:thanks for your thoughts sagerad.  this is a bit of an apples and oranges thing. the discussion about PMID 24491722 (the "Compositional differences in soybeans on the market") is a primary source which we generally steer clear of regardless of what they say.   PMID 26282372 (the seralini paper that was added and is the subject of this thread) is a review - a secondary source - so clears that hurdle.  The discussion about it, is a) whether it is reliable and b) if we use it, how, given Seralini's publication history.