From: dchatterjee@kuhub.cc.ukans.edu
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian
Subject: Re: A request to Deepak Bose
Date: 3 Jan 93 23:33:13 CST
Organization: University of Kansas Academic Computing Services


                     HAR HAR MAHADEV ! JAI SREE RAM !
                     =================================
                  (Let Mahadev be praised ! Hail Sree Ram !)
                   ========================================

                      BISMILLAH-U-R-RAHAMAN-I-R-RAHIM
                     *********************************
           ( In the name of The Allah, The Beneficient, The Merciful)
             ******************************************************* 



In article <1993Jan4.004247.16533@Princeton.EDU>, deb@soil.Princeton.EDU 
(Arghya Deb) writes:
>  Deepakji,
>  Namaste. I do not know why you post this sort of stuff on the net. If you
>  are doing it for fun, I guess you must be getting tired of it by now. If
>  you are merely exercising your rights under the First Ammendment, don't
>  you think there are more wholesome ways of doing so? But if you are truly
>  serious, I would just like to point out that you are misrepresenting and
>  distorting an entire ideology and giving a bad name to something good 
>  and great.
> 
>  Entire groups of people have dedicated their lives, from long before you
>  or I were born. They have done so out of love for the motherland, for the
>  well-being of their fellow citizens. They were humble men and women -
>  unsung heroes all.
> 
>  The sort of virulent Muslim hatred you display is definitely not part of
>  the RSS ethos. Like the 'kar-sevaks' who unilaterally and violently 
>  destroyed the mosque in Ayodhya, you too are causing great harm to the
>  RSS idea. And by bringing Shri Ram into all this, I am sure you are a
>  source of pain and anguish to true devotees everywhere.   
> 
>  The best answer to Mustapha Ibrahim and his likes is to ignore them. If
>  you feel impelled to reply couldn't you lower the octave a bit? 
> 
>  Please do not regard this as an attempt to give advice. It is more in the
>  nature of an appeal. 
>                                With regards,
>                                 Arghya Deb
>  


   With all my due respects and regards, I must say that Deepak is doing 
   what he is suppossed to do. As an Indian, no matter how exalted your
   plane of existence be compared to Deepak's, I feel that it is our moral
   duty to reply back the pakistani rubbish from Moron Incarnate (a la
   Mustafa Ibrahim) in the *strongest* possible words. What you have 
   compared sir, is quite incorrect. As you have correctly stated, "kar-sevaks"
   may have done an act of over-action. However comparing that (if that is
   at all admissable) to this is like similarizing a square and round peg.
   In the former case Hindu activists denied the GOI rules. In the present
   case Pakistanis (Mustafa Ibrahim) sent an abusive posting on my mom's 
   name, and, tomorrow he may say the same about your wife ? Where will be
   your Hindu peace and sanctity when your wife is ABUSED ? I am not at 
   all a chauvinist, but, I feel that you should have given the matter a
   much deeper thought before accussing Deepak Bose. Please note that if
   such an unwanted thing happens (like your wife is insulted), then if
   you cannot preserve her prestige before these mlechchas (Muslims), then
   I think that you are *not* doing your husband's duty.  Would you however
   justify that Indians are suppossed to be penitent before a mad Pakistani
   dog like Mustafa Ibrahim ? (Probably you would argue that Gandhi was a
   preacher of peace, but, then I have no arguments ..., sir). 


     - regards,

        deb chatterjee
      (A GOOD SAMARITAN)    
Xref: sparky soc.culture.indian:42842 soc.culture.pakistan:19167