BACKGROUND
cichlids are a group of rapidly diverging fishes from the great lakes of africa.
each lake harbors a separate endemic radiation of hundreds of species, which have evolved during its recent history.
cichlids are well known for their diversity of feeding specializations and associated trophic morphologies, as well as their beautiful array of color patterns.
we have found that their visual systems are also highly diverse, with some of the most variable visual pigments known in vertebrates  <cit> .
visual pigments comprise opsin proteins bound to a vitamin a-based chromophore, typically 11-cis retinal.
the amino acid sequence of the opsin determines the spectral absorbance of the pigment.
spectral tuning of the pigment occurs through amino acid substitutions at sites directed into the retinal binding pocket  <cit> .
visual pigment absorbance may be tuned to the environment, particularly in aquatic systems.
as water quality or depth varies, visual pigments evolve to better match the surrounding light field  <cit> .
owing to the tight correspondence between opsin sequence and function, opsins are an excellent system for the study of molecular adaptation  <cit> .
vertebrates have one rod opsin and four classes of cone opsins  <cit> .
the cone opsin genes include very short wavelength sensitive , short wavelength sensitive , rhodopsin-like  and long wavelength sensitive  classes.
each covers a unique spectral range  <cit> .
most fishes have opsin genes from each of these opsin classes and can, therefore, produce visual pigments covering a broad spectral range  <cit> .
cichlid fishes possess members of all four cone opsin classes.
additional gene duplications in several of the classes have produced seven distinct cone opsin genes .
analysis of opsin protein expression in tilapia, oreochromis niloticus, has shown that these seven genes produce visual pigments which are spectrally distinct from each other  <cit> .
the corresponding pigments in the lake malawi cichlid metriaclima zebra match their counterparts in tilapia with only small spectral shifts .
microspectrophotometry  data are given as the average ±  <dig> standard deviation and data for rh2a α and β are analyzed as one group.
although sequence differences cause subtle changes in opsin absorbance, rather drastic differences have been detected in the visual pigments of lake malawi cichlids  <cit> .
our previous work has shown that this results from differential expression of unique subsets of the seven cone opsin genes  <cit> .
for example, m. zebra has visual pigment peak absorbances  of  <dig>   <dig> and  <dig> nm, resulting from expression of sws <dig>  rh2b and rh2a opsin genes .
in contrast, dimidiochromis compressiceps has λmax of  <dig>   <dig> and  <dig> nm as the result of expression of the sws2a, rh2a and lws opsin genes.
we have also shown that tilapia, an outgroup riverine cichlid, expresses each of the opsin genes during some developmental stage.
the genes utilized by lake cichlids are, therefore, subsets of the full opsin set retained by tilapia  <cit> .
the mechanism driving the gene expression changes is not known.
in this work, we examine whether differential expression results from temporal changes in the developmental sequence of opsin expression.
heterochronic change in developmental patterning is a central idea linking evolution and development.
phenotypic diversity resulting from heterochrony has been demonstrated elegantly for morphological characters  <cit> .
a textbook example is salamanders of the genus ambystoma.
here, a decoupling of the developmental programs controlling body development and gonad maturation result in different adult forms  <cit> .
in neotenic forms, body development is slowed relative to the gonads such that mature gonads arise within a larval morphology.
plethodontid salamanders have direct developing forms, where the larval phase is abandoned such that only adult morphologies occur throughout development.
these ontogenetic programs can be summarized as differences in the rate or timing of different aspects of development .
although changes in developmental programs are most often associated with morphological differences , heterochronic changes have been identified for a variety of traits including bone ossification  <cit> , brain differentiation  <cit> , pigment patterning  <cit>  and social behavior  <cit> .
sensory systems have not yet been examined in terms of heterochrony.
however, the close association between visual system sensitivity and opsin gene sequence makes this a natural system to examine the role of developmental timing of opsin gene expression in sensory adaptation.
studies have shown that visual pigments can differ between larval and adult fishes  <cit>  including ultraviolet/violet pigment shifts in single cones  <cit>  and green/red pigment shifts in double cones  <cit> .
these ontogenetic shifts could be adaptations to changes in feeding behavior and/or the photic environment following metamorphosis.
shifts can also be more subtle, such as the changes in temporal or spatial expression of rh <dig> or lws gene duplicates that are seen early in the development of zebrafish, danio rerio  <cit> .
we do not expect cichlid visual pigments to change through ontogeny for two reasons.
first, cichlids develop directly without any discrete metamorphosis.
the young are mouth-brooded and pass through three developmental stages: embryonic ; larval ; and juvenile   <cit> .
sexual maturity occurs at the same age in tilapia and the lake malawi species.
second, there are no dramatic changes in habitat, water quality or photic environment as the fish develop.
for most species, juveniles are released and mature in the same general location where they were spawned.
previous cichlid studies support the developmental stability of the retinal mosaic with no obvious morphological changes.
the square retinal mosaic of four double cones surrounding a single cone occurs in o. niloticus  <cit> , the tanganyikan cichlid astatotilapia burtoni  <cit>  and the lake victoria species haplochromis argens  <cit> .
the mosaic is formed by day  <dig> or  <dig> and remains stable throughout development  <cit> .
however, these studies did not examine opsin gene expression or opsin proteins to test whether visual pigments varied developmentally.
in this work, we used real-time or quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction   <cit>  to quantify the relative expression of cone opsin genes through ontogeny.
we compared the outgroup cichlid, o. niloticus, with several species from lake malawi.
we also used microspectrophotometry  to confirm that in tilapia, the genes detected by qrt-pcr correspond to visual pigments present in the retina.
we were able to accurately quantify expression at multiple time points through ontogeny.
this enabled us to map the trajectory of opsin gene expression during the first months of the life cycle and to examine the role of heterochrony in visual sensitivity.
