Claim: Although The Gaslight Anthem had released their debut album and their second album with SideOneDummy, they announced via Facebook on Oct. 6, 2011, that they had signed with Mercury Records, and that they were sorry to leave their friends at SideOneDummy.
Evidence: The '59 Sound, the band's second album and first for SideOneDummy, was released in August 2008 and debuted at number seventy on the US Billboard 200 and fifty-five on the UK Albums Chart, and went Gold in the UK. 
The Gaslight Anthem released their debut album, Sink or Swim, on XOXO Records in May 2007, and their second album, The '59 Sound, on SideOneDummy Records in August 2008.