I see in a post you left on Odd Nature's talk page that you are now claiming that there was a consensus. The trouble is that WP:CONS makes no mention of "weight of argument", let alone of giving Admins fiat to declare which side had it. WP:CONS is based on reaching an agreement, not on some Admin coming along and awarding a victory to one side. No agreement, no consensus. I would also point out this piece of WP:CONS to you: 

 Given that "rough consensus" is the exact wording used in Wikipedia:Categories for discussion, I would suggest that this piece of advice is directly relevant.