RESULTS
microspectrophotometry
msp of adult o. niloticus revealed three cone morphotypes: single cones with a pigment λmax at  <dig> ±  <dig> nm and double cones with a pigment λmax at either  <dig> ±  <dig> nm or  <dig> ±  <dig> nm.
tilapia utilize mixed chromophores consisting of retinal derived from both vitamin a <dig>  and vitamin a <dig>   <cit> .
since the most long wavelength sensitive a1-based pigments are  <dig> nm  <cit> , the presence of a  <dig> nm pigment is consistent with a mixture of a <dig> and a <dig> retinal.
double cone combinations included 542/ <dig> , 542/ <dig>  and 596/ <dig> .
rods contained visual pigments with a peak absorbance of  <dig> ±  <dig> nm.
msp of larval and juvenile tilapia revealed a greater diversity of cone types.
these included visual pigments from six distinct spectral classes from the ultraviolet to the lws pigments .
most individuals had retina utilizing a <dig> chromophores, although a1/a <dig> content differed between individuals resulting in variation in λmax for a given cone type.
as a1/a <dig> shifts increase with wavelength, shifts were most significant for the lws pigments.
the distribution of cone λmax did fall into groups, which were centered around the λmax measured from protein expression of the tilapia cone opsin genes reconstituted with the a <dig> chromophore  <cit> .
additional file  <dig> shows the distribution of cone λmax as well as the λmax determined from the a <dig> reconstituted proteins and the expected shifts between a <dig> and a <dig> pigments  <cit> .
we used the expected a1/a <dig> sensitivities as well as the observed groupings to sort the pigments into the following gene classes: sws <dig> , sws2b , sws2a , rh2b , rh2a  and lws .
based on this sorting, we calculated the average peak λmax ±  <dig> standard deviation  for each class and found they agreed with those determined from protein expression and reconstitution with 11-cis retinal   <cit> , allowing for some a1–a <dig> shift in the lws class.
we grouped the rh2a α and β cones into one rh2a class as there was too much overlap to separate them using msp.
msp measurements demonstrated the diversity of cone types present in the retina.
based on the assignment of cone λmax to opsin gene, we calculated the relative amounts of opsin expression for each developmental stage .
these calculations assume that each cone type expresses only one opsin gene.
these relative gene ratios were compared with those determined by qrt-pcr for whole retinas .
the ratios were in qualitative agreement and support the idea that when a given gene is transcribed, the corresponding protein is present in the retina.
cone opsin expression through tilapia ontogeny
tilapia opsin expression is turned on by  <dig> days post-fertilization.
this was determined by measuring rh2a and lws opsin relative to β-actin expression in whole tilapia embryos.
the lws opsin to β-actin ratio increased from  <dig>  to  <dig>  to  <dig>  on days  <dig>   <dig> and  <dig>  the average lws opsin/β-actin ratio during the first  <dig> days was  <dig>  so that day  <dig> expression was 44% of the larval level.
the rh2a genes showed similar temporal results.
opsin expression by day  <dig> is consistent with observations of complete cone outer segments by day  <dig> in a. burtoni  <cit> .
the dynamic changes in cone opsin gene expression through tilapia development are shown in figure  <dig>  the results from two tilapia broods agreed quite well and are superimposed.
curves have been fitted to the data to summarize the gene expression trends .
the sws <dig> and rh2b genes are expressed strongly in the larval phase, but are not expressed in adults.
expression of both genes steadily decreases until day  <dig>  when they are effectively turned off.
the sws2b gene is weakly expressed at the earliest times, peaks in expression around day  <dig>  and then decreases until it is turned off in adulthood.
expression of the sws2a gene does not turn on until day  <dig>  after which it increases steadily until the adult level is reached.
rh2a genes are expressed throughout ontogeny, but at low levels, while lws increases in expression until it levels off after day  <dig>
analysis of the ontogenetic expression patterns using analysis of variance  showed that several of the genes are correlated temporally.
sws <dig> and rh2b follow similar time courses and are linearly correlated with each other .
both genes are inversely correlated with lws  and sws2a  genes.
finally lws is positively correlated with sws2a  and negatively correlated with rh2aα .
these close temporal associations suggest there may be genetic co-regulation of these genes.
this may be the result of the genomic organization of these genes in tandem arrays similar to the opsin genes of other fishes  <cit> .
comparison of tilapia qrt-pcr gene expression and msp
gene expression determined by qrt-pcr was compared with msp cone count results by averaging gene expression from several individuals at ages comparable with the individuals examined by msp .
