Before revision:  The Hooge et al . (2018) study does not meet this standard.
After revision:  Alternatively, the title should be changed to: "Is human classification by experienced untrained observers a gold standard in fixation detection when data quality is very poor?" Numerous examples of various types of low quality data are presented herein. In addition, it appears that, by including missing data in the data submitted for assessment of agreement statistics, Hooge et al . (2018) study does not meet this standard.