:The objective here is to write an encyclopedia. So I agreed. This departure is a result of a sort of schizophrenia. A desire to portray the evolution of this controversy as absconded email instead of what is actually becoming, a broad spectrum scrutiny of many of the assumption of the IPCC and the AGW collective. It would work much better to separate the two subjects. ie the "hacking" incident and the subsequent media explosion. That would better represent the reality. I don't think anything here violate the wikipedia rules. Play nice. This isn't just your playground. It is everyone's.