the gene expression measured by qrt-pcr and inferred from msp cone counts agreed qualitatively at each of the four developmental stages.
whenever a given gene is expressed, we detected the expected cone type using msp.
these developmental comparisons confirmed previous results, which showed agreement between gene expression and the presence of corresponding cone types in adults .
therefore, qrt-pcr and msp provide consistent descriptions of which cones are present at a given developmental stage.
we also quantitatively compared the msp and qrt-pcr results using regression analysis .
in general, when a given gene's expression increases, more cones are detected.
however, the rh2a gene showed the opposite trend, suggesting the qrt-pcr and msp results were not correlated perfectly.
there are several reasons why these two methods might differ quantitatively.
first, the fish examined by msp and qrt-pcr came from different broods raised at different times.
second, msp is not a comprehensive method and inherently involves sub-sampling just a few cones from one or two parts of the retina.
third, msp convolves gene expression and chromophore usage.
this decreases the accuracy of making one-to-one assignments of the cone class to the opsin gene expressed.
fourth, since the photoreceptor outer segments turn over every  <dig> or  <dig> weeks  <cit> , msp measures the protein which has been produced during the preceding  <dig> or  <dig> weeks.
gene expression measures the genes that are being expressed on a given day.
therefore, the two methods measured proteins or genes across different time frames.
for all of these reasons, we use msp only to make qualitative comparisons and to support the idea that expression of a given gene indicates the presence of the corresponding cone protein at that life stage.
during msp, cells are identified based on cone morphology  providing a link between visual pigment absorbance and cone morphology.
we can therefore draw additional conclusions about the progression of gene expression in a given cone type.
the  <dig> ,  <dig>  and  <dig> nm  pigments are all expressed in single cones.
therefore, the qrt-pcr data suggest that there is an ontogenetic progression in single cones, from sws <dig> to sws2b to sws2a.
in double cones, the  <dig> ,  <dig>  and  <dig> nm  pigments are expressed.
since rh2a expression is relatively constant, this suggests that expression of the rh2b gene is replaced by lws.
in tilapia, cone opsin gene expression reaches the final adult complement of opsin genes at  <dig> days, or approximately  <dig> months .
at this point, the sws <dig>  sws2b, rh2b and rh2aβ genes are turned off and sws2a, rh2aα and lws genes are on.
therefore, the expression of these genes agrees with the observation of three visual pigments in adults by msp.
cone opsin expression through ontogeny of lake malawi cichlids
ontogenetic plots of opsin gene expression in lake malawi cichlids showed two different patterns, both of which differ from that seen in tilapia.
species from the rock-dwelling clade  show one ontogenetic pattern .
for single cone genes, the sws <dig> gene is turned on in larvae and although it decreases somewhat, it is never turned off.
the sws2b gene turns on slowly through development and then stays on.
no expression of the sws2a gene is observed.
although sws2a could be expressed under some other behavioral or reproductive state, it is possible that sws2a may now be a pseudogene in these species.
we have found missense mutations in sws2a showing that it is a pseudogene in the tanganyikan cichlid, neolamprologus brichardi  <cit> .
in double cones, the rh2b gene is turned on and, although it decreases, it stays on into the adult stage, following a pattern similar to sws <dig>  the rh2a genes  are highly expressed while expression of lws is quite low.
these rock-dwelling species, therefore, mimic the expression patterns of young tilapia.
they follow the gene progression pattern up through about  <dig> days post-fertilization  in tilapia, but stretch this progression out over their life cycle.
the malawian rock-dwelling cichlids have altered their developmental pattern, slowing down the progression of opsin gene expression.
another significant change is that the rh2a and lws genes have switched roles.
in tilapia, lws is highly expressed and rh2a is expressed at a low level.
in the malawian rock dwellers, rh2a is highly expressed while lws is expressed at a low level.
species from the sand-dwelling clade  show a different ontogenetic pattern of opsin expression .
in d. compressiceps,  <dig> dpf fry express the same gene complement as adults, with significant expression of only sws2a, rh2a and lws.
t. intermedius also shows strong similarities between its larval, juvenile and adult expression patterns, which center on sws2a, rh2a and lws expression.
therefore, in both sand dwellers, the larval retina appears to have a pattern of gene expression similar to that in adults.
in order to put the different gene expression patterns on a biological scale, which can be plotted through development, we converted gene expression into average peak wavelength of either single or double cones.
this was based on a weighting of the relative expression of each gene and its peak spectral absorbance, determined from protein expression .
for single cones, the sws <dig>  sws2b and sws2a genes are expressed so that the single cone λmax is given by
λmax⁡,s=fsws1λsws1+fsws2bλsws2b+fsws2aλsws2afsws1+fsws2b+fsws2a
for double cones, rh2b, rh2a and lws genes are expressed so that
λmax⁡,d=frh2bλrh2b+frh2aλrh2a+flwsλlwsfrh2b+frh2a+flws
here, fi is the fraction of the ith opsin expressed out of the total and λi is its corresponding peak absorbance.
in figure  <dig>  we plot this average λmax for each cone type, as a function of age, to highlight the wavelength shifts that occur through development.
