:I took up the review because I'm actually an expert in early films with Arctic subjects, and since I've had practically nothing to do with this particular entry, it seemed reasonable for me to assess it. As to "active" I suppose it's a matter of degree  I've been contributing, mostly in very minor ways, to WP for years!  on the other hand, I have a life ). I've worked on a few GA's in my time, though not in this capacity  but I do have a question for you:  how exactly does one complete a review  has enough time lapse, have enough contributions been made  or does one just "make it so"?