Question: In what manner do they evaluate the model output for sentence completion tasks?
Evidence: Recently there has been a considerable interest in language modeling due to various academic and commercial demands. Academically, many studies have investigated this domain such as machine translation, chat-bot, message generation, image tagging and other language-related areas. Commercially, it can be used as a core technology for providing a new application on consumer products or services. For instance, an automatic message-reply prediction service can be launched in mobile devices, thus helping a user to send a reply message when he/she is not provided with a proper input interface.
To model the language of human dialogue, a recurrent neural network (RNN) structure is known to show the state of the arts performance with its ability to learn a sequential pattern of the data BIBREF0 . Among the RNN structures, a Long Short-Term Memory RNN (LSTM-RNN) and its variants are successfully used for language modeling tasks BIBREF1 , BIBREF2 . However, as a kind of deep learning technique, the LSTM-RNN and the RNN structure requires both a large number of data and huge computing power to train the model properly. Hence any attempts for applying the RNN structure to personalized language modeling are mainly constrained by the following two limitations. First, personal mobile devices contain private message data among close acquaintances, so users seldom agree to transfer their log out of the devices. This causes a limitation of gathering the whole user data to common computing spaces, where high-performance machines are available. Second, in relatively small computing machines, i.e., smart phone, it is not always-guaranteed to have enough resources to train a deep model within the devices.
To resolve these limitations, we propose fast transfer learning schemes. It trains a base model with a large dataset and copies its first n-many layers to the first n-many layers of a target model. Then the target model is fine-tuned with relatively small target data. Several learning schemes such as freezing a certain layer or adding a surplus layer are proposed for achieving the result. In experiments, we trained a general language model with huge corpus such as an Workshop on Statistical Machine Translation (WMT) data and a movie script data by using powerful computing machines, and then transferred the model to target environment for updating to be a personalized language model. With this approach, the final model can mimic target user's language style with proper syntax.
In the experiments, we trained the general language model with literary-style data and applied the transfer learning with spoken-style data. Then we evaluated the model output for sentence completion task in a qualitative and a quantitative manner. The test result showed that the model learned the style of the target language properly. Another test was conducted by training the general language model with the script of the drama, “Friends," and by applying transfer learning with main character corpora from the script to generate the personalized language model. The message-reply prediction task was evaluated with this model. The test result shows higher similarity between the output of the personalized language model and the same user dialogue than the one between the output of the personalized language model and other users' dialogues.
The contributions of this paper are as follows. First, we propose efficient transfer learning schemes for personalized language modeling, which is the first research on transfer learning for RNN based language models with privacy preserving. Second, we show the applicability of our research to the target scenario in the short message reply application by training the model in the similar environment to that of the mobile device, and highlight its test results.
In the experiments, we trained the general language model with literary-style data and applied the transfer learning with spoken-style data. Then we evaluated the model output for sentence completion task in a qualitative and a quantitative manner.
Answer: In a qualitative and a quantitative manner.