From: eric@snark.thyrsus.com (Eric S. Raymond)
Newsgroups: rec.arts.sf.written
Subject: Raymond's Reviews #190: Stations of the Tide
Date: 9 Apr 92 19:42:54 GMT


This is Raymond's Reviews #190

%T Stations of the Tide
%A Machael Swanwick
%I Avon
%D March 1992
%O paperback, US$4.50
%P 252
%G ISBN 0-380-71524

The peculiar strengths and values of the SF seldom coexist very well with what
the 20th-century's academic establishment is pleased to call "literary merit".
Most attempts to combine the two are spectacularly stupid farragoes that
highlight all the worst vices of the litcrit crowd and utterly fail as SF; John
Kessel's _Good_News_From_Outer_Space_ (RR#71) and Richard Grant's
_Through_The_Heart_ (RR#180) are particularly odious recent examples.

It doesn't have to be that way.  Michel Swanwick is one of the members of a
notional organization of writers calling itself the Pre-Joycean Fellowship,
dedicated to the notion that literary value needn't imply inaccessibility and
bombast.  The name is intended to recall the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, and
expresses their belief that the rot really set in when academics made an icon
out of James Joyce.

_Stations_of_The_Tide_ demonstrates that Swanwick has the ability to back up
his convictions.  This is a *spectacularly* good SF novel which plays all the
approved literary games with a sure and controlled hand --- a certain Nebula
contender and maybe Hugo material as well.  There's more resonance and idea
content in the 252 pages of this book than in most Hugo-winning meganovels;
indeed, one comparison it begs for is with Dan Simmons's _Hyperion_, and
much as I liked the latter, the economy with which _Stations_ is written
may make it the better book.

The world Miranda is about to undergo the Great Tides, the pivot of a 250-year
climactic cycle.  The tides will drown much of its land area and trigger major
transformations of the planet's peculiar ecology.  Miranda's society, held at
an artificially low technology level by controls from the spaceborne habitats
that surround it, is also in turmoil as the tidal areas prepare for evacuation
and celebrate one last mad carnival before the deluge.

The viewpoint character is a bureaucrat from the office responsible for
technology control.  At the beginning of the book, he is Eliot's gray man, so
faceless that he lacks even a name.  He descends to the planet in search of a
renegade biotechnologist/magus named Gregorian, who claims to be able to
transform humans so they can live as swimmers in Miranda's engulfing seas.
Gregorian may or may not have been passed some dangerous technology by the
agent of Terra, the cybernetic hive-mind described in Swanwick's previous
_Vacuum_Flowers_.

From the moment he first encounters Miranda's riot of sensual experience, the
bureaucrat is doomed --- and half-knows it.  Gregorian is a master of puppets,
and his most deadly allies are the secrets of the bureaucrat's own psyche and
his past in the gleaming, ambiguous corridors of the orbital Puzzle Palace.
The bureaucrat's quest becomes an initiatory journey in which every certainty
he ever possessed is stripped away.

It's difficult to more than hint at the richness of Swanwick's tapestry.  The
intricacies of Mirandan magic; the mysterious artifacts of the extinct(?)
Mirandan indigenes called `haunts'; the lights and music of the pre-flood
festivals; all are bound into the plot (we even get a manual of practical
Tantra).  By the time of the bureaucrat's final confrontation with Gregorian in
the lost city of Ararat, he is no longer what he was.  Miranda and Gregorian's
machinations have remade him as completely as Miranda's tides are transforming
the planet.  The ending is utterly surprising --- and utterly logical.

Treat yourself to this novel.  It's wonderful.