::::::Well, your view is apparently not shared by consensus.  Notability is established when the topic "has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject".  Not when one person happens to think that, if we happen to have a topic on an article, it meets whatever criteria for whatever rating might be given.  There's a project-wide consensus standard here, and it's certainly not clear that it's been met.  That the entire article based solely on primary sources certainly doesn't help. '''' ''''