== you asked why bonewah should recuse himself, now the review is closed, the answer here == 

 since the review is closed i can't respond there.  so your answer is here. 
 he should recuse himself because he was actively involved.  in fact he was was quite the pov-pusher and blanked a lot of content without discussion.  he can not be trusted to give an objective analysis.   that's where the whole idea of "recusal" comes from.  that's why they do it in courts and that's why they do it in juries. (though the process is different - the judges and attorneys dismiss the potential jurors rather than them dismissing themselves.)  it's a very important part of any system of justice or review.  so if you want to argue it's prudence or applicability, good luck with that.