Treaty Clause - wikipedia Treaty Clause This article is part of a series on the Constitution of the United States of America Preamble and Articles of the Constitution Preamble II III IV V VI VII Amendments to the Constitution Bill of Rights II III IV V VI VII VIII IX X XI XII XIII XIV XV XVI XVII XVIII XIX XX XXI XXII XXIII XXIV XXV XXVI XXVII Unratified Amendments Congressional Apportionment Titles of Nobility Corwin Child Labor Equal Rights D.C. Voting Rights History Drafting and ratification timeline Convention Signing Federalism Republicanism Full text of the Constitution and Amendments Preamble and Articles I -- VII Amendments I -- X Amendments XI -- XXVII Unratified Amendments United States portal U.S. Government portal Law portal Wikipedia book Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the United States Constitution, includes the Treaty Clause, which empowers the president of the United States to propose and chiefly negotiate agreements, which must be confirmed by the Senate, between the United States and other countries, which become treaties between the United States and other countries after the advice and consent of a supermajority of the United States Senate. Contents 1 Full text of the clause 2 One of three types of international accord 3 Repeal 4 Scope of presidential powers 5 See also 6 Further reading 7 References 8 External links Full text of the Clause ( The President ) shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur... One of three types of international accord In the United States, the term `` treaty '' is used in a more restricted legal sense than in international law. U.S. law distinguishes what it calls treaties from congressional - executive agreements and sole - executive agreements. All three classes are considered treaties under international law ; they are distinct only from the perspective of internal United States law. Distinctions among the three concern their method of ratification : by two - thirds of the Senate, by normal legislative process, or by the President alone, respectively. The Treaty Clause empowers the President to make or enter into treaties with the `` advice and consent '' of two - thirds of the Senate. In contrast, normal legislation becomes law after approval by simple majorities in both the Senate and the House of Representatives and the signature of the President. Throughout U.S. history, the President has also made international `` agreements '' through congressional - executive agreements ( CEAs ) that are ratified with only a majority from both houses of Congress, or sole - executive agreements made by the President alone. Though the Constitution does not expressly provide for any alternative to the Article II treaty procedure, Article I, Section 10 of the Constitution does distinguish between treaties ( which states are forbidden to make ) and agreements ( which states may make with the consent of Congress ). The Supreme Court of the United States has considered congressional - executive and sole - executive agreements to be valid, and they have been common throughout American history. Thomas Jefferson explained that the Article II treaty procedure is not necessary when there is no long - term commitment : It is desirable, in many instances, to exchange mutual advantages by Legislative Acts rather than by treaty : because the former, though understood to be in consideration of each other, and therefore greatly respected, yet when they become too inconvenient, can be dropped at the will of either party : whereas stipulations by treaty are forever irrevocable but by joint consent... A further distinction embodied in U.S. law is between self - executing treaties, which do not require additional legislative action, and non-self - executing treaties which do require the enactment of new laws. These various distinctions of procedure and terminology do not affect the binding status of accords under international law. Nevertheless, they do have major implications under U.S. domestic law. In Missouri v. Holland, the Supreme Court ruled that the power to make treaties under the U.S. Constitution is a power separate from the other enumerated powers of the federal government, and hence the federal government can use treaties to legislate in areas which would otherwise fall within the exclusive authority of the states. By contrast, a congressional - executive agreement can only cover matters which the Constitution explicitly places within the powers of Congress and the President. Likewise, a sole - executive agreement can only cover matters within the President 's authority or matters in which Congress has delegated authority to the President. For example, a treaty may prohibit states from imposing capital punishment on foreign nationals, but a congressional - executive agreement or sole - executive agreement can not. In general, arms control agreements are often ratified by the treaty mechanism. At the same time, trade agreements ( such as the North American Free Trade Agreement and United States accession to the World Trade Organization ) are generally voted on as a CEA, and such agreements typically include an explicit right to withdraw after giving sufficient written notice to the other parties. If an international commercial accord contains binding `` treaty '' commitments, then a two - thirds vote of the Senate may