we have simplified the data presentation in order to summarize all of the species on one plot and highlight the trends in the data.
for those species where we have a significant number of data points , we fitted the raw data and plot only the fit curves for clarity .
for those species where we had fewer data points, we included the raw data in the figure.
the data in figure  <dig> map out how cone λmax varies through ontogeny.
for tilapia, opsin gene expression  shows that single cones progress from sws <dig>  to sws2b  to sws2a .
this gives an average λmax for tilapia single cones  that starts at  <dig> nm and increases through  <dig> nm at  <dig> dpf and ends at  <dig> nm in adults .
for tilapia double cones, gene expression goes from a mixture of rh2b and rh2aα in early development to rh2aα and lws in adults.
in figure 6b, the average λmax starts at the average of these two double cone pigments  and ends with double cones with λmax close to that of the lws cones .
tilapia, therefore, shows an obvious ontogenetic progression from low to high λmax in both single and double cones.
the tilapia ontogenetic pattern differs significantly from what we see for the lake malawi cichlids.
m. zebra, m. zebra 'gold', m. benetos and l. fuelleborni show λmax values that start low in larvae and stay low or rise more slowly than the tilapia progression.
therefore, they retain the characteristics of tilapia larval/juvenile gene expression patterns and can be considered neotenic, with decelerated rates of opsin progression.
both single and double cone λmax for d. compressiceps and t. intermedius start high early in development and remains high into the adult stage, similar to the λmax of tilapia adults.
this suggests these species have direct developing retinas, which express only adult-like genes resulting in adult-like peak sensitivities.
discussion
differential gene expression, utilizing subsets of the opsin genes, is a powerful mechanism by which the visual system can be tuned through development.
in this work, we used qrt-pcr to document the differential expression of opsin genes during development in several cichlid species.
this study is one of the first to map out the trajectory of opsin gene expression and to demonstrate that heterochronic shifts can occur in neural systems.
the tilapia visual system changes through ontogeny
adult tilapia have a retina based on three spectral classes of cones .
the presence of three spectral classes of cone is similar to that reported for other african cichlids  <cit> .
these three cone types are a direct result of the expression of three cone opsin genes in adults: sws2a, rh2a and lws genes  <cit> .
larval and juvenile tilapia express different subsets of the opsins and have more complex visual pigment complements.
there are periods when four opsin genes are expressed and a brief period around 45– <dig> days when six cone opsins are present.
this dynamic progression of expressed cone opsin genes starts with the short wavelength sensitive genes, sws <dig> and rh2b, which are then replaced with the longer wavelength sensitive juvenile  and adult  genes.
ultraviolet/violet sensitivity occurs in many juvenile fishes, as well as fishes that feed on plankton  <cit> .
the expression of the ultraviolet  and then violet  sensitive genes in the early life stages of tilapia may, therefore, be important for successful foraging.
another temporal change is that more of the double cones become long wavelength sensitive as the lws gene becomes the dominant opsin expressed in double cones.
the shift toward longer wavelength sensitivity may help tilapia adapt to the typically murky african riverine environment  <cit> .
riverine cichlids studied previously use vitamin a <dig> chromophores, a factor which may be correlated with more turbid visual environments and selection for longer wavelength sensitivity  <cit> .
this agrees with our previous observations of increases in lws expression and a <dig> chromophore use in cichlids from the murky habitats of lake victoria  <cit> .
quantifying the temporal patterns of opsin gene expression reveals a dynamic visual system, which changes through tilapia ontogeny.
previous morphological studies indicate that the cichlid retinal mosaic is not restructured through development  <cit> , although additional studies are needed to confirm this.
if this is true, then opsin expression in individual photoreceptors must change through time resulting in co-expression of more than one visual pigment in a given cell for brief periods.
co-expression has been documented in certain rodents  <cit>  and other larval fishes  <cit> .
in msp of tilapia, we did not find evidence for co-expression in single cones.
however, msp of the youngest fish is difficult as the cones are quite small and we may not have had a high enough signal-to-noise ratio to distinguish between two pigments with somewhat overlapping spectra.
however, we did find approximately  <dig> double cones at 30– <dig> dpf having dual absorbance peaks at  <dig> and  <dig> nm, indicating expression of both rh2b and lws genes.
it was possible to bleach the  <dig> and  <dig> nm pigments separately, confirming the presence of two distinct proteins.
we therefore suggest a model in which the retinal mosaic and its associated neural wiring remains constant, while the complement of cone opsins shifts from shorter to longer opsins as the fish matures.
future work to localize opsins using in situ hybridization is needed to confirm retinal spatial patterning and document the succession of opsin genes, in particular photoreceptor cell types.
lake malawi opsin expression exhibits heterochrony
the lake malawi species all have the same seven cone opsin genes possessed by their sister group, tilapia.
however, the ancestral progression of gene expression has been modified as they adapt to their unique ecologies.
two different developmental patterns were identified here.
larval malawi rock dwellers express the short wavelength sensitive genes found in young tilapia fry and either retain this larval gene set  or slowly shift to the tilapia's juvenile gene set .
