:::::Well, maybe we should edit the JFK article to make sure it mentions every woman he slep with.  Seriously, you ought to take this to the sub-article on the Thomas-Hill hearings.  This article is a summary article that's supposed to summarize the sub-articles.  As for ghe 2d Amendment case, all 5 in the majority were deciding votes, and Thomas rejected the rationale of the other 4.  (And use of the word "swallow" above was not consciously related to the BJs!)