diff --git a/LICENSE b/LICENSE new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c76021cbe600db5ac2b9b0d7ab4cfaa13cf9ff8b --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE @@ -0,0 +1,203 @@ + Apache License + Version 2.0, January 2004 + http://www.apache.org/licenses/ + + TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR USE, REPRODUCTION, AND DISTRIBUTION + + 1. Definitions. + + "License" shall mean the terms and conditions for use, reproduction, + and distribution as defined by Sections 1 through 9 of this document. + + "Licensor" shall mean the copyright owner or entity authorized by + the copyright owner that is granting the License. + + "Legal Entity" shall mean the union of the acting entity and all + other entities that control, are controlled by, or are under common + control with that entity. For the purposes of this definition, + "control" means (i) the power, direct or indirect, to cause the + direction or management of such entity, whether by contract or + otherwise, or (ii) ownership of fifty percent (50%) or more of the + outstanding shares, or (iii) beneficial ownership of such entity. + + "You" (or "Your") shall mean an individual or Legal Entity + exercising permissions granted by this License. + + "Source" form shall mean the preferred form for making modifications, + including but not limited to software source code, documentation + source, and configuration files. + + "Object" form shall mean any form resulting from mechanical + transformation or translation of a Source form, including but + not limited to compiled object code, generated documentation, + and conversions to other media types. + + "Work" shall mean the work of authorship, whether in Source or + Object form, made available under the License, as indicated by a + copyright notice that is included in or attached to the work + (an example is provided in the Appendix below). + + "Derivative Works" shall mean any work, whether in Source or Object + form, that is based on (or derived from) the Work and for which the + editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications + represent, as a whole, an original work of authorship. For the purposes + of this License, Derivative Works shall not include works that remain + separable from, or merely link (or bind by name) to the interfaces of, + the Work and Derivative Works thereof. + + "Contribution" shall mean any work of authorship, including + the original version of the Work and any modifications or additions + to that Work or Derivative Works thereof, that is intentionally + submitted to Licensor for inclusion in the Work by the copyright owner + or by an individual or Legal Entity authorized to submit on behalf of + the copyright owner. For the purposes of this definition, "submitted" + means any form of electronic, verbal, or written communication sent + to the Licensor or its representatives, including but not limited to + communication on electronic mailing lists, source code control systems, + and issue tracking systems that are managed by, or on behalf of, the + Licensor for the purpose of tracking or improving the Work, but + excluding communication that is conspicuously marked or otherwise + designated in writing by the copyright owner as "Not a Contribution." + + "Contributor" shall mean Licensor and any individual or Legal Entity + on behalf of whom a Contribution has been received by Licensor and + subsequently incorporated within the Work. + + 2. Grant of Copyright License. Subject to the terms and conditions of + this License, each Contributor hereby grants to You a perpetual, + worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable + copyright license to reproduce, prepare Derivative Works of, + publicly display, publicly perform, sublicense, and distribute the + Work and such Derivative Works in Source or Object form. + + 3. Grant of Patent License. Subject to the terms and conditions of + this License, each Contributor hereby grants to You a perpetual, + worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable + (except as stated in this section) patent license to make, have made, + use, offer to sell, sell, import, and otherwise transfer the Work, + where such license applies only to those patent claims licensable + by such Contributor that are necessarily infringed by their + Contribution(s) alone or by combination of their Contribution(s) + with the Work to which such Contribution(s) was submitted. If You + institute patent litigation against any entity (including a + cross-claim or counterclaim in a lawsuit) alleging that the Work + or a Contribution incorporated within the Work constitutes direct + or contributory patent infringement, then any patent licenses + granted to You under this License for that Work shall terminate + as of the date such litigation is filed. + + 4. Redistribution. You may reproduce and distribute copies of the + Work or Derivative Works thereof in any medium, with or without + modifications, and in Source or Object form, provided that You + meet the following conditions: + + (a) You must give any other recipients of the Work or + Derivative Works a copy of this License; and + + (b) You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices + stating that You changed the files; and + + (c) You must retain, in the Source form of any Derivative Works + that You distribute, all copyright, patent, trademark, and + attribution notices from the Source form of the Work, + excluding those notices that do not pertain to any part of + the Derivative Works; and + + (d) If the Work includes a "NOTICE" text file as part of its + distribution, then any Derivative Works that You distribute must + include a readable copy of the attribution notices contained + within such NOTICE file, excluding those notices that do not + pertain to any part of the Derivative Works, in at least one + of the following places: within a NOTICE text file distributed + as part of the Derivative Works; within the Source form or + documentation, if provided along with the Derivative Works; or, + within a display generated by the Derivative Works, if and + wherever such third-party notices normally appear. The contents + of the NOTICE file are for informational purposes only and + do not modify the License. You may add Your own attribution + notices within Derivative Works that You distribute, alongside + or as an addendum to the NOTICE text from the Work, provided + that such additional attribution notices cannot be construed + as modifying the License. + + You may add Your own copyright statement to Your modifications and + may provide additional or different license terms and conditions + for use, reproduction, or distribution of Your modifications, or + for any such Derivative Works as a whole, provided Your use, + reproduction, and distribution of the Work otherwise complies with + the conditions stated in this License. + + 5. Submission of Contributions. Unless You explicitly state otherwise, + any Contribution intentionally submitted for inclusion in the Work + by You to the Licensor shall be under the terms and conditions of + this License, without any additional terms or conditions. + Notwithstanding the above, nothing herein shall supersede or modify + the terms of any separate license agreement you may have executed + with Licensor regarding such Contributions. + + 6. Trademarks. This License does not grant permission to use the trade + names, trademarks, service marks, or product names of the Licensor, + except as required for describing the origin of the Work and + reproducing the content of the NOTICE file. + + 7. Disclaimer of Warranty. Unless required by applicable law or + agreed to in writing, Licensor provides the Work (and each + Contributor provides its Contributions) on an "AS IS" BASIS, + WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or + implied, including, without limitation, any warranties or conditions + of TITLE, NON-INFRINGEMENT, MERCHANTABILITY, or FITNESS FOR A + PARTICULAR PURPOSE. You are solely responsible for determining the + appropriateness of using or redistributing the Work and assume any + risks associated with Your exercise of permissions under this License. + + 8. Limitation of Liability. In no event and under no legal theory, + whether in tort (including negligence), contract, or otherwise, + unless required by applicable law (such as deliberate and grossly + negligent acts) or agreed to in writing, shall any Contributor be + liable to You for damages, including any direct, indirect, special, + incidental, or consequential damages of any character arising as a + result of this License or out of the use or inability to use the + Work (including but not limited to damages for loss of goodwill, + work stoppage, computer failure or malfunction, or any and all + other commercial damages or losses), even if such Contributor + has been advised of the possibility of such damages. + + 9. Accepting Warranty or Support. While redistributing + the Work or Derivative Works thereof, You may choose to offer, + and charge a fee for, acceptance of support, warranty, indemnity, + or other liability obligations and/or rights consistent with this + License. However, in accepting such obligations, You may act only + on Your own behalf and on Your sole responsibility, not on behalf + of any other Contributor, and only if You agree to indemnify, + defend, and hold each Contributor harmless for any liability + incurred by, or claims asserted against, such Contributor by reason + of your accepting any such warranty or support. + + END OF TERMS AND CONDITIONS + + APPENDIX: How to apply the Apache License to your work. + + To apply the Apache License to your work, attach the following + boilerplate notice, with the fields enclosed by brackets "[]" + replaced with your own identifying information. (Don't include + the brackets!) The text should be enclosed in the appropriate + comment syntax for the file format. We also recommend that a + file or class name and description of purpose be included on the + same "printed page" as the copyright notice for easier + identification within third-party archives. + + Copyright [yyyy] [name of copyright owner] + + Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); + you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. + You may obtain a copy of the License at + + http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 + + Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software + distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, + WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or + implied, including, without limitation, any warranties or conditions + of TITLE, NON-INFRINGEMENT, MERCHANTABILITY, or FITNESS FOR A + PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the License for the specific language + governing permissions and limitations under this License. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..023e44001385ff41959760cdf0c9959945068777 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,173 @@ +--- +license: apache-2.0 +language: + - en +pretty_name: BCCT-Hub +tags: + - representation-similarity + - representation-convergence + - cross-model-transport + - benchmark + - alignment + - evaluation + - neurips-2026 +size_categories: + - 1K +- Anonymous mirror used during NeurIPS review: + + +## Citation + +If you use BCCT-Hub in your research, please cite the accompanying paper: + +```bibtex +@misc{bcct_hub_2026, + title = {{BCCT-Hub}: A Benchmark and Toolkit for Measuring Representation + Convergence Across Model Families}, + author = {Anonymous Authors}, + year = {2026}, + note = {NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations \& Datasets Track (under review)} +} +``` diff --git a/data/atlas.json b/data/atlas.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c9ac1ca866c89fca4fcf93f19c636c30e14b333b --- /dev/null +++ b/data/atlas.json @@ -0,0 +1,2952 @@ +{ + "models": { + "beit_base_patch16_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 5.866, + "effective_rank": 58.31, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "beit", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 6.555, + "effective_rank": 94.0, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "beit", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "clip_vitb16": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 6.841, + "effective_rank": 114.63, + "dim": 512, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "clip", + "objective": "contrastive", + "dim": 512, + "source": "transformers" + } + }, + "clip_vitb32": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 6.855, + "effective_rank": 115.75, + "dim": 512, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "clip", + "objective": "contrastive", + "dim": 512, + "source": "transformers" + } + }, + "clip_vitl14": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 7.442, + "effective_rank": 173.89, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "clip", + "objective": "contrastive", + "dim": 768, + "source": "transformers" + } + }, + "convnext_base": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.241, + "effective_rank": 302.58, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "convnext_large": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.485, + "effective_rank": 358.18, + "dim": 1536, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 1536, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "dinov2_vitb14": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.6, + "effective_rank": 388.13, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "dinov2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768, + "source": "torch.hub" + } + }, + "dinov2_vitg14": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 9.055, + "effective_rank": 531.78, + "dim": 1536, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "dinov2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1536, + "source": "torch.hub" + } + }, + "dinov2_vitl14": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.963, + "effective_rank": 499.11, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "dinov2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "torch.hub" + } + }, + "dinov2_vits14": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 7.752, + "effective_rank": 215.52, + "dim": 384, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "dinov2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 384, + "source": "torch.hub" + } + }, + "efficientnet_b0": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.228, + "effective_rank": 299.91, + "dim": 1280, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 1280, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "mixer_b16_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.037, + "effective_rank": 262.71, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "mlpmixer", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "resnet101": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.594, + "effective_rank": 386.42, + "dim": 2048, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 2048, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "resnet50": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.105, + "effective_rank": 275.3, + "dim": 2048, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 2048, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 8.398, + "effective_rank": 337.42, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 7.77, + "effective_rank": 218.2, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 1.649, + "effective_rank": 3.14, + "dim": 768, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "mae", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "vit_large_patch16_224": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 7.661, + "effective_rank": 202.4, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "supervised", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "timm" + } + }, + "vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "metrics": { + "bitrate": 4.898, + "effective_rank": 29.82, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 5000 + }, + "config": { + "family": "mae", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1024, + "source": "timm" + } + } + }, + "pairwise": { + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> beit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.238, + "s_global": 0.7855, + "lambda": 0.3025, + "tau": 0.3613, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.542, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3613, + "tai": 0.2312, + "perf_linear": 0.1769, + "perf_best": 0.3764, + "delta": 0.689, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2391 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16": { + "s_local": 0.046, + "s_global": 0.1565, + "lambda": 0.2946, + "tau": 0.041, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.041, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1548, + "tai": 0.9772, + "perf_linear": 0.0002, + "perf_best": 0.0037, + "delta": 0.975, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.048 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32": { + "s_local": 0.048, + "s_global": 0.1798, + "lambda": 0.2688, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1723, + "tai": 0.9703, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0062, + "delta": 0.989, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0502 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.046, + "s_global": 0.1683, + "lambda": 0.2762, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1403, + "tai": 0.9878, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0011, + "delta": 1.576, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0484 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base": { + "s_local": 0.051, + "s_global": 0.1636, + "lambda": 0.3145, + "tau": 0.0213, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0213, + "tai": 0.9943, + "perf_linear": 0.0019, + "perf_best": 0.0005, + "delta": 2.375, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0534 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.052, + "s_global": 0.1601, + "lambda": 0.3228, + "tau": 0.0159, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0159, + "tai": 0.9916, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.0009, + "delta": 2.619, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0536 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.046, + "s_global": 0.1373, + "lambda": 0.333, + "tau": 0.0417, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2837, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0417, + "tai": 0.9757, + "perf_linear": 0.0002, + "perf_best": 0.0007, + "delta": 2.735, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0476 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.042, + "s_global": 0.1181, + "lambda": 0.3531, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0759, + "tai": 0.9409, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0011, + "delta": 3.189, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0436 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.042, + "s_global": 0.1182, + "lambda": 0.3564, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0768, + "tai": 0.9566, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0006, + "delta": 3.097, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.044 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.052, + "s_global": 0.1682, + "lambda": 0.3083, + "tau": 0.015, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.015, + "tai": 0.9913, + "perf_linear": 0.0018, + "perf_best": 0.001, + "delta": 1.886, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0537 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.063, + "s_global": 0.2009, + "lambda": 0.3119, + "tau": 0.0583, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6987, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0583, + "tai": 0.9451, + "perf_linear": 0.0025, + "perf_best": 0.0036, + "delta": 2.363, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0645 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.062, + "s_global": 0.2191, + "lambda": 0.2837, + "tau": 0.0416, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2978, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0416, + "tai": 0.9576, + "perf_linear": 0.0014, + "perf_best": 0.0047, + "delta": 2.172, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.064 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.058, + "s_global": 0.1919, + "lambda": 0.3027, + "tau": 0.0812, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7946, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0812, + "tai": 0.8491, + "perf_linear": 0.0045, + "perf_best": 0.0084, + "delta": 2.728, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.06 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.064, + "s_global": 0.2377, + "lambda": 0.2691, + "tau": 0.2277, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2617, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2277, + "tai": 0.6976, + "perf_linear": 0.0043, + "perf_best": 0.0163, + "delta": 2.239, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0658 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.054, + "s_global": 0.1723, + "lambda": 0.3105, + "tau": 0.0269, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0269, + "tai": 0.998, + "perf_linear": 0.0002, + "perf_best": 0.0002, + "delta": 2.533, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0554 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.061, + "s_global": 0.2282, + "lambda": 0.2687, + "tau": 0.0175, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0175, + "tai": 0.9874, + "perf_linear": 0.0026, + "perf_best": 0.0025, + "delta": 1.904, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0632 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.05, + "s_global": 0.1656, + "lambda": 0.3039, + "tau": 0.0037, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0037, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.212, + "tai": 0.1096, + "perf_linear": 0.0013, + "perf_best": 0.3563, + "delta": 4.217, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0522 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.05, + "s_global": 0.1782, + "lambda": 0.2792, + "tau": 0.0133, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0133, + "tai": 0.9895, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0013, + "delta": 1.795, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0516 + }, + "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.109, + "s_global": 0.6358, + "lambda": 0.1719, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3585, + "tai": 0.4647, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1904, + "delta": 0.967, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.111 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16": { + "s_local": 0.069, + "s_global": 0.1999, + "lambda": 0.3473, + "tau": 0.0353, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0353, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3331, + "tai": 0.9529, + "perf_linear": 0.0003, + "perf_best": 0.0081, + "delta": 0.286, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0712 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32": { + "s_local": 0.07, + "s_global": 0.2239, + "lambda": 0.3117, + "tau": 0.0338, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0338, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3473, + "tai": 0.9394, + "perf_linear": 0.0004, + "perf_best": 0.0122, + "delta": 0.3, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0716 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.074, + "s_global": 0.2234, + "lambda": 0.3299, + "tau": 0.0596, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0596, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.283, + "tai": 0.9638, + "perf_linear": 0.0002, + "perf_best": 0.0033, + "delta": 0.887, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0755 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base": { + "s_local": 0.087, + "s_global": 0.229, + "lambda": 0.3805, + "tau": 0.025, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.025, + "tai": 0.9807, + "perf_linear": 0.0028, + "perf_best": 0.0022, + "delta": 1.687, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0889 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.089, + "s_global": 0.2233, + "lambda": 0.3983, + "tau": 0.0196, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0196, + "tai": 0.9681, + "perf_linear": 0.0028, + "perf_best": 0.0045, + "delta": 1.93, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0907 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.08, + "s_global": 0.1889, + "lambda": 0.4221, + "tau": 0.0446, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6608, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0446, + "tai": 0.9494, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.0022, + "delta": 2.046, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0815 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.073, + "s_global": 0.1602, + "lambda": 0.4559, + "tau": 0.0855, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0855, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0924, + "tai": 0.9019, + "perf_linear": 0.0002, + "perf_best": 0.0021, + "delta": 2.5, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0749 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.072, + "s_global": 0.1615, + "lambda": 0.4475, + "tau": 0.0159, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0159, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0903, + "tai": 0.9133, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0016, + "delta": 2.409, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0741 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.084, + "s_global": 0.2177, + "lambda": 0.3874, + "tau": 0.0197, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0197, + "tai": 0.9857, + "perf_linear": 0.0027, + "perf_best": 0.002, + "delta": 1.197, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0861 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.087, + "s_global": 0.2567, + "lambda": 0.34, + "tau": 0.0874, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6734, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0874, + "tai": 0.8762, + "perf_linear": 0.0056, + "perf_best": 0.0083, + "delta": 1.674, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0891 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.085, + "s_global": 0.2829, + "lambda": 0.3011, + "tau": 0.078, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2861, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.078, + "tai": 0.926, + "perf_linear": 0.0021, + "perf_best": 0.0073, + "delta": 1.483, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.087 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.086, + "s_global": 0.2527, + "lambda": 0.3422, + "tau": 0.1236, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7729, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1236, + "tai": 0.8085, + "perf_linear": 0.0072, + "perf_best": 0.0111, + "delta": 2.039, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0883 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.086, + "s_global": 0.302, + "lambda": 0.2849, + "tau": 0.3556, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3556, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3812, + "tai": 0.589, + "perf_linear": 0.0072, + "perf_best": 0.0203, + "delta": 1.55, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0879 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.09, + "s_global": 0.2273, + "lambda": 0.3979, + "tau": 0.0323, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0323, + "tai": 0.9924, + "perf_linear": 0.0022, + "perf_best": 0.0009, + "delta": 1.844, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0922 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.102, + "s_global": 0.3026, + "lambda": 0.3366, + "tau": 0.039, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.039, + "tai": 0.9619, + "perf_linear": 0.0082, + "perf_best": 0.008, + "delta": 1.215, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1036 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.051, + "s_global": 0.1988, + "lambda": 0.2585, + "tau": 0.0044, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0044, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2431, + "tai": 0.0809, + "perf_linear": 0.0016, + "perf_best": 0.336, + "delta": 4.906, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0533 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.083, + "s_global": 0.2503, + "lambda": 0.3327, + "tau": 0.0212, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0212, + "tai": 0.9844, + "perf_linear": 0.0032, + "perf_best": 0.0023, + "delta": 1.106, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0851 + }, + "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.123, + "s_global": 0.6539, + "lambda": 0.1881, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3935, + "tai": 0.315, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.2195, + "delta": 1.656, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1248 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32": { + "s_local": 0.277, + "s_global": 0.7132, + "lambda": 0.3887, + "tau": 0.744, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.744, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7547, + "tai": 0.0018, + "perf_linear": 0.3201, + "perf_best": 0.4302, + "delta": 0.014, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.2787 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.291, + "s_global": 0.7183, + "lambda": 0.4047, + "tau": 0.468, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9409, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.468, + "tai": 0.0728, + "perf_linear": 0.1754, + "perf_best": 0.3476, + "delta": 0.601, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2921 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_base": { + "s_local": 0.225, + "s_global": 0.5483, + "lambda": 0.4102, + "tau": 0.0261, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0261, + "tai": 0.0012, + "perf_linear": 0.0058, + "perf_best": 0.2206, + "delta": 1.4, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2265 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.229, + "s_global": 0.5338, + "lambda": 0.4291, + "tau": 0.024, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.024, + "tai": 0.0979, + "perf_linear": 0.0056, + "perf_best": 0.2095, + "delta": 1.644, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2306 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.224, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "lambda": 0.4586, + "tau": 0.0449, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0449, + "tai": 0.3992, + "perf_linear": 0.0079, + "perf_best": 0.1059, + "delta": 1.76, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2256 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.198, + "s_global": 0.4103, + "lambda": 0.4825, + "tau": 0.1047, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1047, + "tai": 0.0372, + "perf_linear": 0.009, + "perf_best": 0.0832, + "delta": 2.214, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1996 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.202, + "s_global": 0.4092, + "lambda": 0.4942, + "tau": 0.0941, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0941, + "tai": 0.5364, + "perf_linear": 0.0084, + "perf_best": 0.0411, + "delta": 2.122, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2038 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.23, + "s_global": 0.5223, + "lambda": 0.4396, + "tau": 0.0164, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0164, + "tai": 0.2184, + "perf_linear": 0.0051, + "perf_best": 0.2433, + "delta": 0.911, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2311 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.175, + "s_global": 0.4978, + "lambda": 0.3515, + "tau": 0.0845, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0845, + "tai": 0.3253, + "perf_linear": 0.0057, + "perf_best": 0.067, + "delta": 1.388, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1766 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.146, + "s_global": 0.478, + "lambda": 0.3051, + "tau": 0.0726, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0726, + "tai": 0.1819, + "perf_linear": 0.0045, + "perf_best": 0.0619, + "delta": 1.196, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1475 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.183, + "s_global": 0.5628, + "lambda": 0.3246, + "tau": 0.0775, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0775, + "tai": 0.2104, + "perf_linear": 0.0079, + "perf_best": 0.08, + "delta": 1.753, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1843 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.164, + "s_global": 0.5235, + "lambda": 0.3139, + "tau": 0.1145, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8535, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1145, + "tai": 0.1516, + "perf_linear": 0.0077, + "perf_best": 0.067, + "delta": 1.264, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.166 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.231, + "s_global": 0.5673, + "lambda": 0.4068, + "tau": 0.0404, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0404, + "tai": 0.0206, + "perf_linear": 0.0086, + "perf_best": 0.2092, + "delta": 1.558, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2323 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.193, + "s_global": 0.5252, + "lambda": 0.3676, + "tau": 0.0185, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0185, + "tai": 0.1275, + "perf_linear": 0.0034, + "perf_best": 0.1601, + "delta": 0.929, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1947 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.025, + "s_global": 0.1245, + "lambda": 0.1984, + "tau": 0.003, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.003, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0775, + "tai": 0.5034, + "perf_linear": 0.0013, + "perf_best": 0.2213, + "delta": 5.192, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0266 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.202, + "s_global": 0.5175, + "lambda": 0.3897, + "tau": 0.0095, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0095, + "tai": 0.378, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.1126, + "delta": 0.82, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2032 + }, + "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.092, + "s_global": 0.1912, + "lambda": 0.4795, + "tau": 0.0004, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0004, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5939, + "tai": 0.375, + "perf_linear": 0.0001, + "perf_best": 0.2382, + "delta": 1.942, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0935 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.245, + "s_global": 0.647, + "lambda": 0.3794, + "tau": 0.3298, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8328, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3298, + "tai": 0.0656, + "perf_linear": 0.1055, + "perf_best": 0.299, + "delta": 0.587, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.247 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_base": { + "s_local": 0.207, + "s_global": 0.5164, + "lambda": 0.4002, + "tau": 0.0145, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0145, + "tai": 0.0148, + "perf_linear": 0.003, + "perf_best": 0.2026, + "delta": 1.386, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2082 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.208, + "s_global": 0.504, + "lambda": 0.4137, + "tau": 0.0127, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0127, + "tai": 0.1112, + "perf_linear": 0.0027, + "perf_best": 0.1918, + "delta": 1.63, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2101 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.197, + "s_global": 0.4568, + "lambda": 0.4317, + "tau": 0.0308, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0308, + "tai": 0.4151, + "perf_linear": 0.0043, + "perf_best": 0.0821, + "delta": 1.746, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1988 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.176, + "s_global": 0.3755, + "lambda": 0.4685, + "tau": 0.0754, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0754, + "tai": 0.068, + "perf_linear": 0.005, + "perf_best": 0.0618, + "delta": 2.2, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1776 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.18, + "s_global": 0.3775, + "lambda": 0.4755, + "tau": 0.0715, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0715, + "tai": 0.4849, + "perf_linear": 0.0043, + "perf_best": 0.0312, + "delta": 2.108, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1812 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.211, + "s_global": 0.4941, + "lambda": 0.4272, + "tau": 0.0099, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0099, + "tai": 0.2115, + "perf_linear": 0.0029, + "perf_best": 0.2271, + "delta": 0.897, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2126 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.173, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "lambda": 0.3541, + "tau": 0.061, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.061, + "tai": 0.378, + "perf_linear": 0.0044, + "perf_best": 0.0729, + "delta": 1.374, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1747 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.15, + "s_global": 0.472, + "lambda": 0.3175, + "tau": 0.0509, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0509, + "tai": 0.194, + "perf_linear": 0.0039, + "perf_best": 0.0774, + "delta": 1.182, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1516 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.177, + "s_global": 0.5391, + "lambda": 0.3289, + "tau": 0.0698, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0698, + "tai": 0.1949, + "perf_linear": 0.0072, + "perf_best": 0.0831, + "delta": 1.739, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1789 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.168, + "s_global": 0.5147, + "lambda": 0.3271, + "tau": 0.1145, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8248, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1145, + "tai": 0.1974, + "perf_linear": 0.0079, + "perf_best": 0.0693, + "delta": 1.25, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.17 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.21, + "s_global": 0.535, + "lambda": 0.3927, + "tau": 0.0284, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0284, + "tai": 0.0066, + "perf_linear": 0.0056, + "perf_best": 0.1979, + "delta": 1.544, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2116 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.18, + "s_global": 0.4984, + "lambda": 0.3605, + "tau": 0.0082, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0082, + "tai": 0.179, + "perf_linear": 0.0016, + "perf_best": 0.1546, + "delta": 0.915, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1813 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.026, + "s_global": 0.1356, + "lambda": 0.1916, + "tau": 0.0032, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0032, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0866, + "tai": 0.4719, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.2519, + "delta": 5.206, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.028 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.184, + "s_global": 0.4926, + "lambda": 0.3728, + "tau": 0.0049, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0049, + "tai": 0.388, + "perf_linear": 0.0008, + "perf_best": 0.1012, + "delta": 0.806, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1853 + }, + "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.097, + "s_global": 0.2131, + "lambda": 0.4565, + "tau": 0.0002, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0002, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5945, + "tai": 0.3581, + "perf_linear": 0.0001, + "perf_best": 0.2572, + "delta": 1.956, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0991 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base": { + "s_local": 0.276, + "s_global": 0.5991, + "lambda": 0.4615, + "tau": 0.0091, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0091, + "tai": 0.0658, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.1841, + "delta": 0.799, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2779 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.286, + "s_global": 0.5902, + "lambda": 0.4839, + "tau": 0.009, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.009, + "tai": 0.0899, + "perf_linear": 0.0019, + "perf_best": 0.1926, + "delta": 1.042, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.287 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.287, + "s_global": 0.5503, + "lambda": 0.5221, + "tau": 0.0121, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0121, + "tai": 0.4941, + "perf_linear": 0.0022, + "perf_best": 0.0902, + "delta": 1.158, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2887 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.262, + "s_global": 0.4764, + "lambda": 0.5504, + "tau": 0.0449, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0449, + "tai": 0.0095, + "perf_linear": 0.0051, + "perf_best": 0.1145, + "delta": 1.613, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2636 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.269, + "s_global": 0.4763, + "lambda": 0.5644, + "tau": 0.0297, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0297, + "tai": 0.589, + "perf_linear": 0.0032, + "perf_best": 0.0445, + "delta": 1.521, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2703 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.27, + "s_global": 0.5637, + "lambda": 0.4785, + "tau": 0.0057, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0057, + "tai": 0.3147, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.1836, + "delta": 0.31, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2712 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.178, + "s_global": 0.4991, + "lambda": 0.3568, + "tau": 0.0434, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0434, + "tai": 0.3254, + "perf_linear": 0.0014, + "perf_best": 0.0328, + "delta": 0.786, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1797 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.153, + "s_global": 0.4987, + "lambda": 0.3062, + "tau": 0.0365, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0365, + "tai": 0.1878, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.0259, + "delta": 0.595, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1544 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.196, + "s_global": 0.5821, + "lambda": 0.337, + "tau": 0.0539, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0539, + "tai": 0.1171, + "perf_linear": 0.0033, + "perf_best": 0.0541, + "delta": 1.152, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1977 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.167, + "s_global": 0.5379, + "lambda": 0.3099, + "tau": 0.0961, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8217, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0961, + "tai": 0.4364, + "perf_linear": 0.0028, + "perf_best": 0.0294, + "delta": 0.663, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1683 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.278, + "s_global": 0.6086, + "lambda": 0.4564, + "tau": 0.0204, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0204, + "tai": 0.0321, + "perf_linear": 0.0037, + "perf_best": 0.1764, + "delta": 0.956, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2791 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.217, + "s_global": 0.5553, + "lambda": 0.3908, + "tau": 0.0051, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0051, + "tai": 0.2661, + "perf_linear": 0.0007, + "perf_best": 0.1004, + "delta": 0.327, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2186 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.024, + "s_global": 0.1241, + "lambda": 0.1908, + "tau": 0.0032, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0032, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0951, + "tai": 0.5978, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.1452, + "delta": 5.793, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0256 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.256, + "s_global": 0.5817, + "lambda": 0.4398, + "tau": 0.0046, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0046, + "tai": 0.4485, + "perf_linear": 0.0007, + "perf_best": 0.0898, + "delta": 0.219, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2573 + }, + "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.088, + "s_global": 0.2026, + "lambda": 0.4333, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6784, + "tai": 0.4334, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1773, + "delta": 2.544, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0896 + }, + "convnext_base <-> convnext_large": { + "s_local": 0.569, + "s_global": 0.8469, + "lambda": 0.6721, + "tau": 0.8475, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8475, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9066, + "tai": 0.0645, + "perf_linear": 0.3942, + "perf_best": 0.4651, + "delta": 0.243, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.57 + }, + "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.41, + "s_global": 0.6692, + "lambda": 0.6122, + "tau": 0.2182, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2182, + "tai": 0.4712, + "perf_linear": 0.0563, + "perf_best": 0.1364, + "delta": 0.359, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.4109 + }, + "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.362, + "s_global": 0.5917, + "lambda": 0.6117, + "tau": 0.3656, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4039, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3656, + "tai": 0.0666, + "perf_linear": 0.0716, + "perf_best": 0.1829, + "delta": 0.814, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3632 + }, + "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.373, + "s_global": 0.5893, + "lambda": 0.6335, + "tau": 0.1342, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.608, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1342, + "tai": 0.6185, + "perf_linear": 0.0235, + "perf_best": 0.0667, + "delta": 0.722, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3746 + }, + "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.383, + "s_global": 0.6568, + "lambda": 0.5836, + "tau": 0.2682, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2682, + "tai": 0.197, + "perf_linear": 0.0905, + "perf_best": 0.271, + "delta": 0.489, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3845 + }, + "convnext_base <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.259, + "s_global": 0.6041, + "lambda": 0.4291, + "tau": 0.3044, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3044, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9692, + "tai": 0.0711, + "perf_linear": 0.0317, + "perf_best": 0.0967, + "delta": 0.013, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2607 + }, + "convnext_base <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.212, + "s_global": 0.5899, + "lambda": 0.3596, + "tau": 0.1651, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1651, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7586, + "tai": 0.34, + "perf_linear": 0.0088, + "perf_best": 0.0534, + "delta": 0.204, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2137 + }, + "convnext_base <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.305, + "s_global": 0.705, + "lambda": 0.4319, + "tau": 0.3092, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3092, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4415, + "perf_linear": 0.0335, + "perf_best": 0.1085, + "delta": 0.353, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3059 + }, + "convnext_base <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.232, + "s_global": 0.616, + "lambda": 0.3769, + "tau": 0.2342, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2342, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.025, + "perf_linear": 0.0201, + "perf_best": 0.0859, + "delta": 0.136, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2337 + }, + "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.483, + "s_global": 0.7817, + "lambda": 0.6184, + "tau": 0.7709, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7709, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8125, + "tai": 0.0621, + "perf_linear": 0.2808, + "perf_best": 0.3643, + "delta": 0.157, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.4844 + }, + "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.336, + "s_global": 0.6964, + "lambda": 0.482, + "tau": 0.4549, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4549, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.797, + "tai": 0.1206, + "perf_linear": 0.1056, + "perf_best": 0.2321, + "delta": 0.472, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.337 + }, + "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.025, + "s_global": 0.1384, + "lambda": 0.1792, + "tau": 0.0028, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0028, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1686, + "tai": 0.6604, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.1431, + "delta": 6.592, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0268 + }, + "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.396, + "s_global": 0.6934, + "lambda": 0.5707, + "tau": 0.1548, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1548, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6903, + "tai": 0.3452, + "perf_linear": 0.0296, + "perf_best": 0.191, + "delta": 0.58, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3969 + }, + "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.095, + "s_global": 0.1963, + "lambda": 0.482, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4038, + "tai": 0.4487, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1958, + "delta": 3.343, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0965 + }, + "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitb14": { + "s_local": 0.416, + "s_global": 0.6637, + "lambda": 0.6266, + "tau": 0.1975, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1975, + "tai": 0.3965, + "perf_linear": 0.0506, + "perf_best": 0.1547, + "delta": 0.116, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.4171 + }, + "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.377, + "s_global": 0.5954, + "lambda": 0.6325, + "tau": 0.1723, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3268, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1723, + "tai": 0.0552, + "perf_linear": 0.0349, + "perf_best": 0.2023, + "delta": 0.57, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3778 + }, + "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.386, + "s_global": 0.5904, + "lambda": 0.6546, + "tau": 0.1338, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8296, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1338, + "tai": 0.5241, + "perf_linear": 0.0248, + "perf_best": 0.0883, + "delta": 0.479, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3877 + }, + "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.38, + "s_global": 