user
"ad hominem" nature of Puntland Politics?


assistant
"ad hominem" nature of Puntland Politics
================================
Puntland waxay jirtaa muddo ku dhow "Quarter of a century" welina waxaa muuqata in aysan siyaasadeedu u qaan gaarin sidii loo baahnaa. Waxaa soo maray 5 madaxweyne (xukuumadood) oo "Ideologically" aad u kala duwan bulshada iyo siyaasituna ay mudnayd in ay wax ka bartaan. Waxay markasta oo doorasho soo dhowaato ugu jirtaa in ay raadkeedi dib ugu noqoto oo markale kasoo bilowdo "Square #1". 

Haddii aad loogu kuurgalo waxa la oran karaa fahamdarrada siyaasadeed waxay salka ku haysaa in aad looga fog yahay waxaa loo yaqaan "Rational Thinking" oo keenaysa in uu meesha ka baxo "Rational Communication" dadkana intooda badan - oo ay ugu horeeyaan kuwa isugu yeera in ay yihiin "Elite"-ka bulshada iyo horgalayaashooda siyaadeed - waxaa qaab fekerkooda hareeyay waxa cilmiga "Philosophy" loo yaqaan "ad hominem fallacy". Haddaad u baahatid in aad wax ka fahamtid "Logical Fallacies" 

"ad hominem fallacy" waa in qofku uusan si "Rational" ah u fekerin oo qofka weeraro, halka uu fariinta iyo "information"-ka ama xogta uu sheegayo ka falcelin lahaa ama wax ku dhisi lahaa.

Tusaale ahaan (Classic example): haddii qof gawaarida gada uu qof gaari raadinaya uu gaari aad ugu amaano xagga "Quality"-ga laakiin qiimaha gaarigu xoogaa kuwa kale ka sareeyo, waxaa laga yaqaabaa in qofku uu markiiba ninkii gaariga gadayey ku tilmaamo in uu yahay in "Commission"-kiisa fiirsanaya oo sidaas darteed uu gaariga qaaliga ah ugu amaanayo, halkii uu su'aalo ka weydiin lahaa ama ka hubsan lahaa sababka gaari "Quality"-giisa u fiican yahay. 

Waxaa iyaduna badan in hay'ad ama shirkad ganacsi ay mashruuc keento, oo intii laga hadli lahaa faa'iidada mashruuca uu bulshada u leeyahay lagu mashquulo tuhmo ah waxbaa lagu cunayaa.

Aan dib ugu soo noqono siyaasada Puntland iyo qaab fekerka soo noqnoqda 5 sano xilligaan oo kale.
Maxaa muraadka (?) iyo xukuumadda Puntland dhexyaal oo dhalliyey xiisadda hadda taagan?

Dawladda waxay ku doodaysaa in ay fulinayso habraaca siyaasadda ee uu qeexayo dastuurka Puntland oo ah in loo gudbo nidaamka doorashooyinka xorta ah ee 1Q1C iyo nidaamka xisbiyada oo iyagu soo sharaxaya xubnaha golaha shacabka iyo murashaxiinta madaxweynaha. Waxaa la fuliyey tallaabadii saldhiga u ahayd oo in la qabto doorashooyinka golaha deegaanada (33 degmo). Dawladdu waxay ku doodaysaa in weli waqti u harsan yahay lagu dhamaystiri karo hanaanka cusub.

Dhanka mucaaradka (?) iyagu waxay ku doodayaan "madaxweynuhu waa Dictator wuxuuna rabaa in uu si jajuub iyo khasab ah muddo kororsi u sameeyo". Ma u eg tahay "ad hominem fallacy"? Jawaabta idinkaan idiin dayn. 

Runtii waxba kuma gaar aha mucaarad (?)-ka hadda jira ee waa arrin soo noqnota markasta oo doorasho soo dhaw dahay cidday doonto xukunka ha hayso ama mucaarad ha noqoto.

N.B.
Waxaa laga yaabaa in aad isweydiisaan maxaa (?) ugu hordhigtay kelmada mucaarad. Runtii Puntland kama jirto jiho ama koox la oran karo waa "Legitimate Political Opponents" oo leh barnaamij iyo siyaasad ka duwan kuwa xukunka haya ee uu waa rag is haya uun oo marna saaxiibo marna damac kala geeyo ee wax kala duwaansho kale oo u dhexeeyaa uusan jirin.