The only problem is that the "Amy story" holds a bit more weight.  If you actually read more indepth into it, people are inclinded to believe it is true.  Unlike everyone, you think it's a HUGE MASSIVE RIGHT WING CONSPIRACY designed to discredit the anti-war leftist movement without any PROOF at all.  There is no proof that MacBeth served in the Rangers at all, nor was he Special Force.  So why are you trying to discredit the "Amy story" in order to help MacBeth?  Sorry but you have a hard time hiding your bias.