: Since you're one of the disputants, I think it's really bad form (in addition to WikiLawyering) to try and get a "Is the closure endorsed" evaluation.  I came in to shut down the thread because it went far far far too long with you and  providing much of the talking past each other without looking for a way to compromise.  If you both want to fight it out and come up with a community endorsed split then go for it. Or you could work together to craft a new RFC to help figure out how to merge topics together...