*:::Firstly, in my opinion the consensus from that discussion is far from clear (Nilfanion seemed to strongly disagree) and it was a long time ago.  Personally I also don't like consensuses formed by a wikiproject without wider input (e.g. an RfC) as I think the participants are normally too closely involved, although I am aware that many don't share my view on this. Personally I'd give your argument some weight but not too much for the reasons I outline but I'm but one moderately experienced editor and we'll see what the closing admin thinks.  Thanks again for pointing me at relevant discussion, as before your explanation this was starting to feel like a whole of bunch of "ILIKEIT" votes.