My apologies, I thought when you mentioned you were related to the "Jewish Giant" you were ironically referring to Dianne Arbus herself, since it is to the JG himself you are related to my point still holds, as someone of at least partial Jewish ancestry why are you aiding the anti semites of the world?

As to my edit, you totally fail to answer the substance of my point: what is the point of identifying Noam Chomsky as "jewish" other than to lend legitimacy to his anti Jewish stance?  And if that description stands, why is it a pov reference to indicate that while he may be of Jewish ancestry, he does not identify "jewishly" in any way.  Look forward to your non ironical answer.