be required. Between 1946 and 1999, the United States completed nearly 16,000 international agreements. Only 912 of those agreements were treaties, submitted to the Senate for approval as outlined in Article II of the United States Constitution. Since the Franklin Roosevelt presidency, only 6 % of international accords have been completed as Article II treaties. Most of these executive agreements consist of congressional - executive agreements. Repeal American law is that international accords become part of the body of U.S. federal law. Consequently, Congress can modify or repeal treaties by subsequent legislative action, even if this amounts to a violation of the treaty under international law. This was held, for instance, in the Head Money Cases. The most recent changes will be enforced by U.S. courts entirely independent of whether the international community still considers the old treaty obligations binding upon the U.S. Additionally, an international accord that is inconsistent with the U.S. Constitution is void under domestic U.S. law, the same as any other federal law in conflict with the Constitution. This principle was most clearly established in the case of Reid v. Covert. The Supreme Court could rule an Article II treaty provision to be unconstitutional and void under domestic law, although it has not yet done so. In Goldwater v. Carter, Congress challenged the constitutionality of then - president Jimmy Carter 's unilateral termination of a defense treaty. The case went before the Supreme Court and was never heard ; a majority of six Justices ruled that the case should be dismissed without hearing an oral argument, holding that `` The issue at hand... was essentially a political question and could not be reviewed by the court, as Congress had not issued a formal opposition. '' In his opinion, Justice Brennan dissented, `` The issue of decision making authority must be resolved as a matter of constitutional law, not political discretion ; accordingly, it falls within the competence of the courts ''. Presently, there is no official Supreme Court ruling on whether the President has the power to break a treaty without the approval of Congress, and the courts also declined to interfere when President George W. Bush unilaterally withdrew the United States from the ABM Treaty in 2002, six months after giving the required notice of intent. Scope of presidential powers Presidents have regarded the Article II treaty process as necessary where an international accord would bind a future president. For example, Theodore Roosevelt explained : The Constitution did not explicitly give me power to bring about the necessary agreement with Santo Domingo. But the Constitution did not forbid my doing what I did. I put the agreement into effect, and I continued its execution for two years before the Senate acted ; and I would have continued it until the end of my term, if necessary, without any action by Congress. But it was far preferable that there should be action by Congress, so that we might be proceeding under a treaty which was the law of the land and not merely by a direction of the Chief Executive which would lapse when that particular executive left office. I therefore did my best to get the Senate to ratify what I had done. A sole - executive agreement can only be negotiated and entered into through the president 's authority ( 1 ) in foreign policy, ( 2 ) as commander - in - chief of the armed forces, ( 3 ) from a prior act of Congress, or ( 4 ) from a prior treaty. Agreements beyond these competencies must have the approval of Congress ( for congressional - executive agreements ) or the Senate ( for treaties ). In 1972, Congress passed legislation requiring the president to notify Congress of any executive agreements that are formed. Although the nondelegation doctrine prevents Congress from delegating its legislative authority to the executive branch, Congress has allowed the executive to act as Congress 's `` agent '' in trade negotiations, such as by setting tariffs, and, in the case of Trade Promotion Authority, by solely authoring the implementing legislation for trade agreements. The constitutionality of this delegation was upheld by the Supreme Court in Field v. Clark ( 1892 ). See also Advice and consent Appointments Clause Foreign policy of the United States Jus tractatuum List of United States treaties Supremacy Clause Treaty Further reading Warren F. Kimball, Alliances, Coalitions, and Ententes - The American alliance system : an unamerican tradition References ^ Jump up to : Treaties and other International Agreements : the Role of the United States Senate ( Congressional Research Service 2001 ). Jump up ^ ( Article 2 Section 2 Clause 2 ) Jump up ^ The Supreme Court has said that the words `` treaty '' and `` agreement '' were technical terms of international diplomacy, when the Constitution was written. See Holmes v. Jennison, 39 U.S. 540 ( 1840 ) : `` A few extracts from an eminent writer on the laws of nations, showing the manner in which these different words have been used, and the different meanings sometimes attached to them, will, perhaps, contribute to explain the reason for using them all in the Constitution... Vattel, page 192, sec. 152, says : ' A treaty, in Latin foedus, is a compact made with a view to the public welfare, by the superior power, either