Question: Does their method outperform existing state-of-the-art models?
Evidence: Since the advent of large structured knowledge bases (KBs) like Freebase BIBREF0 , YAGO BIBREF1 and DBpedia BIBREF2 , answering natural language questions using those structured KBs, also known as KB-based question answering (or KB-QA), is attracting increasing research efforts from both natural language processing and information retrieval communities.
The state-of-the-art methods for this task can be roughly categorized into two streams. The first is based on semantic parsing BIBREF3 , BIBREF4 , which typically learns a grammar that can parse natural language to a sophisticated meaning representation language. But such sophistication requires a lot of annotated training examples that contains compositional structures, a practically impossible solution for large KBs such as Freebase. Furthermore, mismatches between grammar predicted structures and KB structure is also a common problem BIBREF4 , BIBREF5 , BIBREF6 .
On the other hand, instead of building a formal meaning representation, information extraction methods retrieve a set of candidate answers from KB using relation extraction BIBREF7 , BIBREF8 , BIBREF9 , BIBREF10 or distributed representations BIBREF11 , BIBREF12 . Designing large training datasets for these methods is relatively easy BIBREF7 , BIBREF13 , BIBREF14 . These methods are often good at producing an answer irrespective of their correctness. However, handling compositional questions that involve multiple entities and relations, still remains a challenge. Consider the question what mountain is the highest in north america. Relation extraction methods typically answer with all the mountains in North America because of the lack of sophisticated representation for the mathematical function highest. To select the correct answer, one has to retrieve all the heights of the mountains, and sort them in descending order, and then pick the first entry. We propose a method based on textual evidence which can answer such questions without solving the mathematic functions implicitly.
Knowledge bases like Freebase capture real world facts, and Web resources like Wikipedia provide a large repository of sentences that validate or support these facts. For example, a sentence in Wikipedia says, Denali (also known as Mount McKinley, its former official name) is the highest mountain peak in North America, with a summit elevation of 20,310 feet (6,190 m) above sea level. To answer our example question against a KB using a relation extractor, we can use this sentence as external evidence, filter out wrong answers and pick the correct one.
Using textual evidence not only mitigates representational issues in relation extraction, but also alleviates the data scarcity problem to some extent. Consider the question, who was queen isabella's mother. Answering this question involves predicting two constraints hidden in the word mother. One constraint is that the answer should be the parent of Isabella, and the other is that the answer's gender is female. Such words with multiple latent constraints have been a pain-in-the-neck for both semantic parsing and relation extraction, and requires larger training data (this phenomenon is coined as sub-lexical compositionality by wang2015). Most systems are good at triggering the parent constraint, but fail on the other, i.e., the answer entity should be female. Whereas the textual evidence from Wikipedia, ...her mother was Isabella of Barcelos ..., can act as a further constraint to answer the question correctly.
We present a novel method for question answering which infers on both structured and unstructured resources. Our method consists of two main steps as outlined in sec:overview. In the first step we extract answers for a given question using a structured KB (here Freebase) by jointly performing entity linking and relation extraction (sec:kb-qa). In the next step we validate these answers using an unstructured resource (here Wikipedia) to prune out the wrong answers and select the correct ones (sec:refine). Our evaluation results on a benchmark dataset WebQuestions show that our method outperforms existing state-of-the-art models. Details of our experimental setup and results are presented in sec:experiments. Our code, data and results can be downloaded from https://github.com/syxu828/QuestionAnsweringOverFB.
Our evaluation results on a benchmark dataset WebQuestions show that our method outperforms existing state-of-the-art models.
Answer: Yes.