some possible sources 

Entertainment Weekly review published on CNN
Stylus magazine - pretty critical ("This is truly one of the most stunningly awful albums released by a major band ever." - lol)

will probably add some more later - going to try and use material from these in the article but if anyone else wants to jump in and incorporate it feel free. imho if we're going to give a balanced view of the album's reception we need to point out the views from msot major critics.