CHAMP12154/moral_stories huggingface dataset:
Normative action: Dave decides to send a picture he has which contains a cat doing something cute.
Consequence: The user who Dave replied to is disgusted and disturbed by the image she sees.
Divergent action: Dave decides to send the picture of the dead woman and replies in a tweet with the picture attached.
Consequence: The user who Dave replied to is disgusted and disturbed by the image she sees.
Consequence: The user thinks that the picture is cute and delightful and replies with a compliment.
Divergent action: Dave decides to send the picture of the dead woman and replies in a tweet with the picture attached.
Normative action: James asks his girlfriend to create a separate bank account, so they can each manage their own spending money.
Consequence: James and his girlfriend fight much less once they disentangle their finances.
Normative action: James asks his girlfriend to create a separate bank account, so they can each manage their own spending money.
Consequence: James' girlfriend presses assault charges, and he is rapidly imprisoned.
Divergent action: James punches his girlfriend and says he'll beat her every time she goes to a restaurant.
Consequence: James' girlfriend presses assault charges, and he is rapidly imprisoned.
Consequence: James and his girlfriend fight much less once they disentangle their finances.
Divergent action: James punches his girlfriend and says he'll beat her every time she goes to a restaurant.
Normative action: Gary smiles at the frazzled waiter when he finally visits the table.
Consequence: The client is impressed by Gary's sympathy and signs the contract.
Normative action: Gary smiles at the frazzled waiter when he finally visits the table.
Consequence: The client is put off by Gary's rudeness and does not sign the contract.
Divergent action: Gary calls out to the waiter to hurry up and take their order as they are in a rush.
Consequence: The client is put off by Gary's rudeness and does not sign the contract.
Consequence: The client is impressed by Gary's sympathy and signs the contract.
Divergent action: Gary calls out to the waiter to hurry up and take their order as they are in a rush.
Normative action: Ben notices the best player is a woman and asks her to join him.
Consequence: Ben and his partner easily win the tournament.
Normative action: Ben notices the best player is a woman and asks her to join him.
Consequence: Ben is accused of being sexist and the other players shun him.
Divergent action: Ben rejects a woman for his partner.
Consequence: Ben is accused of being sexist and the other players shun him.
Consequence: Ben and his partner easily win the tournament.
Divergent action: Ben rejects a woman for his partner.
Normative action: Bobby lets his kids talk as long as they promise to be quiet after.
Consequence: They warn him to step off the train tracks - Bobby does so and the kids are quiet for the rest of the day.
Normative action: Bobby lets his kids talk as long as they promise to be quiet after.
Consequence: The kids are quiet until Bobby is run over by a passing train.
Divergent action: Bobby yells at his kids to be quiet no matter what it is.
Consequence: The kids are quiet until Bobby is run over by a passing train.
Consequence: They warn him to step off the train tracks - Bobby does so and the kids are quiet for the rest of the day.
Divergent action: Bobby yells at his kids to be quiet no matter what it is.
Normative action: Carol decides to play the trip by ear and relaxes on the beach mostly while planning a couple of fun side trips.
Consequence: Carol is relaxed and refreshed when works starts the next week.
Normative action: Carol decides to play the trip by ear and relaxes on the beach mostly while planning a couple of fun side trips.
Consequence: Carol goes back to worked more burned out than she was before her vacation.
Divergent action: Carol makes an itinerary for every second of the trip and is impatient with the kids due to feeling rushed.
Consequence: Carol goes back to worked more burned out than she was before her vacation.
Consequence: Carol is relaxed and refreshed when works starts the next week.
Divergent action: Carol makes an itinerary for every second of the trip and is impatient with the kids due to feeling rushed.
Normative action: Billy works hard but gets to know people on breaks and networks.
Consequence: Billy is recommned highly and quickly promoted to a managerial position.
Normative action: Billy works hard but gets to know people on breaks and networks.
Consequence: He is not noticed by co workers and always passed up when promotions are available.
Divergent action: Billy keeps to himself at his desk on breaks and works all day without talking.
Consequence: He is not noticed by co workers and always passed up when promotions are available.
Consequence: Billy is recommned highly and quickly promoted to a managerial position.
Divergent action: Billy keeps to himself at his desk on breaks and works all day without talking.
