Could you please explain... 

I'd be very grateful if you would return to the  on Shona Holmes and explain
your BLP1e assertion.  Several contributors to that discussion have pointed out that her precedent-setting 2007 law-suit is a whole other event.  We have argued that this article encompasses at least two events.  Of course you are entitled to disagree.  But I would be very grateful if you explained why you discounted the civil, meaningful and specific counterarguments to BLP1e.