story: [Constance] went shoe shopping with her sister [Ellen]. [Elsie] had a daughter named [Constance]. [Elsie] had picked her daughter [Margaret] out the cutest new dress to wear on her birthday. [Charles] and his sister [Kathleen] have been best friends ever since childhood. [Nadia] and her father, [James], went to the marina. [James]'s daughter, [Mabel], had purchased a boat, and they were eager to see it. [Mabel] bought her mother, [Ellen], a puppy for her birthday. [James] hung his son [Charles]'s finger paintings on the refrigerator. The paintings were right next to the paintings of [Nadia], [Charles]'s sister. [Kathleen] was n't old enough to make any paintings for her father, [James].
query: ('Charles', 'Margaret')
clean_story: [Charles] and his sister [Kathleen] have been best friends ever since childhood. [James] hung his son [Charles]'s finger paintings on the refrigerator. The paintings were right next to the paintings of [Nadia], [Charles]'s sister. [Kathleen] was n't old enough to make any paintings for her father, [James]. [Nadia] and her father, [James], went to the marina. [James]'s daughter, [Mabel], had purchased a boat, and they were eager to see it. [Mabel] bought her mother, [Ellen], a puppy for her birthday. [Constance] went shoe shopping with her sister [Ellen]. [Elsie] had a daughter named [Constance]. [Elsie] had picked her daughter [Margaret] out the cutest new dress to wear on her birthday.
proof_state: [{('Charles', 'aunt', 'Margaret'): [('Charles', 'mother', 'Ellen'), ('Ellen', 'sister', 'Margaret')]}, {('Ellen', 'sister', 'Margaret'): [('Ellen', 'sister', 'Constance'), ('Constance', 'sister', 'Margaret')]}, {('Charles', 'mother', 'Ellen'): [('Charles', 'sister', 'Kathleen'), ('Kathleen', 'mother', 'Ellen')]}, {('Kathleen', 'mother', 'Ellen'): [('Kathleen', 'sister', 'Mabel'), ('Mabel', 'mother', 'Ellen')]}, {('Kathleen', 'sister', 'Mabel'): [('Kathleen', 'brother', 'Charles'), ('Charles', 'sister', 'Mabel')]}, {('Charles', 'sister', 'Mabel'): [('Charles', 'sister', 'Nadia'), ('Nadia', 'sister', 'Mabel')]}, {('Kathleen', 'brother', 'Charles'): [('Kathleen', 'father', 'James'), ('James', 'son', 'Charles')]}, {('Nadia', 'sister', 'Mabel'): [('Nadia', 'father', 'James'), ('James', 'daughter', 'Mabel')]}, {('Constance', 'sister', 'Margaret'): [('Constance', 'mother', 'Elsie'), ('Elsie', 'daughter', 'Margaret')]}]
edge_types: ['sister', 'father', 'son', 'sister', 'father', 'daughter', 'mother', 'sister', 'mother', 'daughter']