::: Not really, actually.  Anderson was named to play in the All-Star Game four times, and was never selected a season-ending All-Star.  Ciccarelli the same, and his final All-Star Game was at the end of his career as one of those "senior" picks they do now.  Housley was named a Second Team All-Star once, but the flipping back and forth between center and defense probably hurts his credentials.  Even Gilmour in his two monster seasons didn't earn any award more prominent than a single Selke.  What's going on is that these guys played in the era with the most inflated scoring and the longest average career length in league history.  I agree that Duff and Gillies are shockingly bad picks, while Neely at least was a four-time Second Team All-Star, but with seventy players now over 1000 and more to come, that's a mark that's no guarantee.