| Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat ||  || 87 || Legends
|-
| Rob Van Dam ||  || 90 || Legends
|-
| Santino Marella ||  || 79 || Raw
|-
| Shad Gaspard ||  || 79 || SmackDown
|-
| Shawn Michaels ||  || 94 || Legends
|-
| Sheamus ||  || 90 || Raw
|-
| Shelton Benjamin ||  || 86 || SmackDown
|-
| "Stone Cold" Steve Austin ||  || 94 || Legends
|-
| Ted DiBiase Jr. ||  || 83 || Raw
|-
| Terry Funk ||  || 86 || Legends
|-
| The Miz ||  || 88 || Raw
|-
| The Rock ||  || 93 || Legends
|-
| The Undertaker ||  || 95 || SmackDown
|-
| Triple H ||  || 95 || Raw
|-
| Tyson Kidd ||  || 81 || Raw
|-
| Vance Archer ||  || 78 || SmackDown
|-
| Vladimir Kozlov ||  || 82 || Raw
|-
| Wade Barrett ||  || 86 || DLC
|-
| William Regal ||  || 85 || Raw
|-
| Yoshi Tatsu ||  || 79 || Raw
|-
| Zack Ryder ||  || 80 || Raw