this neotenic expression pattern enables these species to retain the short wavelength sensitivities found in young tilapia.
the malawian sand dwellers, d. compressiceps and t. intermedius, have a different pattern.
they express the long wavelength sensitive genes, similar to adult tilapia.
however, they do not follow the same complex ontogenetic progression from shorter to longer wavelength sensitivities seen in tilapia.
instead, they follow a direct development path and express the long wavelength genes beginning in the larval stages.
these changes in developmental program may be an adaptation to the constantly clear waters of lake malawi, which is one of the clearest lakes in the world  <cit> .
fish that inhabit a constant photic environment throughout their life can use the optimal pigment set for those conditions, and may no longer need developmental shifts in visual sensitivity.
these developmental changes may also have been driven by the specialized foraging behaviors of these species.
most rock-dwelling cichlids are opportunistic zooplanktivores.
retaining the larval ultraviolet/violet sensitivities into their adult stages may enable them to feed more efficiently on zooplankton throughout their lives  <cit> .
the sand dwellers studied here are not known for zooplanktivory and, therefore, may not need ultraviolet/violet detection capabilities.
role of heterochrony in sensory systems
this work documents the differing temporal pattern of opsin gene expression in cichlid fishes.
opsin expression can be dynamic, with a progression of different opsin gene combinations from the larval to adult stages.
however, lake malawi cichlids have modified the developmental program of their cichlid tilapia-like ancestor.
some express the adult gene sets at larval stages while others retain the larval genes into adulthood.
these heterochronic shifts cause the large differences in adult sensitivities observed between closely related species  <cit> .
heterochrony is, therefore, a key mechanism by which cichlid visual systems are tuned.
these differences have evolved among closely related species which have radiated in lake malawi within the last  <dig> million years.
figure  <dig> summarizes the cichlid developmental programs within a phylogenetic context including results from lake victoria  <cit> .
the rapid evolution of these expression patterns suggests that regulation of the different opsin genes is coordinated by a developmental program that can be easily modified.
studies of additional species are needed to determine how labile these heterochronic shifts are.
however, it is clear from this work that evolution can alter early developmental stages to shape adult visual systems.
heterochronic shifts in gene expression are a powerful way to modify the senses.
CONCLUSIONS
cichlids have diverse visual sensitivities which differ between species.
these sensitivities can vary through development, with heterochronic shifts in developmental patterning resulting in alternate adult sensitivities.
changes in adult visual sensitivities could have important implications for mate preferences, mate choice and ultimately cichlid speciation.
if closely related species differ in visual sensitivities, females with different visual preferences might prefer differently colored males as mates.
work is in progress to determine whether closely related species differ in visual sensitivities, how these sensitivities relate to the spectral colors of males, and whether these differences affect female mate preferences.

 cichlids are a group of rapidly diverging fishes from the great lakes of africa. each lake harbors a separate endemic radiation of hundreds of species, which have evolved during its recent history. cichlids are well known for their diversity of feeding specializations and associated trophic morphologies, as well as their beautiful array of color patterns. we have found that their visual systems are also highly diverse, with some of the most variable visual pigments known in vertebrates. visual pigments comprise opsin proteins bound to a vitamin a-based chromophore, typically 11-cis retinal. the amino acid sequence of the opsin determines the spectral absorbance of the pigment. spectral tuning of the pigment occurs through amino acid substitutions at sites directed into the retinal binding pocket. visual pigment absorbance may be tuned to the environment, particularly in aquatic systems. as water quality or depth varies, visual pigments evolve to better match the surrounding light field. owing to the tight correspondence between opsin sequence and function, opsins are an excellent system for the study of molecular adaptation. vertebrates have one rod opsin and four classes of cone opsins. the cone opsin genes include very short wavelength sensitive, short wavelength sensitive, rhodopsin-like and long wavelength sensitive classes. each covers a unique spectral range. most fishes have opsin genes from each of these opsin classes and can, therefore, produce visual pigments covering a broad spectral range. cichlid fishes possess members of all four cone opsin classes. additional gene duplications in several of the classes have produced seven distinct cone opsin genes. analysis of opsin protein expression in tilapia, oreochromis niloticus, has shown that these seven genes produce visual pigments which are spectrally distinct from each other. the corresponding pigments in the lake malawi cichlid metriaclima zebra match their counterparts in tilapia with only small spectral shifts. microspectrophotometry data are given as the average ± standard deviation and data for rh2a α and β are analyzed as one group. although sequence differences cause subtle changes in opsin absorbance, rather drastic differences have been detected in the visual pigments of lake malawi cichlids. our previous work has shown that this results from differential expression of unique subsets of the seven cone opsin genes. for example, m. zebra has visual pigment peak absorbances of and nm, resulting from expression of sws rh2b and rh2a opsin genes. in contrast, dimidiochromis compressiceps has λmax of and nm as the result of expression of the sws2a, rh2a and lws opsin genes. we have also shown that tilapia, an outgroup riverine cichlid, expresses each of the opsin genes during some developmental stage. the genes utilized by lake cichlids are, therefore, subsets of the full opsin set retained by tilapia. the mechanism driving the gene expression changes is not