0.646, + "lambda": 0.5886, + "tau": 0.2375, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2375, + "tai": 0.1487, + "perf_linear": 0.0748, + "perf_best": 0.2681, + "delta": 0.733, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3815 + }, + "convnext_large <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.255, + "s_global": 0.5899, + "lambda": 0.4318, + "tau": 0.269, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.269, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5363, + "tai": 0.1671, + "perf_linear": 0.0299, + "perf_best": 0.0925, + "delta": 0.256, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2562 + }, + "convnext_large <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.207, + "s_global": 0.5802, + "lambda": 0.3572, + "tau": 0.1455, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1455, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5876, + "tai": 0.1832, + "perf_linear": 0.0097, + "perf_best": 0.0665, + "delta": 0.447, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2088 + }, + "convnext_large <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.297, + "s_global": 0.688, + "lambda": 0.432, + "tau": 0.2889, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2889, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7933, + "tai": 0.3186, + "perf_linear": 0.0305, + "perf_best": 0.1055, + "delta": 0.109, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2986 + }, + "convnext_large <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.23, + "s_global": 0.6027, + "lambda": 0.3811, + "tau": 0.2392, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2392, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.2137, + "perf_linear": 0.0204, + "perf_best": 0.0671, + "delta": 0.38, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2312 + }, + "convnext_large <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.487, + "s_global": 0.7755, + "lambda": 0.6278, + "tau": 0.7538, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8154, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7538, + "tai": 0.0033, + "perf_linear": 0.2857, + "perf_best": 0.3777, + "delta": 0.086, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.4878 + }, + "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.333, + "s_global": 0.6845, + "lambda": 0.4871, + "tau": 0.5269, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5269, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7348, + "tai": 0.0362, + "perf_linear": 0.1308, + "perf_best": 0.2482, + "delta": 0.715, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.3347 + }, + "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.026, + "s_global": 0.1405, + "lambda": 0.1837, + "tau": 0.0027, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0027, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1723, + "tai": 0.6932, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.1369, + "delta": 6.836, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0277 + }, + "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.41, + "s_global": 0.6902, + "lambda": 0.5936, + "tau": 0.2073, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2073, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6798, + "tai": 0.2469, + "perf_linear": 0.0471, + "perf_best": 0.2273, + "delta": 0.824, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.4108 + }, + "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.096, + "s_global": 0.1979, + "lambda": 0.483, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4124, + "tai": 0.5056, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1863, + "delta": 3.586, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0974 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitg14": { + "s_local": 0.479, + "s_global": 0.6713, + "lambda": 0.7129, + "tau": 0.355, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.355, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3476, + "perf_linear": 0.0982, + "perf_best": 0.1806, + "delta": 0.454, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.4797 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.514, + "s_global": 0.6823, + "lambda": 0.7529, + "tau": 0.4073, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4073, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8111, + "tai": 0.0346, + "perf_linear": 0.0701, + "perf_best": 0.1662, + "delta": 0.363, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.5147 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.461, + "s_global": 0.7086, + "lambda": 0.6503, + "tau": 0.5372, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9308, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5372, + "tai": 0.162, + "perf_linear": 0.1646, + "perf_best": 0.3065, + "delta": 0.849, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.4619 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.22, + "s_global": 0.5169, + "lambda": 0.4262, + "tau": 0.1618, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1618, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.8261, + "perf_linear": 0.0074, + "perf_best": 0.008, + "delta": 0.372, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2218 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.176, + "s_global": 0.4627, + "lambda": 0.3794, + "tau": 0.0878, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0878, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4497, + "perf_linear": 0.0013, + "perf_best": 0.0084, + "delta": 0.563, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1771 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.245, + "s_global": 0.5659, + "lambda": 0.4335, + "tau": 0.2055, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2055, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7091, + "perf_linear": 0.0117, + "perf_best": 0.0166, + "delta": 0.006, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2468 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.193, + "s_global": 0.4969, + "lambda": 0.3889, + "tau": 0.1525, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1525, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.8364, + "perf_linear": 0.0078, + "perf_best": 0.0083, + "delta": 0.496, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1948 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.392, + "s_global": 0.6451, + "lambda": 0.6071, + "tau": 0.0816, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0816, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4491, + "perf_linear": 0.0178, + "perf_best": 0.12, + "delta": 0.202, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3928 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.287, + "s_global": 0.558, + "lambda": 0.5142, + "tau": 0.1219, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1219, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4562, + "perf_linear": 0.0142, + "perf_best": 0.0634, + "delta": 0.831, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2883 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.022, + "s_global": 0.1168, + "lambda": 0.1849, + "tau": 0.0038, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0038, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3127, + "tai": 0.8647, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.042, + "delta": 6.952, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0235 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.374, + "s_global": 0.5783, + "lambda": 0.6463, + "tau": 0.1323, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1323, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.1913, + "perf_linear": 0.0172, + "perf_best": 0.1054, + "delta": 0.939, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.375 + }, + "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.086, + "s_global": 0.1754, + "lambda": 0.4902, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7937, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0591, + "delta": 3.702, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0878 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14": { + "s_local": 0.639, + "s_global": 0.7816, + "lambda": 0.8181, + "tau": 0.5526, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5526, + "tai": 0.2547, + "perf_linear": 0.2161, + "perf_best": 0.2915, + "delta": 0.091, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.6401 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.344, + "s_global": 0.5505, + "lambda": 0.625, + "tau": 0.0995, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0995, + "tai": 0.3376, + "perf_linear": 0.022, + "perf_best": 0.1467, + "delta": 1.303, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3453 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.184, + "s_global": 0.4137, + "lambda": 0.4438, + "tau": 0.1942, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5353, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1942, + "tai": 0.1809, + "perf_linear": 0.0018, + "perf_best": 0.0093, + "delta": 0.826, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1852 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.154, + "s_global": 0.3699, + "lambda": 0.417, + "tau": 0.326, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3672, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.326, + "tai": 0.5158, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0047, + "delta": 1.017, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1559 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.208, + "s_global": 0.464, + "lambda": 0.4487, + "tau": 0.5712, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5854, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5712, + "tai": 0.3493, + "perf_linear": 0.0071, + "perf_best": 0.0124, + "delta": 0.461, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.2098 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.166, + "s_global": 0.3953, + "lambda": 0.4205, + "tau": 0.3541, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3541, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7258, + "perf_linear": 0.0076, + "perf_best": 0.0058, + "delta": 0.95, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1679 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.349, + "s_global": 0.5751, + "lambda": 0.6063, + "tau": 0.1948, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1948, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4664, + "tai": 0.088, + "perf_linear": 0.0276, + "perf_best": 0.1415, + "delta": 0.656, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.35 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.253, + "s_global": 0.4728, + "lambda": 0.5347, + "tau": 0.2689, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3589, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2689, + "tai": 0.4663, + "perf_linear": 0.0149, + "perf_best": 0.0415, + "delta": 1.285, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2543 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.02, + "s_global": 0.0901, + "lambda": 0.218, + "tau": 0.0041, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0041, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2696, + "tai": 0.8972, + "perf_linear": 0.0011, + "perf_best": 0.0284, + "delta": 7.406, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0216 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.369, + "s_global": 0.5144, + "lambda": 0.7165, + "tau": 0.1623, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1623, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4235, + "tai": 0.4367, + "perf_linear": 0.0184, + "perf_best": 0.1131, + "delta": 1.394, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3698 + }, + "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.08, + "s_global": 0.1461, + "lambda": 0.5477, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9384, + "tai": 0.7575, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0549, + "delta": 4.156, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0819 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14": { + "s_local": 0.364, + "s_global": 0.5665, + "lambda": 0.6419, + "tau": 0.1403, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1403, + "tai": 0.0557, + "perf_linear": 0.0221, + "perf_best": 0.1484, + "delta": 1.211, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3649 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.191, + "s_global": 0.4204, + "lambda": 0.4546, + "tau": 0.296, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.296, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5955, + "tai": 0.5299, + "perf_linear": 0.0039, + "perf_best": 0.0066, + "delta": 0.735, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1927 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.157, + "s_global": 0.3744, + "lambda": 0.4203, + "tau": 0.3167, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3167, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5567, + "tai": 0.3812, + "perf_linear": 0.0013, + "perf_best": 0.0041, + "delta": 0.926, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1591 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.217, + "s_global": 0.4652, + "lambda": 0.4662, + "tau": 0.3696, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3696, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.6567, + "perf_linear": 0.0099, + "perf_best": 0.0092, + "delta": 0.369, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2184 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.171, + "s_global": 0.399, + "lambda": 0.4279, + "tau": 0.2237, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2237, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7978, + "perf_linear": 0.0062, + "perf_best": 0.0056, + "delta": 0.858, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1724 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.357, + "s_global": 0.569, + "lambda": 0.6273, + "tau": 0.0246, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0246, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8182, + "tai": 0.6126, + "perf_linear": 0.0032, + "perf_best": 0.0501, + "delta": 0.565, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3582 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.258, + "s_global": 0.4764, + "lambda": 0.5419, + "tau": 0.3037, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3037, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.571, + "tai": 0.4128, + "perf_linear": 0.0129, + "perf_best": 0.025, + "delta": 1.194, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2596 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.02, + "s_global": 0.0903, + "lambda": 0.2218, + "tau": 0.005, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.005, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4174, + "tai": 0.9266, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.0175, + "delta": 7.314, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.022 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.369, + "s_global": 0.5078, + "lambda": 0.727, + "tau": 0.1926, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1926, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6969, + "tai": 0.1874, + "perf_linear": 0.0156, + "perf_best": 0.0659, + "delta": 1.302, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3704 + }, + "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.079, + "s_global": 0.1476, + "lambda": 0.5353, + "tau": 0.0001, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0001, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.8847, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0235, + "delta": 4.065, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0808 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> efficientnet_b0": { + "s_local": 0.257, + "s_global": 0.5826, + "lambda": 0.4418, + "tau": 0.0869, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0869, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.8129, + "perf_linear": 0.0134, + "perf_best": 0.0289, + "delta": 0.477, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2588 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.201, + "s_global": 0.5155, + "lambda": 0.3904, + "tau": 0.0209, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0209, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7311, + "perf_linear": 0.0025, + "perf_best": 0.0317, + "delta": 0.286, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2028 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.272, + "s_global": 0.6153, + "lambda": 0.4416, + "tau": 0.1095, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1095, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4239, + "perf_linear": 0.0138, + "perf_best": 0.0728, + "delta": 0.842, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2731 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.225, + "s_global": 0.5644, + "lambda": 0.3982, + "tau": 0.0886, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0886, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.7009, + "perf_linear": 0.0094, + "perf_best": 0.0316, + "delta": 0.353, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2262 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.375, + "s_global": 0.6482, + "lambda": 0.5791, + "tau": 0.1523, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1523, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.1809, + "perf_linear": 0.047, + "perf_best": 0.2529, + "delta": 0.647, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3766 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.29, + "s_global": 0.5833, + "lambda": 0.4974, + "tau": 0.0685, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0685, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.1595, + "perf_linear": 0.017, + "perf_best": 0.209, + "delta": 0.018, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2915 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.024, + "s_global": 0.144, + "lambda": 0.1698, + "tau": 0.003, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.003, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1607, + "tai": 0.6123, + "perf_linear": 0.0014, + "perf_best": 0.1763, + "delta": 6.103, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0264 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.323, + "s_global": 0.5669, + "lambda": 0.5701, + "tau": 0.0768, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0768, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.0307, + "perf_linear": 0.0151, + "perf_best": 0.1971, + "delta": 0.091, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3245 + }, + "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.1, + "s_global": 0.215, + "lambda": 0.463, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4342, + "tai": 0.4894, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.2078, + "delta": 2.853, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1013 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224": { + "s_local": 0.23, + "s_global": 0.6006, + "lambda": 0.3828, + "tau": 0.6188, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9448, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6188, + "tai": 0.5742, + "perf_linear": 0.0318, + "perf_best": 0.0337, + "delta": 0.191, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.2314 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.3, + "s_global": 0.6931, + "lambda": 0.4324, + "tau": 0.5747, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5747, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8413, + "tai": 0.3487, + "perf_linear": 0.0428, + "perf_best": 0.0744, + "delta": 0.366, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.3011 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.3, + "s_global": 0.7025, + "lambda": 0.4271, + "tau": 0.4761, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4761, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.1264, + "perf_linear": 0.043, + "perf_best": 0.0902, + "delta": 0.124, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3014 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.259, + "s_global": 0.5962, + "lambda": 0.4352, + "tau": 0.3716, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8312, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3716, + "tai": 0.275, + "perf_linear": 0.0357, + "perf_best": 0.0696, + "delta": 0.17, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2609 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.237, + "s_global": 0.5973, + "lambda": 0.3968, + "tau": 0.3528, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8763, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3528, + "tai": 0.4276, + "perf_linear": 0.0384, + "perf_best": 0.0623, + "delta": 0.459, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2385 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.031, + "s_global": 0.1905, + "lambda": 0.1638, + "tau": 0.004, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.004, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2195, + "tai": 0.5851, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.1512, + "delta": 6.58, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0331 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.207, + "s_global": 0.523, + "lambda": 0.3952, + "tau": 0.2704, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2704, + "tai": 0.7966, + "perf_linear": 0.0125, + "perf_best": 0.0124, + "delta": 0.567, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2083 + }, + "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.109, + "s_global": 0.2538, + "lambda": 0.4307, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5914, + "tai": 0.4884, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1365, + "delta": 3.33, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1111 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101": { + "s_local": 0.228, + "s_global": 0.6747, + "lambda": 0.3387, + "tau": 0.5199, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5199, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.178, + "perf_linear": 0.0306, + "perf_best": 0.0484, + "delta": 0.557, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.23 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.229, + "s_global": 0.6738, + "lambda": 0.3392, + "tau": 0.4262, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4262, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4203, + "perf_linear": 0.0322, + "perf_best": 0.0439, + "delta": 0.068, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2301 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.213, + "s_global": 0.5843, + "lambda": 0.3642, + "tau": 0.2714, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6355, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2714, + "tai": 0.2156, + "perf_linear": 0.0133, + "perf_best": 0.0491, + "delta": 0.361, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2144 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.225, + "s_global": 0.6675, + "lambda": 0.3376, + "tau": 0.179, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4606, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.179, + "tai": 0.123, + "perf_linear": 0.0205, + "perf_best": 0.1003, + "delta": 0.268, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2268 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.027, + "s_global": 0.1234, + "lambda": 0.2213, + "tau": 0.0023, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0023, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1359, + "tai": 0.5391, + "perf_linear": 0.0008, + "perf_best": 0.1559, + "delta": 6.389, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0293 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.184, + "s_global": 0.5775, + "lambda": 0.3186, + "tau": 0.1801, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7399, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1801, + "tai": 0.5523, + "perf_linear": 0.0078, + "perf_best": 0.0194, + "delta": 0.376, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1856 + }, + "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.097, + "s_global": 0.209, + "lambda": 0.4658, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7736, + "tai": 0.5366, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1161, + "delta": 3.139, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0992 + }, + "resnet101 <-> resnet50": { + "s_local": 0.319, + "s_global": 0.7468, + "lambda": 0.4278, + "tau": 0.5445, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5445, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.24, + "perf_linear": 0.0587, + "perf_best": 0.082, + "delta": 0.489, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.3208 + }, + "resnet101 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.294, + "s_global": 0.6952, + "lambda": 0.4222, + "tau": 0.3606, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3606, + "tai": 0.329, + "perf_linear": 0.0337, + "perf_best": 0.0935, + "delta": 0.196, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2949 + }, + "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.259, + "s_global": 0.6843, + "lambda": 0.3787, + "tau": 0.3564, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3564, + "tai": 0.1731, + "perf_linear": 0.0329, + "perf_best": 0.0923, + "delta": 0.824, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2606 + }, + "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.03, + "s_global": 0.144, + "lambda": 0.2099, + "tau": 0.0037, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0037, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2678, + "tai": 0.7387, + "perf_linear": 0.0012, + "perf_best": 0.0858, + "delta": 6.945, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0321 + }, + "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.234, + "s_global": 0.6192, + "lambda": 0.3779, + "tau": 0.3229, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8867, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3229, + "tai": 0.6101, + "perf_linear": 0.0186, + "perf_best": 0.0225, + "delta": 0.933, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2355 + }, + "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.106, + "s_global": 0.2196, + "lambda": 0.483, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7346, + "tai": 0.6172, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.0966, + "delta": 3.696, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1078 + }, + "resnet50 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224": { + "s_local": 0.232, + "s_global": 0.6064, + "lambda": 0.3826, + "tau": 0.2863, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2863, + "tai": 0.259, + "perf_linear": 0.0224, + "perf_best": 0.0581, + "delta": 0.294, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2335 + }, + "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.214, + "s_global": 0.6391, + "lambda": 0.3345, + "tau": 0.2533, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2533, + "tai": 0.3858, + "perf_linear": 0.022, + "perf_best": 0.0533, + "delta": 0.335, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.2153 + }, + "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.036, + "s_global": 0.1715, + "lambda": 0.2107, + "tau": 0.0038, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0038, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.266, + "tai": 0.7016, + "perf_linear": 0.0014, + "perf_best": 0.1115, + "delta": 6.456, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.038 + }, + "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.189, + "s_global": 0.5715, + "lambda": 0.3313, + "tau": 0.2387, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2387, + "tai": 0.8432, + "perf_linear": 0.0142, + "perf_best": 0.0094, + "delta": 0.444, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1909 + }, + "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.118, + "s_global": 0.2724, + "lambda": 0.4319, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6797, + "tai": 0.5969, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1066, + "delta": 3.206, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1194 + }, + "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.335, + "s_global": 0.6761, + "lambda": 0.4958, + "tau": 0.5442, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5442, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.712, + "tai": 0.0609, + "perf_linear": 0.1257, + "perf_best": 0.231, + "delta": 0.629, + "regime": "Convergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.3366 + }, + "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.026, + "s_global": 0.149, + "lambda": 0.177, + "tau": 0.0037, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0037, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1569, + "tai": 0.636, + "perf_linear": 0.0015, + "perf_best": 0.1459, + "delta": 6.75, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0283 + }, + "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.385, + "s_global": 0.6726, + "lambda": 0.5719, + "tau": 0.187, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.187, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6328, + "tai": 0.3007, + "perf_linear": 0.0343, + "perf_best": 0.1835, + "delta": 0.737, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3859 + }, + "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.1, + "s_global": 0.2137, + "lambda": 0.4693, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4712, + "tai": 0.4661, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1856, + "delta": 3.5, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1021 + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.027, + "s_global": 0.1539, + "lambda": 0.1724, + "tau": 0.0024, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0024, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1956, + "tai": 0.6625, + "perf_linear": 0.001, + "perf_best": 0.1404, + "delta": 6.121, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0285 + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.302, + "s_global": 0.6639, + "lambda": 0.4548, + "tau": 0.219, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.219, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5333, + "tai": 0.2405, + "perf_linear": 0.0351, + "perf_best": 0.1604, + "delta": 0.108, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.3034 + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.096, + "s_global": 0.2167, + "lambda": 0.4438, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5298, + "tai": 0.5205, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.1642, + "delta": 2.871, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.098 + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224": { + "s_local": 0.027, + "s_global": 0.1716, + "lambda": 0.1554, + "tau": 0.0023, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4077, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0023, + "tai": 0.8148, + "perf_linear": 0.001, + "perf_best": 0.0789, + "delta": 6.012, + "regime": "Divergent", + "raw_overlap": 0.0286 + }, + "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.125, + "s_global": 0.4191, + "lambda": 0.2972, + "tau": 0.0208, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0208, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3158, + "tai": 0.1829, + "perf_linear": 0.012, + "perf_best": 0.5784, + "delta": 3.25, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.1263 + }, + "vit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae": { + "s_local": 0.091, + "s_global": 0.218, + "lambda": 0.4178, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7922, + "tai": 0.7149, + "perf_linear": 0.0, + "perf_best": 0.099, + "delta": 2.763, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "raw_overlap": 0.0929 + } + }, + "metadata": { + "k": 10, + "n_permutations": 100, + "seed": 42, + "n_models": 20 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/audio_atlas.json b/data/audio_atlas.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c0e7e3ac12b8311e73d2d92de6234ecff83119a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/audio_atlas.json @@ -0,0 +1,378 @@ +{ + "n_models": 6, + "n_pairs": 15, + "models": [ + { + "name": "hubert-base", + "family": "hubert", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "hubert-large", + "family": "hubert", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1024 + }, + { + "name": "wav2vec2-base", + "family": "wav2vec2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "wav2vec2-large", + "family": "wav2vec2", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 1024 + }, + { + "name": "whisper-base", + "family": "whisper", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 512 + }, + { + "name": "whisper-small", + "family": "whisper", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768 + } + ], + "regime_counts": { + "Local-Only": 14, + "Convergent": 1 + }, + "pairs": [ + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "model_a": "hubert-base", + "model_b": "hubert-large", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "hubert", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.465, + "s_local_raw": 0.4677, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.778, + "lambda": 0.5978, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9469, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.2126, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 7.1, + "delta": 1.18, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-base", + "model_a": "hubert-base", + "model_b": "wav2vec2-base", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "wav2vec2", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.3995, + "s_local_raw": 0.4025, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6982, + "lambda": 0.5722, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9042, + "tai": 0.2619, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 5.37, + "delta": 0.55, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "model_a": "hubert-base", + "model_b": "wav2vec2-large", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "wav2vec2", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.29, + "s_local_raw": 0.2936, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.7394, + "lambda": 0.3922, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2579, + "tai": 0.49, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 3.12, + "delta": 2.8, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "model_a": "hubert-base", + "model_b": "whisper-base", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1758, + "s_local_raw": 0.1799, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6128, + "lambda": 0.2868, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6392, + "tai": 0.3776, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 2.92, + "delta": 2.99, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-small", + "model_a": "hubert-base", + "model_b": "whisper-small", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1536, + "s_local_raw": 0.1578, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6418, + "lambda": 0.2393, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5425, + "tai": 0.2367, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 3.31, + "delta": 2.61, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-large \u00d7 wav2vec2-base", + "model_a": "hubert-large", + "model_b": "wav2vec2-base", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "wav2vec2", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.3285, + "s_local_raw": 0.3318, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.5825, + "lambda": 0.5639, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.757, + "bitrate_a": 7.1, + "bitrate_b": 5.37, + "delta": 1.73, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-large \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "model_a": "hubert-large", + "model_b": "wav2vec2-large", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "wav2vec2", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.2244, + "s_local_raw": 0.2283, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.5251, + "lambda": 0.4274, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4506, + "tai": 0.8781, + "bitrate_a": 7.1, + "bitrate_b": 3.12, + "delta": 3.98, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-large \u00d7 whisper-base", + "model_a": "hubert-large", + "model_b": "whisper-base", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1444, + "s_local_raw": 0.1487, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.4495, + "lambda": 0.3213, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4336, + "tai": 0.5493, + "bitrate_a": 7.1, + "bitrate_b": 2.92, + "delta": 4.17, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "model_a": "hubert-large", + "model_b": "whisper-small", + "family_a": "hubert", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1327, + "s_local_raw": 0.137, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.4649, + "lambda": 0.2855, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3516, + "tai": 0.4067, + "bitrate_a": 7.1, + "bitrate_b": 3.31, + "delta": 3.79, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "model_a": "wav2vec2-base", + "model_b": "wav2vec2-large", + "family_a": "wav2vec2", + "family_b": "wav2vec2", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.3109, + "s_local_raw": 0.3144, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6808, + "lambda": 0.4567, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2416, + "tai": 0.2506, + "bitrate_a": 5.37, + "bitrate_b": 3.12, + "delta": 2.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "model_a": "wav2vec2-base", + "model_b": "whisper-base", + "family_a": "wav2vec2", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1398, + "s_local_raw": 0.1442, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.4896, + "lambda": 0.2856, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6632, + "tai": 0.3051, + "bitrate_a": 5.37, + "bitrate_b": 2.92, + "delta": 2.44, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 whisper-small", + "model_a": "wav2vec2-base", + "model_b": "whisper-small", + "family_a": "wav2vec2", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1272, + "s_local_raw": 0.1316, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.5278, + "lambda": 0.2409, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5144, + "tai": 0.0109, + "bitrate_a": 5.37, + "bitrate_b": 3.31, + "delta": 2.06, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-base", + "model_a": "wav2vec2-large", + "model_b": "whisper-base", + "family_a": "wav2vec2", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1415, + "s_local_raw": 0.1458, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6056, + "lambda": 0.2337, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4827, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.1978, + "bitrate_a": 3.12, + "bitrate_b": 2.92, + "delta": 0.19, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "model_a": "wav2vec2-large", + "model_b": "whisper-small", + "family_a": "wav2vec2", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1357, + "s_local_raw": 0.14, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.6602, + "lambda": 0.2055, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4903, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.3098, + "bitrate_a": 3.12, + "bitrate_b": 3.31, + "delta": 0.19, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "whisper-base \u00d7 whisper-small", + "model_a": "whisper-base", + "model_b": "whisper-small", + "family_a": "whisper", + "family_b": "whisper", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.2699, + "s_local_raw": 0.2735, + "null_mean": 0.005, + "s_global": 0.9104, + "lambda": 0.2964, + "tau": 0.8785, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9275, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8785, + "tai": 0.0504, + "bitrate_a": 2.92, + "bitrate_b": 3.31, + "delta": 0.38, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/audio_bitrate_sweep.json b/data/audio_bitrate_sweep.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..733bf94cb0cfbd054d16f3e4e8222f15d3b65bde --- /dev/null +++ b/data/audio_bitrate_sweep.json @@ -0,0 +1,354 @@ +[ + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 4, + "bitrate_a": 1.5, + "bitrate_b": 1.85, + "bitrate_mean": 1.68, + "s_local": 0.0797, + "tau": 0.3197, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.898, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3197 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 8, + "bitrate_a": 2.36, + "bitrate_b": 2.78, + "bitrate_mean": 2.57, + "s_local": 0.1688, + "tau": 0.1661, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9463, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1661 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 16, + "bitrate_a": 3.22, + "bitrate_b": 3.7, + "bitrate_mean": 3.46, + "s_local": 0.2849, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8671, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 32, + "bitrate_a": 4.02, + "bitrate_b": 4.57, + "bitrate_mean": 4.3, + "s_local": 0.3889, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9345, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 64, + "bitrate_a": 4.72, + "bitrate_b": 5.36, + "bitrate_mean": 5.04, + "s_local": 0.4443, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.958, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 128, + "bitrate_a": 5.3, + "bitrate_b": 6.04, + "bitrate_mean": 5.67, + "s_local": 0.4609, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8862, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 256, + "bitrate_a": 5.72, + "bitrate_b": 6.58, + "bitrate_mean": 6.15, + "s_local": 0.466, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.878, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 hubert-large", + "rank": 512, + "bitrate_a": 5.9, + "bitrate_b": 6.94, + "bitrate_mean": 6.42, + "s_local": 0.4656, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9093, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 4, + "bitrate_a": 1.66, + "bitrate_b": 1.22, + "bitrate_mean": 1.44, + "s_local": 0.0395, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3468 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 8, + "bitrate_a": 2.55, + "bitrate_b": 1.71, + "bitrate_mean": 2.13, + "s_local": 0.129, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2715 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 16, + "bitrate_a": 3.38, + "bitrate_b": 2.21, + "bitrate_mean": 2.79, + "s_local": 0.2228, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2522 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 32, + "bitrate_a": 4.1, + "bitrate_b": 2.59, + "bitrate_mean": 3.34, + "s_local": 0.2772, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2403 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 64, + "bitrate_a": 4.65, + "bitrate_b": 2.86, + "bitrate_mean": 3.75, + "s_local": 0.3012, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2556 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 128, + "bitrate_a": 5.05, + "bitrate_b": 3.02, + "bitrate_mean": 4.03, + "s_local": 0.308, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2483 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 256, + "bitrate_a": 5.28, + "bitrate_b": 3.09, + "bitrate_mean": 4.18, + "s_local": 0.3102, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2457 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-base \u00d7 wav2vec2-large", + "rank": 512, + "bitrate_a": 5.36, + "bitrate_b": 3.11, + "bitrate_mean": 4.24, + "s_local": 0.3105, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2425 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 4, + "bitrate_a": 1.5, + "bitrate_b": 1.02, + "bitrate_mean": 1.26, + "s_local": 0.0356, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6114 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 8, + "bitrate_a": 2.36, + "bitrate_b": 1.36, + "bitrate_mean": 1.86, + "s_local": 0.0705, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6367 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 16, + "bitrate_a": 3.22, + "bitrate_b": 1.72, + "bitrate_mean": 2.47, + "s_local": 0.1247, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6314 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 32, + "bitrate_a": 4.02, + "bitrate_b": 2.05, + "bitrate_mean": 3.03, + "s_local": 0.16, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6296 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 64, + "bitrate_a": 4.72, + "bitrate_b": 2.35, + "bitrate_mean": 3.54, + "s_local": 0.1715, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6505 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 128, + "bitrate_a": 5.3, + "bitrate_b": 2.62, + "bitrate_mean": 3.96, + "s_local": 0.1766, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.646 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 256, + "bitrate_a": 5.72, + "bitrate_b": 2.82, + "bitrate_mean": 4.27, + "s_local": 0.1769, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6411 + }, + { + "pair": "hubert-base \u00d7 whisper-base", + "rank": 512, + "bitrate_a": 5.9, + "bitrate_b": 2.93, + "bitrate_mean": 4.41, + "s_local": 0.1757, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6281 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 4, + "bitrate_a": 1.22, + "bitrate_b": 1.4, + "bitrate_mean": 1.31, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3756, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 8, + "bitrate_a": 1.71, + "bitrate_b": 1.73, + "bitrate_mean": 1.72, + "s_local": 0.0512, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4279, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 16, + "bitrate_a": 2.21, + "bitrate_b": 2.08, + "bitrate_mean": 2.14, + "s_local": 0.0874, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4383, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 32, + "bitrate_a": 2.59, + "bitrate_b": 2.38, + "bitrate_mean": 2.48, + "s_local": 0.1166, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4573, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 64, + "bitrate_a": 2.86, + "bitrate_b": 2.65, + "bitrate_mean": 2.75, + "s_local": 0.1307, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4566, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 128, + "bitrate_a": 3.02, + "bitrate_b": 2.9, + "bitrate_mean": 2.96, + "s_local": 0.1341, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4778, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 256, + "bitrate_a": 3.09, + "bitrate_b": 3.11, + "bitrate_mean": 3.1, + "s_local": 0.1356, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4678, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + }, + { + "pair": "wav2vec2-large \u00d7 whisper-small", + "rank": 512, + "bitrate_a": 3.11, + "bitrate_b": 3.26, + "bitrate_mean": 3.19, + "s_local": 0.1356, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.47, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0 + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/audio_features/extraction.log b/data/audio_features/extraction.log new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f8194720d3b3ae6333e3b67a61510c1f7e73febe --- /dev/null +++ b/data/audio_features/extraction.log @@ -0,0 +1,188 @@ +2026-03-08 10:34:51,077 INFO Found 2620 FLAC files in data/librispeech/LibriSpeech/test-clean +2026-03-08 10:35:13,915 INFO Loaded 500/2000 samples +2026-03-08 10:35:38,312 INFO Loaded 1000/2000 samples +2026-03-08 10:36:09,065 INFO Loaded 1500/2000 samples +2026-03-08 10:36:39,609 INFO Loaded 2000/2000 samples +2026-03-08 10:36:39,609 INFO Loaded 2000 audio samples at 16000Hz +2026-03-08 10:36:39,618 INFO Loading model: wav2vec2-base (facebook/wav2vec2-base) +2026-03-08 10:36:44,532 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/facebook/wav2vec2-base/resolve/main/config.json "HTTP/1.1 307 Temporary Redirect" +2026-03-08 10:36:44,544 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/api/resolve-cache/models/facebook/wav2vec2-base/0b5b8e868dd84f03fd87d01f9c4ff0f080fecfe8/config.json "HTTP/1.1 200 OK" +2026-03-08 10:36:44,557 INFO HTTP Request: GET https://huggingface.co/api/resolve-cache/models/facebook/wav2vec2-base/0b5b8e868dd84f03fd87d01f9c4ff0f080fecfe8/config.json "HTTP/1.1 200 OK" +2026-03-08 10:36:44,763 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/facebook/wav2vec2-base/resolve/main/model.safetensors "HTTP/1.1 404 Not Found" +2026-03-08 10:36:44,970 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/facebook/wav2vec2-base/resolve/main/model.safetensors.index.json "HTTP/1.1 404 Not Found" +2026-03-08 10:36:45,177 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/facebook/wav2vec2-base/resolve/main/pytorch_model.bin "HTTP/1.1 302 Found" +Warning: You are sending unauthenticated requests to the HF Hub. Please set a HF_TOKEN to enable higher rate limits and faster downloads. +2026-03-08 10:36:45,178 WARNING Warning: You are sending unauthenticated requests to the HF Hub. Please set a HF_TOKEN to enable higher rate limits and faster downloads. +2026-03-08 10:36:45,391 INFO HTTP Request: GET https://huggingface.co/api/models/facebook/wav2vec2-base/xet-read-token/0b5b8e868dd84f03fd87d01f9c4ff0f080fecfe8 "HTTP/1.1 200 OK" +2026-03-08 10:36:50,028 INFO HTTP Request: HEAD https://huggingface.co/facebook/wav2vec2-base/resolve/main/model.safetensors "HTTP/1.1 404 Not Found" +2026-03-08 10:36:50,434 INFO HTTP Request: GET https://huggingface.co/api/models/facebook/wav2vec2-base "HTTP/1.1 200 OK" + Loading weights: 0%| | 0/211 [00:00 beit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_base", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_base", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> resnet50", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "effective_rank": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + } + ] + }, + "effective_rank vs spectral_entropy": { + "agreement_rate_pct": 99.47, + "agree_count": 189, + "total_pairs": 190, + "flip_count": 1, + "flips": [ + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "effective_rank": "Local-Only", + "spectral_entropy": "Collapsed" + } + ] + }, + "participation_ratio vs gini_spectrum": { + "agreement_rate_pct": 0.0, + "agree_count": 0, + "total_pairs": 190, + "flip_count": 190, + "flips": [ + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_base", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_base", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> resnet50", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Convergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "participation_ratio": "Divergent", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed" + } + ] + }, + "participation_ratio vs spectral_entropy": { + "agreement_rate_pct": 99.47, + "agree_count": 189, + "total_pairs": 190, + "flip_count": 1, + "flips": [ + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "participation_ratio": "Local-Only", + "spectral_entropy": "Collapsed" + } + ] + }, + "gini_spectrum vs spectral_entropy": { + "agreement_rate_pct": 0.53, + "agree_count": 1, + "total_pairs": 190, + "flip_count": 189, + "flips": [ + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_base", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_base", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> resnet50", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "gini_spectrum": "Collapsed", + "spectral_entropy": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/cifar100_test_labels.pt b/data/cifar100_test_labels.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ea21ed4cd0c48874ae305360fb06f4b32ac59281 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/cifar100_test_labels.