The Paragraph is the main problem as I have been repeatedly pointing out, before your helped your friend circumvent 3RR. 
 Here is my original edit summary where I clearly call out the editorializing Talbot paragraph and explain why I am removing it in favor of the original factual Talbot quote, which someone curiously removed. Please provide the correct edit summary next time if you wish to put my edits under the microscope. Subsequent edit summaries were during reverts, which were naturally more limited in description. Even those asked whether the reverting editor wanted additional cites([the revision history clearly shows])I was prepared to provide them on request. It takes two hands too clap. You didn't answer my question: are you both interested in resolving this dispute or something else?   
On a side note, I know english isn't your first language, but "chink" is considered a racist insult towards people of asian descent. You may wish to change that. In the interest of WP:Good Faith that can be considered a typo for now.