:I've taken a look. There's a lot of text to read, and links to check out - you may find that you get more responses from people if you give a brief summary. It is also unclear exactly what you are asking people, so it might help to ask a direct question. Example - "Is X (link to source) a reliable source for the article Y (link to article)?" There is no need to argue your case, or to mention that there's a dispute. It is particularly important not to mention the names of editors who disagree with you. That is not relevant. You are simply asking if a particular source is reliable for a particular article. Allow the experienced users at that forum to check the source and the article and make up their own minds. If you get a response from someone on that forum which appears to misunderstand the situation or the source, that is the time to briefly and politely provide additional information; but only provide extra information as and when needed. I hope that helps. ' '