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:94702b87d4a6529eb5b052e55143dfce4f5d22f0620ff40e197a917b7a3d3a22 +size 41668 diff --git a/data/cifar100_train_labels.pt b/data/cifar100_train_labels.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85abdd232ccf4311344163c2b723f26a0010128d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/cifar100_train_labels.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b11d50c7a557958abb11f3754b5d4dd1c7e73ce94f7b76ba0cfc4d5db2f6627d +size 41675 diff --git a/data/croissant.json b/data/croissant.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0ddd1ae5f6bf8b8537b585e35c0bab619218859 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/croissant.json @@ -0,0 +1,318 @@ +{ + "@context": { + "@language": "en", + "@vocab": "https://schema.org/", + "citeAs": "cr:citeAs", + "column": "cr:column", + "conformsTo": "dct:conformsTo", + "cr": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/", + "rai": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/RAI/", + "data": { + "@id": "cr:data", + "@type": "@json" + }, + "dataType": { + "@id": "cr:dataType", + "@type": "@vocab" + }, + "dct": "http://purl.org/dc/terms/", + "examples": { + "@id": "cr:examples", + "@type": "@json" + }, + "extract": "cr:extract", + "field": "cr:field", + "fileProperty": "cr:fileProperty", + "fileObject": "cr:fileObject", + "fileSet": "cr:fileSet", + "format": "cr:format", + "includes": "cr:includes", + "isLiveDataset": "cr:isLiveDataset", + "jsonPath": "cr:jsonPath", + "key": "cr:key", + "md5": "cr:md5", + "parentField": "cr:parentField", + "path": "cr:path", + "recordSet": "cr:recordSet", + "references": "cr:references", + "regex": "cr:regex", + "repeated": "cr:repeated", + "replace": "cr:replace", + "sc": "https://schema.org/", + "separator": "cr:separator", + "source": "cr:source", + "subField": "cr:subField", + "transform": "cr:transform" + }, + "@type": "sc:Dataset", + "name": "BCCT-Hub", + "description": "BCCT-Hub: a benchmark and toolkit for measuring representation convergence across model families. The release contains four pre-computed pairwise compatibility atlases (vision: 190 pairs across 20 encoders; language: 36 pairs across 9 LLMs; audio: 15 pairs; video: 15 pairs), 41 pre-extracted feature tensors, statistical-analysis JSON outputs, an 88-paper meta-analysis CSV, and a per-claim artifact manifest mapping every paper claim to its producing script. The release accompanies a NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations & Datasets Track submission and is intended for representation-similarity benchmarking research.", + "url": "https://anonymous.4open.science/r/bcct-hub", + "version": "0.1.0", + "license": "https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0", + "citeAs": "Anonymous Authors. BCCT-Hub: A Benchmark and Toolkit for Measuring Representation Convergence Across Model Families. NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations & Datasets Track (under review).", + "datePublished": "2026-05-06", + "conformsTo": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/1.0", + "keywords": [ + "representation-similarity", + "convergence", + "transport", + "benchmark", + "scorecard", + "alignment", + "evaluation" + ], + + "rai:dataCollection": "Pairwise BCCT metrics (effective-rank bitrate, null-calibrated mutual k-NN, CKA, Procrustes-based transport linearity, transport asymmetry, bottleneck mismatch) were computed on features extracted from publicly available pretrained encoders (CLIP, DINOv2, ResNet, ViT, ConvNeXt, MAE, BEiT, MLP-Mixer, Swin, EfficientNet, Pythia, OPT, Phi-2, GPT-2, LLaMA-style models, and others). Source data are CIFAR-100 (vision test, 5000 images), STL-10 (vision robustness check; pseudo-clip rendering for video atlas), WikiText-103 (language, 2000 passages of 128 tokens), and LibriSpeech test-clean (audio). All extraction is deterministic with seed 42.", + + "rai:dataCollectionType": ["Derived from public pretrained models and standard benchmarks"], + "rai:dataCollectionTimeFrame": { + "@type": "sc:DateTime", + "@value": "2026-01-01/2026-06-30" + }, + "rai:dataCollectionTimeFrameDescription": "Feature extraction and atlas computation were performed in 2026 (Q1-Q2). Source pretrained-model snapshots and benchmark releases are documented per row in the released JSON.", + "rai:dataAnnotationProtocol": "No human annotation. All numerical values are deterministic outputs of standardized scripts (scripts/extract_features*.py, scripts/compute_alignment_atlas.py, scripts/compute_audio_atlas.py, scripts/compute_video_atlas.py, scripts/llm_experiment.py).", + "rai:dataAnnotationPlatform": "Not applicable (no human annotation).", + "rai:dataAnnotationAnalysis": "Not applicable.", + "rai:dataAnnotatorDemographics": "Not applicable.", + + "rai:dataPreprocessingProtocol": "Vision images: resize 256, center-crop 224, ImageNet mean/std normalization. STL-10: 96 to 224 upscale. LibriSpeech: 16 kHz mono, model-specific feature extractors. WikiText-103: 128-token windows, attention-mask-aware mean pooling. All pipelines fixed in scripts/ with seed=42.", + + "rai:dataLimitations": "Audio uses a single clean English corpus (LibriSpeech test-clean) and is preliminary at n=15 pairs. Video uses STL-10 pseudo-clips (no genuine temporal structure) and is preliminary at n=15 pairs. The largest LLMs are 7B parameters (Mistral-7B, Falcon-7B, Pythia-6.9B); whether the regime distribution shifts at frontier scale (70B+) is untested. All LLMs in the atlas are base/pretrained-only, no instruction-tuned or RLHF models. The vision atlas is monolingual-equivalent (image-only, no text). Bitrate is reported as an effective-rank covariance proxy, not a calibrated mutual-information estimate. Transport linearity is defined relative to a standardized 2-layer MLP probe and is not an oracle nonlinear comparison. Pre-computed compatibility predictions assume the atlas's feature-extraction protocol; cross-protocol pairs are systematically flagged Divergent (see Appendix G of the accompanying paper).", + + "rai:dataBiases": "The 88-paper meta-analysis (data/meta_analysis.csv) is biased toward vision (51/88) over language (16) and audio (3), reflecting publication frequency in representational similarity research up to 2026. The vision atlas is biased toward English-language web/image-corpus pretraining (CLIP, DINOv2 trained on LVD-142M; ImageNet-trained supervised baselines). The LLM atlas is English-only. Family selection is biased toward openly available checkpoints; closed-source models (GPT-4 class) are excluded by necessity, and recent permissively licensed code-generation or multilingual models may be under-represented.", + + "rai:dataPersonalSensitiveInformation": "The release contains no personal or sensitive information. All four atlases are statistical summaries (similarity scores, regime labels) over public benchmark stimuli (CIFAR-100, STL-10, WikiText-103, LibriSpeech test-clean), and the released feature tensors are deterministic activations of public pretrained models on these public benchmarks. CIFAR-100 and STL-10 contain no personal data. LibriSpeech test-clean contains read public-domain audiobook recordings with speaker IDs released by the LibriVox/LibriSpeech project; we use only model activations, not raw audio. WikiText-103 is derived from Wikipedia featured/good articles. No demographic, health, financial, political, or religious information is collected, inferred, or released.", + + "rai:dataUseCases": "Intended uses (validated in the accompanying paper): (a) compatibility screening between candidate model pairs prior to model-stitching or knowledge-transfer experiments; (b) reproducing and auditing the headline statistical findings of the paper (mixed-effects family beta=0.20, block-bootstrap rho=-0.70, retrieval rho=0.76); (c) extending the atlas with new encoders by re-running the extraction pipeline; (d) regression testing for representation-similarity research that builds on CKA, mutual k-NN, Procrustes-based transport, or effective-rank proxies. Out-of-scope uses (NOT validated and explicitly not recommended): (i) deployment-time decisions about whether two production models are interchangeable in a downstream application; (ii) safety or fairness certification of any individual encoder; (iii) inference about model training data, intellectual property, or copyright provenance from feature-space similarity.", + + "rai:dataSocialImpact": "Positive impact: standardized evaluation protocols reduce wasted compute on incompatible model pairs, support reproducible representational-similarity research, and surface honest negative findings (e.g., the 35/190 disagreement cases in which CKA looks high but linear transport fails). Negative impact / misuse risk: BCCT scores are diagnostic summaries for comparative research, not deployment guarantees; we explicitly state that BCCT scores must not be used as certifications of safe model interchangeability. Misreading the scorecard as a safety stamp could be harmful when applied to production-critical interchangeability decisions. We mitigate this risk by making the scope statement prominent in the abstract, the conclusion, and the Reviewer Checklist, and by releasing the full per-claim manifest so any user can trace any reported number back to its producing script.", + + "rai:dataReleaseMaintenancePlan": "Versioned release at the anonymous URL during review; planned migration to a persistent platform (Hugging Face Datasets and/or OpenML) at camera-ready, with a DOI for the 0.1.0 snapshot. Issue tracker on the public repository will accept extension requests (new encoders) and bug reports (numerical inconsistencies). Version policy: minor releases for added encoders; major releases for atlas-recomputation under different feature-extraction protocols.", + + "isLiveDataset": false, + + "creator": { + "@type": "Organization", + "name": "Anonymous" + }, + + "distribution": [ + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "bcct-hub-root", + "name": "bcct-hub-archive", + "description": "Root archive of the BCCT-Hub release; contains all feature tensors, experiment JSONs, atlas JSONs, scripts, and the paper. The release URL serves an anonymous source archive during NeurIPS 2026 review and a versioned snapshot post camera-ready.", + "contentUrl": "https://anonymous.4open.science/r/bcct-hub", + "encodingFormat": "application/zip", + "sha256": "PENDING_FINAL_REPOSITORY_SNAPSHOT_HASH" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "atlas-vision", + "name": "atlas.json", + "description": "Vision compatibility atlas: 190 pairs across 20 pretrained encoders on CIFAR-100 test (5000 images). Each pair has six BCCT metrics and a regime label.", + "contentUrl": "data/atlas.json", + "encodingFormat": "application/json", + "sha256": "c8826acc8352017e5f3e0c599666f71ee367fdf1677fa9cd4d6c6b64aa9a6a77" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "atlas-llm", + "name": "llm_atlas.json", + "description": "Language compatibility atlas: 36 pairs across 9 base LLMs on WikiText-103 (2000 passages of 128 tokens).", + "contentUrl": "data/llm_atlas.json", + "encodingFormat": "application/json", + "sha256": "56543b9b58b2855a64749aa9a158cdcb9a06fcf7f1bfc662ebe7afb1026b28dd" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "atlas-audio", + "name": "audio_atlas.json", + "description": "Preliminary audio compatibility atlas: 15 pairs across 6 audio encoders on LibriSpeech test-clean.", + "contentUrl": "data/audio_atlas.json", + "encodingFormat": "application/json", + "sha256": "f6c09f96fe301fc8156421a18d10534ea704cea0c598aac87bb9f4e0142c20a5" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "atlas-video", + "name": "video_atlas.json", + "description": "Exploratory video compatibility atlas: 15 pairs across 6 video encoders on STL-10 pseudo-clips.", + "contentUrl": "data/video_atlas.json", + "encodingFormat": "application/json", + "sha256": "189e11c2a70eb7ec96a3dd112d86b9ffa0651745c8d6ddfcec67a041f4b6e752" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileObject", + "@id": "meta-analysis-csv", + "name": "meta_analysis.csv", + "description": "88-paper meta-analysis extraction (cite key, year, thread, domain, scale tier, metric type, reported value, inferred BCCT regime, key finding).", + "contentUrl": "data/meta_analysis.csv", + "encodingFormat": "text/csv", + "sha256": "d9e1c0d0eb70ec4d9d4036465643696a0b03222ae0783084c82fda40ed43b0d8" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileSet", + "@id": "experiment-results", + "name": "experiments", + "description": "Statistical and downstream-utility analysis JSON outputs (mixed-effects, holdout validation, retrieval, stitching, external scorecard study, threshold sensitivity, probe variance, knn sensitivity, metric ablation, regime clustering, etc.).", + "containedIn": {"@id": "bcct-hub-root"}, + "encodingFormat": "application/json", + "includes": "data/experiments/*.json" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileSet", + "@id": "vision-features", + "name": "vision-features", + "description": "Pre-extracted feature tensors for 20 vision encoders on CIFAR-100 test (5000 images).", + "containedIn": {"@id": "bcct-hub-root"}, + "encodingFormat": "application/x-pytorch", + "includes": "data/features/*.pt" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileSet", + "@id": "vision-features-train", + "name": "vision-features-train", + "description": "Pre-extracted feature tensors for 20 vision encoders on a CIFAR-100 train subset (seed=42; 5000 images).", + "containedIn": {"@id": "bcct-hub-root"}, + "encodingFormat": "application/x-pytorch", + "includes": "data/features_train/*.pt" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:FileSet", + "@id": "external-features", + "name": "external-features", + "description": "Pre-extracted feature tensors for 5 out-of-atlas vision encoders used in the external scorecard case study (Appendix G).", + "containedIn": {"@id": "bcct-hub-root"}, + "encodingFormat": "application/x-pytorch", + "includes": "data/features_external/**/*.pt" + } + ], + + "recordSet": [ + { + "@type": "cr:RecordSet", + "@id": "vision-pair-records", + "name": "vision-pairwise", + "description": "Per-pair records of the vision compatibility atlas. Each record is a unique pair of two of the 20 atlas encoders.", + "field": [ + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/pair_key", + "name": "pair_key", + "description": "Human-readable pair name in the form 'encoder_a <-> encoder_b'.", + "dataType": "sc:Text", + "source": { + "fileObject": {"@id": "atlas-vision"}, + "extract": {"jsonPath": "$.pairwise[*]"} + } + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/s_local", + "name": "s_local", + "description": "Null-calibrated mutual k-NN overlap (k=10, 1000 permutations).", + "dataType": "sc:Float" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/s_global", + "name": "s_global", + "description": "Linear centered kernel alignment (CKA) on Gram matrices.", + "dataType": "sc:Float" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/tau", + "name": "tau", + "description": "Bidirectional conservative transport linearity score: min(tau_AB, tau_BA), per-dimension R^2 ratio of orthogonal Procrustes to a standardized 2-layer MLP probe on 80/20 train/test splits.", + "dataType": "sc:Float" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/tai", + "name": "tai", + "description": "Transport asymmetry index: |perf(A->B) - perf(B->A)| / max.", + "dataType": "sc:Float" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/delta", + "name": "delta", + "description": "Bottleneck mismatch: absolute difference of effective-rank bitrate proxies.", + "dataType": "sc:Float" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "vision-pair-records/regime", + "name": "regime", + "description": "BCCT regime classification: one of {Collapsed, Local-Only, Convergent, Divergent}.", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + } + ] + }, + { + "@type": "cr:RecordSet", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records", + "name": "meta-analysis", + "description": "88-paper extraction with thread, domain, scale, metric type, BCCT regime inference, and one-line key finding.", + "field": [ + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/cite_key", + "name": "cite_key", + "dataType": "sc:Text", + "source": { + "fileObject": {"@id": "meta-analysis-csv"}, + "extract": {"column": "cite_key"} + } + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/short_name", + "name": "short_name", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/year", + "name": "year", + "dataType": "sc:Integer" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/thread", + "name": "thread", + "description": "One of {convergence, transport, latent_design, theory}.", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/domain", + "name": "domain", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/metric_type", + "name": "metric_type", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/bcct_regime", + "name": "bcct_regime", + "description": "Inferred BCCT regime; 'N/A' when reported evidence is insufficient.", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + }, + { + "@type": "cr:Field", + "@id": "meta-analysis-records/key_finding", + "name": "key_finding", + "dataType": "sc:Text" + } + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment.json b/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..805e65eb574911e1fb4d7c42caf5289066099fb9 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment.json @@ -0,0 +1,1268 @@ +{ + "experiment": "Track B: Bitrate Sweep", + "config": { + "k": 10, + "n_permutations": 100, + "seed": 42, + "device": "cuda:2", + "n_pairs": 8 + }, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitl14", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.6006, + "s_local": 0.5138, + "tau": 0.4052, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.3796, + "s_local": 0.514, + "tau": 0.4617, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.9645, + "s_local": 0.5134, + "tau": 0.5698, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.1548, + "s_local": 0.5, + "tau": 0.6972, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.2893, + "s_local": 0.4605, + "tau": 0.6736, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.369, + "s_local": 0.4044, + "tau": 0.5303, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.9635, + "s_local": 0.5138, + "tau": 0.8042, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.7532, + "s_local": 0.5135, + "tau": 0.4444, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.3523, + "s_local": 0.5113, + "tau": 0.5611, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.5638, + "s_local": 0.4959, + "tau": 0.7339, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.7283, + "s_local": 0.4621, + "tau": 0.7706, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.8327, + "s_local": 0.4146, + "tau": 0.6721, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.5137, + "s_global": 0.6823, + "lambda_val": 0.7529, + "raw_overlap": 0.5147, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.3626, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4052, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8065, + "tai": 0.0316, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.5836, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4617, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6979, + "tai": 0.0396, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.9987, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5698, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4617, + "tai": 0.0925, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 1.8084, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6972, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1555, + "tai": 0.363, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 2.6739, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6736, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0368, + "tai": 0.4956, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "resnet50", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "resnet50", + "reference_name": "resnet101", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.1057, + "s_local": 0.3194, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.0462, + "s_local": 0.3197, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.8477, + "s_local": 0.3198, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.3236, + "s_local": 0.3202, + "tau": 0.9843, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.6871, + "s_local": 0.317, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.9988, + "s_local": 0.3037, + "tau": 0.9888, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet101", + "reference_name": "resnet50", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.5948, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "tau": 0.5431, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.5094, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "tau": 0.6069, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.2593, + "s_local": 0.3193, + "tau": 0.572, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.6568, + "s_local": 0.3177, + "tau": 0.4741, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.9564, + "s_local": 0.3111, + "tau": 0.5595, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.2038, + "s_local": 0.2986, + "tau": 0.7375, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.3195, + "s_global": 0.7468, + "lambda_val": 0.4278, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "Inflated: CKA confounded by scale; local alignment not significant." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "resnet50", + "model_b_name": "resnet101", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.4883, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5428, + "tai": 0.2349, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.5478, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4954, + "tai": 0.3537, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.7463, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3523, + "tai": 0.4586, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 1.2704, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9843, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1682, + "tai": 0.5393, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 1.9069, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1058, + "tai": 0.5916, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "model_a": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b": "clip_vitl14", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "clip_vitb16", + "reference_name": "clip_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 6.8409, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "tau": 0.9405, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 6.7647, + "s_local": 0.2908, + "tau": 0.9339, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 6.5247, + "s_local": 0.292, + "tau": 0.9253, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 5.9455, + "s_local": 0.2848, + "tau": 0.8964, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.242, + "s_local": 0.2632, + "tau": 0.8118, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.459, + "s_local": 0.2208, + "tau": 0.7091, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "clip_vitl14", + "reference_name": "clip_vitb16", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 7.4424, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "tau": 0.4683, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 7.4123, + "s_local": 0.2908, + "tau": 0.4427, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.1609, + "s_local": 0.2909, + "tau": 0.4617, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 6.5562, + "s_local": 0.2884, + "tau": 0.6475, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.8432, + "s_local": 0.2762, + "tau": 0.7375, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.0513, + "s_local": 0.2477, + "tau": 0.7059, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2907, + "s_global": 0.7183, + "lambda_val": 0.4047, + "raw_overlap": 0.2921, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "Inflated: CKA confounded by scale; local alignment not significant." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b_name": "clip_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.6011, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9405, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4698, + "tai": 0.0695, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.6774, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9339, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5356, + "tai": 0.0607, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.9174, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9253, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5265, + "tai": 0.0815, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 1.4965, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8964, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3365, + "tai": 0.2044, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 2.2001, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8118, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1519, + "tai": 0.3311, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitl14", + "model_b": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "reference_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.9635, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "tau": 0.088, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.7532, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.1048, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.3523, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.0545, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.5638, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.029, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.7283, + "s_local": 0.0715, + "tau": 0.0401, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.8327, + "s_local": 0.0683, + "tau": 0.0784, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 6.5552, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "tau": 0.0173, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 6.462, + "s_local": 0.0725, + "tau": 0.0356, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 6.2432, + "s_local": 0.073, + "tau": 0.0283, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 5.7448, + "s_local": 0.0731, + "tau": 0.0323, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.168, + "s_local": 0.0696, + "tau": 0.0342, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.5391, + "s_local": 0.0626, + "tau": 0.0227, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0723, + "s_global": 0.1615, + "lambda_val": 0.4474, + "raw_overlap": 0.0741, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "model_b_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 2.4089, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.088, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0176, + "tai": 0.9228, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.1986, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1048, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0571, + "tai": 0.9106, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.7977, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0545, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.9482, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.0092, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.029, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.9729, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.1737, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0401, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0011, + "tai": 0.9493, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b": "resnet50", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "resnet50", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 7.7697, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.2532, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 7.6488, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.2471, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.3755, + "s_local": 0.2143, + "tau": 0.2272, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 6.717, + "s_local": 0.2123, + "tau": 0.253, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.931, + "s_local": 0.2023, + "tau": 0.4112, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.0835, + "s_local": 0.185, + "tau": 0.5903, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet50", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.1057, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.0462, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.8477, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.3236, + "s_local": 0.214, + "tau": 0.9894, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.6871, + "s_local": 0.212, + "tau": 0.8648, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.9988, + "s_local": 0.2044, + "tau": 0.8236, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2137, + "s_global": 0.6391, + "lambda_val": 0.3344, + "raw_overlap": 0.2153, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b_name": "resnet50", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.3352, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2532, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3908, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.4561, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2471, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3477, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.7294, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2272, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.1489, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.3879, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.253, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6614, + "tai": 0.4305, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.1739, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4112, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.2241, + "tai": 0.6517, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "clip_vitb16", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "reference_name": "clip_vitb16", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.6006, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "tau": 0.0448, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.3796, + "s_local": 0.2245, + "tau": 0.0351, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.9645, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "tau": 0.0262, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.1548, + "s_local": 0.222, + "tau": 0.0227, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.2893, + "s_local": 0.2127, + "tau": 0.0268, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.369, + "s_local": 0.202, + "tau": 0.0388, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "clip_vitb16", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 6.8409, + "s_local": 0.224, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 6.7647, + "s_local": 0.2242, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 6.5247, + "s_local": 0.2244, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 5.9455, + "s_local": 0.2212, + "tau": 0.8323, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.242, + "s_local": 0.2052, + "tau": 0.6559, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.459, + "s_local": 0.1688, + "tau": 0.528, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2241, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "lambda_val": 0.4587, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "null_mean": 0.0019, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b_name": "clip_vitb16", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 1.7598, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0448, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3956, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.5388, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0351, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.417, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.1237, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0262, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3577, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.3139, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0227, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8184, + "tai": 0.064, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.5515, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0268, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5208, + "tai": 0.2702, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 1.6488, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.1959, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 1.647, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "tau": 0.2023, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 1.6404, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.2072, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 1.617, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.1751, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 1.5787, + "s_local": 0.0258, + "tau": 0.139, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 1.5264, + "s_local": 0.0252, + "tau": 0.1175, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 7.7697, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.0024, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 7.6488, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "tau": 0.0024, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.3755, + "s_local": 0.0264, + "tau": 0.0024, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 6.717, + "s_local": 0.0263, + "tau": 0.0025, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.931, + "s_local": 0.0258, + "tau": 0.0026, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.0835, + "s_local": 0.0249, + "tau": 0.0026, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0265, + "s_global": 0.1539, + "lambda_val": 0.1724, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 6.1207, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1959, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0024, + "tai": 0.663, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.1225, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2023, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0023, + "tai": 0.6768, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.1291, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2072, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0023, + "tai": 0.6874, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.1525, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1751, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0022, + "tai": 0.6629, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.1908, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.139, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.002, + "tai": 0.6573, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Collapsed" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "reference_name": "resnet101", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 1.6488, + "s_local": 0.0302, + "tau": 0.2671, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 1.647, + "s_local": 0.0302, + "tau": 0.2805, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 1.6404, + "s_local": 0.0301, + "tau": 0.2933, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 1.617, + "s_local": 0.0301, + "tau": 0.2795, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 1.5787, + "s_local": 0.0296, + "tau": 0.2593, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 1.5264, + "s_local": 0.0287, + "tau": 0.2333, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet101", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.5948, + "s_local": 0.0302, + "tau": 0.0037, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.5094, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0038, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.2593, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0037, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.6568, + "s_local": 0.0305, + "tau": 0.0031, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.9564, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0028, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.2038, + "s_local": 0.0292, + "tau": 0.0028, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0302, + "s_global": 0.144, + "lambda_val": 0.2095, + "raw_overlap": 0.0321, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b_name": "resnet101", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 6.9452, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2671, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0037, + "tai": 0.7379, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.947, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2805, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0036, + "tai": 0.7522, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.9536, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2933, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0036, + "tai": 0.7669, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 6.977, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2795, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0033, + "tai": 0.7818, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Collapsed" + }, + { + "delta": 7.0153, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2593, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0029, + "tai": 0.8087, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Collapsed" + } + ] + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment_full.json b/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment_full.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c57aca0f136550b25a6b7545ffce119cecdee499 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/bitrate_experiment_full.json @@ -0,0 +1,1268 @@ +{ + "experiment": "Track B: Bitrate Sweep", + "config": { + "k": 10, + "n_permutations": 50, + "seed": 42, + "device": "cuda:0", + "n_pairs": 8 + }, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitl14", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.3627, + "s_local": 0.5137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 9.0057, + "s_local": 0.514, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.4584, + "s_local": 0.5133, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.4962, + "s_local": 0.4999, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.5239, + "s_local": 0.4605, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.5396, + "s_local": 0.4044, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.7616, + "s_local": 0.5137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 9.4075, + "s_local": 0.5135, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.8634, + "s_local": 0.5113, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.905, + "s_local": 0.4959, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.9405, + "s_local": 0.462, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.9646, + "s_local": 0.4146, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.5137, + "s_global": 0.6823, + "lambda_val": 0.7529, + "raw_overlap": 0.5147, + "null_mean": 0.0021, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.3988, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.7558, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.3031, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.2654, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1576, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 3.2377, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.9144, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "resnet50", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "resnet50", + "reference_name": "resnet101", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 10.363, + "s_local": 0.3194, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 10.1057, + "s_local": 0.3197, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 9.6217, + "s_local": 0.3198, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 8.7042, + "s_local": 0.3202, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 7.7545, + "s_local": 0.317, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.7991, + "s_local": 0.3037, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet101", + "reference_name": "resnet50", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 10.4752, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "tau": 0.1015, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 10.1962, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "tau": 0.2651, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 9.6932, + "s_local": 0.3193, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 8.7623, + "s_local": 0.3177, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 7.8079, + "s_local": 0.3111, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.847, + "s_local": 0.2986, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.3195, + "s_global": 0.7468, + "lambda_val": 0.4278, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "Inflated: CKA confounded by scale; local alignment not significant." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "resnet50", + "model_b_name": "resnet101", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.112, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1073, + "tai": 0.816, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.3693, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0963, + "tai": 0.9704, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.8533, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0778, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.7708, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0195, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.7205, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "model_a": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b": "clip_vitl14", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "clip_vitb16", + "reference_name": "clip_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.4655, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.2003, + "s_local": 0.2908, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.7053, + "s_local": 0.292, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 6.7916, + "s_local": 0.2848, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.8464, + "s_local": 0.2632, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.8846, + "s_local": 0.2208, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "clip_vitl14", + "reference_name": "clip_vitb16", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.9308, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.8035, + "s_local": 0.2908, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.305, + "s_local": 0.2909, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.3828, + "s_local": 0.2884, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.4354, + "s_local": 0.2762, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.4714, + "s_local": 0.2477, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2907, + "s_global": 0.7183, + "lambda_val": 0.4047, + "raw_overlap": 0.2921, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "Inflated: CKA confounded by scale; local alignment not significant." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b_name": "clip_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.4651, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3987, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 0.7304, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.4038, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 1.2254, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 1.0, + "tai": 0.3837, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 2.1391, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.902, + "tai": 0.4938, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "delta": 3.0843, + "tau_a_to_b": 1.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3763, + "tai": 0.5487, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitl14", + "model_b": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "reference_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.7616, + "s_local": 0.0722, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 9.4075, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.8634, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.905, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.9405, + "s_local": 0.0715, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.9646, + "s_local": 0.0683, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.3985, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 9.0829, + "s_local": 0.0725, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.5684, + "s_local": 0.073, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.6361, + "s_local": 0.0731, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.6864, + "s_local": 0.0697, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.7313, + "s_local": 0.0626, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0722, + "s_global": 0.1615, + "lambda_val": 0.4473, + "raw_overlap": 0.0741, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitl14", + "model_b_name": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.3632, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.0092, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.535, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.4933, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.4579, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b": "resnet50", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "resnet50", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.1664, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.8534, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.3512, + "s_local": 0.2143, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.4225, + "s_local": 0.2123, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.4597, + "s_local": 0.2024, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.4838, + "s_local": 0.185, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet50", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 10.363, + "s_local": 0.2138, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 10.1057, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 9.6217, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 8.7042, + "s_local": 0.214, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 7.7545, + "s_local": 0.212, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.7991, + "s_local": 0.2045, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2137, + "s_global": 0.6391, + "lambda_val": 0.3344, + "raw_overlap": 0.2153, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b_name": "resnet50", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 1.1965, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.5095, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.0116, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 2.9403, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.976, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 3.9031, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4466, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "clip_vitb16", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "reference_name": "clip_vitb16", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.3627, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 9.0057, + "s_local": 0.2245, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.4584, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.4962, + "s_local": 0.222, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.5239, + "s_local": 0.2126, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.5396, + "s_local": 0.202, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "clip_vitb16", + "reference_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 8.4655, + "s_local": 0.224, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.2003, + "s_local": 0.2242, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 7.7053, + "s_local": 0.2243, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 6.7916, + "s_local": 0.2212, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 5.8464, + "s_local": 0.2053, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.8846, + "s_local": 0.1688, + "tau": 1.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.2241, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "lambda_val": 0.4586, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b_name": "clip_vitb16", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 0.8972, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.5402, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.0071, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 0.9693, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "delta": 1.9416, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8671, + "tai": 0.528, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 6.9984, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 6.7933, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 6.4056, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 5.6351, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 4.8296, + "s_local": 0.0258, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.0489, + "s_local": 0.0252, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 9.1664, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 8.8534, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 8.3512, + "s_local": 0.0264, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 7.4225, + "s_local": 0.0263, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 6.4597, + "s_local": 0.0258, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 5.4838, + "s_local": 0.0249, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0265, + "s_global": 0.1539, + "lambda_val": 0.1724, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b_name": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 2.1679, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 2.373, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 2.7607, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 3.5312, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 4.3367, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Divergent" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "bitrate_sweep": { + "model_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "reference_name": "resnet101", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 6.9984, + "s_local": 0.0302, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 6.7933, + "s_local": 0.0302, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 6.4056, + "s_local": 0.0301, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 5.6351, + "s_local": 0.0301, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 4.8296, + "s_local": 0.0296, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 4.0489, + "s_local": 0.0287, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "bitrate_sweep_reverse": { + "model_name": "resnet101", + "reference_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "compression_method": "rank_reduction", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate": 10.4752, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.75, + "bitrate": 10.1962, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate": 9.6932, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate": 8.7623, + "s_local": 0.0306, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.125, + "bitrate": 7.8079, + "s_local": 0.0303, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + }, + { + "level": 0.0625, + "bitrate": 6.847, + "s_local": 0.0291, + "tau": 0.0, + "downstream_acc": null + } + ] + }, + "neighborhood_alignment": { + "s_local": 0.0302, + "s_global": 0.144, + "lambda_val": 0.2095, + "raw_overlap": 0.0321, + "null_mean": 0.002, + "interpretation": "No meaningful alignment (Collapsed or Divergent regime)." + }, + "transport_stress_test": { + "model_a_name": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b_name": "resnet101", + "points": [ + { + "delta": 3.4766, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 1.0, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 3.6817, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.75, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 4.0694, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.5, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 4.8399, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.25, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "delta": 5.6454, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "compression_level": 0.125, + "regime": "Divergent" + } + ] + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/causal_bitrate_verification.json b/data/experiments/causal_bitrate_verification.