In reading the above, I think I have to agree with nearly everyone (and yes, I think that's possible  )

If used for the infobox, then the image should be cropped for various reasons, though I also agree that perhaps the current "cropping" may not be the best (due to ThuranX's concerns, and possibly Peregrine Fisher's suggestion).

For other places in this or other articles, the uncropped version would seem to be appropriate, for the reasons stated by the original uploader and others.

Would