Claim: Redeemer of Souls received positive reviews from music critics, including PopMatters giving it nine out of ten ratings.
Evidence: Redeemer of Souls has been largely praised by critics and has been hailed as a return for the band, following the lackluster response to its previous album Nostradamus. Blabbermouth 8/10 PopMatters 9/10 Metal Hammer 8/10 Drowned in Sound 7/10 Sputnikmusic 3/5