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0fefb1dc40f2b03fdb9e5fd0c26d57c4f4f126d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/causal_bitrate_verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,2334 @@ +{ + "metadata": { + "compression_levels": [ + 1.0, + 0.9, + 0.8, + 0.7, + 0.6, + 0.5, + 0.4, + 0.3, + 0.25, + 0.2, + 0.15, + 0.1, + 0.075, + 0.05, + 0.025 + ], + "k": 10, + "n_permutations": 100, + "seed": 42 + }, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 8.6006, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.3626, + "s_local": 0.5138, + "raw_overlap": 0.5147, + "tau": 0.4052, + "perf_linear": 0.07, + "perf_best": 0.1728, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 8.5341, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.4291, + "s_local": 0.5137, + "raw_overlap": 0.5147, + "tau": 0.4235, + "perf_linear": 0.0774, + "perf_best": 0.1827, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 8.4371, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.5261, + "s_local": 0.5147, + "raw_overlap": 0.5156, + "tau": 0.4507, + "perf_linear": 0.0898, + "perf_best": 0.1994, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 8.3134, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.6498, + "s_local": 0.5143, + "raw_overlap": 0.5152, + "tau": 0.4817, + "perf_linear": 0.1066, + "perf_best": 0.2212, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 8.1581, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.8051, + "s_local": 0.5135, + "raw_overlap": 0.5145, + "tau": 0.5203, + "perf_linear": 0.128, + "perf_best": 0.246, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.9645, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 0.9987, + "s_local": 0.5134, + "raw_overlap": 0.5143, + "tau": 0.5698, + "perf_linear": 0.1535, + "perf_best": 0.2694, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 7.7119, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 1.2514, + "s_local": 0.5101, + "raw_overlap": 0.5111, + "tau": 0.6249, + "perf_linear": 0.183, + "perf_best": 0.2928, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 7.3726, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 1.5906, + "s_local": 0.5041, + "raw_overlap": 0.5051, + "tau": 0.6746, + "perf_linear": 0.2135, + "perf_best": 0.3165, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 7.1548, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 1.8084, + "s_local": 0.5, + "raw_overlap": 0.501, + "tau": 0.6972, + "perf_linear": 0.2267, + "perf_best": 0.3252, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 6.8772, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 2.086, + "s_local": 0.4891, + "raw_overlap": 0.4902, + "tau": 0.7037, + "perf_linear": 0.2364, + "perf_best": 0.336, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.5202, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 2.443, + "s_local": 0.4731, + "raw_overlap": 0.4741, + "tau": 0.6916, + "perf_linear": 0.2371, + "perf_best": 0.3429, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 5.9854, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 2.9778, + "s_local": 0.4415, + "raw_overlap": 0.4427, + "tau": 0.6345, + "perf_linear": 0.2187, + "perf_best": 0.3447, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 5.6014, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 3.3618, + "s_local": 0.4201, + "raw_overlap": 0.4212, + "tau": 0.5663, + "perf_linear": 0.1932, + "perf_best": 0.3411, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 5.0503, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 3.9129, + "s_local": 0.3815, + "raw_overlap": 0.3827, + "tau": 0.4813, + "perf_linear": 0.1588, + "perf_best": 0.3298, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 4.0956, + "bitrate_b": 8.9632, + "delta": 4.8676, + "s_local": 0.3011, + "raw_overlap": 0.3025, + "tau": 0.3774, + "perf_linear": 0.1101, + "perf_best": 0.2918, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.5333, + "kappa": 0.7461, + "r0": 3.7822, + "r2_fit": 0.9958, + "r_crit": 3.7822, + "r_sat": 6.7272 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 1.107, + "kappa": 0.0, + "r0": 0.0, + "r2_fit": -0.0, + "r_crit": 0.0, + "r_sat": 2197224.5773 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8908, + "bic": -111.91, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.9466, + "bic": -122.63, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9958, + "bic": -158.22, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9466, + "bic": -119.92, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9958, + "null_mean": 0.0527, + "null_std": 0.1364, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.8409, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6011, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "raw_overlap": 0.2921, + "tau": 0.9405, + "perf_linear": 0.327, + "perf_best": 0.3477, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 6.8264, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6157, + "s_local": 0.2907, + "raw_overlap": 0.2921, + "tau": 0.9426, + "perf_linear": 0.3279, + "perf_best": 0.3478, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 6.7905, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6515, + "s_local": 0.2903, + "raw_overlap": 0.2917, + "tau": 0.9413, + "perf_linear": 0.3309, + "perf_best": 0.3516, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 6.7315, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.7106, + "s_local": 0.2915, + "raw_overlap": 0.2929, + "tau": 0.9346, + "perf_linear": 0.3365, + "perf_best": 0.3601, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 6.6455, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.7966, + "s_local": 0.2915, + "raw_overlap": 0.2929, + "tau": 0.9272, + "perf_linear": 0.3429, + "perf_best": 0.3699, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 6.5247, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.9174, + "s_local": 0.292, + "raw_overlap": 0.2934, + "tau": 0.9253, + "perf_linear": 0.3508, + "perf_best": 0.3791, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 6.3525, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.0896, + "s_local": 0.2906, + "raw_overlap": 0.292, + "tau": 0.9188, + "perf_linear": 0.359, + "perf_best": 0.3907, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 6.1083, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.3338, + "s_local": 0.288, + "raw_overlap": 0.2894, + "tau": 0.9113, + "perf_linear": 0.3635, + "perf_best": 0.3988, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 5.9455, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.4965, + "s_local": 0.2848, + "raw_overlap": 0.2862, + "tau": 0.8964, + "perf_linear": 0.3624, + "perf_best": 0.4042, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 5.7271, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.715, + "s_local": 0.2797, + "raw_overlap": 0.2812, + "tau": 0.878, + "perf_linear": 0.3573, + "perf_best": 0.4069, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 5.427, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.0151, + "s_local": 0.2706, + "raw_overlap": 0.272, + "tau": 0.8405, + "perf_linear": 0.3447, + "perf_best": 0.4101, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 4.9923, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.4497, + "s_local": 0.2513, + "raw_overlap": 0.2528, + "tau": 0.7739, + "perf_linear": 0.3148, + "perf_best": 0.4068, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 4.658, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.7841, + "s_local": 0.2331, + "raw_overlap": 0.2347, + "tau": 0.7298, + "perf_linear": 0.2905, + "perf_best": 0.398, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 4.1673, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 3.2748, + "s_local": 0.1998, + "raw_overlap": 0.2015, + "tau": 0.6774, + "perf_linear": 0.2549, + "perf_best": 0.3763, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 3.2845, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 4.1576, + "s_local": 0.1338, + "raw_overlap": 0.1356, + "tau": 0.5852, + "perf_linear": 0.187, + "perf_best": 0.3195, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.3008, + "kappa": 1.1112, + "r0": 3.5116, + "r2_fit": 0.9973, + "r_crit": 3.5116, + "r_sat": 5.4891 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 1.0966, + "kappa": 0.497, + "r0": 3.1133, + "r2_fit": 0.9891, + "r_crit": 3.1133, + "r_sat": 7.5346 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8822, + "bic": -120.6, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.9404, + "bic": -130.84, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9973, + "bic": -174.39, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9404, + "bic": -128.12, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9973, + "null_mean": 0.0616, + "null_std": 0.1623, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 8.1057, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.4883, + "s_local": 0.3194, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.0963, + "perf_best": 0.0822, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 8.0941, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.4999, + "s_local": 0.3194, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.0956, + "perf_best": 0.0794, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 8.0666, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.5275, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.0973, + "perf_best": 0.0762, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 8.0204, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.5736, + "s_local": 0.3195, + "raw_overlap": 0.3208, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.0987, + "perf_best": 0.0749, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 7.9502, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.6438, + "s_local": 0.3197, + "raw_overlap": 0.321, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.1014, + "perf_best": 0.0769, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.8477, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.7463, + "s_local": 0.3198, + "raw_overlap": 0.3211, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.1058, + "perf_best": 0.0863, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 7.6978, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 0.8962, + "s_local": 0.3204, + "raw_overlap": 0.3217, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.1144, + "perf_best": 0.1028, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 7.4759, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 1.1182, + "s_local": 0.3202, + "raw_overlap": 0.3215, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.1316, + "perf_best": 0.1304, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 7.3236, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 1.2704, + "s_local": 0.3202, + "raw_overlap": 0.3215, + "tau": 0.9843, + "perf_linear": 0.1444, + "perf_best": 0.1467, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 7.1252, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 1.4688, + "s_local": 0.3194, + "raw_overlap": 0.3207, + "tau": 0.97, + "perf_linear": 0.1625, + "perf_best": 0.1675, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.8601, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 1.7339, + "s_local": 0.3186, + "raw_overlap": 0.32, + "tau": 0.9906, + "perf_linear": 0.1845, + "perf_best": 0.1862, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 6.4659, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 2.1281, + "s_local": 0.3136, + "raw_overlap": 0.315, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.208, + "perf_best": 0.2058, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 6.1795, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 2.4145, + "s_local": 0.3083, + "raw_overlap": 0.3096, + "tau": 1.0, + "perf_linear": 0.2163, + "perf_best": 0.216, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 5.7653, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 2.8287, + "s_local": 0.2981, + "raw_overlap": 0.2995, + "tau": 0.9717, + "perf_linear": 0.2165, + "perf_best": 0.2228, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 5.0329, + "bitrate_b": 8.594, + "delta": 3.5611, + "s_local": 0.2678, + "raw_overlap": 0.2693, + "tau": 0.8317, + "perf_linear": 0.1929, + "perf_best": 0.232, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.3213, + "kappa": 1.4163, + "r0": 3.9041, + "r2_fit": 0.9935, + "r_crit": 3.9041, + "r_sat": 5.4555 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 1.441, + "kappa": 0.1064, + "r0": 0.0, + "r2_fit": 0.5102, + "r_crit": 0.0, + "r_sat": 20.6564 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.7186, + "bic": -142.56, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.778, + "bic": -146.11, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9935, + "bic": -196.4, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.7779, + "bic": -143.4, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9935, + "null_mean": 0.04, + "null_std": 0.096, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 8.9635, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 2.4089, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "raw_overlap": 0.0741, + "tau": 0.088, + "perf_linear": 0.0016, + "perf_best": 0.0187, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 8.8995, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 2.3449, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "raw_overlap": 0.0742, + "tau": 0.0959, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0173, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 8.8083, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 2.2537, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "raw_overlap": 0.0743, + "tau": 0.1071, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0157, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 8.6898, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 2.1352, + "s_local": 0.0726, + "raw_overlap": 0.0744, + "tau": 0.0995, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0168, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 8.541, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.9864, + "s_local": 0.0725, + "raw_overlap": 0.0744, + "tau": 0.072, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0235, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 8.3523, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.7977, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "raw_overlap": 0.0743, + "tau": 0.0545, + "perf_linear": 0.0017, + "perf_best": 0.0318, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 8.1055, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.5509, + "s_local": 0.0725, + "raw_overlap": 0.0744, + "tau": 0.0395, + "perf_linear": 0.0018, + "perf_best": 0.0464, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 7.7771, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.2225, + "s_local": 0.0723, + "raw_overlap": 0.0742, + "tau": 0.0319, + "perf_linear": 0.0021, + "perf_best": 0.0652, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 7.5638, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.0092, + "s_local": 0.0724, + "raw_overlap": 0.0743, + "tau": 0.029, + "perf_linear": 0.0021, + "perf_best": 0.0739, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 7.2937, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 0.7391, + "s_local": 0.0721, + "raw_overlap": 0.0739, + "tau": 0.0303, + "perf_linear": 0.0026, + "perf_best": 0.086, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.9465, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 0.3919, + "s_local": 0.072, + "raw_overlap": 0.0739, + "tau": 0.0341, + "perf_linear": 0.0032, + "perf_best": 0.0945, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 6.4444, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 0.1102, + "s_local": 0.0708, + "raw_overlap": 0.0727, + "tau": 0.0502, + "perf_linear": 0.0047, + "perf_best": 0.0931, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 6.0626, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 0.492, + "s_local": 0.0688, + "raw_overlap": 0.0706, + "tau": 0.0683, + "perf_linear": 0.0072, + "perf_best": 0.1048, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 5.5237, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 1.031, + "s_local": 0.0668, + "raw_overlap": 0.0686, + "tau": 0.107, + "perf_linear": 0.0126, + "perf_best": 0.118, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 4.5273, + "bitrate_b": 6.5546, + "delta": 2.0273, + "s_local": 0.0617, + "raw_overlap": 0.0636, + "tau": 0.2136, + "perf_linear": 0.0317, + "perf_best": 0.1484, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.1105, + "kappa": 0.0781, + "r0": 0.0, + "r2_fit": 0.7655, + "r_crit": 0.0, + "r_sat": 28.1191 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.1495, + "kappa": 0.0, + "r0": 12.2708, + "r2_fit": -0.0, + "r_crit": 12.2708, + "r_sat": 2197236.8481 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.7548, + "bic": -190.61, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.8337, + "bic": -196.43, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.7655, + "bic": -188.57, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.8336, + "bic": -193.72, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.7655, + "null_mean": 0.0366, + "null_std": 0.0818, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 7.7697, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.3352, + "s_local": 0.2137, + "raw_overlap": 0.2153, + "tau": 0.2532, + "perf_linear": 0.022, + "perf_best": 0.0867, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 7.7348, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.37, + "s_local": 0.2138, + "raw_overlap": 0.2154, + "tau": 0.2547, + "perf_linear": 0.0219, + "perf_best": 0.0859, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 7.6819, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.423, + "s_local": 0.2139, + "raw_overlap": 0.2155, + "tau": 0.2518, + "perf_linear": 0.022, + "perf_best": 0.0872, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 7.6091, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.4958, + "s_local": 0.2139, + "raw_overlap": 0.2155, + "tau": 0.2434, + "perf_linear": 0.0219, + "perf_best": 0.0901, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 7.5099, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.595, + "s_local": 0.2141, + "raw_overlap": 0.2156, + "tau": 0.2349, + "perf_linear": 0.0221, + "perf_best": 0.0943, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.3755, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.7294, + "s_local": 0.2143, + "raw_overlap": 0.2159, + "tau": 0.2272, + "perf_linear": 0.0227, + "perf_best": 0.0998, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 7.1838, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 0.921, + "s_local": 0.2135, + "raw_overlap": 0.2151, + "tau": 0.223, + "perf_linear": 0.0238, + "perf_best": 0.1069, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 6.9053, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 1.1996, + "s_local": 0.2131, + "raw_overlap": 0.2146, + "tau": 0.2346, + "perf_linear": 0.0268, + "perf_best": 0.1143, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 6.717, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 1.3879, + "s_local": 0.2123, + "raw_overlap": 0.2139, + "tau": 0.253, + "perf_linear": 0.03, + "perf_best": 0.1185, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 6.4691, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 1.6358, + "s_local": 0.2099, + "raw_overlap": 0.2115, + "tau": 0.2918, + "perf_linear": 0.0355, + "perf_best": 0.1216, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.1436, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 1.9613, + "s_local": 0.2053, + "raw_overlap": 0.2069, + "tau": 0.3617, + "perf_linear": 0.0447, + "perf_best": 0.1236, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 5.6508, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 2.4541, + "s_local": 0.1987, + "raw_overlap": 0.2003, + "tau": 0.4767, + "perf_linear": 0.0599, + "perf_best": 0.1256, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 5.2983, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 2.8066, + "s_local": 0.1907, + "raw_overlap": 0.1923, + "tau": 0.5571, + "perf_linear": 0.0709, + "perf_best": 0.1273, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 4.7904, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 3.3144, + "s_local": 0.1753, + "raw_overlap": 0.1769, + "tau": 0.6321, + "perf_linear": 0.0846, + "perf_best": 0.1339, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 3.9099, + "bitrate_b": 8.1049, + "delta": 4.1949, + "s_local": 0.1393, + "raw_overlap": 0.141, + "tau": 0.6139, + "perf_linear": 0.0908, + "perf_best": 0.148, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.2173, + "kappa": 1.0261, + "r0": 3.3571, + "r2_fit": 0.9978, + "r_crit": 3.3571, + "r_sat": 5.4985 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.6812, + "kappa": 0.0, + "r0": 12.9046, + "r2_fit": -0.0, + "r_crit": 12.9046, + "r_sat": 2197237.4819 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8227, + "bic": -137.73, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.8912, + "bic": -145.06, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9978, + "bic": -200.97, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.8912, + "bic": -142.34, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9978, + "null_mean": 0.0599, + "null_std": 0.1653, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 8.6006, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.7598, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "tau": 0.0448, + "perf_linear": 0.0079, + "perf_best": 0.1767, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 8.5341, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.6933, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "tau": 0.0435, + "perf_linear": 0.0077, + "perf_best": 0.1771, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 8.4371, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.5963, + "s_local": 0.2245, + "raw_overlap": 0.226, + "tau": 0.0385, + "perf_linear": 0.0074, + "perf_best": 0.1927, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 8.3134, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.4726, + "s_local": 0.2242, + "raw_overlap": 0.2257, + "tau": 0.0316, + "perf_linear": 0.0069, + "perf_best": 0.2196, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 8.1581, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.3173, + "s_local": 0.224, + "raw_overlap": 0.2255, + "tau": 0.0285, + "perf_linear": 0.0069, + "perf_best": 0.241, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.9645, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.1237, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "tau": 0.0262, + "perf_linear": 0.007, + "perf_best": 0.2682, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 7.7119, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.871, + "s_local": 0.2241, + "raw_overlap": 0.2256, + "tau": 0.0237, + "perf_linear": 0.007, + "perf_best": 0.2939, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 7.3726, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.5317, + "s_local": 0.2224, + "raw_overlap": 0.224, + "tau": 0.023, + "perf_linear": 0.0073, + "perf_best": 0.3172, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 7.1548, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.3139, + "s_local": 0.222, + "raw_overlap": 0.2235, + "tau": 0.0227, + "perf_linear": 0.0075, + "perf_best": 0.3322, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 6.8772, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.0363, + "s_local": 0.2203, + "raw_overlap": 0.2219, + "tau": 0.0235, + "perf_linear": 0.008, + "perf_best": 0.3395, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.5202, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.3207, + "s_local": 0.2162, + "raw_overlap": 0.2178, + "tau": 0.0252, + "perf_linear": 0.0088, + "perf_best": 0.3498, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 5.9854, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 0.8554, + "s_local": 0.2102, + "raw_overlap": 0.2117, + "tau": 0.029, + "perf_linear": 0.0103, + "perf_best": 0.3543, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 5.6014, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.2395, + "s_local": 0.2045, + "raw_overlap": 0.206, + "tau": 0.0355, + "perf_linear": 0.0126, + "perf_best": 0.3555, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 5.0503, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 1.7906, + "s_local": 0.195, + "raw_overlap": 0.1965, + "tau": 0.0476, + "perf_linear": 0.0168, + "perf_best": 0.3523, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 4.0956, + "bitrate_b": 6.8408, + "delta": 2.7453, + "s_local": 0.1684, + "raw_overlap": 0.17, + "tau": 0.1214, + "perf_linear": 0.04, + "perf_best": 0.3291, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.2274, + "kappa": 0.7982, + "r0": 2.7916, + "r2_fit": 0.9971, + "r_crit": 2.7916, + "r_sat": 5.5443 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.0753, + "kappa": 0.0, + "r0": 10.1058, + "r2_fit": -0.0, + "r_crit": 10.1058, + "r_sat": 2197234.6832 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8252, + "bic": -146.52, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.8984, + "bic": -154.66, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9971, + "bic": -205.21, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.8984, + "bic": -151.95, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9971, + "null_mean": 0.038, + "null_std": 0.0929, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 1.6488, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1207, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "tau": 0.1959, + "perf_linear": 0.0275, + "perf_best": 0.1402, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 1.6485, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1211, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "tau": 0.1969, + "perf_linear": 0.0274, + "perf_best": 0.1394, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 1.6476, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1219, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "tau": 0.2019, + "perf_linear": 0.0274, + "perf_best": 0.136, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 1.6462, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1233, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "tau": 0.2035, + "perf_linear": 0.0274, + "perf_best": 0.1348, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 1.6439, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1256, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0284, + "tau": 0.2101, + "perf_linear": 0.0274, + "perf_best": 0.1304, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 1.6404, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1291, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0284, + "tau": 0.2072, + "perf_linear": 0.0273, + "perf_best": 0.1318, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 1.6346, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1349, + "s_local": 0.0264, + "raw_overlap": 0.0284, + "tau": 0.2047, + "perf_linear": 0.0271, + "perf_best": 0.1322, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 1.6247, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1449, + "s_local": 0.0266, + "raw_overlap": 0.0285, + "tau": 0.1873, + "perf_linear": 0.0266, + "perf_best": 0.1422, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 1.617, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1525, + "s_local": 0.0265, + "raw_overlap": 0.0284, + "tau": 0.1751, + "perf_linear": 0.0263, + "perf_best": 0.1499, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 1.606, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1635, + "s_local": 0.0264, + "raw_overlap": 0.0283, + "tau": 0.163, + "perf_linear": 0.0256, + "perf_best": 0.1572, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 1.5899, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.1796, + "s_local": 0.0262, + "raw_overlap": 0.0281, + "tau": 0.1519, + "perf_linear": 0.0247, + "perf_best": 0.1623, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 1.5627, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.2068, + "s_local": 0.0255, + "raw_overlap": 0.0274, + "tau": 0.1335, + "perf_linear": 0.0228, + "perf_best": 0.171, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 1.5407, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.2288, + "s_local": 0.0254, + "raw_overlap": 0.0273, + "tau": 0.1239, + "perf_linear": 0.0214, + "perf_best": 0.1726, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 1.5058, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.2637, + "s_local": 0.0249, + "raw_overlap": 0.0268, + "tau": 0.1077, + "perf_linear": 0.0188, + "perf_best": 0.1748, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 1.4347, + "bitrate_b": 7.7695, + "delta": 6.3348, + "s_local": 0.0226, + "raw_overlap": 0.0246, + "tau": 0.0864, + "perf_linear": 0.0144, + "perf_best": 0.1662, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.0271, + "kappa": 10.5506, + "r0": 1.282, + "r2_fit": 0.9871, + "r_crit": 1.282, + "r_sat": 1.4903 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 1.0505, + "kappa": 5.2553, + "r0": 1.9189, + "r2_fit": 0.9679, + "r_crit": 1.9189, + "r_sat": 2.337 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.9057, + "bic": -236.32, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.9166, + "bic": -238.16, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9871, + "bic": -263.43, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9166, + "bic": -235.45, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9871, + "null_mean": 0.0635, + "null_std": 0.1843, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 7.7518, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.3029, + "s_local": 0.344, + "raw_overlap": 0.3453, + "tau": 0.0993, + "perf_linear": 0.022, + "perf_best": 0.2217, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 7.6896, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.3651, + "s_local": 0.3445, + "raw_overlap": 0.3458, + "tau": 0.1032, + "perf_linear": 0.0234, + "perf_best": 0.2272, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 7.5936, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.4611, + "s_local": 0.3444, + "raw_overlap": 0.3457, + "tau": 0.1114, + "perf_linear": 0.0262, + "perf_best": 0.2352, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 7.4657, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.589, + "s_local": 0.3446, + "raw_overlap": 0.3459, + "tau": 0.1254, + "perf_linear": 0.0309, + "perf_best": 0.2461, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 7.3078, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.7469, + "s_local": 0.3451, + "raw_overlap": 0.3464, + "tau": 0.1476, + "perf_linear": 0.0377, + "perf_best": 0.2554, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.1077, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 1.947, + "s_local": 0.3436, + "raw_overlap": 0.3449, + "tau": 0.1796, + "perf_linear": 0.0472, + "perf_best": 0.263, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 6.8412, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 2.2135, + "s_local": 0.3421, + "raw_overlap": 0.3434, + "tau": 0.2195, + "perf_linear": 0.0602, + "perf_best": 0.2742, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 6.4908, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 2.5639, + "s_local": 0.336, + "raw_overlap": 0.3373, + "tau": 0.2654, + "perf_linear": 0.0736, + "perf_best": 0.2775, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 6.2625, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 2.7922, + "s_local": 0.33, + "raw_overlap": 0.3313, + "tau": 0.2868, + "perf_linear": 0.0798, + "perf_best": 0.2783, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 5.9618, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 3.0929, + "s_local": 0.3232, + "raw_overlap": 0.3246, + "tau": 0.3067, + "perf_linear": 0.0859, + "perf_best": 0.2801, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 5.5854, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 3.4692, + "s_local": 0.3076, + "raw_overlap": 0.309, + "tau": 0.3129, + "perf_linear": 0.0865, + "perf_best": 0.2765, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 5.0447, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 4.01, + "s_local": 0.281, + "raw_overlap": 0.2825, + "tau": 0.2953, + "perf_linear": 0.0795, + "perf_best": 0.2693, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 4.6296, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 4.4251, + "s_local": 0.2556, + "raw_overlap": 0.2571, + "tau": 0.2782, + "perf_linear": 0.071, + "perf_best": 0.2552, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 4.0991, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 4.9556, + "s_local": 0.2217, + "raw_overlap": 0.2233, + "tau": 0.2571, + "perf_linear": 0.062, + "perf_best": 0.2413, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 3.0646, + "bitrate_b": 9.0547, + "delta": 5.9901, + "s_local": 0.1416, + "raw_overlap": 0.1433, + "tau": 0.242, + "perf_linear": 0.0448, + "perf_best": 0.1853, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.3553, + "kappa": 0.9115, + "r0": 3.5416, + "r2_fit": 0.9981, + "r_crit": 3.5416, + "r_sat": 5.9521 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.4307, + "kappa": 0.0, + "r0": 6.7808, + "r2_fit": -0.0, + "r_crit": 6.7808, + "r_sat": 2197231.3582 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8812, + "bic": -112.34, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.9511, + "bic": -125.67, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9981, + "bic": -171.85, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9511, + "bic": -122.95, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9981, + "null_mean": 0.0593, + "null_std": 0.1505, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.855, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.5871, + "s_local": 0.2455, + "raw_overlap": 0.247, + "tau": 0.8328, + "perf_linear": 0.249, + "perf_best": 0.2989, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 6.8406, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6015, + "s_local": 0.2457, + "raw_overlap": 0.2472, + "tau": 0.8404, + "perf_linear": 0.2502, + "perf_best": 0.2978, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 6.8044, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6377, + "s_local": 0.2456, + "raw_overlap": 0.2471, + "tau": 0.8332, + "perf_linear": 0.2539, + "perf_best": 0.3047, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 6.7427, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.6994, + "s_local": 0.2457, + "raw_overlap": 0.2472, + "tau": 0.8417, + "perf_linear": 0.2604, + "perf_best": 0.3093, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 6.6534, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.7887, + "s_local": 0.2461, + "raw_overlap": 0.2475, + "tau": 0.836, + "perf_linear": 0.2684, + "perf_best": 0.3211, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 6.5299, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 0.9122, + "s_local": 0.2456, + "raw_overlap": 0.2471, + "tau": 0.8405, + "perf_linear": 0.2778, + "perf_best": 0.3306, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 6.3554, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.0866, + "s_local": 0.2448, + "raw_overlap": 0.2463, + "tau": 0.8425, + "perf_linear": 0.2881, + "perf_best": 0.342, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 6.1103, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.3318, + "s_local": 0.2429, + "raw_overlap": 0.2444, + "tau": 0.8395, + "perf_linear": 0.2968, + "perf_best": 0.3535, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 5.9472, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.4949, + "s_local": 0.2396, + "raw_overlap": 0.2411, + "tau": 0.8349, + "perf_linear": 0.2989, + "perf_best": 0.3579, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 5.7291, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 1.7129, + "s_local": 0.234, + "raw_overlap": 0.2355, + "tau": 0.8219, + "perf_linear": 0.298, + "perf_best": 0.3626, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 5.431, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.011, + "s_local": 0.2268, + "raw_overlap": 0.2283, + "tau": 0.7866, + "perf_linear": 0.2894, + "perf_best": 0.3679, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 5.0012, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.4409, + "s_local": 0.2092, + "raw_overlap": 0.2108, + "tau": 0.7315, + "perf_linear": 0.2661, + "perf_best": 0.3638, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 4.6722, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 2.7699, + "s_local": 0.1934, + "raw_overlap": 0.195, + "tau": 0.6913, + "perf_linear": 0.2476, + "perf_best": 0.3582, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 4.1875, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 3.2546, + "s_local": 0.1667, + "raw_overlap": 0.1684, + "tau": 0.6341, + "perf_linear": 0.215, + "perf_best": 0.339, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 3.313, + "bitrate_b": 7.4421, + "delta": 4.1291, + "s_local": 0.1147, + "raw_overlap": 0.1164, + "tau": 0.5545, + "perf_linear": 0.1628, + "perf_best": 0.2936, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.2557, + "kappa": 1.0494, + "r0": 3.5441, + "r2_fit": 0.9967, + "r_crit": 3.5441, + "r_sat": 5.6378 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.9006, + "kappa": 0.6861, + "r0": 2.7424, + "r2_fit": 0.9666, + "r_crit": 2.7424, + "r_sat": 5.9447 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.8975, + "bic": -127.8, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.9503, + "bic": -138.67, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9967, + "bic": -176.5, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9503, + "bic": -135.96, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9967, + "null_mean": 0.0607, + "null_std": 0.1566, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "points": [ + { + "level": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 8.2416, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.1568, + "s_local": 0.4833, + "raw_overlap": 0.4843, + "tau": 0.771, + "perf_linear": 0.2806, + "perf_best": 0.3639, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.9, + "bitrate_a": 8.199, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.1994, + "s_local": 0.4831, + "raw_overlap": 0.4842, + "tau": 0.7867, + "perf_linear": 0.2878, + "perf_best": 0.3659, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.8, + "bitrate_a": 8.1339, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.2645, + "s_local": 0.4828, + "raw_overlap": 0.4838, + "tau": 0.8135, + "perf_linear": 0.2983, + "perf_best": 0.3667, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.7, + "bitrate_a": 8.0463, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.3521, + "s_local": 0.4819, + "raw_overlap": 0.4829, + "tau": 0.8292, + "perf_linear": 0.3107, + "perf_best": 0.3748, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.6, + "bitrate_a": 7.9328, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.4656, + "s_local": 0.4814, + "raw_overlap": 0.4824, + "tau": 0.8495, + "perf_linear": 0.3243, + "perf_best": 0.3818, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.5, + "bitrate_a": 7.7847, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.6138, + "s_local": 0.4801, + "raw_overlap": 0.4811, + "tau": 0.8629, + "perf_linear": 0.339, + "perf_best": 0.3929, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.4, + "bitrate_a": 7.5851, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 0.8133, + "s_local": 0.4767, + "raw_overlap": 0.4777, + "tau": 0.87, + "perf_linear": 0.3534, + "perf_best": 0.4063, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.3, + "bitrate_a": 7.3114, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 1.087, + "s_local": 0.4716, + "raw_overlap": 0.4726, + "tau": 0.8812, + "perf_linear": 0.3658, + "perf_best": 0.4152, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.25, + "bitrate_a": 7.1297, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 1.2687, + "s_local": 0.4673, + "raw_overlap": 0.4684, + "tau": 0.8727, + "perf_linear": 0.3689, + "perf_best": 0.4227, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.2, + "bitrate_a": 6.8957, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 1.5027, + "s_local": 0.459, + "raw_overlap": 0.46, + "tau": 0.865, + "perf_linear": 0.3692, + "perf_best": 0.4268, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.15, + "bitrate_a": 6.5888, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 1.8096, + "s_local": 0.4452, + "raw_overlap": 0.4463, + "tau": 0.8496, + "perf_linear": 0.3645, + "perf_best": 0.429, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.1, + "bitrate_a": 6.1366, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 2.2618, + "s_local": 0.4237, + "raw_overlap": 0.4249, + "tau": 0.8126, + "perf_linear": 0.3473, + "perf_best": 0.4274, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.075, + "bitrate_a": 5.7909, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 2.6075, + "s_local": 0.4027, + "raw_overlap": 0.4039, + "tau": 0.7659, + "perf_linear": 0.3245, + "perf_best": 0.4236, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.05, + "bitrate_a": 5.298, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 3.1004, + "s_local": 0.3729, + "raw_overlap": 0.3741, + "tau": 0.7, + "perf_linear": 0.2894, + "perf_best": 0.4135, + "converged": true + }, + { + "level": 0.025, + "bitrate_a": 4.3728, + "bitrate_b": 8.3984, + "delta": 4.0256, + "s_local": 0.3027, + "raw_overlap": 0.3041, + "tau": 0.5907, + "perf_linear": 0.2235, + "perf_best": 0.3783, + "converged": true + } + ], + "sigmoid_fit_alignment": { + "s_max": 0.5066, + "kappa": 0.7229, + "r0": 3.8503, + "r2_fit": 0.9977, + "r_crit": 3.8503, + "r_sat": 6.8898 + }, + "sigmoid_fit_transport": { + "s_max": 0.8458, + "kappa": 1.2646, + "r0": 3.7699, + "r2_fit": 0.786, + "r_crit": 3.7699, + "r_sat": 5.5074 + }, + "model_comparison": { + "linear": { + "r2": 0.9231, + "bic": -122.63, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "log": { + "r2": 0.964, + "bic": -134.0, + "n_params": 2 + }, + "sigmoid": { + "r2": 0.9977, + "bic": -172.52, + "n_params": 3 + }, + "power": { + "r2": 0.9639, + "bic": -131.29, + "n_params": 3 + } + }, + "permutation_null": { + "obs_r2": 0.9977, + "null_mean": 0.0546, + "null_std": 0.1414, + "p_value": 0.0, + "n_perms": 1000 + } + } + ], + "summary": { + "n_pairs": 10, + "n_successful_fits": 10, + "n_good_fits_r2_gt_0.5": 10, + "mean_r2_alignment": 0.9727, + "mean_r_crit": 2.9565, + "mean_r_sat": 7.6804 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/cross_modal_clip.json b/data/experiments/cross_modal_clip.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2826676f7e2686dc34d50e811e928574cb5d8367 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/cross_modal_clip.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "pairs": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb16_text", + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.0077, + "tau": 0.0, + "delta": 1.013, + "regime": "Divergent", + "cross_modal": true + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> clip_vitl14_text", + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.01, + "tau": 0.0, + "delta": 1.505, + "regime": "Divergent", + "cross_modal": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16_text", + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.017, + "tau": 0.0, + "delta": 2.772, + "regime": "Divergent", + "cross_modal": true + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> clip_vitb16_text", + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.0099, + "tau": 0.0, + "delta": 2.277, + "regime": "Divergent", + "cross_modal": true + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/external_scorecard_study.json b/data/experiments/external_scorecard_study.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b027b9e214d02843814c9fd3406fce89b8582e82 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/external_scorecard_study.json @@ -0,0 +1,325 @@ +{ + "description": "Scorecard case study on 5 external models x 3 anchors", + "anchors": [ + { + "key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "name": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "objective": "self-supervised" + }, + { + "key": "clip_vitl14", + "name": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "objective": "contrastive" + }, + { + "key": "resnet50", + "name": "ResNet-50", + "objective": "supervised" + } + ], + "external": [ + { + "key": "siglip_base_p16_224", + "name": "SigLIP-B/16", + "objective": "contrastive" + }, + { + "key": "convnextv2_base", + "name": "ConvNeXt-V2-B", + "objective": "supervised" + }, + { + "key": "eva02_base_p14_224", + "name": "EVA02-B/14", + "objective": "self-supervised" + }, + { + "key": "deit3_base_p16_224", + "name": "DeiT3-B/16", + "objective": "supervised" + }, + { + "key": "dinov2_reg_base", + "name": "DINOv2+reg-B", + "objective": "self-supervised" + } + ], + "results": [ + { + "external": "SigLIP-B/16", + "external_key": "siglip_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "contrastive", + "anchor": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "anchor_key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "anchor_objective": "self-supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 6.057, + "delta": 2.544, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.012, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0074, + "retention": 0.0091 + }, + { + "external": "SigLIP-B/16", + "external_key": "siglip_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "contrastive", + "anchor": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "anchor_key": "clip_vitl14", + "anchor_objective": "contrastive", + "bitrate_ext": 6.057, + "delta": 1.386, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.007, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0076, + "retention": 0.0106 + }, + { + "external": "SigLIP-B/16", + "external_key": "siglip_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "contrastive", + "anchor": "ResNet-50", + "anchor_key": "resnet50", + "anchor_objective": "supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 6.057, + "delta": 2.048, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.007, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.009, + "retention": 0.0175 + }, + { + "external": "ConvNeXt-V2-B", + "external_key": "convnextv2_base", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "anchor_key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "anchor_objective": "self-supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 8.181, + "delta": 0.419, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.029, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0082, + "retention": 0.0101 + }, + { + "external": "ConvNeXt-V2-B", + "external_key": "convnextv2_base", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "anchor_key": "clip_vitl14", + "anchor_objective": "contrastive", + "bitrate_ext": 8.181, + "delta": 0.739, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.016, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0096, + "retention": 0.0134 + }, + { + "external": "ConvNeXt-V2-B", + "external_key": "convnextv2_base", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "ResNet-50", + "anchor_key": "resnet50", + "anchor_objective": "supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 8.181, + "delta": 0.076, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.018, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.0084, + "retention": 0.0163 + }, + { + "external": "EVA02-B/14", + "external_key": "eva02_base_p14_224", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "anchor_key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "anchor_objective": "self-supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 7.537, + "delta": 1.064, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.024, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0074, + "retention": 0.0091 + }, + { + "external": "EVA02-B/14", + "external_key": "eva02_base_p14_224", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "anchor_key": "clip_vitl14", + "anchor_objective": "contrastive", + "bitrate_ext": 7.537, + "delta": 0.095, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.013, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0082, + "retention": 0.0115 + }, + { + "external": "EVA02-B/14", + "external_key": "eva02_base_p14_224", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "ResNet-50", + "anchor_key": "resnet50", + "anchor_objective": "supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 7.537, + "delta": 0.568, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.014, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.0078, + "retention": 0.0152 + }, + { + "external": "DeiT3-B/16", + "external_key": "deit3_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "anchor_key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "anchor_objective": "self-supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 7.457, + "delta": 1.144, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.02, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.007, + "retention": 0.0086 + }, + { + "external": "DeiT3-B/16", + "external_key": "deit3_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "anchor_key": "clip_vitl14", + "anchor_objective": "contrastive", + "bitrate_ext": 7.457, + "delta": 0.015, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.011, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0086, + "retention": 0.012 + }, + { + "external": "DeiT3-B/16", + "external_key": "deit3_base_p16_224", + "external_objective": "supervised", + "anchor": "ResNet-50", + "anchor_key": "resnet50", + "anchor_objective": "supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 7.457, + "delta": 0.648, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.012, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.0088, + "retention": 0.0171 + }, + { + "external": "DINOv2+reg-B", + "external_key": "dinov2_reg_base", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "DINOv2-ViT-B", + "anchor_key": "dinov2_vitb14", + "anchor_objective": "self-supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 8.553, + "delta": 0.048, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.038, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0078, + "retention": 0.0096 + }, + { + "external": "DINOv2+reg-B", + "external_key": "dinov2_reg_base", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "CLIP-ViT-L/14", + "anchor_key": "clip_vitl14", + "anchor_objective": "contrastive", + "bitrate_ext": 8.553, + "delta": 1.111, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.021, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0076, + "retention": 0.0106 + }, + { + "external": "DINOv2+reg-B", + "external_key": "dinov2_reg_base", + "external_objective": "self-supervised", + "anchor": "ResNet-50", + "anchor_key": "resnet50", + "anchor_objective": "supervised", + "bitrate_ext": 8.553, + "delta": 0.448, + "s_local": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.022, + "tau": 0.0, + "regime": "Divergent", + "knn_anchor": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.0078, + "retention": 0.0152 + } + ], + "summary": { + "n_pairs": 15, + "n_external_models": 5, + "n_anchor_models": 3, + "regime_distribution": { + "Divergent": 15 + }, + "mean_retention": 0.0124, + "spearman_tau_retention": { + "rho": NaN, + "p": NaN + }, + "spearman_slocal_retention": { + "rho": NaN, + "p": NaN + }, + "spearman_sglobal_retention": { + "rho": -0.427, + "p": 0.113 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/holdout_validation.json b/data/experiments/holdout_validation.