:If you feel the current WP:BIO guidelines are inadequate, the better venue for discussing altering them is the Wikipedia talk:Notability (people) talkpage; I don't know how familiar you are with Wikipedia dispute resolution, despite your five years here, but the ArbCom normally only takes case of user behavior, not render down judgment to modify guidelines or policy against consensus. 

 :For the record, it makes no difference that I am "dealing with a religion and its leaders".  Everyone is equal in my eyes, and rabbis are held to the same standards of notability as lion trainers or singers, or whatever else.  Either they meet WP:BIO or they do not.  Why they do not is not material. 

 :Again, I must insist you keep this conversation on the article's AfD discussion.  I have no desire to hold a private discussion about the relative merits of this (or other) articles outside the proper venue.  —