From: kono@csl.sony.co.jp (Shinji Kono)
Newsgroups: fj.news.policy
Subject: News Group Management Protocol Rev. J (part 3/3)
Date: 17 Nov 92 15:24:29 GMT
Reply-To: kono@csl.sony.co.jp
Distribution: fj
Organization: Sony Computer Science Laboratory, Inc.

$@2OLn(J@CSL.Sony$@$G$9!#$7$D$3$/=`Hw0Q0w2q$NA*=PJ}K!$rDs0F$7$^$9!#(J

$@$$$m$$$m5DO@$,$"$j$^$7$?$1$I!"(J
   $@?.G$EjI<$O(J 200$@I<2<8B(J 2/3 $@DxEY$N87$7$$>r7o$,NI$$(J
$@$H$$$&46$8$G$7$?!#0J2<$N<j0z$K$O$^$@$$$l$F$"$j$^$;$s$1$I!#(J

$@5DD9$N$_$rA*=P$9$kJ}$,NI$$$H8@$&0U8+$,(J($@$b$H$b$H$O$=$&$@$C$?(J...)$@0l$D$"$j(J
$@$^$7$?!#KM$O:#$O0Q0w$rA*$s$@$"$H8_A*$9$kJ}$,NI$$$+$J$H;W$C$F$$$^$9!#(J

$@;n831?MQ$OH>G/!#(J5$@$+7nL\$KB3$1$k$+$I$&$+EjI<$G7h$a$^$9!#J,Ln$r8B$C$F1?MQ(J
$@$9$Y$-$@$H8@$&0U8+$b$"$j$^$7$?$M!#(J($@$I$NJ,Ln$K$9$k$N$@$m$&(J?) $@KM$O!";D$j$N(J
$@J,Ln$r$I$&$9$k$+$,$+$($C$F?4G[$K$J$j$^$9!#7k6I!"=`Hw0Q0w2q$,$a$s$I$&$r8+(J
$@$k$h$&$K$J$k$h$&$J5$$,$7$^$9$,(J...

$@4IM}J,C4$b!"$=$s$J$KITET9g$O$J$$$h$&$G$9$M!#:Y$+$$D4@0$O$$$k$G$7$g$&$1$I!#(J
fj.misc.handicap$@$H$+(Jfj.living/fj.life.*$@$H$+(J...

$@$O$8$^$j$O$8$^$j(J...

** 3. $@0\9TJ}K!(J
 
$@K\(JNG$@:n@.J}K!$r;CDjHG$H$7!";n831?MQ$r$*$3$J$&$b$N$H$9$k!#$=$N$?$a$K!"0J(J
$@2<$NJ}<0$G=`Hw0Q0w2q$r:n@.$9$k!#;n831?MQ4|4VCf$O8=4IM}?M$,(Jcontrol message
$@$rC4Ev$9$k!#(J
 

*** 3.1. $@=`Hw0Q0w2q$NJ,Ln(J

$@=`Hw0Q0w2q$K$*$1$kJ,Ln$o$1$O0J2<$N$b$N$H$9$k!#J,N`$H8=:_$N(JNG$@$NBP1~$O0Q0w(J
$@2q$G7h$a$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J

archives (including software, sources, binaries)
comp
net (including junet, juice)
rec
soc
sci
misc (including announce, mail-lists, test)

*** 3.2. $@=`Hw0Q0w2q$NA*=P(J

$@$^$:A*5s4IM}5!4X$r(Jfj.news.policy$@>e$NM-;V$G:n$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J
$@A*=P$O$3$N5!4X$K$h$j0J2<$N$h$&$K$*$3$J$o$l$k!#A*=P$N>\:Y$O(J
$@$3$N5!4X$K$h$C$FD4@0$5$l$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J

2$@=54V$NJg=84|4V$rDj$a!"=`Hw0Q0w2q$N8uJd<T$r5DD9$*$h$S3FJ,Ln$N0Q0w$4$H$K(J
$@<+A&B>A&$K$h$jJg=8$9$k!#$3$N;~!"5DD9$OI,$:0l$DC4EvJ,Ln$r7sG$$9$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J

$@$=$N8e?.G$EjI<$r$*$3$J$&!#EjI<4|4V$O(J3$@=54V$H$9$k!#?.G$$O0l?M0l?M$*$3$J$$!"(J
$@?.G$(J100$@I<0J>e(J $@IT?.G$H>?t0J2<$G?.G$$,@.N)$9$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J