for perpetuity, or for a considerable time. ' Section 153. ' The compacts which have temporary matters for their object, are called agreements, conventions, and pactions. They are accomplished by one single act, and not by repeated acts. These compacts are perfected in their execution once for all ; treaties receive a successive execution, whose duration equals that of the treaty. ' Section 154... After reading these extracts, we can be at no loss to comprehend the intention of the framers of the Constitution in using all these words, ' treaty, ' ' compact, ' ' agreement. ' '' Jump up ^ Jefferson, Thomas. `` Report of the Secretary of State to the President '' ( January 18, 1791 ) quoted in The Jeffersonian Cyclopedia ( 1900 ). Jump up ^ Medellin v. Texas, 2008 Jump up ^ Charnovitz, Steve. `` Analysis of Congressional - Executive Agreements '', American Journal of International Law ( 2004 ). Jump up ^ Hyman, Andrew. `` The Unconstitutionality of Long - Term Nuclear Pacts that are Rejected by Over One - Third of the Senate '', Denver Journal of International Law and Policy ( 1995 ). Jump up ^ Sherman, Roger. `` Observations on the Alterations Proposed as Amendments to the New Federal Constitution '' ( 1788 ) reprinted in Essays on the Constitution of the United States, Published During its Discussion by the People, 1787 - 1788 ( Paul Leicester Ford ed. 1892 ), page 235 : `` It is provided by the constitution that no commercial treaty shall be made by the president without the consent of two - thirds of the senators present... '' Retrieved 2008 - 04 - 12. Jump up ^ Reid v. Covert, 354 U.S. 1 ( 1957 ). Jump up ^ Goldwater v. Carter, 444 U.S. 996 ( 1979 ). Jump up ^ Ackerman, David. `` Withdrawal from the ABM Treaty : Legal Considerations '', CRS Report for Congress ( 2002 - 12 - 31 ). Jump up ^ Roosevelt, Theodore. An Autobiography, page 510 ( 1913 ). Jump up ^ 1 U.S.C. 112 ( b ). Via Findlaw. Retrieved 2008 - 04 - 12. External links Treaties Pending in the Senate List of rejected treaties and other info United States Constitution Text ( via Wikisource ) Preamble and Articles I -- VII Amendments 1 -- 10 Amendments 11 -- 27 Unsuccessful Proposed Amendments Debates in State Conventions on the Adoption of the Constitution Preamble and articles Preamble II III IV V VI VII Amendments Ratified Bill of Rights 5 6 7 8 9 10 Others 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 Pending Congressional Apportionment Titles of Nobility Corwin Amendment Child Labor Repealed Eighteenth Amendment Unsuccessful Equal Rights District of Columbia Voting Rights List of Amendments Bill of Rights ( Amendments 1 -- 10 ) Reconstruction Amendments ( Amendments 13 -- 15 ) Amendment proposals in Congress Convention to propose amendments State ratifying conventions Formation History Articles of Confederation Mount Vernon Conference Annapolis Convention Philadelphia Convention Virginia Plan New Jersey Plan Connecticut Compromise Three - Fifths Compromise Committee of Detail Signing Independence Hall Syng inkstand The Federalist Papers Anti-Federalist Papers Massachusetts Compromise Virginia Ratifying Convention Hillsborough Convention Rhode Island ratification Drafting and ratification timeline Clauses Appointments Appropriations Assistance of Counsel Bill of credit Case or Controversy Citizenship Commerce Compact Compulsory Process Confrontation Contract Copyright and Patent Double Jeopardy Due Process Equal Protection Establishment Exceptions Excessive Bail Ex post facto Extradition Free Exercise Free Speech Fugitive Slave Full Faith and Credit General Welfare Guarantee Impeachment Import - Export Ineligibility Militia Natural - born citizen Necessary and Proper New States No Religious Test Oath or Affirmation Origination Petition Postal Presentment Privileges and Immunities Privileges or Immunities Recommendation Self - Incrimination Speech or Debate Speedy Trial State of the Union Supremacy Suspension Take Care Takings Taxing and Spending Territorial Title of Nobility Treaty Trial by Jury Vesting Vicinage War Powers List of clauses Interpretation Concurrent powers Congressional enforcement Constitutional law Criminal procedure Criminal sentencing Dormant Commerce Clause Enumerated powers Equal footing Executive privilege Incorporation of the Bill of Rights Judicial review Nondelegation doctrine Preemption Saxbe fix Separation of church and state Separation of powers Taxation power Unitary executive theory Display and legacy National Archives Charters of Freedom Rotunda Independence Mall Constitution Day Constitution Gardens National Constitution Center Scene at the Signing of the Constitution ( painting ) A More Perfect Union ( film ) Worldwide influence US Government Portal Law Portal Wikipedia book United States Congress House of Representatives Senate ( 114th ← 115th → 116th ) Lists of congressional lists Members and leaders Members Current By length of service Freshmen Youngest members Resident Commissioner of Puerto Rico Delegates Longest - serving members ever Senate Current by seniority Dean of the Senate Former senators Living Earliest serving Earliest living Expelled or censured Classes Born outside the U.S. House Current by seniority Dean of the House Former representatives Living Oldest living Earliest serving Expelled, censured, and reprimanded Leaders Senate President ( list ) President