, 6 January 2008 (UTC)

Thank you, User:Charles, for eagerly coming to "help" one of your brethren, user:Xantios. By the way, I note that Xantios has to this date produced yet no more than those three edits. But the number of edits made by the user account Charles is of course higher (although possibly of no better quality).
Interestingly enough, as a careful reader understands, I pointed out that the Hohenzollern succession rights are a disputed issue and that scholars are aware of various contingencies of those rights and lineages. Which of course means disagreement between scholars. Charles was good enough to point out that "at least one of scholars disagrees...". I regard that as further proof of (a) the Hohenzollern rights are a disputed issue, (b) scholars are aware of those Hohenzollerns and their putative rights.  Charles however appears to be unable to specify who is the "one" scholar he meant and what precisely was the disagreement. Writing such specifics would of course help, but we of course cannot expect anything specific nor anything helpful from individuals who say to "generally" be positive.   10:00