known. in this work, we examine whether differential expression results from temporal changes in the developmental sequence of opsin expression. heterochronic change in developmental patterning is a central idea linking evolution and development. phenotypic diversity resulting from heterochrony has been demonstrated elegantly for morphological characters. a textbook example is salamanders of the genus ambystoma. here, a decoupling of the developmental programs controlling body development and gonad maturation result in different adult forms. in neotenic forms, body development is slowed relative to the gonads such that mature gonads arise within a larval morphology. plethodontid salamanders have direct developing forms, where the larval phase is abandoned such that only adult morphologies occur throughout development. these ontogenetic programs can be summarized as differences in the rate or timing of different aspects of development. although changes in developmental programs are most often associated with morphological differences, heterochronic changes have been identified for a variety of traits including bone ossification, brain differentiation, pigment patterning and social behavior. sensory systems have not yet been examined in terms of heterochrony. however, the close association between visual system sensitivity and opsin gene sequence makes this a natural system to examine the role of developmental timing of opsin gene expression in sensory adaptation. studies have shown that visual pigments can differ between larval and adult fishes including ultraviolet/violet pigment shifts in single cones and green/red pigment shifts in double cones. these ontogenetic shifts could be adaptations to changes in feeding behavior and/or the photic environment following metamorphosis. shifts can also be more subtle, such as the changes in temporal or spatial expression of rh or lws gene duplicates that are seen early in the development of zebrafish, danio rerio. we do not expect cichlid visual pigments to change through ontogeny for two reasons. first, cichlids develop directly without any discrete metamorphosis. the young are mouth-brooded and pass through three developmental stages: embryonic; larval; and juvenile. sexual maturity occurs at the same age in tilapia and the lake malawi species. second, there are no dramatic changes in habitat, water quality or photic environment as the fish develop. for most species, juveniles are released and mature in the same general location where they were spawned. previous cichlid studies support the developmental stability of the retinal mosaic with no obvious morphological changes. the square retinal mosaic of four double cones surrounding a single cone occurs in o. niloticus, the tanganyikan cichlid astatotilapia burtoni and the lake victoria species haplochromis argens. the mosaic is formed by day or and remains stable throughout development. however, these studies did not examine opsin gene expression or opsin proteins to test whether visual pigments varied developmentally. in this work, we used real-time or quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction to quantify the relative expression of cone opsin genes through ontogeny. we compared the outgroup cichlid, o. niloticus, with several species from lake malawi. we also used microspectrophotometry to confirm that in tilapia, the genes detected by qrt-pcr correspond to visual pigments present in the retina. we were able to accurately quantify expression at multiple time points through ontogeny. this enabled us to map the trajectory of opsin gene expression during the first months of the life cycle and to examine the role of heterochrony in visual sensitivity.  microspectrophotometry msp of adult o. niloticus revealed three cone morphotypes: single cones with a pigment λmax at ± nm and double cones with a pigment λmax at either ± nm or ± nm. tilapia utilize mixed chromophores consisting of retinal derived from both vitamin a and vitamin a. since the most long wavelength sensitive a1-based pigments are nm, the presence of a nm pigment is consistent with a mixture of a and a retinal. double cone combinations included 542/, 542/ and 596/. rods contained visual pigments with a peak absorbance of ± nm. msp of larval and juvenile tilapia revealed a greater diversity of cone types. these included visual pigments from six distinct spectral classes from the ultraviolet to the lws pigments. most individuals had retina utilizing a chromophores, although a1/a content differed between individuals resulting in variation in λmax for a given cone type. as a1/a shifts increase with wavelength, shifts were most significant for the lws pigments. the distribution of cone λmax did fall into groups, which were centered around the λmax measured from protein expression of the tilapia cone opsin genes reconstituted with the a chromophore. additional file shows the distribution of cone λmax as well as the λmax determined from the a reconstituted proteins and the expected shifts between a and a pigments. we used the expected a1/a sensitivities as well as the observed groupings to sort the pigments into the following gene classes: sws, sws2b, sws2a, rh2b, rh2a and lws. based on this sorting, we calculated the average peak λmax ± standard deviation for each class and found they agreed with those determined from protein expression and reconstitution with 11-cis retinal, allowing for some a1–a shift in the lws class. we grouped the rh2a α and β cones into one rh2a class as there was too much overlap to separate them using msp. msp measurements demonstrated the diversity of cone types present in the retina. based on the assignment of cone λmax to opsin gene, we calculated the relative amounts of opsin expression for each developmental stage. these calculations assume that each cone type expresses only one opsin gene. these relative gene ratios were compared with those determined by qrt-pcr for whole retinas. the ratios were in qualitative agreement and support the idea that when a given gene is transcribed, the corresponding protein is present in the retina. cone opsin expression through tilapia ontogeny tilapia opsin expression is turned on by days post-fertilization. this was determined by measuring rh2a and lws opsin relative to β-actin expression in whole tilapia embryos. the lws opsin to β-actin ratio increased from to to on days and the average lws opsin/β-actin ratio during the first days was so that day expression was 44% of the