pro tempore ( list ) Majority and minority leaders Assistant party leaders Democratic Caucus ( Chair Secretary Policy Committee Chair ) Republican Conference ( Chair Vice-Chair Policy Committee Chair ) House Speaker Leaders Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group Democratic Caucus Republican Conference Districts List Apportionment Caucuses, women and minorities Congressional caucus African Americans in the House Congressional Black Caucus African Americans in the Senate Asian Pacific American members Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus Hispanic and Latino members Congressional Hispanic Caucus Congressional Hispanic Conference Jewish members LGBT members LGBT Equality Caucus Native American members Women in the House Congressional Caucus for Women 's Issues Women in the Senate Powers, privileges, procedure, committees, history, and media Powers Article I Copyright Commerce ( Dormant ) Contempt of Congress Declaration of war Impeachment Naturalization `` Necessary and Proper '' Power of enforcement Taxing / spending Privileges and benefits Salaries Franking Immunity Procedure Act of Congress ( list ) Appropriation bill Blue slip Budget resolution Censure Closed sessions House Senate Cloture Concurrent resolution Continuing resolution Dear colleague letter Discharge petition Engrossed bill Enrolled bill Expulsion Joint resolution Joint session ( list ) Lame - duck session Majority of the majority ( Hastert Rule ) Multiple referral Procedures ( House ) Quorum call Reconciliation Rider Saxbe fix Sponsorship Suspension of the rules Unanimous consent Veto Line - item veto Pocket veto Veto override Senate - specific Advice and consent Classes Executive communication Executive session Filibuster Jefferson 's Manual Senate Journal Morning business Nuclear option Presiding Officer Recess appointment Reconciliation Riddick 's Senate Procedure Senate hold Senatorial courtesy Seniority Standing Rules Tie - breaking votes Traditions Treaty Clause Committees Chairman and ranking member Of the Whole Conference Discharge petition Hearings Markup Oversight List ( Joint ) List ( House ) List ( Senate ) Select and special Standing Subcommittees Items Gavels Mace of the House Seal of the Senate History Biographical Directory Divided government House Gerrymandering Party control Senate Senate election disputes Senatorial memoirs Representative memoirs Media C - SPAN Congressional Quarterly The Hill Politico Roll Call Offices, employees, services, and the Capitol Complex Legislative offices Congressional staff Government Accountability Office ( Comptroller General ) Architect of the Capitol Capitol Police ( Capitol Police Board ) Capitol Guide Service ( Capitol Guide Board ) Congressional Budget Office ( CBO ) Compliance Library of Congress Government Publishing Office ( GPO ) Technology Assessment Offices Senate Curator Historical Library House Congressional Ethics Emergency Planning, Preparedness, and Operations Interparliamentary Affairs Legislative Counsel Law Revision Counsel Library Employees Senate Secretary Chaplain Curator Inspector General Historian Librarian Pages Parliamentarian Sergeant at Arms and Doorkeeper House Chaplain Chief Administrative Officer Clerk Doorkeeper Floor Operations Floor Services Chief Historian Pages ( Page Board ) Parliamentarian Postmaster Reading Clerk Sergeant at Arms Library of Congress Congressional Research Service ( reports ) Copyright Office ( Register of Copyrights ) Law Library Poet Laureate THOMAS Adams Building Jefferson Building Madison Building Government Publishing Office Public Printer Congressional Pictorial Directory Congressional Record Official Congressional Directory United States Government Manual Serial Set Statutes at Large United States Code Capitol Brumidi Corridors Congressional Prayer Room Crypt Dome Statue of Freedom Rotunda Hall of Columns Statuary Hall Visitor Center The Apotheosis of Washington Statue of Freedom Declaration of Independence painting Scene at the Signing of the Constitution of the United States Apotheosis of Democracy First Reading of the Emancipation Proclamation of President Lincoln Surrender of General Burgoyne Surrender of Lord Cornwallis Revolutionary War Door Westward the Course of Empire Takes Its Way Vice President 's Room Vice Presidential Bust Collection Office buildings Senate Dirksen Hart Mountains and Clouds Russell House Building Commission Cannon Ford Longworth O'Neill Rayburn Other facilities Botanic Garden Health and Fitness Facility House Recording Studio Senate chamber Old Senate Chamber Old Supreme Court Chamber Power Plant Webster Page Residence Subway Websites House of Representatives Senate Retrieved from `` https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Treaty_Clause&oldid=784354973 '' Categories : Article Two of the United States Constitution Treaties of the United States Foreign relations of the United States Clauses of the United States Constitution Talk Contents About Wikipedia Add links This page was last edited on 7 June 2017, at 21 : 41. Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution - ShareAlike License ; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia ® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. About Wikipedia

Question: who has to ratify a treaty made by the president
Answer: a majority from both houses of Congress