Assholes: Captain Aaron Frank Kyler 
 Nice Guys: Captain Derek Valerie Amber Garrett 
 {| class="wikitable" 
 |- 
 ! Challenge 
 ! Winner 
 ! Sphere 
 ! Players 
 ! Winner 
 ! Eliminated 
 |- 
 | Football 
 | Nice Guys 
 | Rope 
 | Valerie (Nice Guy) vs. Amber (Nice Guy) 
 | Valerie 
 | Amber 
 |- 
 | Basketball 
 | Nice Guys 
 | Rope 
 | Frank (Asshole) vs. Garrett (Nice Guy) 
 | Garrett 
 | Frank 
 |- 
 | Toss Over 
 | Nice Guys 
 | Goal 
 | Derek (Nice Guy) vs. Garrett (Nice Guy) 
 | Derek 
 | Garrett 
 |- 
 | Tap That 
 | Assholes 
 | Rope 
 | Derek (Nice Guy) vs. Valerie (Nice Guy) 
 | Derek and Valerie both Advance after three attempts of Rope 
 | None 
 |- 
 | Finale 
 | Assholes (Kyler and Aaron) 
 | None 
 | None 
 | None 
 | Nice Guys (Valerie and Derek)