And the examples you cited didn't include a single instance of that. The closes thing you might have is where I told Filll to stop lying, but that's not a personal attack, because he was in fact lying, and doesn't even deny it. In fact, I've caught him lying about me on my talk page at least 5 times, and he doesn't deny those either. Is it uncivil to protect yourself, or other editors, when someone is lying in order to gain leverage in a content dispute?