Before revision: The paper [S{\o}rensen et al., Nature 532] presents and discusses results for a Quantum Moves game , BringHomeWater , where players have attempted to move a quantum state from one position to another in a simulated optical tweezer and atoms setup. The paper compares the player solutions to numerical methods that the authors discuss. In particular, [S{\o}rensen et al., Nature 532] show evidence that ] the so-called Krotov optimization method performs worse than solutions that the human players have come up with.
After revision: The paper [S{\o}rensen et al., Nature 532] presents and discusses results for a Quantum Moves game BringHomeWater and design new algorithms based on the intuition extracted from players. The claim by [S{\o}rensen et al., Nature 532] show evidence that ] the so-called Krotov optimization method performs worse than solutions that the human players have come up with.