larval level. the rh2a genes showed similar temporal results. opsin expression by day is consistent with observations of complete cone outer segments by day in a. burtoni. the dynamic changes in cone opsin gene expression through tilapia development are shown in figure the results from two tilapia broods agreed quite well and are superimposed. curves have been fitted to the data to summarize the gene expression trends. the sws and rh2b genes are expressed strongly in the larval phase, but are not expressed in adults. expression of both genes steadily decreases until day when they are effectively turned off. the sws2b gene is weakly expressed at the earliest times, peaks in expression around day and then decreases until it is turned off in adulthood. expression of the sws2a gene does not turn on until day after which it increases steadily until the adult level is reached. rh2a genes are expressed throughout ontogeny, but at low levels, while lws increases in expression until it levels off after day analysis of the ontogenetic expression patterns using analysis of variance showed that several of the genes are correlated temporally. sws and rh2b follow similar time courses and are linearly correlated with each other. both genes are inversely correlated with lws and sws2a genes. finally lws is positively correlated with sws2a and negatively correlated with rh2aα. these close temporal associations suggest there may be genetic co-regulation of these genes. this may be the result of the genomic organization of these genes in tandem arrays similar to the opsin genes of other fishes. comparison of tilapia qrt-pcr gene expression and msp gene expression determined by qrt-pcr was compared with msp cone count results by averaging gene expression from several individuals at ages comparable with the individuals examined by msp. the gene expression measured by qrt-pcr and inferred from msp cone counts agreed qualitatively at each of the four developmental stages. whenever a given gene is expressed, we detected the expected cone type using msp. these developmental comparisons confirmed previous results, which showed agreement between gene expression and the presence of corresponding cone types in adults. therefore, qrt-pcr and msp provide consistent descriptions of which cones are present at a given developmental stage. we also quantitatively compared the msp and qrt-pcr results using regression analysis. in general, when a given gene's expression increases, more cones are detected. however, the rh2a gene showed the opposite trend, suggesting the qrt-pcr and msp results were not correlated perfectly. there are several reasons why these two methods might differ quantitatively. first, the fish examined by msp and qrt-pcr came from different broods raised at different times. second, msp is not a comprehensive method and inherently involves sub-sampling just a few cones from one or two parts of the retina. third, msp convolves gene expression and chromophore usage. this decreases the accuracy of making one-to-one assignments of the cone class to the opsin gene expressed. fourth, since the photoreceptor outer segments turn over every or weeks, msp measures the protein which has been produced during the preceding or weeks. gene expression measures the genes that are being expressed on a given day. therefore, the two methods measured proteins or genes across different time frames. for all of these reasons, we use msp only to make qualitative comparisons and to support the idea that expression of a given gene indicates the presence of the corresponding cone protein at that life stage. during msp, cells are identified based on cone morphology providing a link between visual pigment absorbance and cone morphology. we can therefore draw additional conclusions about the progression of gene expression in a given cone type. the, and nm pigments are all expressed in single cones. therefore, the qrt-pcr data suggest that there is an ontogenetic progression in single cones, from sws to sws2b to sws2a. in double cones, the, and nm pigments are expressed. since rh2a expression is relatively constant, this suggests that expression of the rh2b gene is replaced by lws. in tilapia, cone opsin gene expression reaches the final adult complement of opsin genes at days, or approximately months. at this point, the sws sws2b, rh2b and rh2aβ genes are turned off and sws2a, rh2aα and lws genes are on. therefore, the expression of these genes agrees with the observation of three visual pigments in adults by msp. cone opsin expression through ontogeny of lake malawi cichlids ontogenetic plots of opsin gene expression in lake malawi cichlids showed two different patterns, both of which differ from that seen in tilapia. species from the rock-dwelling clade show one ontogenetic pattern. for single cone genes, the sws gene is turned on in larvae and although it decreases somewhat, it is never turned off. the sws2b gene turns on slowly through development and then stays on. no expression of the sws2a gene is observed. although sws2a could be expressed under some other behavioral or reproductive state, it is possible that sws2a may now be a pseudogene in these species. we have found missense mutations in sws2a showing that it is a pseudogene in the tanganyikan cichlid, neolamprologus brichardi. in double cones, the rh2b gene is turned on and, although it decreases, it stays on into the adult stage, following a pattern similar to sws the rh2a genes are highly expressed while expression of lws is quite low. these rock-dwelling species, therefore, mimic the expression patterns of young tilapia. they follow the gene progression pattern up through about days post-fertilization in tilapia, but stretch this progression out over their life cycle. the malawian rock-dwelling cichlids have altered their developmental pattern, slowing down the progression of opsin gene expression. another significant change is that the rh2a and lws genes have switched roles. in tilapia, lws is highly expressed and rh2a is expressed at a low level. in the malawian rock dwellers, rh2a is highly expressed while lws is expressed at a low level. species from the sand-dwelling clade show a different ontogenetic pattern of opsin expression. in d. compressiceps, dpf fry express the same gene complement as adults, with significant expression of only sws2a, rh2a and lws. t. intermedius also shows strong similarities between its larval, juvenile and adult expression patterns, which center on