I break it down as follows: 

 * SKATER - support 
 * SarekOfVulcan - support 
 * Baseball Bugs - oppose 
 * Malleus Fatuorum - "Both suggestions are silly" - oppose 
 * Lara - oppose 
 * Folantin - support 
 * BWilkins - unknown 
 * Master of Puppets - oppose 
 * RegentsPark - your involvement 
 * Hans Adler - support 
 * Akhilleus - support 
 * Excirial - support 
 * SandyGeorgia - unknown 
 * Philcha - states "Only an uninvolved admin should allowed to rule on an sanction - on any editor" so falls under oppose (and an oppose for you closing the sanction and ruling on it) 
 * Moreschi - unknown 
 * iMatthew - oppose 
 * rʨanaɢ - unknown "So if this discussion yields a unified result then maybe that can be called a "community sanction", but the one in place now holds no water" 
 * TenOfAllTrades - support 
 * Black Kite - oppose 
 * S Marshall - oppose 
 * Antandrus - support 
 * 4wajzkd02 - support 
 * user:J - support 
 * Ssilvers - support 
 * Will Beback - support 
 * JohnWBarber - support 
 * ChrisO - support 
 * jbmurray - support 
 * Until It Sleeps - support 
 * ChildofMidnight - oppose 
 * Tarc - oppose 
 * John - support 
 * Jeni - support 
 * Wikidemon - support 
 * Fritzpoll - no consensus/oppose - "sanctions are to be imposed based on a consensus of uninvolved editors (see WP:BAN - will check this is the right link), with many of those favouring a ban expressly indicating that they have had negative interactions with him" 
 * HalfShadow - oppose "Would all of you kindly shut the fuck up, please?" 
 * Protonk - oppose per HalfShadow 
 * SMC - oppose per HalfShadow 
 * SB_Johnny - unknown but "I find it absolutely ridiculous that Wikipedia:Requests for Comment/Ottava Rima remains a redlink while there are apparently so many people willing to bitch about him ad infinitum. WTF is the issue? If you all have so many things you want him to change about his behavior, why not just open a doggone RfC and let him know? Are you scared of him or something? You needn't be." 

 18 supports, 14 opposes, and other comments with many pointing out that restriction standards nullify many of the supports.