:I'm honored that you would approach me in this manner to seek advice about making the website seem less "Islamophobic".  Thanks for that.  However, I don't know how much I could help you because the very premise of the site seems to stem from an anger towards Islam.  
 #The first problem is that you have a disingenuous disclaimer: "Welcome to WikiIslam.org, which anyone can edit. Here you can safely state the facts about Islam without fear of censorship, NPOV or political correctness."  Yet, as you write yourself, "Anyway WikiIslam functions more as a collaborative wiki for people writing against Islam - we have enough pro-Islam websites."  I have no problem with a website that has a specific agenda (or and ideological inclination), and if you think there are too many "pro-Islam sites" then you are more than welcome to add your own flavor to the world wide web, but why not be honest about it?  Why couch the site in ideas about freedom from censorship?   
 #This leads to a second problem in regards to the claims made by WikiIslam.  Can anyone really edit it?  If a "pro-Islamic" editor started filling up your pages with quotes and information that was favorable to Islam (but not "false") would it be left on the site?  Would your site, dedicated to letting people write about the negative aspects of Islam, tolerate the diffusion of its agenda with that kind of information?  Does it have to?  No it doesn't, but be honest (and see #1). 
 #Actually this is really all one big point.  If you honestly claimed to be a site dedicated to expose those things that "are negative about Islam" and only that then I would perhaps disagree with some of your claims, and I would most probably have a low opinion of your agenda, but I wouldn't think what you were doing was so disgraceful, because after all we are all welcome to our opinions in a free society.   
 #So really where I would start is with the masquarade, which is insulting and just makes those who disagree with you even angrier.  Don't lie or pretend to be simply freely telling the "truth" about Islam when you are only telling one very specific side of the story.  That's my one point diffused accross four for some odd reason.