEY CANNOT
   PRODUCE A VIVEKANANDA, DAYANANDA, RAJA RAM MOHAN ROY, whom do they follow?
   The leaders they know of are all fanatical fundamentalists. 
   SO WE CANNOT OVERLOOK our Ideals and principles. Though what I write is not 
   applicable to the whole Muslims as a group, this is what remains the net 
   product.

   No WONDER! Someone  remarked,  ( was it Gandhiji?)
     an average Muslim is a Goonda! 
     An average HINDU  is a coward.

> country. (.......... stuff deleted     ........................
> .......................................)

   IT IS HERE WE SHOULD REALISE THAT ALL present day muslims are not the 
   actual muslims. These are convert-Hindus. YES! Other wise how do you think
   these masses have created? So once we convince these people that our 
   long lost HINDUs, IMAGINE THE ATTITUDE AND CHANGE. It is to fight these
   the MUSLIM league was formed, to keep the masses in ignorance. Since these 
   Hindu converts were converted into Islam, they never had a chance to get 
   converted back. FOOLISH groups among HINDUs were arguing against
   their coming back. (Even here there were faults).
   
   Also these neo-Muslims were given other materialistic 
   benefits to retain them back in Islam (materialism in the name Religion)

   To turn around this situation many reformers like Dayananda, RamaKrishna,
   Raja Rama Mohan Roy started chastising this society. First we make this 
   society enlightened, then we can convince our converted Brothers. Islam, 
   you should realise is a religion with certain principles, and its way 
   to reach the ultimate truth. 

   WHAT OBJECTION DOES AN AVERAGE PERSON HAVE TO THESE RELIGIOUS PRACTICES?

   It is only the social attitude of these people which is a pain. As such,
   I'm a shaivite. How am I concerned with what my neighbour practices in his
   house whether Vaishnavism or Islam?

   But look at the following :
   - Their practices are all totally opposite to Indian practices
     They would like to eat COW, which is a sacred animal in Indian society.
     (Does COW eating have any religious sanctity, religious purpose
      to a MUSLIM?)

   - They still follow and think in terms of Invaders and Invaded(INDIANS)
     (As in case of Rama Janma Bhoomi, Somnath, Mathura, Varanasi,...)

   - the Invaders while in India had raped woman (irrespective of age),
     Killed old, young, and massacred Hindus, destroyed temples,...
     (I need to repeat volumes of our History)

     WHEN A NATION IS BURNT UP ON THESE, and leave alone a community,
     a normal average Indian sides with those Invaders: HOW DO WE FEEL?
     
     Hence the feeling of anti-pathy. You are not communal. You are made to 
     come to those terms. In this garb, what we (yes WE, not you alone
     there are 80 crores of Hindus) want to buy some peace, and forget this 
     Headache.

     BUT THIS CANNOT GO-ON for ever. This same mentality has brought our 
     down fall IN TACKLING  Islamic Invasions, British rule. If we can change 
     this mentality And imbibe the AKHANDAtha of Bharat, then all these 
     minorities will learn to live. WHY DON'T WE HAVE ANY PROBLEMS WITH SAY
     Jews, Parsis, or for that matter the races which were assimilated in this 
     society like Hunas, Shakas? The reason they were never brought up with 
     a timid Hindu. TODAY We need to to show our STRENGTH. Indian is a Hindu 
     Nation. No doubt. But it is a Divided Hindu Nation. It is this we need 
     realise.

        IT IS ONLY WHEN WE REALISE THIS OUR STRENGTH, WE CAN TACKLE 
    THESE PROBLEMS. God has given us that immense strength. But we are in 
    AATMA-VISMRITI. We need to shake this off. We need not  terrorize.
    IF WE ARE AWAKE THAT IS ENOUGH. 

                 SWAYAM EVA MRIGENDRATA!
 
    WHY DO YOU THINK ALL THIS HUE AND CRY ABOUT THIS RAMAJANMA-BHOOMI issue?
    Once we realise that Rama Janma Bhoomi, then a small kid asks 
    "WHY DID THIS HAPPEN 1400 years BACK? AND HOW DID OUR LEADERS FORGET IT?."
    As you know, Muslim leadreship is not worried over Rama Janma Bhoomi. 
    It is  the question of existence of 3000 Temple-Converted-Mossque 
    structures which is hanging. An average muslim will feel guilty over that.
    These structures do not have Islamic Sanctions ( I heard prayers offered
    in those structures are not accepted by ALLAH, someone quoted from QURAN).
    The basic question of Mass Hindu coversions into ISLAM would come into
    picture. 

   SO THIS  AKHANDAtha of Bharat is inevitable. And BHARAT can remain 
   united only based on these principles. All other Nehruvian sociologies,
   Communism, Capitalism would only break that nation. The fabric of that Nation
   is woven around HINDU principles and is time tested. And the reason we are
   one nation even after 1200 years of Slave rule is, this Ideology which
   still remained and was always renewed by many Leadres, Thinkers born.


> but I think the overwhelming Hindu population is the only guarantee of India's
> integrity.
> 
> Any call for an unified India must address this question of the dilution of the
> Hindu majority by the Muslim population and the question that it will generate
> a lot of fear in the minds of most Indians.

        <...   Answered above ...>
> 
> Talk to you later,
> 
> Samit
> 

-Indu.
+----------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  The views expressed above are on my personal basis.                 |
|  No Group or  Organization   can be held responsible                 |
|                                ( for those in quest of truth .......)|
+----------------------------------------------------------------------+
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian