:::::I generally agree with you that ignoring theoreticals is the best way to proceed, but your position on WP:V is hard for me to comprehend.  I'm just trying to establish the parameters.  Anyway, probably you and I aren't going to get any further on this with just the two of us.  How about if we let the question sit here for a week or so to see if others weigh in, and if we don't get any further input or there's no way to discern consensus, we publicize the discussion in some agreed-on manner?—