$@?.G$$N7k2L!"(J
a)   $@5DD9$,J#?t?.G$$5$l$?>l9g(J
       $@?.G$$5$l$?<T$NCf$+$iOC$79g$$$K$h$j0l?M$rA*=P$9$k(J
b)   $@5DD9$,0l?M$b?.G$$5$l$J$+$C$?>l9g(J
       $@B>$K?.G$$5$l$?0Q0w$,$$$l$P!"(J
       $@?.G$$5$l$?<T$NCf$+$iOC$79g$$$K$h$j0l?M$rA*=P$9$k(J
c)   $@0l$D$NJ,Ln$KJ#?t?.G$$,@.N)$7$?>l9g$O!"$=$NJ#?t?M$G4IM}$r$*$3$J$&(J
       $@$?$@$7!"0l?M$r0Q0w$I$&$7$NOC$79g$$$K$h$jBeI=$H$9$k$3$H$K$9$k(J
d)   $@0l?M$N?.G$$b$J$+$C$?J,Ln$O5DD9$,C4Ev$9$k$b$N$H$9$k(J
e)   $@?.G$$5$l$?5DD95Z$S0Q0w$,0l?M$b$$$J$$>l9g$O!"(J
       $@=`Hw0Q0w2q$O:n@.$7$J$$(J

*** 3.3. NG$@4IM}(Jnews group$@$N:n@.0F(J

$@C4Ev4IM}?M$O4IM}J,Ln$K$7$?$,$C$F!"(Jfj.news.group$@$N2<$K<!$N(Jsub group$@$r:n(J
$@@.$9$k!#(J

fj.news.group.archives
fj.news.group.comp
fj.news.group.net
fj.news.group.rec
fj.news.group.soc
fj.news.group.sci
fj.news.gruop.misc

$@:n@.$O!"K\:n@.$N<j0z$-$K$=$C$F$*$3$J$o$l$k!#(Jsub group$@$N$G$-$J$+$C$?C4(J
$@EvJ,Ln$O>CLG$9$k$b$N$H$9$k!#>CLG$7$?J,Ln$O(Jfj.news.group$@$H$7$F5DD9$,C4Ev$9$k!#(J

*** 3.4. $@K\1?MQ$X$N0\9T(J
 
$@>e5-=`Hw0Q0w2q$N$b$H$G;n831?MQ$r(J6$@%+7n$*$3$J$&!#=`Hw0Q0w2q$O!"(J5$@%+7n7P2a$7$?(J
$@;~E@$G!"K\(JNG$@4IM}$N<j0z$K=$@5$NI,MW$,$"$k$+$I$&$+$HK\1?MQ$K0\$k$Y$-$+$I(J
$@$&$+$N5DO@$r3+;O$9$k!#(J1$@%+7n5DO@$r$*$3$J$C$?8e!"=`Hw0Q0w2q$O!";22C<T$N0U8+(J
$@$K4p$E$-!"<!$N$&$A$N0l$D$rA*Br$9$k!#5DO@$G7hCe$,$D$+$J$$>l9g$O!"EjI<$r(J
$@$*$3$J$$7hDj$9$k!#EjI<$NJ}K!Ey$O=`Hw0Q0w2q$,@)Dj$9$k!#(J

a) $@K\(JNG$@4IM}$N<j0z$rK\:NMQ$9$k$3$H$H$7!"K\J8=q$N5,Dj$K$7$?$,$C$F4IM}?M$N(J
$@A*=P$r3+;O$9$k!#4IM}?M$NA*=P$,40N;$9$k$^$G$O!"=`Hw0Q0w2q$,4IM}?M$N?&L3(J
$@$r$*$3$J$&!#(J

b) $@K\(JNG$@4IM}$N<j0z$r=$@5$r$*$3$J$C$?>e$GK\:NMQ$9$k$3$H$H$9$k!#=$@5$N;EJ}$O(J
$@;22C<T$N0U8+$K4p$E$-=`Hw0Q0w2q$,7hDj$9$k!#=$@5$,40N;$7$?$i!"K\J8=q$N5,(J
$@Dj$K$7$?$,$C$F4IM}?M$NA*=P$r3+;O$9$k!#4IM}?M$NA*=P$,40N;$9$k$^$G$O!"=`(J
$@Hw0Q0w2q$,4IM}?M$N?&L3$r$*$3$J$&!#(J

c) $@K\(JNG$@4IM}$N<j0z$O:NMQ$7$J$$$3$H$H$9$k!#;n831?MQ$b=*N;$5$;!"=>Mh$N4I(J
$@M}J}K!$K$h$k4IM}$r:F3+$9$k!#=`Hw0Q0w2q$O$?$@$A$K2r;6$9$k!#(J

