(a)it is a genetic study, and your alone persist in denying the evidence of the source itself. I.e. you defy commonsense in plain sight (b) you have no RS defining Elhaik's work as a 'fringe theory' (b) the Haaretz source does not say it is not supported by geneticists: it said geneticists refrained from being interviewed. (c) AnkhMorpork, Shirke (sic: check the dictionary),Evildoer187 have made no serious policy-based arguments so far.