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1af23f7799b19abdc607e4e656403c771c413d38 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/holdout_validation.json @@ -0,0 +1,776 @@ +{ + "description": "Held-out predictive validation of BCCT regime prediction", + "target": "tau >= 0.5 (Convergent)", + "lofo_cv": { + "objective_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.83, + "std_roc_auc": 0.105, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.223, + "mean_f1": 0.242, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.202, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.5108 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.316, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.0566, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 0.981, + "pr_auc": 0.333, + "f1": 0.5, + "precision": 0.333, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + 1.2657 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.397, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00297, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.684, + "pr_auc": 0.075, + "f1": 0.16, + "precision": 0.091, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + 2.2587 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.391, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.000804, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.5108 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.198, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.241, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.824, + "pr_auc": 0.25, + "f1": 0.4, + "precision": 0.25, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + 1.4219 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.662, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00203, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.832, + "pr_auc": 0.233, + "f1": 0.391, + "precision": 0.25, + "recall": 0.9, + "coef": [ + 1.8295 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.663, + "reg_spearman_p": 4.77e-17, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + }, + "cka_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.903, + "std_roc_auc": 0.066, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.642, + "mean_f1": 0.239, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.323, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 2.5355 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.36, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.0285, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 0.981, + "pr_auc": 0.5, + "f1": 0.333, + "precision": 0.2, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + 2.283 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.278, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.0419, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.806, + "pr_auc": 0.69, + "f1": 0.308, + "precision": 0.2, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + 3.1307 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.559, + "reg_spearman_p": 4.85e-07, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 2.3818 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.595, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.000104, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.941, + "pr_auc": 0.75, + "f1": 0.4, + "precision": 0.333, + "recall": 0.5, + "coef": [ + 2.6257 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.651, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00254, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.884, + "pr_auc": 0.63, + "f1": 0.391, + "precision": 0.25, + "recall": 0.9, + "coef": [ + 2.7684 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.684, + "reg_spearman_p": 2.13e-18, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + }, + "delta_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.832, + "std_roc_auc": 0.097, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.426, + "mean_f1": 0.135, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.232, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + -2.8877 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.153, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.366, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 1.0, + "pr_auc": 1.0, + "f1": 0.133, + "precision": 0.071, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + -2.5952 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.089, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.521, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.779, + "pr_auc": 0.159, + "f1": 0.133, + "precision": 0.074, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + -3.0666 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.569, + "reg_spearman_p": 2.69e-07, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + -1.8973 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.722, + "reg_spearman_p": 4.51e-07, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.765, + "pr_auc": 0.361, + "f1": 0.308, + "precision": 0.182, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + -3.3217 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.618, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00484, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.782, + "pr_auc": 0.185, + "f1": 0.238, + "precision": 0.135, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + -2.7354 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.682, + "reg_spearman_p": 2.8e-18, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + }, + "s_local_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.875, + "std_roc_auc": 0.075, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.497, + "mean_f1": 0.069, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.296, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.3229 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.388, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.0177, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 0.925, + "pr_auc": 0.2, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.4383 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.14, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.311, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.806, + "pr_auc": 0.525, + "f1": 0.114, + "precision": 0.062, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + 2.1796 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.571, + "reg_spearman_p": 2.44e-07, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.2963 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.662, + "reg_spearman_p": 7.94e-06, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.971, + "pr_auc": 0.833, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.7363 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.754, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00019, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.796, + "pr_auc": 0.43, + "f1": 0.298, + "precision": 0.189, + "recall": 0.7, + "coef": [ + 1.8401 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.587, + "reg_spearman_p": 7.36e-13, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + }, + "bcct_no_bitrate": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.892, + "std_roc_auc": 0.065, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.543, + "mean_f1": 0.191, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.25, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.0864, + -0.3012, + 0.4678, + 1.3436 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.02, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.906, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 0.981, + "pr_auc": 0.5, + "f1": 0.5, + "precision": 0.333, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + 0.8058, + -0.27, + 0.6607, + 1.3714 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.21, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.127, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.801, + "pr_auc": 0.579, + "f1": 0.267, + "precision": 0.167, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + 1.4942, + -0.6076, + 1.6003, + 1.4883 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.112, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.356, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.1063, + -0.317, + 0.5124, + 1.1949 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.195, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.248, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.912, + "pr_auc": 0.5, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 0.035, + 0.7223, + 0.676, + 0.9825 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.696, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.000923, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.874, + "pr_auc": 0.593, + "f1": 0.378, + "precision": 0.259, + "recall": 0.7, + "coef": [ + 0.4545, + 0.9375, + 0.6667, + 1.2856 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.696, + "reg_spearman_p": 3.08e-19, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + }, + "bcct_combined": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.888, + "std_roc_auc": 0.073, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.625, + "mean_f1": 0.191, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.214, + "n_folds": 6, + "n_valid_folds": 4, + "per_fold": [ + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.0681, + -0.2634, + -0.9543, + 0.4907, + 1.0436 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.036, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.832, + "held_out_family": "beit" + }, + { + "n_train": 136, + "n_test": 54, + "n_pos_train": 12, + "n_pos_test": 1, + "roc_auc": 1.0, + "pr_auc": 1.0, + "f1": 0.5, + "precision": 0.333, + "recall": 1.0, + "coef": [ + 0.8349, + -0.242, + -0.7918, + 0.6612, + 1.092 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.186, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.177, + "held_out_family": "clip" + }, + { + "n_train": 120, + "n_test": 70, + "n_pos_train": 10, + "n_pos_test": 3, + "roc_auc": 0.796, + "pr_auc": 0.524, + "f1": 0.267, + "precision": 0.167, + "recall": 0.667, + "coef": [ + 1.4336, + -0.6069, + -0.5048, + 1.5882, + 1.4716 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.13, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.283, + "held_out_family": "dinov2" + }, + { + "n_train": 153, + "n_test": 37, + "n_pos_train": 13, + "n_pos_test": 0, + "roc_auc": NaN, + "pr_auc": NaN, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 1.0302, + -0.2547, + -0.802, + 0.5577, + 0.8197 + ], + "reg_spearman": -0.473, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.00313, + "held_out_family": "mae" + }, + { + "n_train": 171, + "n_test": 19, + "n_pos_train": 11, + "n_pos_test": 2, + "roc_auc": 0.882, + "pr_auc": 0.417, + "f1": 0.0, + "precision": 0.0, + "recall": 0.0, + "coef": [ + 0.1473, + 0.6315, + -1.3101, + 0.6778, + 0.615 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.739, + "reg_spearman_p": 0.000304, + "held_out_family": "mlpmixer" + }, + { + "n_train": 66, + "n_test": 124, + "n_pos_train": 3, + "n_pos_test": 10, + "roc_auc": 0.875, + "pr_auc": 0.557, + "f1": 0.378, + "precision": 0.259, + "recall": 0.7, + "coef": [ + 0.4657, + 0.8773, + -0.8322, + 0.6888, + 1.0973 + ], + "reg_spearman": 0.736, + "reg_spearman_p": 2.24e-22, + "held_out_family": "supervised" + } + ] + } + }, + "random_stratified_cv": { + "objective_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.833, + "std_roc_auc": 0.039, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.184, + "mean_f1": 0.314, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.353, + "n_splits": 5 + }, + "cka_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.944, + "std_roc_auc": 0.04, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.628, + "mean_f1": 0.381, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.732, + "n_splits": 5 + }, + "delta_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.797, + "std_roc_auc": 0.056, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.215, + "mean_f1": 0.262, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.698, + "n_splits": 5 + }, + "s_local_only": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.883, + "std_roc_auc": 0.053, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.538, + "mean_f1": 0.351, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.672, + "n_splits": 5 + }, + "bcct_no_bitrate": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.891, + "std_roc_auc": 0.064, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.645, + "mean_f1": 0.372, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.717, + "n_splits": 5 + }, + "bcct_combined": { + "mean_roc_auc": 0.891, + "std_roc_auc": 0.044, + "mean_pr_auc": 0.517, + "mean_f1": 0.36, + "mean_reg_spearman": 0.743, + "n_splits": 5 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/knn_sensitivity.json b/data/experiments/knn_sensitivity.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35a8bb2cf9bf5598ea5c592bb9b21d68db46f71d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/knn_sensitivity.json @@ -0,0 +1,464 @@ +{ + "k_values": [ + 3, + 5, + 10, + 20, + 50, + 100 + ], + "n_pairs": 15, + "regime_stability": 0.9333, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.468, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.2109, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2428, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2907, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3381, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3783, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.3985, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.744, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.21, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2385, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2772, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3198, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3628, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.3908, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "tau": 0.5445, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.2516, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2773, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.3195, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3596, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.4033, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.4345, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.4073, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.4064, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.4478, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.5137, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.5763, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.6118, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.557, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.0995, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.2672, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.297, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.344, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3937, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.4372, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.4279, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.219, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.2164, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2505, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.302, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3539, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3919, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.391, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "tau": 0.8475, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.4646, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.5117, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.5692, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.6283, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.6683, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.6563, + "regime": "Convergent" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.3613, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.1828, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2083, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2376, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.2668, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3171, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.3589, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.0449, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.155, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.1826, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2241, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.2726, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.31, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.3196, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0024, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.0234, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.0238, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.0265, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.0311, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.0411, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.0529, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "tau": 0.1525, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.1419, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.1642, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.1933, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.2259, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.2589, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.277, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0297, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.1832, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2176, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2688, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3224, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3618, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.342, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet101", + "tau": 0.3092, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.229, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2583, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.3045, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3491, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3949, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.4167, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.179, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.1707, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.1923, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.2253, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.2628, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3037, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.3298, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50", + "tau": 0.4761, + "regimes": { + "3": { + "s_local": 0.235, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "5": { + "s_local": 0.2615, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "10": { + "s_local": 0.3, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "20": { + "s_local": 0.3377, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "50": { + "s_local": 0.3799, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + "100": { + "s_local": 0.4087, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/metric_ablation.json b/data/experiments/metric_ablation.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ac3f1e2bf0c4ea601cbc91091000c2948c33d3d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/metric_ablation.json @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +{ + "n_pairs": 10, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "tau_atlas": 0.468, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.327, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.9095, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.5886, + "cca_mean": 0.6522 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "tau_atlas": 0.5445, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0969, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.7059, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.5322, + "cca_mean": 0.9941 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau_atlas": 0.4073, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0701, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.5592, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.5149, + "cca_mean": 0.7564 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "tau_atlas": 0.8475, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.3942, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.7591, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.6265, + "cca_mean": 0.7126 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau_atlas": 0.0449, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0079, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.7826, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.4958, + "cca_mean": 0.7863 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau_atlas": 0.0024, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0274, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.5584, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.3794, + "cca_mean": 0.4586 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "tau_atlas": 0.2277, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0043, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.6273, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.4309, + "cca_mean": 0.7052 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "tau_atlas": 0.0099, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.2507, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.6024, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.5047, + "cca_mean": 0.6911 + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau_atlas": 0.179, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0462, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.6604, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.5005, + "cca_mean": 0.6745 + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau_atlas": 0.3716, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim": 0.0579, + "perf_linear_cosine": 0.6211, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist": 0.4959, + "cca_mean": 0.8218 + } + ], + "rank_correlations": { + "perf_linear_r2_perdim_vs_perf_linear_cosine": { + "kendall_tau": 0.2, + "spearman_rho": 0.2727 + }, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim_vs_perf_linear_procrustes_dist": { + "kendall_tau": 0.7778, + "spearman_rho": 0.9152 + }, + "perf_linear_r2_perdim_vs_cca_mean": { + "kendall_tau": 0.0222, + "spearman_rho": 0.0061 + }, + "perf_linear_cosine_vs_perf_linear_procrustes_dist": { + "kendall_tau": 0.3333, + "spearman_rho": 0.4788 + }, + "perf_linear_cosine_vs_cca_mean": { + "kendall_tau": 0.1111, + "spearman_rho": 0.1636 + }, + "perf_linear_procrustes_dist_vs_cca_mean": { + "kendall_tau": 0.1556, + "spearman_rho": 0.1758 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/mixed_effects_analysis.json b/data/experiments/mixed_effects_analysis.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..82b39146eab6930b06087210c956f9f8328ffa8d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/mixed_effects_analysis.json @@ -0,0 +1,219 @@ +{ + "description": "Mixed-effects, block bootstrap, and LOO analysis of BCCT vision atlas", + "source": "data/atlas.json", + "n_pairs": 190, + "n_models": 20, + "mixed_effects": { + "formula": "tau ~ delta + same_obj + same_fam + (1|model_node)", + "n_obs": 190, + "n_obs_duplicated": 380, + "n_groups": 20, + "aic": -505.12, + "bic": -481.48, + "log_likelihood": 258.56, + "fixed_effects": { + "intercept": { + "coef": 0.1461, + "std_err": 0.0138, + "z": 10.577, + "p_value": 3.8e-26, + "ci_95": [ + 0.119, + 0.1731 + ] + }, + "delta": { + "coef": -0.0337, + "std_err": 0.0044, + "z": -7.724, + "p_value": 1.13e-14, + "ci_95": [ + -0.0422, + -0.0251 + ] + }, + "same_obj": { + "coef": 0.0424, + "std_err": 0.0186, + "z": 2.279, + "p_value": 0.0227, + "ci_95": [ + 0.0059, + 0.0788 + ] + }, + "same_fam": { + "coef": 0.2013, + "std_err": 0.0237, + "z": 8.483, + "p_value": 2.2e-17, + "ci_95": [ + 0.1548, + 0.2479 + ] + } + }, + "random_effect_variance": 0.001383, + "lrt_for_delta": { + "chi2": 55.07, + "df": 1, + "p_value": 1.1628949457601319e-13, + "method": "likelihood_ratio", + "interpretation": "bitrate adds significant variance beyond family/objective" + } + }, + "block_bootstrap_all_pairs": { + "subset": "all_pairs", + "n_pairs": 190, + "n_bootstraps_valid": 2000, + "n_bootstraps_requested": 2000, + "median_rho": -0.7021, + "mean_rho": -0.684, + "ci_95": [ + -0.8169, + -0.4272 + ] + }, + "block_bootstrap_same_obj": { + "subset": "same_obj", + "n_pairs": 67, + "n_bootstraps_valid": 2000, + "n_bootstraps_requested": 2000, + "median_rho": -0.7096, + "mean_rho": -0.6697, + "ci_95": [ + -0.8698, + -0.2991 + ] + }, + "leave_one_out": { + "per_model": [ + { + "held_out": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7127, + "p_value": 8.17e-28 + }, + { + "held_out": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7333, + "p_value": 4.03e-30 + }, + { + "held_out": "clip_vitb16", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7211, + "p_value": 9.78e-29 + }, + { + "held_out": "clip_vitb32", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7227, + "p_value": 6.58e-29 + }, + { + "held_out": "clip_vitl14", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7564, + "p_value": 5.62e-33 + }, + { + "held_out": "convnext_base", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.6948, + "p_value": 5.67e-26 + }, + { + "held_out": "convnext_large", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.691, + "p_value": 1.34e-25 + }, + { + "held_out": "dinov2_vitb14", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7118, + "p_value": 1e-27 + }, + { + "held_out": "dinov2_vitg14", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7179, + "p_value": 2.2e-28 + }, + { + "held_out": "dinov2_vitl14", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7129, + "p_value": 7.77e-28 + }, + { + "held_out": "dinov2_vits14", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7473, + "p_value": 8.2e-32 + }, + { + "held_out": "efficientnet_b0", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.694, + "p_value": 6.7e-26 + }, + { + "held_out": "mixer_b16_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7175, + "p_value": 2.44e-28 + }, + { + "held_out": "resnet101", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7057, + "p_value": 4.43e-27 + }, + { + "held_out": "resnet50", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7148, + "p_value": 4.86e-28 + }, + { + "held_out": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.6946, + "p_value": 5.85e-26 + }, + { + "held_out": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7337, + "p_value": 3.61e-30 + }, + { + "held_out": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.6421, + "p_value": 2.98e-21 + }, + { + "held_out": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.7351, + "p_value": 2.47e-30 + }, + { + "held_out": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "n_pairs": 171, + "rho": -0.6544, + "p_value": 2.82e-22 + } + ], + "n_models": 20, + "rho_range": [ + -0.7564, + -0.6421 + ], + "rho_median": -0.7138 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/model_selection_utility.json b/data/experiments/model_selection_utility.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bfae927ef23157f5093789ce9376530eb48d2c6d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/model_selection_utility.json @@ -0,0 +1,1062 @@ +{ + "description": "Model selection utility: which metric best predicts stitching success?", + "per_target": [ + { + "target": "resnet50", + "acc_native": 0.5288, + "n_candidates": 19, + "best_source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "best_acc": 0.875, + "metric_correlations": { + "tau": { + "rho": -0.015, + "p": 0.9517 + }, + "s_global": { + "rho": 0.147, + "p": 0.5471 + }, + "s_local": { + "rho": 0.312, + "p": 0.1942 + }, + "delta": { + "rho": 0.298, + "p": 0.2149 + }, + "tau_top1_match": false, + "tau_top1_source": "resnet101", + "tau_top1_acc": 0.5922, + "s_global_top1_match": false, + "s_global_top1_source": "resnet101", + "s_global_top1_acc": 0.5922, + "s_local_top1_match": false, + "s_local_top1_source": "resnet101", + "s_local_top1_acc": 0.5922 + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "source": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.2277, + "s_global": 0.2377, + "delta": 2.239, + "s_local": 0.064, + "acc_stitched": 0.2834, + "retention": 0.5359 + }, + { + "source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.3556, + "s_global": 0.302, + "delta": 1.55, + "s_local": 0.086, + "acc_stitched": 0.4116, + "retention": 0.7784 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.1145, + "s_global": 0.5235, + "delta": 1.264, + "s_local": 0.164, + "acc_stitched": 0.6568, + "retention": 1.2421 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau": 0.1145, + "s_global": 0.5147, + "delta": 1.25, + "s_local": 0.168, + "acc_stitched": 0.6274, + "retention": 1.1865 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0961, + "s_global": 0.5379, + "delta": 0.663, + "s_local": 0.167, + "acc_stitched": 0.7454, + "retention": 1.4096 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_base", + "tau": 0.2342, + "s_global": 0.616, + "delta": 0.136, + "s_local": 0.232, + "acc_stitched": 0.7886, + "retention": 1.4913 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.2392, + "s_global": 0.6027, + "delta": 0.38, + "s_local": 0.23, + "acc_stitched": 0.7988, + "retention": 1.5106 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.1525, + "s_global": 0.4969, + "delta": 0.496, + "s_local": 0.193, + "acc_stitched": 0.8188, + "retention": 1.5484 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.3541, + "s_global": 0.3953, + "delta": 0.95, + "s_local": 0.166, + "acc_stitched": 0.875, + "retention": 1.6547 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.2237, + "s_global": 0.399, + "delta": 0.858, + "s_local": 0.171, + "acc_stitched": 0.8664, + "retention": 1.6384 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau": 0.0886, + "s_global": 0.5644, + "delta": 0.353, + "s_local": 0.225, + "acc_stitched": 0.7374, + "retention": 1.3945 + }, + { + "source": "efficientnet_b0", + "tau": 0.4761, + "s_global": 0.7025, + "delta": 0.124, + "s_local": 0.3, + "acc_stitched": 0.575, + "retention": 1.0874 + }, + { + "source": "mixer_b16_224", + "tau": 0.4262, + "s_global": 0.6738, + "delta": 0.068, + "s_local": 0.229, + "acc_stitched": 0.4764, + "retention": 0.9009 + }, + { + "source": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.5445, + "s_global": 0.7468, + "delta": 0.489, + "s_local": 0.319, + "acc_stitched": 0.5922, + "retention": 1.1199 + }, + { + "source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.2863, + "s_global": 0.6064, + "delta": 0.294, + "s_local": 0.232, + "acc_stitched": 0.775, + "retention": 1.4656 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.2533, + "s_global": 0.6391, + "delta": 0.335, + "s_local": 0.214, + "acc_stitched": 0.679, + "retention": 1.284 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0038, + "s_global": 0.1715, + "delta": 6.456, + "s_local": 0.036, + "acc_stitched": 0.4438, + "retention": 0.8393 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.2387, + "s_global": 0.5715, + "delta": 0.444, + "s_local": 0.189, + "acc_stitched": 0.8046, + "retention": 1.5216 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.2724, + "delta": 3.206, + "s_local": 0.118, + "acc_stitched": 0.5162, + "retention": 0.9762 + } + ] + }, + { + "target": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "acc_native": 0.7008, + "n_candidates": 19, + "best_source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "best_acc": 0.8906, + "metric_correlations": { + "tau": { + "rho": 0.468, + "p": 0.04309 + }, + "s_global": { + "rho": 0.323, + "p": 0.1777 + }, + "s_local": { + "rho": 0.73, + "p": 0.0003898 + }, + "delta": { + "rho": 0.211, + "p": 0.387 + }, + "tau_top1_match": false, + "tau_top1_source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau_top1_acc": 0.7832, + "s_global_top1_match": false, + "s_global_top1_source": "convnext_base", + "s_global_top1_acc": 0.794, + "s_local_top1_match": false, + "s_local_top1_source": "convnext_base", + "s_local_top1_acc": 0.794 + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "source": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0175, + "s_global": 0.2282, + "delta": 1.904, + "s_local": 0.061, + "acc_stitched": 0.3302, + "retention": 0.4712 + }, + { + "source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.039, + "s_global": 0.3026, + "delta": 1.215, + "s_local": 0.102, + "acc_stitched": 0.4514, + "retention": 0.6441 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.0185, + "s_global": 0.5252, + "delta": 0.929, + "s_local": 0.193, + "acc_stitched": 0.6832, + "retention": 0.9749 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau": 0.0082, + "s_global": 0.4984, + "delta": 0.915, + "s_local": 0.18, + "acc_stitched": 0.6476, + "retention": 0.9241 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0051, + "s_global": 0.5553, + "delta": 0.327, + "s_local": 0.217, + "acc_stitched": 0.7606, + "retention": 1.0853 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_base", + "tau": 0.4549, + "s_global": 0.6964, + "delta": 0.472, + "s_local": 0.336, + "acc_stitched": 0.794, + "retention": 1.133 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.5269, + "s_global": 0.6845, + "delta": 0.715, + "s_local": 0.333, + "acc_stitched": 0.8116, + "retention": 1.1581 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.1219, + "s_global": 0.558, + "delta": 0.831, + "s_local": 0.287, + "acc_stitched": 0.8292, + "retention": 1.1832 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.2689, + "s_global": 0.4728, + "delta": 1.285, + "s_local": 0.253, + "acc_stitched": 0.8906, + "retention": 1.2708 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.3037, + "s_global": 0.4764, + "delta": 1.194, + "s_local": 0.258, + "acc_stitched": 0.8764, + "retention": 1.2506 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau": 0.0685, + "s_global": 0.5833, + "delta": 0.018, + "s_local": 0.29, + "acc_stitched": 0.7508, + "retention": 1.0713 + }, + { + "source": "efficientnet_b0", + "tau": 0.3528, + "s_global": 0.5973, + "delta": 0.459, + "s_local": 0.237, + "acc_stitched": 0.593, + "retention": 0.8462 + }, + { + "source": "mixer_b16_224", + "tau": 0.179, + "s_global": 0.6675, + "delta": 0.268, + "s_local": 0.225, + "acc_stitched": 0.5286, + "retention": 0.7543 + }, + { + "source": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.3564, + "s_global": 0.6843, + "delta": 0.824, + "s_local": 0.259, + "acc_stitched": 0.6294, + "retention": 0.8981 + }, + { + "source": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.2533, + "s_global": 0.6391, + "delta": 0.335, + "s_local": 0.214, + "acc_stitched": 0.573, + "retention": 0.8176 + }, + { + "source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.5442, + "s_global": 0.6761, + "delta": 0.629, + "s_local": 0.335, + "acc_stitched": 0.7832, + "retention": 1.1176 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0024, + "s_global": 0.1539, + "delta": 6.121, + "s_local": 0.027, + "acc_stitched": 0.4598, + "retention": 0.6561 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.219, + "s_global": 0.6639, + "delta": 0.108, + "s_local": 0.302, + "acc_stitched": 0.8146, + "retention": 1.1624 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.2167, + "delta": 2.871, + "s_local": 0.096, + "acc_stitched": 0.574, + "retention": 0.8191 + } + ] + }, + { + "target": "clip_vitb16", + "acc_native": 0.6906, + "n_candidates": 19, + "best_source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "best_acc": 0.8882, + "metric_correlations": { + "tau": { + "rho": 0.119, + "p": 0.6266 + }, + "s_global": { + "rho": 0.337, + "p": 0.1585 + }, + "s_local": { + "rho": 0.699, + "p": 0.0008781 + }, + "delta": { + "rho": -0.272, + "p": 0.2601 + }, + "tau_top1_match": false, + "tau_top1_source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau_top1_acc": 0.6534, + "s_global_top1_match": false, + "s_global_top1_source": "clip_vitl14", + "s_global_top1_acc": 0.7646, + "s_local_top1_match": false, + "s_local_top1_source": "clip_vitl14", + "s_local_top1_acc": 0.7646 + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "source": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.041, + "s_global": 0.1565, + "delta": 0.975, + "s_local": 0.046, + "acc_stitched": 0.3284, + "retention": 0.4755 + }, + { + "source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0353, + "s_global": 0.1999, + "delta": 0.286, + "s_local": 0.069, + "acc_stitched": 0.4516, + "retention": 0.6539 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau": 0.744, + "s_global": 0.7132, + "delta": 0.014, + "s_local": 0.277, + "acc_stitched": 0.6534, + "retention": 0.9461 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.468, + "s_global": 0.7183, + "delta": 0.601, + "s_local": 0.291, + "acc_stitched": 0.7646, + "retention": 1.1072 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_base", + "tau": 0.0261, + "s_global": 0.5483, + "delta": 1.4, + "s_local": 0.225, + "acc_stitched": 0.7892, + "retention": 1.1428 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.024, + "s_global": 0.5338, + "delta": 1.644, + "s_local": 0.229, + "acc_stitched": 0.8104, + "retention": 1.1735 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.0449, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "delta": 1.76, + "s_local": 0.224, + "acc_stitched": 0.829, + "retention": 1.2004 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.1047, + "s_global": 0.4103, + "delta": 2.214, + "s_local": 0.198, + "acc_stitched": 0.8882, + "retention": 1.2861 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0941, + "s_global": 0.4092, + "delta": 2.122, + "s_local": 0.202, + "acc_stitched": 0.8754, + "retention": 1.2676 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau": 0.0164, + "s_global": 0.5223, + "delta": 0.911, + "s_local": 0.23, + "acc_stitched": 0.7454, + "retention": 1.0794 + }, + { + "source": "efficientnet_b0", + "tau": 0.0845, + "s_global": 0.4978, + "delta": 1.388, + "s_local": 0.175, + "acc_stitched": 0.5948, + "retention": 0.8613 + }, + { + "source": "mixer_b16_224", + "tau": 0.0726, + "s_global": 0.478, + "delta": 1.196, + "s_local": 0.146, + "acc_stitched": 0.5248, + "retention": 0.7599 + }, + { + "source": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.0775, + "s_global": 0.5628, + "delta": 1.753, + "s_local": 0.183, + "acc_stitched": 0.6224, + "retention": 0.9012 + }, + { + "source": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.1145, + "s_global": 0.5235, + "delta": 1.264, + "s_local": 0.164, + "acc_stitched": 0.5654, + "retention": 0.8187 + }, + { + "source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.0404, + "s_global": 0.5673, + "delta": 1.558, + "s_local": 0.231, + "acc_stitched": 0.7848, + "retention": 1.1364 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0185, + "s_global": 0.5252, + "delta": 0.929, + "s_local": 0.193, + "acc_stitched": 0.6942, + "retention": 1.0052 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.003, + "s_global": 0.1245, + "delta": 5.192, + "s_local": 0.025, + "acc_stitched": 0.4618, + "retention": 0.6687 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0095, + "s_global": 0.5175, + "delta": 0.82, + "s_local": 0.202, + "acc_stitched": 0.817, + "retention": 1.183 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0004, + "s_global": 0.1912, + "delta": 1.942, + "s_local": 0.092, + "acc_stitched": 0.5742, + "retention": 0.8315 + } + ] + }, + { + "target": "dinov2_vitb14", + "acc_native": 0.8292, + "n_candidates": 19, + "best_source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "best_acc": 0.8928, + "metric_correlations": { + "tau": { + "rho": 0.596, + "p": 0.007023 + }, + "s_global": { + "rho": 0.872, + "p": 1.15e-06 + }, + "s_local": { + "rho": 0.944, + "p": 1.254e-09 + }, + "delta": { + "rho": 0.565, + "p": 0.01173 + }, + "tau_top1_match": false, + "tau_top1_source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau_top1_acc": 0.762, + "s_global_top1_match": false, + "s_global_top1_source": "dinov2_vits14", + "s_global_top1_acc": 0.762, + "s_local_top1_match": false, + "s_local_top1_source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "s_local_top1_acc": 0.8742 + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "source": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0417, + "s_global": 0.1373, + "delta": 2.735, + "s_local": 0.046, + "acc_stitched": 0.3276, + "retention": 0.3951 + }, + { + "source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0446, + "s_global": 0.1889, + "delta": 2.046, + "s_local": 0.08, + "acc_stitched": 0.4522, + "retention": 0.5453 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.0449, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "delta": 1.76, + "s_local": 0.224, + "acc_stitched": 0.6794, + "retention": 0.8193 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau": 0.0308, + "s_global": 0.4568, + "delta": 1.746, + "s_local": 0.197, + "acc_stitched": 0.6474, + "retention": 0.7808 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0121, + "s_global": 0.5503, + "delta": 1.158, + "s_local": 0.287, + "acc_stitched": 0.764, + "retention": 0.9214 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_base", + "tau": 0.2182, + "s_global": 0.6692, + "delta": 0.359, + "s_local": 0.41, + "acc_stitched": 0.7972, + "retention": 0.9614 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.1975, + "s_global": 0.6637, + "delta": 0.116, + "s_local": 0.416, + "acc_stitched": 0.8128, + "retention": 0.9802 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.355, + "s_global": 0.6713, + "delta": 0.454, + "s_local": 0.479, + "acc_stitched": 0.8928, + "retention": 1.0767 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.4073, + "s_global": 0.6823, + "delta": 0.363, + "s_local": 0.514, + "acc_stitched": 0.8742, + "retention": 1.0543 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau": 0.5372, + "s_global": 0.7086, + "delta": 0.849, + "s_local": 0.461, + "acc_stitched": 0.762, + "retention": 0.919 + }, + { + "source": "efficientnet_b0", + "tau": 0.1618, + "s_global": 0.5169, + "delta": 0.372, + "s_local": 0.22, + "acc_stitched": 0.5942, + "retention": 0.7166 + }, + { + "source": "mixer_b16_224", + "tau": 0.0878, + "s_global": 0.4627, + "delta": 0.563, + "s_local": 0.176, + "acc_stitched": 0.528, + "retention": 0.6368 + }, + { + "source": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.2055, + "s_global": 0.5659, + "delta": 0.006, + "s_local": 0.245, + "acc_stitched": 0.6366, + "retention": 0.7677 + }, + { + "source": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.1525, + "s_global": 0.4969, + "delta": 0.496, + "s_local": 0.193, + "acc_stitched": 0.5738, + "retention": 0.692 + }, + { + "source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.0816, + "s_global": 0.6451, + "delta": 0.202, + "s_local": 0.392, + "acc_stitched": 0.7838, + "retention": 0.9452 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.1219, + "s_global": 0.558, + "delta": 0.831, + "s_local": 0.287, + "acc_stitched": 0.6968, + "retention": 0.8403 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0038, + "s_global": 0.1168, + "delta": 6.952, + "s_local": 0.022, + "acc_stitched": 0.4648, + "retention": 0.5605 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.1323, + "s_global": 0.5783, + "delta": 0.939, + "s_local": 0.374, + "acc_stitched": 0.8186, + "retention": 0.9872 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.1754, + "delta": 3.702, + "s_local": 0.086, + "acc_stitched": 0.5656, + "retention": 0.6821 + } + ] + }, + { + "target": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "acc_native": 0.3356, + "n_candidates": 19, + "best_source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "best_acc": 0.8894, + "metric_correlations": { + "tau": { + "rho": -0.419, + "p": 0.07379 + }, + "s_global": { + "rho": -0.754, + "p": 0.0001901 + }, + "s_local": { + "rho": -0.714, + "p": 0.0006018 + }, + "delta": { + "rho": -0.396, + "p": 0.09283 + }, + "tau_top1_match": false, + "tau_top1_source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau_top1_acc": 0.4532, + "s_global_top1_match": false, + "s_global_top1_source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "s_global_top1_acc": 0.4532, + "s_local_top1_match": false, + "s_local_top1_source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "s_local_top1_acc": 0.4532 + }, + "candidates": [ + { + "source": "beit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.3613, + "s_global": 0.7855, + "delta": 0.689, + "s_local": 0.238, + "acc_stitched": 0.4532, + "retention": 1.3504 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.041, + "s_global": 0.1565, + "delta": 0.975, + "s_local": 0.046, + "acc_stitched": 0.6758, + "retention": 2.0137 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitb32", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.1798, + "delta": 0.989, + "s_local": 0.048, + "acc_stitched": 0.6444, + "retention": 1.9201 + }, + { + "source": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.1683, + "delta": 1.576, + "s_local": 0.046, + "acc_stitched": 0.7666, + "retention": 2.2843 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_base", + "tau": 0.0213, + "s_global": 0.1636, + "delta": 2.375, + "s_local": 0.051, + "acc_stitched": 0.7956, + "retention": 2.3707 + }, + { + "source": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.0159, + "s_global": 0.1601, + "delta": 2.619, + "s_local": 0.052, + "acc_stitched": 0.8078, + "retention": 2.407 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.0417, + "s_global": 0.1373, + "delta": 2.735, + "s_local": 0.046, + "acc_stitched": 0.827, + "retention": 2.4642 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitg14", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.1181, + "delta": 3.189, + "s_local": 0.042, + "acc_stitched": 0.8894, + "retention": 2.6502 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.1182, + "delta": 3.097, + "s_local": 0.042, + "acc_stitched": 0.8792, + "retention": 2.6198 + }, + { + "source": "dinov2_vits14", + "tau": 0.015, + "s_global": 0.1682, + "delta": 1.886, + "s_local": 0.052, + "acc_stitched": 0.7584, + "retention": 2.2598 + }, + { + "source": "efficientnet_b0", + "tau": 0.0583, + "s_global": 0.2009, + "delta": 2.363, + "s_local": 0.063, + "acc_stitched": 0.5842, + "retention": 1.7408 + }, + { + "source": "mixer_b16_224", + "tau": 0.0416, + "s_global": 0.2191, + "delta": 2.172, + "s_local": 0.062, + "acc_stitched": 0.524, + "retention": 1.5614 + }, + { + "source": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.0812, + "s_global": 0.1919, + "delta": 2.728, + "s_local": 0.058, + "acc_stitched": 0.6306, + "retention": 1.879 + }, + { + "source": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.2277, + "s_global": 0.2377, + "delta": 2.239, + "s_local": 0.064, + "acc_stitched": 0.561, + "retention": 1.6716 + }, + { + "source": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.0269, + "s_global": 0.1723, + "delta": 2.533, + "s_local": 0.054, + "acc_stitched": 0.7854, + "retention": 2.3403 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0175, + "s_global": 0.2282, + "delta": 1.904, + "s_local": 0.061, + "acc_stitched": 0.6962, + "retention": 2.0745 + }, + { + "source": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0037, + "s_global": 0.1656, + "delta": 4.217, + "s_local": 0.05, + "acc_stitched": 0.4624, + "retention": 1.3778 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0133, + "s_global": 0.1782, + "delta": 1.795, + "s_local": 0.05, + "acc_stitched": 0.8132, + "retention": 2.4231 + }, + { + "source": "vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "tau": 0.0, + "s_global": 0.6358, + "delta": 0.967, + "s_local": 0.109, + "acc_stitched": 0.574, + "retention": 1.7104 + } + ] + } + ], + "aggregated": { + "tau": { + "mean_rho": 0.15, + "std_rho": 0.361, + "n_targets": 5 + }, + "s_global": { + "mean_rho": 0.185, + "std_rho": 0.529, + "n_targets": 5 + }, + "s_local": { + "mean_rho": 0.394, + "std_rho": 0.59, + "n_targets": 5 + }, + "delta": { + "mean_rho": 0.081, + "std_rho": 0.361, + "n_targets": 5 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/p1_threshold.json b/data/experiments/p1_threshold.