The list seemed to be getting clogged, particularly with recent alumni who have yet to accomplish any particularly notable achievements as professional athletes. I removed Marlins pitcher Andrew Miller, who has had one mediocre season in the majors, Red Sox prospect and minor leaguer Daniel Bard, NFL free agent Brian Simmons, tennis player Nick Monroe, runner Shalane Flanagan,  Charlotte Bobcats Sean May and Raymond Felton and ESPN announcer Stuart Scott. 

None of these folks, aside from Stuart Scott, have made their respective sports all-star teams, won a major event, or even been honored as their league's top rookie. If being a professional athlete is the only standard needed to be on this list, then it needs to be much longer. But that would be unweildy.  Stuart Scott doesn't belong because of the way the list is introduced. He is an announcer, not an "alumni from the varsity athletic program." 

I left current professional athletes who have been recognized within their sport, and the iconic retirees such as Eddie Pope and Michael Jordan. I'll happily revert if that's what people want.