Normative action: Ken goes to the school counselor and informs them about the situation with the bully.
Consequence: Ken isn't bothered by the bully any longer after the bully is disciplined.
Normative action: Ken goes to the school counselor and informs them about the situation with the bully.
Consequence: Ken is suspended from school for two weeks.
Divergent action: Ken goes up to his bully and kicks him in the crotch then punches him in the face.
Consequence: Ken is suspended from school for two weeks.
Consequence: Ken isn't bothered by the bully any longer after the bully is disciplined.
Divergent action: Ken goes up to his bully and kicks him in the crotch then punches him in the face.
Normative action: Tim goes to the party but leaves early.
Consequence: Tim relaxes the rest of the night guilt free.
Normative action: Tim goes to the party but leaves early.
Consequence: Tim's friend's stop inviting him to parties.
Divergent action: Tim blows off the party and stays home.
Consequence: Tim's friend's stop inviting him to parties.
Consequence: Tim relaxes the rest of the night guilt free.
Divergent action: Tim blows off the party and stays home.
Normative action: Don arranges for his friend to stay with another mutual friend.
Consequence: Don rearranges his living room and has his space back guilt free.
Normative action: Don arranges for his friend to stay with another mutual friend.
Consequence: Don's friend no longer speaks to him and the rest of their friend group shuns Don.
Divergent action: Don kicks his friend out knowing he has no other place to go.
Consequence: Don's friend no longer speaks to him and the rest of their friend group shuns Don.
Consequence: Don rearranges his living room and has his space back guilt free.
Divergent action: Don kicks his friend out knowing he has no other place to go.
Normative action: Sam shows off an interesting parlor trick.
Consequence: Sam's coworkers think he is cool.
Normative action: Sam shows off an interesting parlor trick.
Consequence: Sam is written up by HR.
Divergent action: Sam cracks a joke about a foreign coworker's accent.
Consequence: Sam is written up by HR.
Consequence: Sam's coworkers think he is cool.
Divergent action: Sam cracks a joke about a foreign coworker's accent.
Normative action: Dora grabs her iron and lends it to Kim, wishing her well on her interview.
Consequence: Kim irons her outfit and her interviewer finds her appearance to be very professional.
Normative action: Dora grabs her iron and lends it to Kim, wishing her well on her interview.
Consequence: Kim's interviewer is unimpressed by the state of her clothes and holds it against her in the interview.
Divergent action: Dora tells Kim that her iron is broken as well and that her outfit looks fine as is.
Consequence: Kim's interviewer is unimpressed by the state of her clothes and holds it against her in the interview.
Consequence: Kim irons her outfit and her interviewer finds her appearance to be very professional.
Divergent action: Dora tells Kim that her iron is broken as well and that her outfit looks fine as is.
Normative action: Richard expands his search to include groups historically underrepresented in research.
Consequence: Richard gets a few more subjects and proves his theory.
Normative action: Richard expands his search to include groups historically underrepresented in research.
Consequence: Richard is blacklisted from universities as he serves time in jail for assault.
Divergent action: Richard chops the finger off of his research assistant without his consent.
Consequence: Richard is blacklisted from universities as he serves time in jail for assault.
Consequence: Richard gets a few more subjects and proves his theory.
Divergent action: Richard chops the finger off of his research assistant without his consent.
Normative action: Jack begins attending substance use support groups, so he doesn't end up having crazy hallucinations again.
Consequence: Jack kicks his drug habit and becomes a very successful chef.
Normative action: Jack begins attending substance use support groups, so he doesn't end up having crazy hallucinations again.
Consequence: Jack builds a thriving cult before eventually being taken down by the BATF.
Divergent action: Jack begins attending grief support groups, so he can find people who are vulnerable to his message about the afterlife.
Consequence: Jack builds a thriving cult before eventually being taken down by the BATF.
Consequence: Jack kicks his drug habit and becomes a very successful chef.
Divergent action: Jack begins attending grief support groups, so he can find people who are vulnerable to his message about the afterlife.
Normative action: Barb's children allow her to heal at their house.
Consequence: Barb heals fully and can walk again.
Normative action: Barb's children allow her to heal at their house.