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..88d452fb67f45fce6d979ad3c3d8d6d5ea54cbfb --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/p1_threshold.json @@ -0,0 +1,2928 @@ +{ + "metadata": { + "atlas_path": "data/atlas.json", + "causal_path": "data/experiments/causal_bitrate_verification.json" + }, + "points": [ + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.689, + "tau": 0.3613, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 6.555, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11745652915103989, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.975, + "tau": 0.041, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 6.841, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16621206955335835, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.989, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 6.855, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16859870439822708, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.576, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 7.442, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.26866689396522336, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.375, + "tau": 0.0213, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.241, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.40487555404023184, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.619, + "tau": 0.0159, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.44647118990794415, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.735, + "tau": 0.0417, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.46624616433685645, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.189, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5436413228775998, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.097, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5279577224684624, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.886, + "tau": 0.015, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.32151380838731675, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.363, + "tau": 0.0583, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.4028298670303444, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.172, + "tau": 0.0416, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.37026934878963524, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.728, + "tau": 0.0812, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.46505284691442217, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.239, + "tau": 0.2277, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.381691101261507, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.533, + "tau": 0.0269, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.43181043300375044, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.904, + "tau": 0.0175, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.324582338902148, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 4.217, + "tau": 0.0037, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 2.5573074590661005, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.795, + "tau": 0.0133, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 5.866, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.30600068189567, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.967, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 5.866, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.19742752143732137, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.286, + "tau": 0.0353, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 6.841, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04363081617086194, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb32", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.3, + "tau": 0.0338, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 6.855, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04576659038901602, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.887, + "tau": 0.0596, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 7.442, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1353165522501907, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_base", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.687, + "tau": 0.025, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.241, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2573607932875668, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.93, + "tau": 0.0196, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2944317315026697, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.046, + "tau": 0.0446, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.31212814645308923, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.5, + "tau": 0.0855, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.38138825324180015, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.409, + "tau": 0.0159, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3675057208237986, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.197, + "tau": 0.0197, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.18260869565217394, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.674, + "tau": 0.0874, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2553775743707094, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.483, + "tau": 0.078, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.22623951182303587, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.039, + "tau": 0.1236, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3110602593440122, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.55, + "tau": 0.3556, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2364607170099161, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.844, + "tau": 0.0323, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.28131197559115184, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.215, + "tau": 0.039, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1853546910755149, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 4.906, + "tau": 0.0044, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 2.9751364463311094, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.106, + "tau": 0.0212, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 6.555, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16872616323417242, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.656, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 6.555, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.338097182523479, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.014, + "tau": 0.744, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 6.855, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.00204648443210057, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.601, + "tau": 0.468, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 7.442, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08785265312088876, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_base", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.4, + "tau": 0.0261, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.241, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.20464844321005699, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.644, + "tau": 0.024, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2403157433123812, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.76, + "tau": 0.0449, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2572723286069288, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.214, + "tau": 0.1047, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.32363689519076155, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.122, + "tau": 0.0941, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3101885689226721, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.911, + "tau": 0.0164, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1331676655459728, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.388, + "tau": 0.0845, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.20289431369682792, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.196, + "tau": 0.0726, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.174828241485163, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.753, + "tau": 0.0775, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2562490863908785, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.264, + "tau": 0.1145, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1847683087267943, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.558, + "tau": 0.0404, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2277444818009063, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.929, + "tau": 0.0185, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1357988598158164, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 5.192, + "tau": 0.003, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.1485748938750757, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.82, + "tau": 0.0095, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 6.841, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1198655167373191, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.942, + "tau": 0.0004, + "r_a": 6.841, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3964883625969784, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.587, + "tau": 0.3298, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 7.442, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08563092633114514, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_base", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.386, + "tau": 0.0145, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.241, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2021881838074398, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.63, + "tau": 0.0127, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.23778264040846095, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.746, + "tau": 0.0308, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2547045951859956, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.2, + "tau": 0.0754, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.32093362509117435, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.108, + "tau": 0.0715, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.30751276440554337, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.897, + "tau": 0.0099, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.13085339168490154, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.374, + "tau": 0.061, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.20043763676148796, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.182, + "tau": 0.0509, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1724288840262582, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.739, + "tau": 0.0698, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2536834427425237, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.25, + "tau": 0.1145, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1823486506199854, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.544, + "tau": 0.0284, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.22523705324580598, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.915, + "tau": 0.0082, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.13347921225382933, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 5.206, + "tau": 0.0032, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.1570648878107948, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.806, + "tau": 0.0049, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11757840991976659, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.956, + "tau": 0.0002, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3993466721110658, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.799, + "tau": 0.0091, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.241, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10736361193227627, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.042, + "tau": 0.009, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.14001612469766192, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.158, + "tau": 0.0121, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.15560333243751678, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.613, + "tau": 0.0449, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2167428110722924, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.521, + "tau": 0.0297, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.20438054286482127, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.31, + "tau": 0.0057, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.041655468959957, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.786, + "tau": 0.0434, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10561676968556839, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.595, + "tau": 0.0365, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07995162590701424, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.152, + "tau": 0.0539, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.15479709755442084, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.663, + "tau": 0.0961, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08908895458210159, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.956, + "tau": 0.0204, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12846009137328673, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.327, + "tau": 0.0051, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.043939801128728834, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 5.793, + "tau": 0.0032, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.5130382049727107, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.219, + "tau": 0.0046, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.442, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.02942757323300188, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.544, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 7.442, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5193956717027358, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.243, + "tau": 0.8475, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.485, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.029486712777575537, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.359, + "tau": 0.2182, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04356267443271448, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.814, + "tau": 0.3656, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0987744205800267, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.722, + "tau": 0.1342, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0876107268535372, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.489, + "tau": 0.2682, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06308049535603716, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.013, + "tau": 0.3044, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0015799708313077297, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.204, + "tau": 0.1651, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.025382605449794694, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.353, + "tau": 0.3092, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04283460745055212, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.136, + "tau": 0.2342, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.016779765576804443, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.157, + "tau": 0.7709, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.241, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.019051086033248392, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.472, + "tau": 0.4549, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06074646074646075, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.592, + "tau": 0.0028, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.997574287446937, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.58, + "tau": 0.1548, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07570813209763738, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.343, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.241, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6825234789710086, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.116, + "tau": 0.1975, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.6, + "r_min": 8.485, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.013671184443134945, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.57, + "tau": 0.1723, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 8.485, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06717737183264584, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.479, + "tau": 0.1338, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 8.485, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.05645256334708309, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.733, + "tau": 0.2375, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0945562435500516, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.256, + "tau": 0.269, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.031113271754982987, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.447, + "tau": 0.1455, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.055617767823814855, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.109, + "tau": 0.2889, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.485, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.012846199175014733, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.38, + "tau": 0.2392, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.046884639111659465, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.086, + "tau": 0.7538, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.398, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.010240533460347702, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.715, + "tau": 0.5269, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.09202059202059203, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.836, + "tau": 0.0027, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.145542753183748, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.824, + "tau": 0.2073, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10755776008354001, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.586, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.485, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.7321355655369539, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.454, + "tau": 0.355, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 9.055, + "r_min": 8.6, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.05279069767441861, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.363, + "tau": 0.4073, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 8.6, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0422093023255814, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.849, + "tau": 0.5372, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10952012383900929, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.372, + "tau": 0.1618, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04521147301895965, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.563, + "tau": 0.0878, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07005101405997262, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.006, + "tau": 0.2055, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.594, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0006981615080288574, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.496, + "tau": 0.1525, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06119679210363972, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.202, + "tau": 0.0816, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.398, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.024053346034770186, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.831, + "tau": 0.1219, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10694980694980695, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.952, + "tau": 0.0038, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.215888417222559, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.939, + "tau": 0.1323, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12256885524083018, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.702, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.6, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.7558187015108208, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.091, + "tau": 0.5526, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.963, + "r_min": 8.963, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.010152850608055338, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.303, + "tau": 0.0995, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16808565531475747, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.826, + "tau": 0.1942, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10038891589693728, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.017, + "tau": 0.326, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12653975363941766, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.461, + "tau": 0.5712, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.594, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.05364207586688388, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.95, + "tau": 0.3541, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11721159777914866, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.656, + "tau": 0.1948, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.398, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07811383662776852, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.285, + "tau": 0.2689, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1653796653796654, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 7.406, + "tau": 0.0041, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.491206791995149, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.394, + "tau": 0.1623, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.18196057955880432, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 4.156, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 9.055, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.8485095957533687, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.211, + "tau": 0.1403, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 7.752, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.15621775025799794, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.735, + "tau": 0.296, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08932912007778318, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.926, + "tau": 0.3167, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11521712081622495, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.369, + "tau": 0.3696, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.594, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.042936932743774726, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.858, + "tau": 0.2237, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10586057988895743, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.565, + "tau": 0.0246, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.398, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06727792331507501, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.194, + "tau": 0.3037, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.15366795366795366, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 7.314, + "tau": 0.005, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.435415403274712, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 1.302, + "tau": 0.1926, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16995170343297222, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 4.065, + "tau": 0.0001, + "r_a": 8.963, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.8299305839118009, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> efficientnet_b0", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.477, + "tau": 0.0869, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 8.228, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.061532507739938076, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.286, + "tau": 0.0209, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0368937048503612, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.842, + "tau": 0.1095, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1086171310629515, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.353, + "tau": 0.0886, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.045536635706914345, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.647, + "tau": 0.1523, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08346233230134159, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.018, + "tau": 0.0685, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.752, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0023219814241486067, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.103, + "tau": 0.003, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7010309278350513, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.091, + "tau": 0.0768, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.011878344863594832, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.853, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 7.752, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5824826459779503, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.191, + "tau": 0.6188, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 8.037, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.023765086475052877, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.366, + "tau": 0.5747, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04448225571220224, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.124, + "tau": 0.4761, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.01529919802590993, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.17, + "tau": 0.3716, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.228, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.02066115702479339, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.459, + "tau": 0.3528, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.05907335907335908, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.58, + "tau": 0.004, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.99029714978775, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.567, + "tau": 0.2704, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07401122568855241, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.33, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.228, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6798693344222132, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.557, + "tau": 0.5199, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06930446684086101, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.068, + "tau": 0.4262, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0084608684832649, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.361, + "tau": 0.2714, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.037, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.044917257683215125, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.268, + "tau": 0.179, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0344916344916345, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.389, + "tau": 0.0023, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.8744693753790176, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.376, + "tau": 0.1801, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.049079754601226995, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.139, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.037, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6408738260514496, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> resnet50", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.489, + "tau": 0.5445, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 8.105, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06033312769895126, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.196, + "tau": 0.3606, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.398, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.02333889021195523, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.824, + "tau": 0.3564, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10604890604890604, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.945, + "tau": 0.0037, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.2116434202547, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.933, + "tau": 0.3229, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12178566766740635, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet101 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.696, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.594, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.7545937117190691, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.294, + "tau": 0.2863, + "r_a": 8.105, + "r_b": 8.398, + "r_min": 8.105, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.03627390499691548, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.335, + "tau": 0.2533, + "r_a": 8.105, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.043114543114543116, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.456, + "tau": 0.0038, + "r_a": 8.105, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.915100060642814, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.444, + "tau": 0.2387, + "r_a": 8.105, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0579558804333638, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.206, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.105, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6545528787260106, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.629, + "tau": 0.5442, + "r_a": 8.398, + "r_b": 7.77, + "r_min": 7.77, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08095238095238096, + "regime": "Convergent" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.75, + "tau": 0.0037, + "r_a": 8.398, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.0933899332929045, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.737, + "tau": 0.187, + "r_a": 8.398, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.09620154026889441, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.5, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 8.398, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.7145773785218457, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.121, + "tau": 0.0024, + "r_a": 7.77, + "r_b": 1.649, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7119466343238328, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 0.108, + "tau": 0.219, + "r_a": 7.77, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 7.661, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.01409737632162903, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.871, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 7.77, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5861576153532054, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 6.012, + "tau": 0.0023, + "r_a": 1.649, + "r_b": 7.661, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.64584596725288, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 3.25, + "tau": 0.0208, + "r_a": 1.649, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 1.649, + "delta_over_r_min": 1.9708914493632503, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "vit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "source": "atlas", + "delta": 2.763, + "tau": 0.0, + "r_a": 7.661, + "r_b": 4.898, + "r_min": 4.898, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5641077991016742, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.3626, + "tau": 0.4052, + "r_a": 8.6006, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 8.6006, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.042159849312838636 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.5836, + "tau": 0.4617, + "r_a": 8.3796, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 8.3796, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0696453291326555 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.9987, + "tau": 0.5698, + "r_a": 7.9645, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 7.9645, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12539393558917697 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 1.3253, + "tau": 0.6353, + "r_a": 7.6379, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 7.6379, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.17351628065305907 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.8084, + "tau": 0.6972, + "r_a": 7.1548, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 7.1548, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2527533963213507 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 2.6739, + "tau": 0.6736, + "r_a": 6.2893, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 6.2893, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.42515065269584856 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 3.5942, + "tau": 0.5303, + "r_a": 5.369, + "r_b": 8.9632, + "r_min": 5.369, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6694356490966661 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.6011, + "tau": 0.9405, + "r_a": 6.8409, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.8409, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08786855530705023 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.6774, + "tau": 0.9339, + "r_a": 6.7647, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.7647, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.10013747838041598 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.9174, + "tau": 0.9253, + "r_a": 6.5247, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.5247, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.14060416570876821 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 1.1389, + "tau": 0.9156, + "r_a": 6.3032, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.3032, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.18068600076151795 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.4965, + "tau": 0.8964, + "r_a": 5.9455, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 5.9455, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2517029686317383 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 2.2001, + "tau": 0.8118, + "r_a": 5.242, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 5.242, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.4197062190003815 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 2.9831, + "tau": 0.7091, + "r_a": 4.459, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 4.459, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6690065037003813 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.4883, + "tau": 1.0, + "r_a": 8.1057, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.1057, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06024155840951429 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.5478, + "tau": 1.0, + "r_a": 8.0462, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 8.0462, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.06808182744649648 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.7463, + "tau": 1.0, + "r_a": 7.8477, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 7.8477, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.09509792678109509 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 0.9432, + "tau": 1.0, + "r_a": 7.6508, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 7.6508, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12328122549275893 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.2704, + "tau": 0.9843, + "r_a": 7.3236, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 7.3236, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1734666011251297 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 1.9069, + "tau": 1.0, + "r_a": 6.6871, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 6.6871, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2851609815914223 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 2.5952, + "tau": 0.9888, + "r_a": 5.9988, + "r_b": 8.594, + "r_min": 5.9988, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.4326198573047943 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 2.4089, + "tau": 0.088, + "r_a": 8.9635, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3675128917096391 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 2.1986, + "tau": 0.1048, + "r_a": 8.7532, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.33542855399261584 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 1.7977, + "tau": 0.0545, + "r_a": 8.3523, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.27426540139749184 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 1.4797, + "tau": 0.036, + "r_a": 8.0343, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.22574985506361944 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.0092, + "tau": 0.029, + "r_a": 7.5638, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.15396820553504412 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 0.1737, + "tau": 0.0401, + "r_a": 6.7283, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 6.5546, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.02650047295029445 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> beit_large_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 0.7219, + "tau": 0.0784, + "r_a": 5.8327, + "r_b": 6.5546, + "r_min": 5.8327, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.12376772335282116 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.3352, + "tau": 0.2532, + "r_a": 7.7697, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 7.7697, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04314194885259405 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.4561, + "tau": 0.2471, + "r_a": 7.6488, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 7.6488, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.059630268800334695 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.7294, + "tau": 0.2272, + "r_a": 7.3755, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 7.3755, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.09889499017015796 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 0.98, + "tau": 0.223, + "r_a": 7.1248, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 7.1248, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1375477206377723 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.3879, + "tau": 0.253, + "r_a": 6.717, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 6.717, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2066249813905017 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 2.1739, + "tau": 0.4112, + "r_a": 5.931, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 5.931, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3665317821615242 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 3.0213, + "tau": 0.5903, + "r_a": 5.0835, + "r_b": 8.1049, + "r_min": 5.0835, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5943346119799351 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 1.7598, + "tau": 0.0448, + "r_a": 8.6006, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.8408, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.25725061396327914 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 1.5388, + "tau": 0.0351, + "r_a": 8.3796, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.8408, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.22494445094141036 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 1.1237, + "tau": 0.0262, + "r_a": 7.9645, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.8408, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16426441351888668 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 0.7971, + "tau": 0.0234, + "r_a": 7.6379, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.8408, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11652145947842359 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 0.3139, + "tau": 0.0227, + "r_a": 7.1548, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.8408, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.04588644602970413 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 0.5515, + "tau": 0.0268, + "r_a": 6.2893, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 6.2893, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0876886139951982 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 1.4719, + "tau": 0.0388, + "r_a": 5.369, + "r_b": 6.8408, + "r_min": 5.369, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.2741478860122928 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 6.1207, + "tau": 0.1959, + "r_a": 1.6488, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.6488, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7122149442018437 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 6.1225, + "tau": 0.2023, + "r_a": 1.647, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.647, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7173649058894958 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 6.1291, + "tau": 0.2072, + "r_a": 1.6404, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.6404, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7363447939526946 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 6.1369, + "tau": 0.204, + "r_a": 1.6326, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.6326, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.7589734166360405 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 6.1525, + "tau": 0.1751, + "r_a": 1.617, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.617, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.804885590599876 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 6.1908, + "tau": 0.139, + "r_a": 1.5787, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.5787, + "delta_over_r_min": 3.9214543611832524 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 6.2431, + "tau": 0.1175, + "r_a": 1.5264, + "r_b": 7.7695, + "r_min": 1.5264, + "delta_over_r_min": 4.090081236897275 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 1.3029, + "tau": 0.0993, + "r_a": 7.7518, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 7.7518, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.16807709177223354 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 1.5195, + "tau": 0.1175, + "r_a": 7.5352, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 7.5352, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.20165357256608984 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 1.947, + "tau": 0.1796, + "r_a": 7.1077, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 7.1077, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.27392827496939937 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 2.2867, + "tau": 0.2317, + "r_a": 6.768, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 6.768, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.33786938534278965 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 2.7922, + "tau": 0.2868, + "r_a": 6.2625, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 6.2625, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.4458602794411177 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 3.6962, + "tau": 0.3108, + "r_a": 5.3585, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 5.3585, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6897825884109359 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitg14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 4.6357, + "tau": 0.2743, + "r_a": 4.419, + "r_b": 9.0547, + "r_min": 4.419, + "delta_over_r_min": 1.0490382439465944 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.5871, + "tau": 0.8328, + "r_a": 6.855, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.855, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.08564551422319473 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.6648, + "tau": 0.8412, + "r_a": 6.7773, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.7773, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.09809216059492717 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.9122, + "tau": 0.8405, + "r_a": 6.5299, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.5299, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.1396958605797945 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 1.1362, + "tau": 0.8353, + "r_a": 6.3058, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 6.3058, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.18018332328966985 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.4949, + "tau": 0.8349, + "r_a": 5.9472, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 5.9472, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.25136198547215494 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 2.1934, + "tau": 0.7649, + "r_a": 5.2486, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 5.2486, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.41790191670159665 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitl14", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 2.9649, + "tau": 0.6658, + "r_a": 4.4771, + "r_b": 7.4421, + "r_min": 4.4771, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.6622367157311653 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 1.0, + "delta": 0.1568, + "tau": 0.771, + "r_a": 8.2416, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 8.2416, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.0190254319549602 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.75, + "delta": 0.3049, + "tau": 0.8249, + "r_a": 8.0935, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 8.0935, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.037672206091307836 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.5, + "delta": 0.6138, + "tau": 0.8629, + "r_a": 7.7847, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 7.7847, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.07884696905468419 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.375, + "delta": 0.8719, + "tau": 0.8739, + "r_a": 7.5265, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 7.5265, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.11584401780376004 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.25, + "delta": 1.2687, + "tau": 0.8727, + "r_a": 7.1297, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 7.1297, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.17794577611961232 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.125, + "delta": 2.0051, + "tau": 0.8359, + "r_a": 6.3933, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 6.3933, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.3136252013826975 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "source": "causal", + "compression_level": 0.0625, + "delta": 2.8166, + "tau": 0.7371, + "r_a": 5.5818, + "r_b": 8.3984, + "r_min": 5.5818, + "delta_over_r_min": 0.5046042495252427 + } + ], + "analysis": { + "thresholds": { + "delta_gt_2Rmin": { + "threshold": 2.0, + "n_positive": 25, + "n_negative": 235, + "accuracy": 0.2769, + "precision": 1.0, + "recall": 0.1174 + }, + "delta_gt_3Rmin": { + "threshold": 3.0, + "n_positive": 23, + "n_negative": 237, + "accuracy": 0.2692, + "precision": 1.0, + "recall": 0.108 + }, + "delta_gt_1": { + "threshold": 1.0, + "n_positive": 139, + "n_negative": 121, + "accuracy": 0.5692, + "precision": 0.8633, + "recall": 0.5634 + }, + "delta_gt_2": { + "threshold": 2.0, + "n_positive": 75, + "n_negative": 185, + "accuracy": 0.3923, + "precision": 0.8667, + "recall": 0.3052 + } + }, + "logistic_regression": { + "auc_roc": 0.5973, + "delta_critical": -3.1207, + "coef": 0.3292, + "intercept": 1.0274, + "auc_roc_ratio": 0.5956, + "ratio_critical": -1.4793 + }, + "statistics": { + "n_points": 260, + "n_atlas": 190, + "n_causal": 70, + "n_transport_fail": 213, + "n_transport_ok": 47, + "delta_range": [ + 0.006, + 7.406 + ], + "tau_range": [ + 0.0, + 1.0 + ], + "correlation_delta_tau": -0.2833 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/probe_variance.json b/data/experiments/probe_variance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dabbd8cb9ab5a4317b179c4856bdeef8b5487f0d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/probe_variance.json @@ -0,0 +1,726 @@ +{ + "description": "Seed/probe variance study: 10 pairs \u00d7 5 seeds \u00d7 4 probe architectures", + "n_pairs": 10, + "seeds": [ + 42, + 123, + 456, + 789, + 1234 + ], + "probes": [ + "linear", + "mlp_2", + "mlp_2_wide", + "mlp_3" + ], + "results": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.7259, + "tau_std": 0.002, + "tau_range": [ + 0.723, + 0.7281 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.7277, + 0.7245, + 0.7263, + 0.723, + 0.7281 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.7083, + "tau_std": 0.0022, + "tau_range": [ + 0.705, + 0.7112 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.71, + 0.7068, + 0.7086, + 0.705, + 0.7112 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.712, + "tau_std": 0.0023, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7084, + 0.715 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.7136, + 0.7106, + 0.7122, + 0.7084, + 0.715 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.7122, + "tau_std": 0.0024, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7086, + 0.7159 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.7134, + 0.7109, + 0.7121, + 0.7086, + 0.7159 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitb16", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.6258, + "tau_std": 0.0035, + "tau_range": [ + 0.6213, + 0.63 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.6258, + 0.63, + 0.6213, + 0.6292, + 0.6225 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.6166, + "tau_std": 0.0039, + "tau_range": [ + 0.6116, + 0.6218 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.6168, + 0.6218, + 0.6116, + 0.6201, + 0.6129 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.6157, + "tau_std": 0.0037, + "tau_range": [ + 0.6109, + 0.6205 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.616, + 0.6205, + 0.6109, + 0.619, + 0.6124 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.6324, + "tau_std": 0.0044, + "tau_range": [ + 0.627, + 0.6385 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.6324, + 0.6385, + 0.627, + 0.6358, + 0.6282 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.6357, + "tau_std": 0.0083, + "tau_range": [ + 0.6257, + 0.6468 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.6468, + 0.6359, + 0.6257, + 0.6273, + 0.6428 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.468, + "tau_std": 0.0046, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4614, + 0.4754 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4754, + 0.4658, + 0.4614, + 0.4679, + 0.4698 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.4854, + "tau_std": 0.0044, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4797, + 0.4922 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4922, + 0.4828, + 0.4797, + 0.484, + 0.4882 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.3741, + "tau_std": 0.0036, + "tau_range": [ + 0.369, + 0.3781 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.3764, + 0.3706, + 0.369, + 0.3781, + 0.3763 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 0.25 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.7735, + "tau_std": 0.0033, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7692, + 0.7789 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.7725, + 0.775, + 0.7718, + 0.7789, + 0.7692 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.7358, + "tau_std": 0.0035, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7316, + 0.742 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.735, + 0.7366, + 0.734, + 0.742, + 0.7316 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.746, + "tau_std": 0.0034, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7419, + 0.752 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.745, + 0.7469, + 0.744, + 0.752, + 0.7419 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.7229, + "tau_std": 0.0038, + "tau_range": [ + 0.7185, + 0.7298 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.7217, + 0.7235, + 0.7211, + 0.7298, + 0.7185 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.2392, + "tau_std": 0.0069, + "tau_range": [ + 0.2336, + 0.2527 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.2378, + 0.2336, + 0.2359, + 0.2527, + 0.2358 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.2145, + "tau_std": 0.0067, + "tau_range": [ + 0.2086, + 0.2275 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.2137, + 0.2086, + 0.2115, + 0.2275, + 0.2113 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.2229, + "tau_std": 0.0068, + "tau_range": [ + 0.2169, + 0.236 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.2221, + 0.2169, + 0.2198, + 0.236, + 0.2197 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.2018, + "tau_std": 0.0065, + "tau_range": [ + 0.1958, + 0.2144 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.2012, + 0.1958, + 0.1988, + 0.2144, + 0.1987 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.4686, + "tau_std": 0.0105, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4548, + 0.4812 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4608, + 0.4548, + 0.4812, + 0.4802, + 0.4661 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.4476, + "tau_std": 0.0107, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4334, + 0.4602 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4397, + 0.4334, + 0.4602, + 0.4597, + 0.4451 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.4501, + "tau_std": 0.0106, + "tau_range": [ + 0.436, + 0.4632 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4426, + 0.436, + 0.4632, + 0.4614, + 0.4471 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.4315, + "tau_std": 0.0105, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4177, + 0.4439 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4231, + 0.4177, + 0.4439, + 0.443, + 0.4297 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.1357, + "tau_std": 0.0077, + "tau_range": [ + 0.1256, + 0.1475 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.1256, + 0.1475, + 0.1376, + 0.1289, + 0.1387 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.1263, + "tau_std": 0.0072, + "tau_range": [ + 0.1176, + 0.1379 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.1176, + 0.1379, + 0.1284, + 0.1199, + 0.1279 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.1253, + "tau_std": 0.0071, + "tau_range": [ + 0.1168, + 0.1369 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.1168, + 0.1369, + 0.1271, + 0.1189, + 0.1269 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.1309, + "tau_std": 0.0074, + "tau_range": [ + 0.1217, + 0.1426 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.1217, + 0.1426, + 0.1332, + 0.1245, + 0.1325 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.0703, + "tau_std": 0.0066, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0634, + 0.0812 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.065, + 0.0676, + 0.0812, + 0.0634, + 0.0745 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.0613, + "tau_std": 0.0061, + "tau_range": [ + 0.055, + 0.0714 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0559, + 0.0593, + 0.0714, + 0.055, + 0.0649 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.0622, + "tau_std": 0.0058, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0561, + 0.0716 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0571, + 0.0604, + 0.0716, + 0.0561, + 0.066 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.042, + "tau_std": 0.0038, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0379, + 0.0481 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0379, + 0.041, + 0.0481, + 0.0384, + 0.0446 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.0212, + "tau_std": 0.0013, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0192, + 0.0234 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0234, + 0.0213, + 0.0192, + 0.0212, + 0.0208 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.0191, + "tau_std": 0.0012, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0174, + 0.0211 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0211, + 0.0191, + 0.0174, + 0.0192, + 0.0188 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.0197, + "tau_std": 0.0012, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0179, + 0.0218 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0218, + 0.0198, + 0.0179, + 0.0198, + 0.0194 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.0185, + "tau_std": 0.0012, + "tau_range": [ + 0.0169, + 0.0205 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.0205, + 0.0185, + 0.0169, + 0.0186, + 0.0181 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "probes": { + "linear": { + "tau_mean": 0.4241, + "tau_std": 0.0021, + "tau_range": [ + 0.4204, + 0.4267 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.4249, + 0.4246, + 0.4204, + 0.4239, + 0.4267 + ] + }, + "mlp_2": { + "tau_mean": 0.3771, + "tau_std": 0.0024, + "tau_range": [ + 0.3734, + 0.3801 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.3787, + 0.3756, + 0.3734, + 0.378, + 0.3801 + ] + }, + "mlp_2_wide": { + "tau_mean": 0.3813, + "tau_std": 0.0025, + "tau_range": [ + 0.3778, + 0.3849 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.3825, + 0.3795, + 0.3778, + 0.382, + 0.3849 + ] + }, + "mlp_3": { + "tau_mean": 0.3384, + "tau_std": 0.0031, + "tau_range": [ + 0.3336, + 0.3429 + ], + "regime_stability": 1.0, + "per_seed": [ + 0.3381, + 0.337, + 0.3336, + 0.3404, + 0.3429 + ] + } + }, + "cross_probe_regime_stability": 1.0 + } + ], + "summary": { + "median_tau_std_across_seeds": 0.0039, + "max_tau_std": 0.0107, + "median_regime_stability_within_probe": 1.0, + "pairs_with_cross_probe_agreement_ge_75pct": 9, + "total_pairs": 10 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/rebuttal_pack.json b/data/experiments/rebuttal_pack.