::Yes, as well as on Peiser's discussion.  If you think that this merits a "consensus" then our definitions of the word vary.  Essentially, what is happening is that Peiser's work is being diminished on Oreskes' page (which should focus on her biography and relative importance) and being highlighted on the Peiser page which should do the same for him.  You are attempting to diminish his positions on both pages so that a person looking for the link on Peiser will not be able to identify the basis of the controversy.