Academy, Emmy, Grammy and Tony Awards 

I seek clarification from interested editors on the inclusion of winning Academy, Emmy, Grammy or Tony Awards in the listing for a deceased. According to WP:ANYBIO criteria for notability includes "has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for one several times". One editor differs from this position, with summaries such as "undue weight"  and "Oscar nomination outweighs Emmy win" . Your thoughts?