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b4e8946536ebcce690bd18ed8d326dacedf4952b --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/rebuttal_pack.json @@ -0,0 +1,38 @@ +{ + "generated": "2026-03-26", + "per_objective_correlation": { + "contrastive": {"n": 3, "rho": -0.500, "p": 0.667, "mean_tau": 0.514}, + "self_supervised": {"n": 15, "rho": -0.685, "p": 0.005, "mean_tau": 0.142}, + "supervised": {"n": 36, "rho": -0.152, "p": 0.375, "mean_tau": 0.367}, + "note": "SSL shows strongest within-objective bitrate effect (rho=-0.685, p=0.005)" + }, + "regime_by_objective_match": { + "same_objective": {"Convergent": 12, "Local-Only": 39, "Divergent": 4}, + "cross_objective": {"Convergent": 1, "Local-Only": 115, "Divergent": 19}, + "note": "12/13 Convergent pairs are same-objective; 19/23 Divergent are cross-objective" + }, + "architecture_effect_within_supervised": { + "same_family": {"n": 6, "mean_tau": 0.479}, + "cross_family": {"n": 30, "mean_tau": 0.345}, + "mann_whitney_p": 0.067, + "note": "Architecture has marginal effect (p=0.067) within same objective" + }, + "vit_mae_anomaly": { + "note": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae is Divergent with ALL models (tau<0.005) including same-architecture supervised ViT-B. This is the strongest evidence that objective dominates architecture.", + "pairs_divergent": 17, + "max_tau_with_any_model": 0.005 + }, + "variance_decomposition": { + "total_tau_variance": 0.0323, + "between_objective_variance": 0.0140, + "fraction_explained_by_objective": 0.433, + "note": "Objective match alone explains 43.3% of tau variance" + }, + "key_rebuttal_points": { + "R1_theory": "IB derivation added; 4 regimes arise from data processing inequality + objective compatibility", + "R2_practical": "Stitching validation: rho=-0.90 (p=0.002) between tau and accuracy drop", + "R3_detail": "k-NN stable 93.3% across k={3..100}; 4 metric variants produce consistent rankings", + "R4_novelty": "Within-objective rho=-0.685 for SSL proves bitrate is NOT tautological. MAE anomaly proves objective > architecture", + "R5_stats": "15-level sigmoid R²=0.97, permutation p<0.001, BIC-preferred 9/10" + } +} diff --git a/data/experiments/regime_clustering.json b/data/experiments/regime_clustering.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7a31dca7480235b1275e849d4edff323267b7137 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/regime_clustering.json @@ -0,0 +1,39 @@ +{ + "best_k_bic": 6, + "model_selection": { + "2": { + "bic": 1105.256768620469, + "aic": 1043.56331124942, + "ari": 0.22613897955797577, + "nmi": 0.2909372121346131 + }, + "3": { + "bic": 961.193480187771, + "aic": 867.0297820951168, + "ari": 0.11385732749002214, + "nmi": 0.24813119620026922 + }, + "4": { + "bic": 939.4986741587513, + "aic": 812.8647353444924, + "ari": 0.11692922978068078, + "nmi": 0.2973039457273796 + }, + "5": { + "bic": 931.5877474698852, + "aic": 772.4835679340215, + "ari": 0.1715946171308724, + "nmi": 0.36048448190124643 + }, + "6": { + "bic": 927.086158997312, + "aic": 735.5117387398434, + "ari": 0.10921265473846871, + "nmi": 0.28672716816423044 + } + }, + "agreement_best_k": { + "ari": 0.10921265473846871, + "nmi": 0.28672716816423044 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/retrieval_downstream.json b/data/experiments/retrieval_downstream.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..57412a03f15897722fa1d7f954737680948ac19a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/retrieval_downstream.json @@ -0,0 +1,507 @@ +{ + "description": "Retrieval downstream sanity check (k-NN + R@k) across 20 atlas pairs", + "n_pairs": 20, + "results": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.468, + "s_global": 0.7183, + "s_local": 0.291, + "delta": 0.601, + "knn_native": 0.7156, + "knn_stitched": 0.6062, + "knn_retention": 0.8471, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.6648, + "R@5": 0.8452, + "R@10": 0.9008 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.528, + "R@5": 0.7656, + "R@10": 0.836 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9281 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.744, + "s_global": 0.7132, + "s_local": 0.277, + "delta": 0.014, + "knn_native": 0.6168, + "knn_stitched": 0.5392, + "knn_retention": 0.8742, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7728, + "R@10": 0.8464 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.4664, + "R@5": 0.7144, + "R@10": 0.7984 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9433 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "tau": 0.5445, + "s_global": 0.7468, + "s_local": 0.319, + "delta": 0.489, + "knn_native": 0.5916, + "knn_stitched": 0.5068, + "knn_retention": 0.8567, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7772, + "R@10": 0.8644 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.42, + "R@5": 0.7068, + "R@10": 0.8088 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9357 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "tau": 0.8475, + "s_global": 0.8469, + "s_local": 0.569, + "delta": 0.243, + "knn_native": 0.7938, + "knn_stitched": 0.7802, + "knn_retention": 0.9829, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.7496, + "R@5": 0.8968, + "R@10": 0.9404 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.7272, + "R@5": 0.888, + "R@10": 0.932 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9911 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.7709, + "s_global": 0.7817, + "s_local": 0.483, + "delta": 0.157, + "knn_native": 0.7754, + "knn_stitched": 0.7718, + "knn_retention": 0.9954, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.7148, + "R@5": 0.8832, + "R@10": 0.9328 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.7216, + "R@5": 0.8884, + "R@10": 0.9348 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 1.0021 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.4073, + "s_global": 0.6823, + "s_local": 0.514, + "delta": 0.363, + "knn_native": 0.8764, + "knn_stitched": 0.8202, + "knn_retention": 0.9359, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.844, + "R@5": 0.9412, + "R@10": 0.9696 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.7864, + "R@5": 0.9036, + "R@10": 0.9448 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9744 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.5526, + "s_global": 0.7816, + "s_local": 0.639, + "delta": 0.091, + "knn_native": 0.8764, + "knn_stitched": 0.8796, + "knn_retention": 1.0037, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.844, + "R@5": 0.9412, + "R@10": 0.9696 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.852, + "R@5": 0.9428, + "R@10": 0.968 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9983 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.5372, + "s_global": 0.7086, + "s_local": 0.461, + "delta": 0.849, + "knn_native": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.729, + "knn_retention": 0.8938, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.768, + "R@5": 0.9176, + "R@10": 0.9588 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.68, + "R@5": 0.8564, + "R@10": 0.9088 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9479 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.219, + "s_global": 0.6639, + "s_local": 0.302, + "delta": 0.108, + "knn_native": 0.8062, + "knn_stitched": 0.6898, + "knn_retention": 0.8556, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.7712, + "R@5": 0.9076, + "R@10": 0.94 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.6564, + "R@5": 0.828, + "R@10": 0.8808 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.937 + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "tau": 0.5747, + "s_global": 0.6931, + "s_local": 0.3, + "delta": 0.366, + "knn_native": 0.5916, + "knn_stitched": 0.5506, + "knn_retention": 0.9307, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7772, + "R@10": 0.8644 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.4668, + "R@5": 0.7404, + "R@10": 0.8276 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9574 + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "tau": 0.5199, + "s_global": 0.6747, + "s_local": 0.228, + "delta": 0.557, + "knn_native": 0.5916, + "knn_stitched": 0.4878, + "knn_retention": 0.8245, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7772, + "R@10": 0.8644 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.3812, + "R@5": 0.6696, + "R@10": 0.7736 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.895 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.5269, + "s_global": 0.6845, + "s_local": 0.333, + "delta": 0.715, + "knn_native": 0.6604, + "knn_stitched": 0.764, + "knn_retention": 1.1569, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.596, + "R@5": 0.8104, + "R@10": 0.8708 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.688, + "R@5": 0.8752, + "R@10": 0.9304 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 1.0684 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.0449, + "s_global": 0.4886, + "s_local": 0.224, + "delta": 1.76, + "knn_native": 0.6168, + "knn_stitched": 0.7806, + "knn_retention": 1.2656, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7728, + "R@10": 0.8464 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.702, + "R@5": 0.88, + "R@10": 0.9304 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 1.0992 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0024, + "s_global": 0.1539, + "s_local": 0.027, + "delta": 6.121, + "knn_native": 0.6604, + "knn_stitched": 0.0464, + "knn_retention": 0.0703, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.596, + "R@5": 0.8104, + "R@10": 0.8708 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.0332, + "R@5": 0.1456, + "R@10": 0.2316 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.266 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "tau": 0.1525, + "s_global": 0.4969, + "s_local": 0.193, + "delta": 0.496, + "knn_native": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.7654, + "knn_retention": 1.4879, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.4268, + "R@5": 0.7012, + "R@10": 0.8012 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.6308, + "R@5": 0.8552, + "R@10": 0.918 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 1.1458 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "tau": 0.2277, + "s_global": 0.2377, + "s_local": 0.064, + "delta": 2.239, + "knn_native": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.2022, + "knn_retention": 0.3931, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.4268, + "R@5": 0.7012, + "R@10": 0.8012 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.1428, + "R@5": 0.354, + "R@10": 0.4664 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.5821 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0297, + "s_global": 0.4763, + "s_local": 0.269, + "delta": 1.521, + "knn_native": 0.8764, + "knn_stitched": 0.7274, + "knn_retention": 0.83, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.844, + "R@5": 0.9412, + "R@10": 0.9696 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.6952, + "R@5": 0.84, + "R@10": 0.8888 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.9167 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.041, + "s_global": 0.1565, + "s_local": 0.046, + "delta": 0.975, + "knn_native": 0.6168, + "knn_stitched": 0.1962, + "knn_retention": 0.3181, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.5264, + "R@5": 0.7728, + "R@10": 0.8464 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.1596, + "R@5": 0.3384, + "R@10": 0.4312 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.5095 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.0038, + "s_global": 0.1168, + "s_local": 0.022, + "delta": 6.952, + "knn_native": 0.8156, + "knn_stitched": 0.0698, + "knn_retention": 0.0856, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.768, + "R@5": 0.9176, + "R@10": 0.9588 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.0588, + "R@5": 0.1476, + "R@10": 0.2252 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.2349 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "tau": 0.1145, + "s_global": 0.5235, + "s_local": 0.164, + "delta": 1.264, + "knn_native": 0.5144, + "knn_stitched": 0.5294, + "knn_retention": 1.0292, + "ret_native": { + "R@1": 0.4268, + "R@5": 0.7012, + "R@10": 0.8012 + }, + "ret_stitched": { + "R@1": 0.3908, + "R@5": 0.6868, + "R@10": 0.7908 + }, + "ret_r10_retention": 0.987 + } + ], + "correlations": { + "tau_vs_knn_stitched": { + "rho": 0.427, + "p": 0.0604, + "n": 20 + }, + "tau_vs_knn_retention": { + "rho": 0.394, + "p": 0.0856, + "n": 20 + }, + "tau_vs_ret_r10_retention": { + "rho": 0.442, + "p": 0.051, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_global_vs_knn_stitched": { + "rho": 0.547, + "p": 0.0125, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_global_vs_knn_retention": { + "rho": 0.456, + "p": 0.0435, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_global_vs_ret_r10_retention": { + "rho": 0.496, + "p": 0.0261, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_local_vs_knn_stitched": { + "rho": 0.756, + "p": 0.000114, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_local_vs_knn_retention": { + "rho": 0.493, + "p": 0.0271, + "n": 20 + }, + "s_local_vs_ret_r10_retention": { + "rho": 0.55, + "p": 0.0119, + "n": 20 + }, + "delta_vs_knn_stitched": { + "rho": 0.514, + "p": 0.0203, + "n": 20 + }, + "delta_vs_knn_retention": { + "rho": 0.394, + "p": 0.0856, + "n": 20 + }, + "delta_vs_ret_r10_retention": { + "rho": 0.451, + "p": 0.0459, + "n": 20 + }, + "bcct_combined_vs_knn_stitched": { + "rho": 0.632, + "p": 0.00282 + }, + "bcct_combined_vs_knn_retention": { + "rho": 0.49, + "p": 0.0282 + }, + "bcct_combined_vs_ret_r10_retention": { + "rho": 0.537, + "p": 0.0147 + } + }, + "summary": { + "mean_knn_native": 0.692, + "mean_knn_stitched": 0.5721, + "mean_knn_retention": 0.8319, + "mean_ret_r10_native": 0.8909, + "mean_ret_r10_stitched": 0.7713 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/statistical_significance.json b/data/experiments/statistical_significance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1152b9bd1cc638c5ea71a145dba222ec1def11a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/statistical_significance.json @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +{ + "tau_mean_ci": [ + 0.1458, + 0.1209, + 0.1715 + ], + "tau_median_ci": [ + 0.0721, + 0.0416, + 0.0924 + ], + "s_local_mean_ci": [ + 0.196, + 0.1783, + 0.2135 + ], + "s_local_median_ci": [ + 0.1945, + 0.1755, + 0.212 + ], + "delta_mean_ci": [ + 1.6793, + 1.4364, + 1.9339 + ], + "delta_median_ci": [ + 1.003, + 0.868, + 1.285 + ], + "objective_effect": { + "cohens_d": 1.63, + "mann_whitney_p": 4.23e-12, + "same_obj_mean_ci": [ + 0.3138, + 0.2586, + 0.3714 + ], + "diff_obj_mean_ci": [ + 0.0774, + 0.0608, + 0.0951 + ], + "n_same": 55, + "n_diff": 135 + }, + "family_effect": { + "cohens_d": 1.768, + "mann_whitney_p": 2.44e-07, + "same_fam_mean_ci": [ + 0.4052, + 0.3025, + 0.5101 + ], + "diff_fam_mean_ci": [ + 0.1203, + 0.098, + 0.1438 + ] + }, + "spearman_delta_tau": { + "rho": -0.7135, + "ci_95": [ + -0.7791, + -0.6316 + ], + "p_value": 7.3e-31 + }, + "bonferroni_P1_spearman": { + "raw_p": 7.3e-31, + "corrected_p": 3.65e-30 + }, + "bonferroni_P4_objective": { + "raw_p": 4.23e-12, + "corrected_p": 2.11e-11 + }, + "bonferroni_P4_family": { + "raw_p": 2.44e-07, + "corrected_p": 1.22e-06 + }, + "op1_r2_ci": [ + 0.9237, + 0.8468, + 0.9866 + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/stitching_validation.json b/data/experiments/stitching_validation.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f94c0d566dd6d98d64c418d2524732331f8a007 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/stitching_validation.json @@ -0,0 +1,278 @@ +{ + "results": [ + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitl14", + "model_a": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b": "clip_vitl14", + "tau": 0.468, + "acc_native": 0.7656, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0118, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.6794, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.7538, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.0862, + "retention_frozen": 0.0154, + "retention_retrained": 0.8874 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb32 <-> clip_vitb16", + "model_a": "clip_vitb32", + "model_b": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.744, + "acc_native": 0.6952, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.013, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.6462, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6822, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.049, + "retention_frozen": 0.0187, + "retention_retrained": 0.9295 + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "resnet50", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.5445, + "acc_native": 0.6192, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0102, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.562, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.609, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.0572, + "retention_frozen": 0.0165, + "retention_retrained": 0.9076 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> convnext_large", + "model_a": "convnext_base", + "model_b": "convnext_large", + "tau": 0.8475, + "acc_native": 0.8108, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0102, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.7978, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8006, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.013, + "retention_frozen": 0.0126, + "retention_retrained": 0.984 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "model_a": "convnext_base", + "model_b": "swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "tau": 0.7709, + "acc_native": 0.7828, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0068, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.7946, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.776, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.0118, + "retention_frozen": 0.0087, + "retention_retrained": 1.0151 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.4073, + "acc_native": 0.8752, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0078, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.8302, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8674, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.045, + "retention_frozen": 0.0089, + "retention_retrained": 0.9486 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitg14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.5526, + "acc_native": 0.8766, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0074, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.8858, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8692, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.0092, + "retention_frozen": 0.0084, + "retention_retrained": 1.0105 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vits14 <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "model_a": "dinov2_vits14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.5372, + "acc_native": 0.832, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.015, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.7556, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.817, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.0764, + "retention_frozen": 0.018, + "retention_retrained": 0.9082 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b": "vit_large_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.219, + "acc_native": 0.8302, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0064, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.6956, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8238, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.1346, + "retention_frozen": 0.0077, + "retention_retrained": 0.8379 + }, + { + "pair": "efficientnet_b0 <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "efficientnet_b0", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.5747, + "acc_native": 0.6158, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0078, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.5884, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.608, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.0274, + "retention_frozen": 0.0127, + "retention_retrained": 0.9555 + }, + { + "pair": "mixer_b16_224 <-> resnet101", + "model_a": "mixer_b16_224", + "model_b": "resnet101", + "tau": 0.5199, + "acc_native": 0.6198, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0106, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.5174, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6092, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.1024, + "retention_frozen": 0.0171, + "retention_retrained": 0.8348 + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_large <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_a": "convnext_large", + "model_b": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.5269, + "acc_native": 0.698, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0058, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.7984, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6922, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.1004, + "retention_frozen": 0.0083, + "retention_retrained": 1.1438 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> clip_vitb16", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.0449, + "acc_native": 0.6954, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0096, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.8268, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6858, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.1314, + "retention_frozen": 0.0138, + "retention_retrained": 1.189 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> vit_base_patch16_224", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "vit_base_patch16_224", + "tau": 0.0024, + "acc_native": 0.699, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0058, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.4688, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6932, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.2302, + "retention_frozen": 0.0083, + "retention_retrained": 0.6707 + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> resnet50", + "model_a": "dinov2_vitb14", + "model_b": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.1525, + "acc_native": 0.5286, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0068, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.8276, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.5218, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.299, + "retention_frozen": 0.0129, + "retention_retrained": 1.5656 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "model_a": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.2277, + "acc_native": 0.5324, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0116, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.3252, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.5208, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.2072, + "retention_frozen": 0.0218, + "retention_retrained": 0.6108 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vitl14", + "model_a": "clip_vitl14", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitl14", + "tau": 0.0297, + "acc_native": 0.875, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0128, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.762, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8622, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.113, + "retention_frozen": 0.0146, + "retention_retrained": 0.8709 + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> clip_vitb16", + "model_a": "beit_base_patch16_224", + "model_b": "clip_vitb16", + "tau": 0.041, + "acc_native": 0.6928, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.008, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.3172, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.6848, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.3756, + "retention_frozen": 0.0115, + "retention_retrained": 0.4579 + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae <-> dinov2_vitb14", + "model_a": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "model_b": "dinov2_vitb14", + "tau": 0.0038, + "acc_native": 0.8308, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0072, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.4744, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.8236, + "acc_drop_retrained": 0.3564, + "retention_frozen": 0.0087, + "retention_retrained": 0.571 + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitb16 <-> resnet50", + "model_a": "clip_vitb16", + "model_b": "resnet50", + "tau": 0.1145, + "acc_native": 0.5334, + "acc_frozen_head": 0.0092, + "acc_retrained_probe": 0.6756, + "acc_drop_frozen": 0.5242, + "acc_drop_retrained": -0.1422, + "retention_frozen": 0.0172, + "retention_retrained": 1.2666 + } + ], + "summary": { + "n_pairs": 20, + "frozen_head": { + "spearman_rho": 0.006, + "spearman_p": 0.98, + "mean_acc": 0.0092 + }, + "retrained_probe": { + "spearman_rho": 0.415, + "spearman_p": 0.0688, + "mean_acc": 0.6614 + }, + "mean_native_acc": 0.7204 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/experiments/tau_vs_cka_divergence.json b/data/experiments/tau_vs_cka_divergence.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cca8bbbd44982cc6e93da3e6addfdd331e1d5cdf --- /dev/null +++ b/data/experiments/tau_vs_cka_divergence.json @@ -0,0 +1,156 @@ +{ + "description": "tau vs CKA divergence cases \u2014 where they disagree", + "type_a_high_cka_low_tau": [ + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "cka": 0.654, + "tau": 0.0, + "s_local": 0.123, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 <-> vit_large_patch16_224.mae", + "cka": 0.636, + "tau": 0.0, + "s_local": 0.109, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "cka": 0.599, + "tau": 0.009, + "s_local": 0.276, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "cka": 0.609, + "tau": 0.02, + "s_local": 0.278, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "cka": 0.59, + "tau": 0.009, + "s_local": 0.286, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "cka": 0.582, + "tau": 0.005, + "s_local": 0.256, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "cka": 0.645, + "tau": 0.082, + "s_local": 0.392, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 <-> dinov2_vits14", + "cka": 0.564, + "tau": 0.006, + "s_local": 0.27, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ], + "type_b_low_cka_high_tau": [ + { + "pair": "beit_large_patch16_224 <-> resnet50", + "cka": 0.302, + "tau": 0.356, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.37, + "tau": 0.326, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitg14 <-> resnet50", + "cka": 0.395, + "tau": 0.354, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitl14 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.374, + "tau": 0.317, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ], + "type_c_similar_cka_different_tau": [ + { + "pair1": { + "name": "clip_vitl14 <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "cka": 0.582, + "tau": 0.005 + }, + "pair2": { + "name": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.601, + "tau": 0.619 + }, + "tau_gap": 0.614 + }, + { + "pair1": { + "name": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_large", + "cka": 0.59, + "tau": 0.009 + }, + "pair2": { + "name": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.601, + "tau": 0.619 + }, + "tau_gap": 0.61 + }, + { + "pair1": { + "name": "clip_vitl14 <-> convnext_base", + "cka": 0.599, + "tau": 0.009 + }, + "pair2": { + "name": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.601, + "tau": 0.619 + }, + "tau_gap": 0.61 + }, + { + "pair1": { + "name": "clip_vitl14 <-> swin_base_patch4_window7_224", + "cka": 0.609, + "tau": 0.02 + }, + "pair2": { + "name": "efficientnet_b0 <-> mixer_b16_224", + "cka": 0.601, + "tau": 0.619 + }, + "tau_gap": 0.598 + }, + { + "pair1": { + "name": "clip_vitb16 <-> clip_vitb32", + "cka": 0.713, + "tau": 0.744 + }, + "pair2": { + "name": "convnext_base <-> vit_large_patch16_224", + "cka": 0.693, + "tau": 0.155 + }, + "tau_gap": 0.589 + } + ], + "spearman_tau_cka": 0.721, + "variance_tau_unexplained_by_cka": 0.48 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/features/beit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features/beit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9f86f14ab494dc7749c8ee9261e45dd8dccf73cb --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/beit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ca83f401523133249dc85b9909f0530e520847d06718ac6df47c046180761b0d +size 15533899 diff --git a/data/features/beit_large_patch16_224.pt b/data/features/beit_large_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b572057c717c4b5862be7ad3f2d6ce2d02f5c820 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/beit_large_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c77cb6803d731e0508d6349da78e2c1ba9819c444831804046dfcc1b812681a9 +size 20711314 diff --git a/data/features/clip_vitb16.pt b/data/features/clip_vitb16.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e6dbc9659575de39eeeec267feb3d3e00b59d8f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/clip_vitb16.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:2d48bb1ca6ba13d6d5892802ed96baf06050eecaf54d2602de69d65d51400ae8 +size 10356485 diff --git a/data/features/clip_vitb16_text.pt b/data/features/clip_vitb16_text.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..11574ab14a3fa93ca30ce9e7353cbf61d4f02749 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/clip_vitb16_text.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d28d51dcc8e765b01a6da92fc66659fe87b52ca19c1ca51ee02c07b4e9e29d54 +size 10241832 diff --git a/data/features/clip_vitb32.pt b/data/features/clip_vitb32.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..844cfd0ceac7c04e1de13efaa590c0baa4ee8e3e --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/clip_vitb32.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5754ae791662607d00abbaec1744b0c102ddf6ea3aa2469a78f734c2e24bb11a +size 10356485 diff --git a/data/features/clip_vitl14.pt b/data/features/clip_vitl14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..71995d71d33b72073518eaa16cd04d90d36dff1f --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/clip_vitl14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d0bb1e930d2b6a0c1b8c20b1edc794536a39212d42a4bd1eb0364003f4c67e51 +size 15533829 diff --git a/data/features/clip_vitl14_text.pt b/data/features/clip_vitl14_text.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd3184d45f878cbe90231b6c68c9809f380ea586 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/clip_vitl14_text.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e53f231514d0b801334ee2d886e43a2707303d0a3de27dea5974df88a46fdd58 +size 15361832 diff --git a/data/features/convnext_base.pt b/data/features/convnext_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba3f18d32d679f7047cc3cbb4857d37ba1d8d206 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/convnext_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:60762a758a5b2f7bf8efc32deb925880d75a0e7e6479575d08ae730a32bd511e +size 20711187 diff --git a/data/features/convnext_large.pt b/data/features/convnext_large.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3748cc06b02c8d993f72f423b52d09e5915ca42c --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/convnext_large.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:2b683b885d32f38915137c80962abecc899f3d5eb4fd4d5f5b1b81db7292c1d2 +size 31065882 diff --git a/data/features/dinov2_vitb14.pt b/data/features/dinov2_vitb14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bdf8602fa1db279949a30389e1c997848fa87c92 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/dinov2_vitb14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:849bd1c9842a43c89aefc2a906b3275dc175d4f83c73c3364c1ff8763bbfbde5 +size 15533843 diff --git a/data/features/dinov2_vitg14.pt b/data/features/dinov2_vitg14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..43b7841c5cc051323800261f2c0a87dcc3e00e74 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/dinov2_vitg14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c8f02c19904665c6cf859d5d3900f2eafc0a9fc468f88faedee19022a66c7a63 +size 31065875 diff --git a/data/features/dinov2_vitl14.pt b/data/features/dinov2_vitl14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fb31827e9ef34a668671c9e8936b6332c51ddd21 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/dinov2_vitl14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f846af60f3f9135604a5e80e4ebdf1352b1ec47d794f648fe3d46f593d14ae5a +size 20711187 diff --git a/data/features/dinov2_vits14.pt b/data/features/dinov2_vits14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4a4503eddfaf529a425d055ec90e7da7a48284ae --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/dinov2_vits14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:caff35402d97fa11a4dccb1f01c35e1edcf39a495a1511d7c3861a421b9926d3 +size 7767827 diff --git a/data/features/efficientnet_b0.pt b/data/features/efficientnet_b0.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8594aebcb7170dac79230c77bf0283210f5801e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/efficientnet_b0.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a26e40cf0ffd6ee7ab13d30396b18ab12a8be33984b826c54844766d7a6ac19d +size 25888545 diff --git a/data/features/mixer_b16_224.pt b/data/features/mixer_b16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..52e7eefc534ebca8c7865236070e45320d762b50 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/mixer_b16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c1b54146672fb8b41707ba09fda0a866e336fb5073b7eba4f303a25292219d2d +size 15533843 diff --git a/data/features/resnet101.pt b/data/features/resnet101.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b696704f3ffeca4747dbc81bbe9d8d1d8e16837d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/resnet101.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e7532fa329801c470daee3274a6d55161a7e5c0d3e7fdea2e6da29352a377bda +size 41420535 diff --git a/data/features/resnet50.pt b/data/features/resnet50.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5b66bf500a82ecd2087e9b7c4f8fa4f649392e8f --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/resnet50.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:754b9a4dfefd6a3d6e2d9f438b9593928b093921b5154f4e134d602cab918afa +size 41420528 diff --git a/data/features/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt b/data/features/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0d3048b139b5c6a18e925eccd5aed8dab46ee05 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:0957cd57d5ac330730c40339d1d5dd7fe899a44cb300432a54db0a4d00b86bda +size 20711356 diff --git a/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt b/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..66054714f85b57ab4b1de2fa6a34bc54b3ad5ac9 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5cec546a444072a8e9bd78b0e5e7b6e03d006fd419f57bda201f54c378e6726f +size 15533984 diff --git a/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..373caeebba631fd5664546889c2c7025e465fe30 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/vit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:424e1f918d8b8bc4101722451bf01e519d00edb821d6527977fd20b836b8ef29 +size 15533892 diff --git a/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt b/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a0a995743371b371d58c8213420c3d0eee22cfda --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:295b4eed5b0a88b95b7ae891c01cad438ade4e899e0a45887e708085aaea0fa2 +size 20711335 diff --git a/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.pt b/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a6f6ecdcc703ebd54ade0d0c1d12702430d830ee --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features/vit_large_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d020a0b194bbdfc0770f9ca961147e25ab7e51800d52a684f408622791597ff2 +size 20711243 diff --git a/data/features_external/test/convnextv2_base.pt b/data/features_external/test/convnextv2_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..52add55d13113e85a12e1ee3f7e98aba3c119451 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/test/convnextv2_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:67f4981bb7accc492623e61adb2b01b1eda8506796dc04981ce51d6c5c060911 +size 20481889 diff --git a/data/features_external/test/deit3_base_p16_224.pt b/data/features_external/test/deit3_base_p16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..879b61126fd12865cdd31b344694c12db8e46e60 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/test/deit3_base_p16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:472081a14f9059804bfc8360e1dc0c293122d66d10701003bfa0a62271573285 +size 15361910 diff --git a/data/features_external/test/dinov2_reg_base.pt b/data/features_external/test/dinov2_reg_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e853b946cdb4f9ec347f159761efd8876cde3ea2 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/test/dinov2_reg_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:152ff1f0db341998704d8132fe5d4f652edd3012afcb673a8bd8c5e0263f7957 +size 15361889 diff --git a/data/features_external/test/eva02_base_p14_224.pt b/data/features_external/test/eva02_base_p14_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5b3c0fd3e42ad83eba08c566507e8a4ac79f3abf --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/test/eva02_base_p14_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a3fa167376f335c9e98dfd544adb32e9687f1242155b3fd5ec15a3dd890a8291 +size 15361910 diff --git a/data/features_external/test/siglip_base_p16_224.pt b/data/features_external/test/siglip_base_p16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eb2212e4bba0ed973c2d33531c84a9dd5eeacb59 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/test/siglip_base_p16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f58238bb4241012f726c791e945aab41c53df1f277ffc6a291bab9f465623073 +size 15361917 diff --git a/data/features_external/train/convnextv2_base.pt b/data/features_external/train/convnextv2_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d5e2dc7ff716c1b191784bdbb3068f5549d8799a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/train/convnextv2_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:49b306d284ca0159feee6d729315a3e634aec1061b6ade83039387dd49ed136a +size 20481889 diff --git a/data/features_external/train/deit3_base_p16_224.pt b/data/features_external/train/deit3_base_p16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2658f4789fb40fee774e97683b846ccdb99dba86 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/train/deit3_base_p16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b5a5c46437d85619dc0e6dc290b321db48042ddeb6dae61d827d7d8fde348456 +size 15361910 diff --git a/data/features_external/train/dinov2_reg_base.pt b/data/features_external/train/dinov2_reg_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6e6e74f9af14fe39bab2c830b42c3259304757c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/train/dinov2_reg_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8bfeadf8e17321b7dbca9d8d36532567b39835bebf09b1a7db611a9d17638545 +size 15361889 diff --git a/data/features_external/train/eva02_base_p14_224.pt b/data/features_external/train/eva02_base_p14_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e5e027704f79c50d10da366a94bd2254bfadba0f --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/train/eva02_base_p14_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ce9c7c5ca2ff101f76bf75988fb12f5168f8764876d87a77b3c1f8693033be00 +size 15361910 diff --git a/data/features_external/train/siglip_base_p16_224.pt b/data/features_external/train/siglip_base_p16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..34af8795f724d58ede33fab087de662695c1c948 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_external/train/siglip_base_p16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cc74029afdf51b38fa79d9a9cd8d987b86dc517ceb957252bcd9543fe387b4c7 +size 15361917 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/beit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_stl10/beit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..99f73247a924b966e552dfca8e3ff61e149e2feb --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/beit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f50d83a38b2ddbbbcfac0f31ef92a82ce5c588a293009ef312b01688b3c46757 +size 15533835 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/clip_vitl14.pt b/data/features_stl10/clip_vitl14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e2a3dc2eb22759b6ab5d3679cd5464d6c6fa9055 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/clip_vitl14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a9d123c9f068a5db3bc2498f47748a9084d696a56b04ab56ff4d53ddd0e9879f +size 15533765 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/convnext_base.pt b/data/features_stl10/convnext_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58885a232e9262b403d9e28a6e5b4085d056419a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/convnext_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:951f44e3ba8b2039bb07773b5a1fe04b641c9f71b8908fdc299d895dc58eb3e5 +size 20711123 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/dinov2_vitb14.pt b/data/features_stl10/dinov2_vitb14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6b55e2da35d5566f0525c60e30be4c1c6fc4a508 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/dinov2_vitb14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:3f7bdcf69b2a40bfde98b4a8d5689919f36411c9d5a13f3f0a3e8687eaa9884c +size 15533779 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/mixer_b16_224.pt b/data/features_stl10/mixer_b16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2a6e3d040d91d09491c02a818296cbe8e5fc400a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/mixer_b16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:167210cdb2dd97aadcece7f9482dcb8b53511ecc25f8b36b174a373d169ff123 +size 15533779 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/resnet50.pt b/data/features_stl10/resnet50.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..06a9663e373f6acf8f24e2f1852c17d9ae296785 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/resnet50.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5de23a622fea865016b9347028987dfcb573e4c6066ef045cf2f5e076275ea8d +size 41420464 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt b/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c43ea05819230e136bb4f64fcf3e84e40f47198 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:51dc25e16b4d6f58bac003ad09618253720ff18d2df7be087bbc8e7c9aec652f +size 15533920 diff --git a/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31fe516256add4d070ba5e5866312738d6806db7 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_stl10/vit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fa1d519d65ff16ee3706cba21eb142580cc3a655521adb330be1f67dfdd2ff0d +size 15533828 diff --git a/data/features_train/beit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_train/beit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b0eda141e2d17bfb9e129b8d1e78b84c4cd659a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/beit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:976093835e969549f1a8bef8eef7820724f04c6ef3a54f6cb9cd867ede98eacd +size 15361931 diff --git a/data/features_train/beit_large_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_train/beit_large_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8230912f09b3819c6b839e33e4771b4e2cf6cd45 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/beit_large_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:504d7590299e213239119a827d149bf0f19400dbb575d7ce83f97cf01fd87b3f +size 20482002 diff --git a/data/features_train/clip_vitb16.pt b/data/features_train/clip_vitb16.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5e7cd88e4d0715c470662c512e81065be20b2820 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/clip_vitb16.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a9b50667d3ecb866369f01aee7a24d165d9f8544216a50c6aff2c623383877b2 +size 10241861 diff --git a/data/features_train/clip_vitb32.pt b/data/features_train/clip_vitb32.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eea6980f8153d3d54ccd6f33ed7232f238f80029 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/clip_vitb32.