story: [Charles]'s mother, [Ellen], took him shopping for a new television [Ellen] and her sister, [Margaret], frequently bicker. However, they always make up quickly. [Charles] is [Nadia]'s older brother. He has never liked any of her boyfriends. [Mabel]'s mother, [Ellen], wanted to throw a surprise birthday party for [Ellen]'s sister, [Margaret], this weekend. [Nadia] just had a baby and presented the baby proudly to the new maternal grandmother, [Ellen]. [Cesar]'s mother, [Elsie], waited impatiently for him at the diner. [Ellen] was excited to visit her son, [Charles], at college. [Cesar] likes to visit his sister. Her name is [Ellen]. [Mabel] went to dinner with her daughter [Ellen]. They then went to the park afterwards.
query: ('Charles', 'Elsie')
clean_story: [Charles] is [Nadia]'s older brother. He has never liked any of her boyfriends. [Nadia] just had a baby and presented the baby proudly to the new maternal grandmother, [Ellen]. [Ellen] was excited to visit her son, [Charles], at college. [Charles]'s mother, [Ellen], took him shopping for a new television [Mabel] went to dinner with her daughter [Ellen]. They then went to the park afterwards. [Mabel]'s mother, [Ellen], wanted to throw a surprise birthday party for [Ellen]'s sister, [Margaret], this weekend. [Ellen] and her sister, [Margaret], frequently bicker. However, they always make up quickly. [Cesar] likes to visit his sister. Her name is [Ellen]. [Cesar]'s mother, [Elsie], waited impatiently for him at the diner.
proof_state: [{('Charles', 'grandmother', 'Elsie'): [('Charles', 'sister', 'Nadia'), ('Nadia', 'grandmother', 'Elsie')]}, {('Nadia', 'grandmother', 'Elsie'): [('Nadia', 'sister', 'Mabel'), ('Mabel', 'grandmother', 'Elsie')]}, {('Mabel', 'grandmother', 'Elsie'): [('Mabel', 'mother', 'Ellen'), ('Ellen', 'mother', 'Elsie')]}, {('Nadia', 'sister', 'Mabel'): [('Nadia', 'brother', 'Charles'), ('Charles', 'sister', 'Mabel')]}, {('Nadia', 'brother', 'Charles'): [('Nadia', 'mother', 'Ellen'), ('Ellen', 'son', 'Charles')]}, {('Charles', 'sister', 'Mabel'): [('Charles', 'mother', 'Ellen'), ('Ellen', 'daughter', 'Mabel')]}, {('Ellen', 'mother', 'Elsie'): [('Ellen', 'sister', 'Margaret'), ('Margaret', 'mother', 'Elsie')]}, {('Margaret', 'mother', 'Elsie'): [('Margaret', 'brother', 'Cesar'), ('Cesar', 'mother', 'Elsie')]}, {('Margaret', 'brother', 'Cesar'): [('Margaret', 'sister', 'Ellen'), ('Ellen', 'brother', 'Cesar')]}]
edge_types: ['sister', 'mother', 'son', 'mother', 'daughter', 'mother', 'sister', 'sister', 'brother', 'mother']