:Then I am off a bit. ) I didn't assume it was the critique, though, I presumed it was the strong divergence in opinion about the status of the piece (copyright okay versus blatantly not), which is why I mention the subjectivity of this particular work. I've seen stuff show up at CP marked as a copyvio for close paraphrasing that I myself found at worst superficially similar; I've also seen content restored to articles by others as "okay" that I thought was blatantly over the line. Sometimes when working at CP we do gut checks by asking other admins to check rewrites in particular.