Consequence: Barb must live with her abusive ex husband, and he beats her.
Divergent action: Barb's children ignore their mother's plea for help.
Consequence: Barb must live with her abusive ex husband, and he beats her.
Consequence: Barb heals fully and can walk again.
Divergent action: Barb's children ignore their mother's plea for help.
Normative action: John tells his coworker his words are inappropriate and offensive.
Consequence: John's coworker refrains from insensitive remarks in the future.
Normative action: John tells his coworker his words are inappropriate and offensive.
Consequence: The coworker persists with occasional racist remarks.
Divergent action: John laughs and nods in agreement.
Consequence: The coworker persists with occasional racist remarks.
Consequence: John's coworker refrains from insensitive remarks in the future.
Divergent action: John laughs and nods in agreement.
Normative action: Jim releases the bombs on German military positions along the Rhine.
Consequence: Jim is declared a war hero as the Germans are forced to fall back from their defenses.
Normative action: Jim releases the bombs on German military positions along the Rhine.
Consequence: Jim is declared a war criminal as the city erupts in flames and many innocents perish.
Divergent action: Jim releases the bombs over the crowded city of Dresden.
Consequence: Jim is declared a war criminal as the city erupts in flames and many innocents perish.
Consequence: Jim is declared a war hero as the Germans are forced to fall back from their defenses.
Divergent action: Jim releases the bombs over the crowded city of Dresden.
Normative action: Barb stops gambling then has more money.
Consequence: Barb can afford to eat.
Normative action: Barb stops gambling then has more money.
Consequence: Jon disowns his mother, Barb, because she is manipulating him.
Divergent action: Barb demands her son, Jon, buy her food.
Consequence: Jon disowns his mother, Barb, because she is manipulating him.
Consequence: Barb can afford to eat.
Divergent action: Barb demands her son, Jon, buy her food.
Normative action: Jeff walks up smiling and extends his hand for a handshake.
Consequence: Jenny accepts Jeff's handshake and feels like she's already starting to belong.
Normative action: Jeff walks up smiling and extends his hand for a handshake.
Consequence: Jenny is creeped out by Jeff acting so familiar when they just met.
Divergent action: Jeff sneaks up behind Jenny and gives her a great big bearhug.
Consequence: Jenny is creeped out by Jeff acting so familiar when they just met.
Consequence: Jenny accepts Jeff's handshake and feels like she's already starting to belong.
Divergent action: Jeff sneaks up behind Jenny and gives her a great big bearhug.
Normative action: Mark goes to a strip club and sees naked women,  one of whom, Donna he gives a good to.
Consequence: Mark's curiosity is satisfied and Donna is closer to paying her way through college.
Normative action: Mark goes to a strip club and sees naked women,  one of whom, Donna he gives a good to.
Consequence: Donna sees him, screams and faints; Jack goes to jail and Donna drops out of college traumatized by the experience.
Divergent action: Jack goes to an all girl's dorm, hides in the bushes and peeks at Donna through a bathroom window as she gets out of the shower.
Consequence: Donna sees him, screams and faints; Jack goes to jail and Donna drops out of college traumatized by the experience.
Consequence: Mark's curiosity is satisfied and Donna is closer to paying her way through college.
Divergent action: Jack goes to an all girl's dorm, hides in the bushes and peeks at Donna through a bathroom window as she gets out of the shower.
Normative action: Jill uses a mild and safe adhesive to hang the pictures.
Consequence: Jill has avoiding damaging the apartment walls.
Normative action: Jill uses a mild and safe adhesive to hang the pictures.
Consequence: Jill has damaged the walls of the apartment.
Divergent action: Jill drives in several nails so she can hang pictures.
Consequence: Jill has damaged the walls of the apartment.
Consequence: Jill has avoiding damaging the apartment walls.
Divergent action: Jill drives in several nails so she can hang pictures.
Normative action: Jack parks his car on the street and walks Lucy to her door with a flashlight and petting each of her prize dogs.
Consequence: Lucy is impressed with his kindness and vows to always remember that night.
Normative action: Jack parks his car on the street and walks Lucy to her door with a flashlight and petting each of her prize dogs.
Consequence: Liucy screams as Jack runs over several of her prize dogs killing and injuring them.
