Personally, I think given the shortness of the articles it would currently make more sense to have the whole think as a set of subsections of James Gamble Rogers IV. I'd go along with a single Oklawaha County, Florida article, but I suspect it would keep getting nominated for deletion (on the "non-notable fictional element" grounds I used for the nomination of the current sub-pages). The main article is short enough that it won't make it insanely long. —   (talk to me!)