Question: What are the contributions of this article?
Evidence: Wikipedia is the largest source of open and collaboratively curated knowledge in the world. Introduced in 2001, it has evolved into a reference work with around 5m pages for the English Wikipedia alone. In addition, entities and event pages are updated quickly via collaborative editing and all edits are encouraged to include source citations, creating a knowledge base which aims at being both timely as well as authoritative. As a result, it has become the preferred source of information consumption about entities and events. Moreso, this knowledge is harvested and utilized in building knowledge bases like YAGO BIBREF0 and DBpedia BIBREF1 , and used in applications like text categorization BIBREF2 , entity disambiguation BIBREF3 , entity ranking BIBREF4 and distant supervision BIBREF5 , BIBREF6 .
However, not all Wikipedia pages referring to entities (entity pages) are comprehensive: relevant information can either be missing or added with a delay. Consider the city of New Orleans and the state of Odisha which were severely affected by cyclones Hurricane Katrina and Odisha Cyclone, respectively. While Katrina finds extensive mention in the entity page for New Orleans, Odisha Cyclone which has 5 times more human casualties (cf. Figure FIGREF2 ) is not mentioned in the page for Odisha. Arguably Katrina and New Orleans are more popular entities, but Odisha Cyclone was also reported extensively in national and international news outlets. This highlights the lack of important facts in trunk and long-tail entity pages, even in the presence of relevant sources. In addition, previous studies have shown that there is an inherent delay or lag when facts are added to entity pages BIBREF7 .
To remedy these problems, it is important to identify information sources that contain novel and salient facts to a given entity page. However, not all information sources are equal. The online presence of major news outlets is an authoritative source due to active editorial control and their articles are also a timely container of facts. In addition, their use is in line with current Wikipedia editing practice, as is shown in BIBREF7 that almost 20% of current citations in all entity pages are news articles. We therefore propose news suggestion as a novel task that enhances entity pages and reduces delay while keeping its pages authoritative.
Existing efforts to populate Wikipedia BIBREF8 start from an entity page and then generate candidate documents about this entity using an external search engine (and then post-process them). However, such an approach lacks in (a) reproducibility since rankings vary with time with obvious bias to recent news (b) maintainability since document acquisition for each entity has to be periodically performed. To this effect, our news suggestion considers a news article as input, and determines if it is valuable for Wikipedia. Specifically, given an input news article INLINEFORM0 and a state of Wikipedia, the news suggestion problem identifies the entities mentioned in INLINEFORM1 whose entity pages can improve upon suggesting INLINEFORM2 . Most of the works on knowledge base acceleration BIBREF9 , BIBREF10 , BIBREF11 , or Wikipedia page generation BIBREF8 rely on high quality input sources which are then utilized to extract textual facts for Wikipedia page population. In this work, we do not suggest snippets or paraphrases but rather entire articles which have a high potential importance for entity pages. These suggested news articles could be consequently used for extraction, summarization or population either manually or automatically – all of which rely on high quality and relevant input sources.
We identify four properties of good news recommendations: salience, relative authority, novelty and placement. First, we need to identify the most salient entities in a news article. This is done to avoid pollution of entity pages with only marginally related news. Second, we need to determine whether the news is important to the entity as only the most relevant news should be added to a precise reference work. To do this, we compute the relative authority of all entities in the news article: we call an entity more authoritative than another if it is more popular or noteworthy in the real world. Entities with very high authority have many news items associated with them and only the most relevant of these should be included in Wikipedia whereas for entities of lower authority the threshold for inclusion of a news article will be lower. Third, a good recommendation should be able to identify novel news by minimizing redundancy coming from multiple news articles. Finally, addition of facts is facilitated if the recommendations are fine-grained, i.e., recommendations are made on the section level rather than the page level (placement).
Approach and Contributions. We propose a two-stage news suggestion approach to entity pages. In the first stage, we determine whether a news article should be suggested for an entity, based on the entity's salience in the news article, its relative authority and the novelty of the article to the entity page. The second stage takes into account the class of the entity for which the news is suggested and constructs section templates from entities of the same class. The generation of such templates has the advantage of suggesting and expanding entity pages that do not have a complete section structure in Wikipedia, explicitly addressing long-tail and trunk entities. Afterwards, based on the constructed template our method determines the best fit for the news article with one of the sections.
We evaluate the proposed approach on a news corpus consisting of 351,982 articles crawled from the news external references in Wikipedia from 73,734 entity pages. Given the Wikipedia snapshot at a given year (in our case [2009-2014]), we suggest news articles that might be cited in the coming years. The existing news references in the entity pages along with their reference date act as our ground-truth to evaluate our approach. In summary, we make the following contributions.
In summary, we make the following contributions. • we propose a two-stage news suggestion approach for Wikipedia entity pages. • we adopt and address the problem of determining whether a news article should be referenced to an entity considering the entity salience, relative authority and novelty of the article for the entity page. • we are able to place articles in a specific section of the entity page. Through section templates, we address the problems of entities with a limited section structure by class-based generalization i.e. we can expand entity pages with sections that come from entities of a similar class. • an extensive evaluation on 351,982 news articles and 73,734 entity pages, using their state for the years [2009-2013].
Answer: • They propose a two-stage news suggestion approach for Wikipedia entity pages. • They adopt and address the problem of determining whether a news article should be referenced to an entity considering the entity salience, relative authority and novelty of the article for the entity page.• They are able to place articles in a specific section of the entity page.• An extensive evaluation on 351,982 news articles and 73,734 entity pages, using their state for the years.