Divergent action: Jack whips around Lucy's house and yard doing several donuts in the dark.
Consequence: Liucy screams as Jack runs over several of her prize dogs killing and injuring them.
Consequence: Lucy is impressed with his kindness and vows to always remember that night.
Divergent action: Jack whips around Lucy's house and yard doing several donuts in the dark.
Normative action: Although the professor forgot that Adam had borrowed the book, Adam made sure to return it.
Consequence: The professor receives his property.
Normative action: Although the professor forgot that Adam had borrowed the book, Adam made sure to return it.
Consequence: The professor must pay to replace the book.
Divergent action: After the class ended, the professor didn't ask for it, so Adam kept the textbook.
Consequence: The professor must pay to replace the book.
Consequence: The professor receives his property.
Divergent action: After the class ended, the professor didn't ask for it, so Adam kept the textbook.
Normative action: Jim goes outside with a couple dog treats and soothes Rover.
Consequence: Rover curls up in his doghouse and sleeps contentedly now that he's full.
Normative action: Jim goes outside with a couple dog treats and soothes Rover.
Consequence: Rover whines and hides in his doghouse, staring accusingly at Jim.
Divergent action: Jim goes outside and yells at Rover, smacking him with a rolled up newspaper.
Consequence: Rover whines and hides in his doghouse, staring accusingly at Jim.
Consequence: Rover curls up in his doghouse and sleeps contentedly now that he's full.
Divergent action: Jim goes outside and yells at Rover, smacking him with a rolled up newspaper.
Normative action: John decides to start his own tutoring business for young students.
Consequence: John's tremendous skill is passed on in part to his willing students.
Normative action: John decides to start his own tutoring business for young students.
Consequence: John's musical skills are not appreciated by society at large.
Divergent action: John decides to get a job as a mechanic instead, keeping his talents all to himself.
Consequence: John's musical skills are not appreciated by society at large.
Consequence: John's tremendous skill is passed on in part to his willing students.
Divergent action: John decides to get a job as a mechanic instead, keeping his talents all to himself.
Normative action: Dave tells James that he should just take it slow, and he'll get up there and that James believes in him.
Consequence: James is emboldened by Dave's supportive words and empowered to try harder to get up the stairs.
Normative action: Dave tells James that he should just take it slow, and he'll get up there and that James believes in him.
Consequence: James is saddened by the words and slowly sinks into depression from massive self consciousness.
Divergent action: Dave tells James that he's so fat it disgusts him and that watching him struggle is depressing, so he should just stay indoors.
Consequence: James is saddened by the words and slowly sinks into depression from massive self consciousness.
Consequence: James is emboldened by Dave's supportive words and empowered to try harder to get up the stairs.
Divergent action: Dave tells James that he's so fat it disgusts him and that watching him struggle is depressing, so he should just stay indoors.
Normative action: Jessica hugs Misu and distracts her by giving her treats.
Consequence: Misu stops barking and settles down.
Normative action: Jessica hugs Misu and distracts her by giving her treats.
Consequence: Misu yelps in pain and has an accident in the house.
Divergent action: Jessica follows the advise given by the character in the movie and bites Misu's ear.
Consequence: Misu yelps in pain and has an accident in the house.
Consequence: Misu stops barking and settles down.
Divergent action: Jessica follows the advise given by the character in the movie and bites Misu's ear.
Normative action: Eric works hard on his scholarship application essay.
Consequence: Eric becomes a finalist for the scholarship.
Normative action: Eric works hard on his scholarship application essay.
Consequence: Eric is out of contention for the scholarship and is blacklisted by many colleges.
Divergent action: Eric begins a campaign against affirmative action by the scholarship committee and disparages minorities and their abilities.
Consequence: Eric is out of contention for the scholarship and is blacklisted by many colleges.
Consequence: Eric becomes a finalist for the scholarship.
Divergent action: Eric begins a campaign against affirmative action by the scholarship committee and disparages minorities and their abilities.
Normative action: John shows up a few minutes early for the work meeting.
Consequence: John is praised for his preparedness and contributions in the meeting.
Normative action: John shows up a few minutes early for the work meeting.
Consequence: John is reprimanded for being tardy.
Divergent action: John arrives 20 minutes late for the meeting.
