:::::You reached out to me on my talk page with a threat and I reached out to you on yours with details chronicling a persistent multi-year pattern of vicious personal attacks by AndyTheGrump, variously with and without the use of malicious foul language and / or code words based on religion. I'm not sure why AndyTheGrump thought that it was his place to jump into my conversation with you, so I'm not sure who your proposed ban would effect. The repeated use of "Jew-tagging" remains utterly unacceptable, despite AndyTheGrump's rationalizations. If Bus stop had been tagging people as LGBT or African American, substituting the corresponding slurs and appending "-tagging" to describe his actions would not have been treated quite as charitably. I'm not the expert in bigotry that AndyTheGrump is, but when you say that "Bus stop is a Jew-tagging bigot" after calling him variants of a "Jew-tagging troll" on about a dozen different occasions, you have crossed a line into using religion for the worst possible kind of personal attacks. There is nothing that Bus stop could ever have done to justify these attacks and there were plenty of ways without these vicious provocations to address the issues with him. WP:CIR notwithstanding, no one is competent  or authorized  to use "Jew-tagging troll" or "Jew-tagging bigot" as a slur; It's banned by WP:NPA, but that doesn't seem to apply to AndyTheGrump, only other people.