*** 3.5. $@K\1?MQ$G$N4IM}J,Ln(J 

$@K\(JNG$@4IM}$N<j0z$-$,:NMQ$5$l$?>l9g!"K\1?MQ$G$NJ,Ln$o$1$O0J2<$N$h$&$K(J
fj.news.misc $@$N5DO@$K1h$C$F7hDj$5$l$k$b$N$H$9$k!#(J

fj.news.misc$@$N5DO@$O!"(JNG$@4IM}$N;n9T4|4V$,=*$k$^$G$K7kO@$r=P$9$h$&$KEXNO(J
$@$9$k!#(J

fj.news.misc$@$K$*$$$F7kO@$,=P$F$$$l$P!"$=$N7k2L$K=>$C$F7hDj$9$k!#(J

fj.news.misc$@$K$*$$$F7kO@$,=P$F$J$/!">e5-=`Hw0Q0w2qJ,Ln0F$KLdBj$,G'$a$i(J
$@$l$J$+$C$?>l9g$O!">e5-0F$r0zB3$-:NMQ$9$k!#(J

fj.news.misc$@$K$*$$$F7kO@$,=P$F$J$/!">e5-0F$KLdBj$,G'$a$i$l$?>l9g$O!"=`(J
$@Hw0Q0w2q$,Cf?4$K$J$j?7$?$JJ,Ln$o$1$N5DO@$r$*$3$J$$7hDj$9$k!#(J

** 4. $@IUO?(J

*** 4.1. $@N,8l(J

   Proposal: preliminary definition of new news group before CFD.
   CFD:  call for discussion 
         (CFDs for the same NG must have 12 weeks interval)
   CFA:  call for approval
   CFV:  call for vote
   CFR:  call for rejection
   CFX:  CFV, CFA or CFR
   Vote: Vote start
   Vote Result:
   Exec: Decision by the manager
   Result:

   note.  CFD and CFX can be simultaneous.
          When CFX fails, CFV is automatically accepted and the vote starts.

*** 4.2. Time Table

Simulteneous CFA (the shortest agreement)
    |---|---| 2 weeks
   CFD/CFA  Exec

CFA/CFR agree
    |------|---|---| 2-6 weeks
   CFD    CFA/CFR  Exec
CFV
    |------|---|---|---|---|---| 5-9 weeks
   CFD    CFV      Vote       Exec

CFX$@$,=P$J$+$C$?>l9g$O4IM}?M$,H=CG$r2<$9!#(J

CFD Time Out
    |---|---|---|---| 4 weeks
   CFD             CFA/CFR/Exec
CFD Time Out with Vote
    |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| 7 weeks
   CFD             CFV/Vote     Exec

CFX$@$,<:GT$7$?$N$r3NG'$7$F4IM}?M$,H=CG$r2<$9!#(J

CFA/CFR fail and Time out
    |------|---|---| 4-6 weeks
   CFD    CFX    fail/CFA/CFR by Manager
CFV fail and Time out
    |------|---|---|---|---|---| 7-9 weeks (longest agreement)
   CFD    CFX    fail/CFV by Manager


*** 4.3  $@$"$H$,$-(J

$@$3$l$r:n$k$K:]$7!"(Jfj.junet, fj.news.group, fj.news.policy$@$J$G$N$5$^$6$^(J
$@$J?M$N%]%9%H$rL@5-$;$:$K0zMQ$"$k$$$O;29M$K$5$;$F$$$?$@$-$^$7$?!#$I$&$b$"(J
$@$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$7$?!#B>$N5DO@$K;22C$7$F$/$@$5$C$?$_$J$5$s!"$"$j$,$H$&!#(J

$@$J$*!"$3$N%]%9%H$O$=$l$i$N?M!9$N0U8+$rBeI=$9$k$b$N$G$J$/!"$"$/$^$G2OLn8D(J
$@?M$KJ8@U$,$"$j$^$9!#(J

$$$ $@=*$o$j(J $$$
---
Shinji Kono @           kono@csl.sony.co.jp
Sony Computer Science Laboratory, Inc,Japan
Newsgroups: fj.news.policy,fj.news.group