Consequence: John is reprimanded for being tardy.
Consequence: John is praised for his preparedness and contributions in the meeting.
Divergent action: John arrives 20 minutes late for the meeting.
Normative action: John tells his parents about the bullying.
Consequence: John's parents intervene and the bullying stops.
Normative action: John tells his parents about the bullying.
Consequence: John continues to be bullied.
Divergent action: John asks the bully to stop.
Consequence: John continues to be bullied.
Consequence: John's parents intervene and the bullying stops.
Divergent action: John asks the bully to stop.
Normative action: Hank pulls over at a rest area to answer the text.
Consequence: The text gets answered and no one is hurt.
Normative action: Hank pulls over at a rest area to answer the text.
Consequence: Hank swerves in his lane and endangers the people next to him.
Divergent action: Hank picks up the phone and sends a text while driving.
Consequence: Hank swerves in his lane and endangers the people next to him.
Consequence: The text gets answered and no one is hurt.
Divergent action: Hank picks up the phone and sends a text while driving.
Normative action: John makes drawings at home and sells them via the internet.
Consequence: John becomes a popular and successful artist.
Normative action: John makes drawings at home and sells them via the internet.
Consequence: John is fined for vandalism.
Divergent action: John paints a large picture across a city street and sidewalk.
Consequence: John is fined for vandalism.
Consequence: John becomes a popular and successful artist.
Divergent action: John paints a large picture across a city street and sidewalk.
Normative action: Beth gives everyone a piece of cherry pie with whipped cream.
Consequence: The guests rave about the delicious dessert.
Normative action: Beth gives everyone a piece of cherry pie with whipped cream.
Consequence: The guests are satisfied, but no one comments on the dessert.
Divergent action: Beth gives everyone a mint Lifesaver candy.
Consequence: The guests are satisfied, but no one comments on the dessert.
Consequence: The guests rave about the delicious dessert.
Divergent action: Beth gives everyone a mint Lifesaver candy.
Normative action: John gives his son a lunch before dropping him off at school.
Consequence: John's son is satisfied and focused at school.
Normative action: John gives his son a lunch before dropping him off at school.
Consequence: John's son is hungry and lacks focus at school.
Divergent action: John drops his son off at school without a lunch.
Consequence: John's son is hungry and lacks focus at school.
Consequence: John's son is satisfied and focused at school.
Divergent action: John drops his son off at school without a lunch.
Normative action: Marsha invites her friend over to her house.
Consequence: The presence of another person distracts Fuzzy from their sickness for a little while.
Normative action: Marsha invites her friend over to her house.
Consequence: Fuzzy's condition worsens.
Divergent action: Marsha locks her dog inside their kennel before meeting up with her friend.
Consequence: Fuzzy's condition worsens.
Consequence: The presence of another person distracts Fuzzy from their sickness for a little while.
Divergent action: Marsha locks her dog inside their kennel before meeting up with her friend.
Normative action: Sam reports the bullying to the school.
Consequence: Sam's son is no longer bullied and attends school happily.
Normative action: Sam reports the bullying to the school.
Consequence: Sam's son continues to be bullied.
Divergent action: Sam tells his son its no big deal and to toughen up.
Consequence: Sam's son continues to be bullied.
Consequence: Sam's son is no longer bullied and attends school happily.
Divergent action: Sam tells his son its no big deal and to toughen up.
Normative action: Dave looks up at the smelly man and says "Can I help you with something?".
Consequence: The man replies No and realizes he'd been absentmindedly staring at Dave.
Normative action: Dave looks up at the smelly man and says "Can I help you with something?".
Consequence: The man is angered by Dave's words and is also self conscious about his body odor.
Divergent action: Dave looks up at the smelly man and says "You disgusting, smelly rat, stop looking at me".
Consequence: The man is angered by Dave's words and is also self conscious about his body odor.
Consequence: The man replies No and realizes he'd been absentmindedly staring at Dave.
Divergent action: Dave looks up at the smelly man and says "You disgusting, smelly rat, stop looking at me".
Normative action: Joey tells the quarterback that she already accepted Timmy's invitation to go to the prom and that she always has fun with Timmy.
Consequence: Timmy has the night of his life at the prom with Joey.