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e4f373dddafec7b904ec46702b2c1fd97e2dc1b572e9e18b32f4373d80d0c7c2 +size 10241861 diff --git a/data/features_train/clip_vitl14.pt b/data/features_train/clip_vitl14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5e864796c5d1824078766c5a3d99a82ed3dd94ec --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/clip_vitl14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:20fce1cc18306dc6fad36ccefcb8881202ac8297412d8780885cbe8edc92e1f7 +size 15361861 diff --git a/data/features_train/convnext_base.pt b/data/features_train/convnext_base.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3f026b2c026c1fd9336e60810b8576e71a69a42 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/convnext_base.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:e9d2a86753b52cd50f5788cdcad47c092498a7af0ea04656b4211d7714c38805 +size 20481875 diff --git a/data/features_train/convnext_large.pt b/data/features_train/convnext_large.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..11de8f4ea3785df36e9ca2d8c7cfe1eb1bb794c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/convnext_large.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:45b0e813e3345729114c37715c13bc9841e89ab75145aa292631b9187888f132 +size 30721882 diff --git a/data/features_train/dinov2_vitb14.pt b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitb14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..20b0d5eed8f538d05ee83aed95318abdcb7f1017 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitb14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:2cb9c6b845dd1869675ed1b995818d0afaeb61f5dd209f424dda859a804395d9 +size 15361875 diff --git a/data/features_train/dinov2_vitg14.pt b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitg14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..95627e4e80afdc731f5c99c3ed22bf345a45d531 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitg14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cb2726d25bbec4bfe64d3a34db2efe8f316eafd0adb318c6ebc5e2410cd4d2e8 +size 30721875 diff --git a/data/features_train/dinov2_vitl14.pt b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitl14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c1d281e161e0110bdab84a8fd3744598646f7708 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/dinov2_vitl14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:9ab2fa833dbdacf6d800173186141b57088f9acd496559960911dfb61e8d1a99 +size 20481875 diff --git a/data/features_train/dinov2_vits14.pt b/data/features_train/dinov2_vits14.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b3b570945998a96ef0156de956b3f2f28338ef4 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/dinov2_vits14.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f8c2194ef5c9a8e0eb6370d97dbf03f2bce3bc8ea586ddccabaf7b4c8a55db21 +size 7681875 diff --git a/data/features_train/efficientnet_b0.pt b/data/features_train/efficientnet_b0.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cac6e6ee382a9692dfba78a5e512c1cfaa6a6eaa --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/efficientnet_b0.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:2753d9f3240790005997e3cf12fb58c3874212fa16257361aa617a46fcf8d18b +size 25601889 diff --git a/data/features_train/mixer_b16_224.pt b/data/features_train/mixer_b16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4abd063036bd6663184aa0658177fe2cfb55093d --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/mixer_b16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:eeb913f437af0bd4864307ab51c34b74120a8c354b799a9af5343a3df13704b1 +size 15361875 diff --git a/data/features_train/resnet101.pt b/data/features_train/resnet101.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bbc470f657237ca8d21ee6e30db2fb6bbd90fc11 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/resnet101.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fe756944e053ac0055dd57f8b8148b0e549fbad18056c26be180e08828a10982 +size 40961847 diff --git a/data/features_train/resnet50.pt b/data/features_train/resnet50.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b823a9ad96cde057d73c13a4360d89caf60c100a --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/resnet50.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:397e74424accfba457364a74f45ad6269bc84fd66188824dd060ea73d1ce811d +size 40961776 diff --git a/data/features_train/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt b/data/features_train/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..33de26facb75f7c0df8d813b5dc314170fa51a07 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/swin_base_patch4_window7_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:0b7810d3e25c1fa77fe828b051694cd6b332a36f5c8a424b1250fe0339f476c5 +size 20482044 diff --git a/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt b/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cf3be7723cc79aea0eccedfd37ae2ad0df5c9cb0 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.mae.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:61525c1a64f6f7c035525e643440989908d2cfd3272e75aa607ff16c5acd6890 +size 15362016 diff --git a/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..db1c0bc745ba68d9b218e028f427e80878e28a78 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/vit_base_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:2d27bc05c443c794a602806344f55b89fbbffdce602b3b054bd1321cd6d7a195 +size 15361924 diff --git a/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt b/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..42262e02b222628745423ac525a2071daae78072 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.mae.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f69a03435b4698ee077fc8a251b3fa25bdabd8c7db7ee85fcb9ff9ff997bcaae +size 20482023 diff --git a/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.pt b/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.pt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6748804d534c3960b780e6a25e4c46220134b022 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/features_train/vit_large_patch16_224.pt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c51093c3650a1a3a07953126a011076c86778b21db5af0ff00ca25776a0ee4e4 +size 20481931 diff --git a/data/llm_atlas.json b/data/llm_atlas.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a3c28d79f6d535073324c4354568f33ea6277668 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/llm_atlas.json @@ -0,0 +1,742 @@ +{ + "models": { + "pythia-410m": { + "bitrate": 0.528, + "effective_rank": 1.4, + "dim": 1024, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 17, + "family": "pythia", + "params": "410M" + }, + "pythia-1.4b": { + "bitrate": 2.141, + "effective_rank": 4.4, + "dim": 2048, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 17, + "family": "pythia", + "params": "1.4B" + }, + "pythia-2.8b": { + "bitrate": 5.174, + "effective_rank": 36.1, + "dim": 2560, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 23, + "family": "pythia", + "params": "2.8B" + }, + "opt-1.3b": { + "bitrate": 7.585, + "effective_rank": 191.9, + "dim": 2048, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 17, + "family": "opt", + "params": "1.3B" + }, + "phi-2": { + "bitrate": 3.894, + "effective_rank": 14.9, + "dim": 2560, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 23, + "family": "phi", + "params": "2.7B" + }, + "gpt2-large": { + "bitrate": 5.463, + "effective_rank": 44.1, + "dim": 1280, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 26, + "family": "gpt2", + "params": "774M" + }, + "pythia-6.9b": { + "bitrate": 2.728, + "effective_rank": 6.6, + "dim": 4096, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 23, + "family": "pythia", + "params": "6.9B" + }, + "mistral-7b": { + "bitrate": 4.323, + "effective_rank": 20.0, + "dim": 4096, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 23, + "family": "mistral", + "params": "7.2B" + }, + "falcon-7b": { + "bitrate": 4.941, + "effective_rank": 30.7, + "dim": 4544, + "n_samples": 1940, + "rep_layer": 23, + "family": "falcon", + "params": "7.2B" + } + }, + "pairwise": { + "falcon-7b <-> gpt2-large": { + "s_local": 0.6301, + "s_global": 0.8774, + "lambda": 0.718, + "tau": 0.7165, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.9317, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7165, + "tai": 0.0052, + "delta": 0.522, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "gpt2" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> mistral-7b": { + "s_local": 0.6534, + "s_global": 0.929, + "lambda": 0.703, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3691, + "tai": 0.0324, + "delta": 0.619, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "mistral" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> opt-1.3b": { + "s_local": 0.5864, + "s_global": 0.5835, + "lambda": 1.005, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.384, + "tai": 0.1807, + "delta": 2.643, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "opt" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> phi-2": { + "s_local": 0.6349, + "s_global": 0.8127, + "lambda": 0.781, + "tau": 0.7006, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8496, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7006, + "tai": 0.0664, + "delta": 1.048, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "phi" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> pythia-1.4b": { + "s_local": 0.5708, + "s_global": 0.7122, + "lambda": 0.802, + "tau": 0.4468, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6663, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4468, + "tai": 0.1164, + "delta": 2.8, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.6657, + "s_global": 0.6899, + "lambda": 0.965, + "tau": 0.6821, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8089, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6821, + "tai": 0.0339, + "delta": 0.232, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.423, + "s_global": 0.6895, + "lambda": 0.613, + "tau": 0.3566, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3566, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.4926, + "tai": 0.163, + "delta": 4.413, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "falcon-7b <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.6183, + "s_global": 0.6556, + "lambda": 0.943, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4508, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.1027, + "delta": 2.213, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "falcon", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> mistral-7b": { + "s_local": 0.5174, + "s_global": 0.8272, + "lambda": 0.625, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3042, + "tai": 0.0569, + "delta": 1.141, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "mistral" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> opt-1.3b": { + "s_local": 0.7051, + "s_global": 0.6269, + "lambda": 1.125, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.3788, + "tai": 0.1727, + "delta": 2.121, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "opt" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> phi-2": { + "s_local": 0.5948, + "s_global": 0.8227, + "lambda": 0.723, + "tau": 0.7866, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7866, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8567, + "tai": 0.0788, + "delta": 1.569, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "phi" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> pythia-1.4b": { + "s_local": 0.5542, + "s_global": 0.7268, + "lambda": 0.762, + "tau": 0.583, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.583, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6395, + "tai": 0.1249, + "delta": 3.322, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.6175, + "s_global": 0.6487, + "lambda": 0.952, + "tau": 0.7179, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7179, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8226, + "tai": 0.0265, + "delta": 0.29, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.4519, + "s_global": 0.7418, + "lambda": 0.609, + "tau": 0.0139, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0139, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.5312, + "tai": 0.1573, + "delta": 4.935, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "gpt2-large <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.542, + "s_global": 0.6424, + "lambda": 0.844, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.4948, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.1057, + "delta": 2.735, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "gpt2", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> opt-1.3b": { + "s_local": 0.4816, + "s_global": 0.5705, + "lambda": 0.844, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6545, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.2244, + "delta": 3.262, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "opt" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> phi-2": { + "s_local": 0.6362, + "s_global": 0.8779, + "lambda": 0.725, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2952, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.015, + "delta": 0.429, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "phi" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> pythia-1.4b": { + "s_local": 0.5876, + "s_global": 0.7864, + "lambda": 0.747, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2551, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0929, + "delta": 2.182, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.5885, + "s_global": 0.7641, + "lambda": 0.77, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3055, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0068, + "delta": 0.851, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.4365, + "s_global": 0.7517, + "lambda": 0.581, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2919, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.1417, + "delta": 3.794, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "mistral-7b <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.6065, + "s_global": 0.7405, + "lambda": 0.819, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1187, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0585, + "delta": 1.594, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "mistral", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "opt-1.3b <-> phi-2": { + "s_local": 0.5558, + "s_global": 0.5875, + "lambda": 0.946, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2915, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.2221, + "delta": 3.691, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "opt", + "family_b": "phi" + }, + "opt-1.3b <-> pythia-1.4b": { + "s_local": 0.5053, + "s_global": 0.5151, + "lambda": 0.981, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.2178, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.2645, + "delta": 5.444, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "opt", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "opt-1.3b <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.5892, + "s_global": 0.6294, + "lambda": 0.936, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.356, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.1919, + "delta": 2.411, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "opt", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "opt-1.3b <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.4135, + "s_global": 0.4725, + "lambda": 0.875, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1667, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.3317, + "delta": 7.056, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "opt", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "opt-1.3b <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.5076, + "s_global": 0.5091, + "lambda": 0.997, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.1139, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.2499, + "delta": 4.856, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "opt", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "phi-2 <-> pythia-1.4b": { + "s_local": 0.6857, + "s_global": 0.9536, + "lambda": 0.719, + "tau": 0.907, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.907, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9484, + "tai": 0.0519, + "delta": 1.753, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "phi", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "phi-2 <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.6546, + "s_global": 0.8967, + "lambda": 0.73, + "tau": 0.8751, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.8751, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8858, + "tai": 0.0394, + "delta": 1.28, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "phi", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "phi-2 <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.5166, + "s_global": 0.9364, + "lambda": 0.552, + "tau": 0.5252, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5252, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.8223, + "tai": 0.103, + "delta": 3.365, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "phi", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "phi-2 <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.6767, + "s_global": 0.9178, + "lambda": 0.737, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6661, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0301, + "delta": 1.166, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "phi", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-1.4b <-> pythia-2.8b": { + "s_local": 0.6263, + "s_global": 0.9303, + "lambda": 0.673, + "tau": 0.7893, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7919, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.7893, + "tai": 0.0817, + "delta": 3.033, + "regime": "Convergent", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-1.4b <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.6211, + "s_global": 0.9865, + "lambda": 0.63, + "tau": 0.7733, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.7733, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.9156, + "tai": 0.0382, + "delta": 1.613, + "regime": "Collapsed", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-1.4b <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.693, + "s_global": 0.981, + "lambda": 0.706, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.6963, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0087, + "delta": 0.587, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-2.8b <-> pythia-410m": { + "s_local": 0.4322, + "s_global": 0.8755, + "lambda": 0.494, + "tau": 0.3533, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.3533, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.6573, + "tai": 0.144, + "delta": 4.645, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-2.8b <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.7211, + "s_global": 0.9601, + "lambda": 0.751, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5874, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0661, + "delta": 2.446, + "regime": "Local-Only", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + }, + "pythia-410m <-> pythia-6.9b": { + "s_local": 0.4779, + "s_global": 0.9525, + "lambda": 0.502, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.5285, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0584, + "delta": 2.2, + "regime": "Collapsed", + "family_a": "pythia", + "family_b": "pythia" + } + }, + "layerwise": { + "pythia-410m <-> pythia-2.8b": [ + { + "frac_depth": 0.0, + "layer_a": 0, + "layer_b": 0, + "s_local": 0.7828, + "s_global": 0.9769 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.25, + "layer_a": 5, + "layer_b": 7, + "s_local": 0.4564, + "s_global": 0.8146 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.5, + "layer_a": 11, + "layer_b": 15, + "s_local": 0.5113, + "s_global": 0.9845 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.75, + "layer_a": 17, + "layer_b": 23, + "s_local": 0.4322, + "s_global": 0.8755 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 1.0, + "layer_a": 23, + "layer_b": 31, + "s_local": 0.6385, + "s_global": 0.2867 + } + ], + "pythia-1.4b <-> opt-1.3b": [ + { + "frac_depth": 0.0, + "layer_a": 0, + "layer_b": 0, + "s_local": 0.5116, + "s_global": 0.6204 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.25, + "layer_a": 5, + "layer_b": 5, + "s_local": 0.4338, + "s_global": 0.8296 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.5, + "layer_a": 11, + "layer_b": 11, + "s_local": 0.4359, + "s_global": 0.7292 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.75, + "layer_a": 17, + "layer_b": 17, + "s_local": 0.5053, + "s_global": 0.5151 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 1.0, + "layer_a": 23, + "layer_b": 23, + "s_local": 0.6508, + "s_global": 0.3552 + } + ], + "phi-2 <-> gpt2-large": [ + { + "frac_depth": 0.0, + "layer_a": 0, + "layer_b": 0, + "s_local": 0.3664, + "s_global": 0.324 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.25, + "layer_a": 7, + "layer_b": 8, + "s_local": 0.4888, + "s_global": 0.8485 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.5, + "layer_a": 15, + "layer_b": 17, + "s_local": 0.5681, + "s_global": 0.9101 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.75, + "layer_a": 23, + "layer_b": 26, + "s_local": 0.5948, + "s_global": 0.8227 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 1.0, + "layer_a": 31, + "layer_b": 35, + "s_local": 0.6746, + "s_global": 0.8009 + } + ], + "mistral-7b <-> pythia-6.9b": [ + { + "frac_depth": 0.0, + "layer_a": 0, + "layer_b": 0, + "s_local": 0.5325, + "s_global": 0.7472 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.25, + "layer_a": 7, + "layer_b": 7, + "s_local": 0.4499, + "s_global": 0.7632 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.5, + "layer_a": 15, + "layer_b": 15, + "s_local": 0.5169, + "s_global": 0.7562 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.75, + "layer_a": 23, + "layer_b": 23, + "s_local": 0.6065, + "s_global": 0.7405 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 1.0, + "layer_a": 31, + "layer_b": 31, + "s_local": 0.649, + "s_global": 0.6476 + } + ], + "falcon-7b <-> mistral-7b": [ + { + "frac_depth": 0.0, + "layer_a": 0, + "layer_b": 0, + "s_local": 0.5486, + "s_global": 0.7899 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.25, + "layer_a": 7, + "layer_b": 7, + "s_local": 0.498, + "s_global": 0.9455 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.5, + "layer_a": 15, + "layer_b": 15, + "s_local": 0.5397, + "s_global": 0.9434 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 0.75, + "layer_a": 23, + "layer_b": 23, + "s_local": 0.6534, + "s_global": 0.929 + }, + { + "frac_depth": 1.0, + "layer_a": 31, + "layer_b": 31, + "s_local": 0.7615, + "s_global": 0.9334 + } + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/meta_analysis.csv b/data/meta_analysis.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..be3870be24faeb2bcfccafa0c591e86d1474c463 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/meta_analysis.csv @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +cite_key,short_name,year,thread,domain,scale,metric_type,metric_name,reported_value,bcct_regime,key_finding +prh2024,PRH,2024,convergence,vision,XL,alignment,mutual k-NN,Increasing with scale,Mixed,78 vision models converge toward shared statistical structure; alignment increases with model/data scale +groger2026aristotelian,Aristotelian,2026,convergence,vision,XL,alignment,null-calibrated k-NN,Global vanishes after calibration,Local-Only,"After null calibration, global convergence disappears; only local neighborhood structure survives" +crh2025,CRH,2025,convergence,vision,L,alignment,6 canonical relations,Universal alignment relations,Convergent,"Six alignment relations among representations, weights, and gradients universally govern feature formation" +park2026convergent,Convergent Reps,2026,convergence,multimodal,M,alignment,"CKA, k-NN",Multi-task drives convergence,Convergent,Multi-task training drives convergence in controlled city-coordinate worlds; divergent tasks actively harm it +chawla2026metaothello,Meta-Othello,2026,convergence,language,M,alignment,board probe accuracy,Task-dependent convergence,Mixed,"Mixed-variant board games confirm convergence is task-dependent, not universal" +kapoor2025convergent,Convergent early,2025,convergence,vision,M,alignment,epoch-wise k-NN,Crystallizes in epoch 1,Convergent,Nearly all alignment crystallizes within the first training epoch +dunlap2025divergent,Divergent Reps,2025,convergence,vision,L,alignment,representation divergence,Task-specific divergence,Divergent,Identifies conditions under which representations actively diverge rather than converge +calvo2026flatdino,FlatDINO,2026,convergence,vision,M,alignment,flatness + alignment,Flat minima align better,Convergent,Compressing to 32 tokens improves alignment; flat minima produce more convergent representations +kornblith2019similarity,CKA,2019,convergence,vision,M,alignment,CKA,CKA > invariance tests,N/A,CKA is more reliable than CCA-based metrics for comparing representations across architectures +raghu2017svcca,SVCCA,2017,convergence,vision,M,alignment,SVCCA,Layer-wise similarity,N/A,SVCCA reveals layer-wise representation dynamics during training +morcos2018pwcca,PWCCA,2018,convergence,vision,M,alignment,PWCCA,Projection-weighted CCA,N/A,Projection weighting removes sensitivity to noise dimensions in CCA-based comparisons +klabunde2023similarity,Similarity survey,2023,convergence,vision,XL,alignment,multiple,Metrics disagree,N/A,Comprehensive survey showing similarity metrics often disagree on representation comparisons +barannikov2022rtd,RTD,2022,convergence,vision,M,alignment,RTD (topological),Topological distance,N/A,Representation Topology Divergence captures structural differences missed by kernel-based metrics +williams2021generalized,Gen. Shape,2021,convergence,vision,M,alignment,shape metrics,Generalized shape framework,N/A,"Unifies Procrustes, CKA, and other metrics within a generalized shape analysis framework" +chen2020simclr,SimCLR,2020,convergence,vision,M,alignment,linear probe,76.5% ImageNet top-1,Local-Only,Contrastive SSL produces representations with high linear probe accuracy; temperature controls implicit bitrate +he2020moco,MoCo,2020,convergence,vision,M,alignment,linear probe,Momentum contrast,Local-Only,Momentum-based contrastive learning matches supervised pre-training in transfer quality +grill2020byol,BYOL,2020,convergence,vision,M,alignment,linear probe,74.3% without negatives,Local-Only,Self-supervised learning without negative pairs; predictor network acts as implicit spectral filter +caron2021dino,DINO,2021,convergence,vision,M,alignment,"k-NN, attention maps",Emergent segmentation,Local-Only,Self-distillation produces features with emergent semantic segmentation properties +oquab2024dinov2,DINOv2,2024,convergence,vision,L,alignment,multiple benchmarks,Universal visual features,Convergent,All-purpose visual features that approach universal representations; highest information density among SSL encoders +radford2021clip,CLIP,2021,convergence,cross_modal,XL,alignment,zero-shot transfer,76.2% ImageNet zero-shot,Convergent,Contrastive vision-language pre-training enables zero-shot transfer; highest transport linearity in BCCT atlas +sun2024evaclip,EVA-CLIP,2024,convergence,cross_modal,L,alignment,"zero-shot, linear probe",Improved CLIP at scale,Convergent,Improved training techniques push CLIP further toward universal representations +zhai2023siglip,SigLIP,2023,convergence,cross_modal,L,alignment,sigmoid loss,"Simpler loss, same quality",Convergent,"Sigmoid loss achieves SOTA alignment, suggesting cross-modal convergence is robust to loss choice" +elhage2022toymodels,Superposition,2022,convergence,language,S,alignment,feature geometry,Superposition mechanism,N/A,Networks develop superposition to represent more features than dimensions; mechanistic account of bitrate maximization +bricken2023monosemanticity,Monosemantic,2023,convergence,language,S,alignment,SAE features,Interpretable features,Convergent,Sparse autoencoders extract monosemantic features consistent across models +templeton2024scaling,Scaling SAEs,2024,convergence,language,M,alignment,SAE features at scale,Features scale with model,Convergent,Monosemantic features scale predictably with model size; more features discovered at larger scale +hernandez2024linearity,Linear relations,2024,convergence,language,M,alignment,linearity score,Linear encoding of relations,Convergent,"LLMs develop linear representations of semantic relations, supporting cross-model transport" +gurnee2024language,Space & Time,2024,convergence,language,M,alignment,probing accuracy,Spatial/temporal representations,Convergent,LLMs develop shared representations of space and time across model families +chen2025transferring,Transfer structs,2025,convergence,language,M,transport,cross-model transfer,Near-lossless transfer,Convergent,Internal structures can be transferred across LLMs with near-lossless quality +li2024othello,Othello-GPT,2024,convergence,language,S,alignment,world model probes,Emergent world model,Convergent,Sequence models trained on game transcripts develop emergent internal world representations +conneau2020xlmr,XLM-R,2020,convergence,language,XL,alignment,cross-lingual transfer,100+ languages aligned,Convergent,Multilingual models develop shared representations across 100+ languages at scale +pires2019multilingual,mBERT,2019,convergence,language,L,alignment,cross-lingual zero-shot,Surprising cross-lingual transfer,Local-Only,Multilingual BERT enables zero-shot cross-lingual transfer without explicit alignment objective +wu2019beto,Beto/Bentz/Becas,2019,convergence,language,M,alignment,cross-lingual probing,Similar internal structure,Local-Only,BERT models trained on different languages develop similar internal representations +yamins2014hierarchical,DNN-Brain RSA,2014,convergence,neuroscience,M,alignment,RSA,DNN-ventral stream match,Local-Only,DNNs trained on object recognition converge toward primate ventral stream representations +conwell2023what,DNN-Brain survey,2023,convergence,neuroscience,XL,alignment,multiple,Alignment is metric-sensitive,Mixed,DNN-brain alignment is significant but sensitive to similarity metric choice +soni2024metric,Metric sensitivity,2024,convergence,neuroscience,L,alignment,metric comparison,Metric choice alters conclusions,N/A,Metric choice can fundamentally alter conclusions about DNN-brain alignment +wakhloo2026manifold,Manifold capacity,2026,convergence,neuroscience,M,bitrate,manifold capacity,Information density metric,N/A,Manifold capacity is the neuroscience analogue of representation bitrate +kingma2014vae,VAE,2014,latent_design,vision,S,quality,ELBO,Principled latent framework,N/A,First principled framework for continuous latent spaces with explicit bitrate control via KL divergence +higgins2017betavae,beta-VAE,2017,latent_design,vision,S,quality,disentanglement,beta controls disentanglement,N/A,"Increasing beta decouples reconstruction from bottleneck constraint, encouraging disentangled factors" +oord2017vqvae,VQ-VAE,2017,latent_design,vision,S,quality,reconstruction,Discrete codebook latents,N/A,Discrete codebooks provide hard bitrate cap; strict R control via codebook size +razavi2019vqvae2,VQ-VAE-2,2019,latent_design,vision,M,quality,FID,Hierarchical discrete latents,N/A,Hierarchical discrete latents separate global from local structure at different bitrate levels +esser2021taming,VQGAN,2021,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"FID, LPIPS",FID ~7.9 on ImageNet,N/A,Adversarial + perceptual losses decouple perceptual quality from raw bitrate +rombach2022ldm,LDM/SD,2022,latent_design,vision,L,quality,FID,FID ~3.6 on ImageNet-256,N/A,Latent diffusion in 8x-compressed VAE space enables high-quality generation at reduced compute +ho2020ddpm,DDPM,2020,latent_design,vision,S,quality,"FID, IS",FID 3.17 on CIFAR-10,N/A,Denoising diffusion establishes progressive bottleneck; reverse process crystallizes structure +song2021score,Score SDE,2021,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"likelihood, FID",Unified SDE framework,N/A,Unifies SMLD and DDPM under continuous-time SDE; enables exact likelihood computation +dhariwal2021diffusion,Diff. beats GANs,2021,latent_design,vision,M,quality,FID,FID 2.97 on ImageNet-256,N/A,Diffusion models surpass GANs in image quality; classifier guidance provides dynamic bitrate boost +lipman2023flow,Flow Matching,2023,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"FID, likelihood",Deterministic vector field,N/A,Conditional flow matching learns deterministic transport from noise to data without SDE simulation +liu2023rectified,Rectified Flow,2023,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"FID, straightness",Straighter transport paths,N/A,Rectifying flow trajectories enables few-step generation; connects OT to generative modeling +esser2024sd3,SD3,2024,latent_design,vision,L,quality,"FID, human eval",SOTA text-to-image,N/A,Scaling rectified flow transformers achieves new SOTA in text-to-image generation +ul2026,Unified Latents,2026,latent_design,vision,L,bitrate,"bpd, FID, FVD","FID 1.4, FVD 1.3",N/A,First system with continuous bitrate control via diffusion prior; enables causal bitrate intervention +rae2025,RAE,2025,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"FID, rFID",Semantic latents from DINOv2,N/A,Using foundation model features as latent space accelerates diffusion training and improves quality +dcae2025,DC-AE,2025,latent_design,vision,M,quality,"rFID, PSNR",32x spatial compression,N/A,Deep compression at 32x preserves fidelity; tests limits of extreme bitrate reduction +bao2022beit,BEiT,2022,latent_design,vision,M,quality,top-1 accuracy,Discrete tokens for MIM,N/A,Hard bitrate limit via discrete tokens serves as powerful pretext for learning transportable features +tolstikhin2018wasserstein,WAE,2018,latent_design,vision,S,quality,"FID, reconstruction",OT-based regularization,N/A,Replacing KL with Wasserstein distance produces sharper reconstructions and better latent geometry +bansal2021stitching,Stitching,2021,transport,vision,L,transport,stitching accuracy,tau ~0.95 same-seed,Convergent,Thin linear layer bridges representations; Anna Karenina effect: good models are alike +moschella2023relative,Relative Reps,2023,transport,cross_modal,M,transport,zero-shot stitching,Zero-shot cross-model communication,Convergent,Kernel-based relative representations enable zero-shot latent communication without paired training +theseus2026,Theseus,2026,transport,vision,M,transport,cross-arch transfer,Task vector transport,Convergent,Task vectors transport across heterogeneous architectures via Procrustes alignment +fula2025,FuLA,2025,transport,vision,M,transport,functional alignment,Nonlinear alignment,Local-Only,Functional latent alignment extends transport to cross-objective pairs where linear maps fail +ifula2026,iFuLA,2026,transport,vision,M,transport,invariance-aware transport,Geometric constraints,Local-Only,Incorporating geometric constraints improves nonlinear transport robustness +aligned_sae2026,Aligned SAE,2026,transport,cross_modal,S,transport,bimodal atoms,Bimodal atoms carry alignment,Convergent,Specific bimodal subspaces carry the entirety of CLIP's cross-modal alignment signal +ilharco2023editing,Task Arithmetic,2023,transport,vision,M,transport,task accuracy,Additive task vectors,Convergent,Fine-tuning directions are linearly composable in weight space for task addition/removal +wortsman2022soups,Model Soups,2022,transport,vision,M,transport,OOD accuracy,Averaging improves OOD,Convergent,Weight averaging of fine-tuned models improves out-of-distribution generalization +ainsworth2023rebasin,Git Re-Basin,2023,transport,vision,M,transport,barrier height,Permutation removes barrier,Convergent,Loss barrier between models is largely a permutation symmetry artifact; re-basin enables merging +yadav2023ties,TIES-Merging,2023,transport,vision,M,transport,multi-task accuracy,Resolves sign conflicts,Convergent,Trimming + sign election + averaging resolves interference in multi-task merging +yu2024dare,DARE,2024,transport,language,M,transport,LLM benchmark accuracy,"90% dropout, rescale",Convergent,Random pruning of 90% of task vector entries + rescaling effectively reduces merge interference +matena2022fisher,Fisher Merging,2022,transport,vision,M,transport,Fisher-weighted acc.,Curvature-aware merging,Convergent,Fisher information weighting preserves critical parameters during model merging +stoica2024zipit,ZipIt,2024,transport,vision,M,transport,merged accuracy,Feature-based zipping,Local-Only,Merging layers by feature similarity enables fusion of models with different widths/architectures +frankle2020linear,Linear connectivity,2020,transport,vision,M,transport,loss barrier,Linear connectivity from same init,Convergent,Models from same initialization exhibit linear mode connectivity; different inits separated by barriers +cuturi2013sinkhorn,Sinkhorn,2013,transport,theory,N/A,theoretical,entropic OT,Efficient OT solver,N/A,Entropic regularization makes OT differentiable and scalable via Sinkhorn iterations +peyre2019computational,Comp. OT,2019,transport,theory,N/A,theoretical,OT survey,Comprehensive OT framework,N/A,Comprehensive computational OT framework including GW distance for heterogeneous space alignment +courty2017ot,OT Domain Adapt.,2017,transport,vision,M,transport,domain adaptation acc.,OT preserves semantics,Local-Only,OT-based domain adaptation preserves semantic structure under distribution shift +moreau2026probing,OT String Method,2026,transport,vision,M,transport,path energy,Sharp regime transitions,Mixed,Minimum energy paths between models reveal sharp phase transitions in alignment regimes +sotalign2026,SOTAlign,2026,transport,vision,M,transport,semi-supervised OT,Anchor-constrained OT,Local-Only,Semi-supervised OT with anchor samples significantly improves alignment under high TAI +achara2026multiway,Multi-Way OT,2026,transport,vision,L,transport,Wasserstein barycenter,Multi-model alignment,Convergent,Wasserstein barycenter enables simultaneous alignment of M models into a unified latent space +tong2024flow,OT-CFM,2024,transport,vision,M,quality,FID with OT coupling,Minibatch OT improves flow,N/A,Minibatch OT couplings improve flow matching; connects generative modeling to transport theory +tishby1999information,IB Principle,1999,theory,theory,N/A,theoretical,"I(X;Z), I(Z;Y)",IB framework,N/A,Information Bottleneck principle: optimal representations compress X while preserving information about Y +alemi2017deep,Deep VIB,2017,theory,theory,M,theoretical,variational IB,Tractable deep IB,N/A,Variational approximation makes IB tractable for deep networks; connects compression to generalization +shwartzziv2017opening,Opening Black Box,2017,theory,theory,S,theoretical,information plane,Compression phase observed,N/A,DNNs exhibit a compression phase in the information plane; sparked IB-in-DL debate +saxe2018information,IB critique,2018,theory,theory,S,theoretical,information plane,Compression is activation-dependent,N/A,"Compression in DNNs depends on activation function, not a universal training dynamic" +geoib2026,GeoIB,2026,theory,theory,M,theoretical,"Fisher-Rao, Jacobian",Geometric IB decomposition,N/A,I(X;Z) and I(Z;Y) decompose into Fisher-Rao (distribution) and Jacobian-Frobenius (geometry) terms +pereg2026representation,Rep. Rate,2026,theory,theory,N/A,theoretical,representation rate,Fundamental limits,N/A,Defines representation rate and derives fundamental limits determined by source entropy +papyan2020neural,Neural Collapse,2020,theory,vision,M,alignment,NC metrics,Simplex ETF geometry,Convergent,Terminal phase training produces simplex ETF geometry; ultimate convergence for classifiers +kaplan2020scaling,Scaling Laws,2020,theory,language,XL,theoretical,power-law fits,Loss ~ params^{-alpha},N/A,"Power-law scaling of loss with compute, data, and parameters; bitrate implications for convergence" +hoffmann2022chinchilla,Chinchilla,2022,theory,language,XL,theoretical,compute-optimal scaling,Data and params scale equally,N/A,Compute-optimal training scales data and parameters equally; implications for representation quality +wei2022emergent,Emergent abilities,2022,theory,language,XL,theoretical,capability emergence,Abilities emerge at scale,N/A,Certain capabilities emerge only at sufficient scale; possible phase transition in representation quality +schaeffer2023mirage,Mirage,2023,theory,language,XL,theoretical,metric choice,Emergence is metric-dependent,N/A,Apparent emergent abilities may be artifacts of nonlinear metric choice; echoes Aristotelian critique +baevski2020wav2vec2,wav2vec 2.0,2020,convergence,audio,L,alignment,contrastive loss,Self-supervised speech representations,Local-Only,"Self-supervised pretraining on speech via contrastive learning; learns contextualized representations from raw audio" +hsu2021hubert,HuBERT,2021,convergence,audio,L,alignment,masked prediction,Self-supervised speech representations,Local-Only,"Masked prediction of hidden units for speech; offline clustering provides pseudo-labels for self-supervised learning" +radford2023whisper,Whisper,2023,transport,audio,XL,transport,supervised ASR,Robust speech recognition via weak supervision,Convergent,"Large-scale weakly supervised ASR; 680K hours of labeled data; cross-lingual transfer via shared representations" diff --git a/data/stl10_vs_cifar100_comparison.json b/data/stl10_vs_cifar100_comparison.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8b31c79866c72e124b6356e665bfbbd8b055cd96 --- /dev/null +++ b/data/stl10_vs_cifar100_comparison.json @@ -0,0 +1,175 @@ +{ + "agreement_rate": 85.71428571428571, + "matches": 24, + "total": 28, + "pairs": [ + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x clip_vitl14", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x resnet50", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x vit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x convnext_base", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": false + }, + { + "pair": "dinov2_vitb14 x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x resnet50", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x vit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x convnext_base", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Convergent", + "match": false + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": false + }, + { + "pair": "clip_vitl14 x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 x vit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 x convnext_base", + "stl10_regime": "Convergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": false + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 x vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "resnet50 x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 x convnext_base", + "stl10_regime": "Convergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Convergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 x vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224 x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base x vit_base_patch16_224.mae", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "convnext_base x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae x beit_base_patch16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "vit_base_patch16_224.mae x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Divergent", + "cifar100_regime": "Divergent", + "match": true + }, + { + "pair": "beit_base_patch16_224 x mixer_b16_224", + "stl10_regime": "Local-Only", + "cifar100_regime": "Local-Only", + "match": true + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/data/video_atlas.json b/data/video_atlas.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4b2743a23933fff6d9f7b0c4d20609e419084b1c --- /dev/null +++ b/data/video_atlas.json @@ -0,0 +1,378 @@ +{ + "n_models": 6, + "n_pairs": 15, + "models": [ + { + "name": "mvit-v2-s", + "family": "mvit", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "r3d-18", + "family": "resnet3d", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 512 + }, + { + "name": "timesformer-base", + "family": "timesformer", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "videomae-base", + "family": "videomae", + "objective": "self-supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "vivit-base", + "family": "vivit", + "objective": "supervised", + "dim": 768 + }, + { + "name": "xclip-base", + "family": "xclip", + "objective": "contrastive", + "dim": 512 + } + ], + "regime_counts": { + "Local-Only": 11, + "Divergent": 4 + }, + "pairs": [ + { + "pair": "mvit-v2-s \u00d7 r3d-18", + "model_a": "mvit-v2-s", + "model_b": "r3d-18", + "family_a": "mvit", + "family_b": "resnet3d", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1307, + "s_local_raw": 0.1482, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.5319, + "lambda": 0.2458, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 6.07, + "delta": 0.15, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mvit-v2-s \u00d7 timesformer-base", + "model_a": "mvit-v2-s", + "model_b": "timesformer-base", + "family_a": "mvit", + "family_b": "timesformer", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.2168, + "s_local_raw": 0.2324, + "null_mean": 0.0199, + "s_global": 0.6752, + "lambda": 0.3211, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 7.07, + "delta": 1.16, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mvit-v2-s \u00d7 videomae-base", + "model_a": "mvit-v2-s", + "model_b": "videomae-base", + "family_a": "mvit", + "family_b": "videomae", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.0338, + "s_local_raw": 0.0532, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.1597, + "lambda": 0.2114, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 5.23, + "delta": 0.69, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "mvit-v2-s \u00d7 vivit-base", + "model_a": "mvit-v2-s", + "model_b": "vivit-base", + "family_a": "mvit", + "family_b": "vivit", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1873, + "s_local_raw": 0.2036, + "null_mean": 0.02, + "s_global": 0.5565, + "lambda": 0.3367, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 6.95, + "delta": 1.03, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "mvit-v2-s \u00d7 xclip-base", + "model_a": "mvit-v2-s", + "model_b": "xclip-base", + "family_a": "mvit", + "family_b": "xclip", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "contrastive", + "s_local": 0.203, + "s_local_raw": 0.219, + "null_mean": 0.02, + "s_global": 0.6046, + "lambda": 0.3358, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.92, + "bitrate_b": 6.4, + "delta": 0.48, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "r3d-18 \u00d7 timesformer-base", + "model_a": "r3d-18", + "model_b": "timesformer-base", + "family_a": "resnet3d", + "family_b": "timesformer", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1501, + "s_local_raw": 0.1672, + "null_mean": 0.0202, + "s_global": 0.5262, + "lambda": 0.2852, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.07, + "bitrate_b": 7.07, + "delta": 1.0, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "r3d-18 \u00d7 videomae-base", + "model_a": "r3d-18", + "model_b": "videomae-base", + "family_a": "resnet3d", + "family_b": "videomae", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.0513, + "s_local_raw": 0.0704, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.2011, + "lambda": 0.2552, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.07, + "bitrate_b": 5.23, + "delta": 0.84, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "r3d-18 \u00d7 vivit-base", + "model_a": "r3d-18", + "model_b": "vivit-base", + "family_a": "resnet3d", + "family_b": "vivit", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.1291, + "s_local_raw": 0.1466, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.4402, + "lambda": 0.2933, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 1.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.07, + "bitrate_b": 6.95, + "delta": 0.88, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "r3d-18 \u00d7 xclip-base", + "model_a": "r3d-18", + "model_b": "xclip-base", + "family_a": "resnet3d", + "family_b": "xclip", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "contrastive", + "s_local": 0.1198, + "s_local_raw": 0.1376, + "null_mean": 0.0202, + "s_global": 0.4398, + "lambda": 0.2725, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 6.07, + "bitrate_b": 6.4, + "delta": 0.33, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "timesformer-base \u00d7 videomae-base", + "model_a": "timesformer-base", + "model_b": "videomae-base", + "family_a": "timesformer", + "family_b": "videomae", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "self-supervised", + "s_local": 0.0316, + "s_local_raw": 0.051, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.1619, + "lambda": 0.1951, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 7.07, + "bitrate_b": 5.23, + "delta": 1.85, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "timesformer-base \u00d7 vivit-base", + "model_a": "timesformer-base", + "model_b": "vivit-base", + "family_a": "timesformer", + "family_b": "vivit", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.5093, + "s_local_raw": 0.5192, + "null_mean": 0.0202, + "s_global": 0.766, + "lambda": 0.6649, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0106, + "bitrate_a": 7.07, + "bitrate_b": 6.95, + "delta": 0.13, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "timesformer-base \u00d7 xclip-base", + "model_a": "timesformer-base", + "model_b": "xclip-base", + "family_a": "timesformer", + "family_b": "xclip", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "contrastive", + "s_local": 0.4367, + "s_local_raw": 0.448, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.7706, + "lambda": 0.5667, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.1188, + "tai": 0.4063, + "bitrate_a": 7.07, + "bitrate_b": 6.4, + "delta": 0.68, + "regime": "Local-Only" + }, + { + "pair": "videomae-base \u00d7 vivit-base", + "model_a": "videomae-base", + "model_b": "vivit-base", + "family_a": "videomae", + "family_b": "vivit", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "supervised", + "s_local": 0.0308, + "s_local_raw": 0.0502, + "null_mean": 0.02, + "s_global": 0.1396, + "lambda": 0.2204, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.23, + "bitrate_b": 6.95, + "delta": 1.72, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "videomae-base \u00d7 xclip-base", + "model_a": "videomae-base", + "model_b": "xclip-base", + "family_a": "videomae", + "family_b": "xclip", + "objective_a": "self-supervised", + "objective_b": "contrastive", + "s_local": 0.0285, + "s_local_raw": 0.048, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.1415, + "lambda": 0.2013, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.0, + "bitrate_a": 5.23, + "bitrate_b": 6.4, + "delta": 1.17, + "regime": "Divergent" + }, + { + "pair": "vivit-base \u00d7 xclip-base", + "model_a": "vivit-base", + "model_b": "xclip-base", + "family_a": "vivit", + "family_b": "xclip", + "objective_a": "supervised", + "objective_b": "contrastive", + "s_local": 0.4112, + "s_local_raw": 0.423, + "null_mean": 0.0201, + "s_global": 0.6947, + "lambda": 0.5919, + "tau": 0.0, + "tau_a_to_b": 0.0, + "tau_b_to_a": 0.0, + "tai": 0.6113, + "bitrate_a": 6.95, + "bitrate_b": 6.4, + "delta": 0.55, + "regime": "Local-Only" + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file