That is one possibility. If we want to use the existing Template:Guideline, the issue comes down to knowing exactly how many people are required to say that "many editors agree with" it. The Template:Guideline does not say that the guideline was approved by the Cabal, so we can use any process we want to get the "many editors" to formally agree with it if we want the Template:Guideline sticker. Personally, I don't like that template, nor do I think that Carbonite would ever commit to a specific number of people as being "many editors." For that reason, I agree that we should create our own template that does not require "many editors," and probably has better looking graphics, but I don't see why we would have to get the new template approved by anyone except those affected by it.