:I have e-mailed you the book... so, now we can tell if it's an error with your internet browsers or with your acrobat.  They aren't exactly scans... so.. I'm not sure if DP would accept them... but, they should be facsimile's of the original... if you can open them then please do and show me the DP project... I'll do some proofreading.    

  
 Striver, I found something intersting.  Go to this book on the site you provided.  Go to the PDF version (or very near the end on Html) page 120/122 and see the quote about Omar... then look at the footnote.  That quote is by William Muir and says "I need hardly say that this sentiment is entirely at variance with the liberal and 
 tolerant policy of Omar."  So, how would we interpret something like that?  He was a very important scholar... and, I had never heard of Margoliouth until now but Muir I did know of... my point is... Zora was trying to say you weren't representing the whole picture by choosing Margoliouth... and, well, there's a part of the picture you're not showing.  One quote does not mean it's representative. And all my quote is trying to prove is that... we can't just accept your assertion that that was the prominent view of Umar.