In contrast to the currently available templates containing standardized information by cancer type, our findings indicate that SCPs should be individually tailored to reflect the prioritized needs of survivors, primary care physicians, and oncologists. Our findings should be confirmed and compared to other larger cohorts or cohorts of other cancer subtypes. Comparative effectiveness research is needed to evaluate whether the implementation of personalized survivorship care plans provide higher levels of survivor and/or physician satisfaction, knowledge, and quality of life than the use of a single standardized survivorship care plan.