sws2a, rh2a and lws expression. therefore, in both sand dwellers, the larval retina appears to have a pattern of gene expression similar to that in adults. in order to put the different gene expression patterns on a biological scale, which can be plotted through development, we converted gene expression into average peak wavelength of either single or double cones. this was based on a weighting of the relative expression of each gene and its peak spectral absorbance, determined from protein expression. for single cones, the sws sws2b and sws2a genes are expressed so that the single cone λmax is given by λmax⁡,s=fsws1λsws1+fsws2bλsws2b+fsws2aλsws2afsws1+fsws2b+fsws2a for double cones, rh2b, rh2a and lws genes are expressed so that λmax⁡,d=frh2bλrh2b+frh2aλrh2a+flwsλlwsfrh2b+frh2a+flws here, fi is the fraction of the ith opsin expressed out of the total and λi is its corresponding peak absorbance. in figure we plot this average λmax for each cone type, as a function of age, to highlight the wavelength shifts that occur through development. we have simplified the data presentation in order to summarize all of the species on one plot and highlight the trends in the data. for those species where we have a significant number of data points, we fitted the raw data and plot only the fit curves for clarity. for those species where we had fewer data points, we included the raw data in the figure. the data in figure map out how cone λmax varies through ontogeny. for tilapia, opsin gene expression shows that single cones progress from sws to sws2b to sws2a. this gives an average λmax for tilapia single cones that starts at nm and increases through nm at dpf and ends at nm in adults. for tilapia double cones, gene expression goes from a mixture of rh2b and rh2aα in early development to rh2aα and lws in adults. in figure 6b, the average λmax starts at the average of these two double cone pigments and ends with double cones with λmax close to that of the lws cones. tilapia, therefore, shows an obvious ontogenetic progression from low to high λmax in both single and double cones. the tilapia ontogenetic pattern differs significantly from what we see for the lake malawi cichlids. m. zebra, m. zebra'gold', m. benetos and l. fuelleborni show λmax values that start low in larvae and stay low or rise more slowly than the tilapia progression. therefore, they retain the characteristics of tilapia larval/juvenile gene expression patterns and can be considered neotenic, with decelerated rates of opsin progression. both single and double cone λmax for d. compressiceps and t. intermedius start high early in development and remains high into the adult stage, similar to the λmax of tilapia adults. this suggests these species have direct developing retinas, which express only adult-like genes resulting in adult-like peak sensitivities. discussion differential gene expression, utilizing subsets of the opsin genes, is a powerful mechanism by which the visual system can be tuned through development. in this work, we used qrt-pcr to document the differential expression of opsin genes during development in several cichlid species. this study is one of the first to map out the trajectory of opsin gene expression and to demonstrate that heterochronic shifts can occur in neural systems. the tilapia visual system changes through ontogeny adult tilapia have a retina based on three spectral classes of cones. the presence of three spectral classes of cone is similar to that reported for other african cichlids. these three cone types are a direct result of the expression of three cone opsin genes in adults: sws2a, rh2a and lws genes. larval and juvenile tilapia express different subsets of the opsins and have more complex visual pigment complements. there are periods when four opsin genes are expressed and a brief period around 45– days when six cone opsins are present. this dynamic progression of expressed cone opsin genes starts with the short wavelength sensitive genes, sws and rh2b, which are then replaced with the longer wavelength sensitive juvenile and adult genes. ultraviolet/violet sensitivity occurs in many juvenile fishes, as well as fishes that feed on plankton. the expression of the ultraviolet and then violet sensitive genes in the early life stages of tilapia may, therefore, be important for successful foraging. another temporal change is that more of the double cones become long wavelength sensitive as the lws gene becomes the dominant opsin expressed in double cones. the shift toward longer wavelength sensitivity may help tilapia adapt to the typically murky african riverine environment. riverine cichlids studied previously use vitamin a chromophores, a factor which may be correlated with more turbid visual environments and selection for longer wavelength sensitivity. this agrees with our previous observations of increases in lws expression and a chromophore use in cichlids from the murky habitats of lake victoria. quantifying the temporal patterns of opsin gene expression reveals a dynamic visual system, which changes through tilapia ontogeny. previous morphological studies indicate that the cichlid retinal mosaic is not restructured through development, although additional studies are needed to confirm this. if this is true, then opsin expression in individual photoreceptors must change through time resulting in co-expression of more than one visual pigment in a given cell for brief periods. co-expression has been documented in certain rodents and other larval fishes. in msp of tilapia, we did not find evidence for co-expression in single cones. however, msp of the youngest fish is difficult as the cones are quite small and we may not have had a high enough signal-to-noise ratio to distinguish between two pigments with somewhat overlapping spectra. however, we did find approximately double cones at 30– dpf having dual absorbance peaks at and nm, indicating expression of both rh2b and lws genes. it was possible to bleach the and nm pigments separately, confirming the presence of two distinct proteins. we therefore suggest a model in which the retinal mosaic and its associated neural wiring remains constant, while the complement of cone opsins shifts from shorter to longer opsins as the fish matures. future work to localize opsins using in situ hybridization is needed to confirm retinal spatial patterning and document the succession of opsin genes, in particular photoreceptor cell types. lake malawi opsin expression exhibits heterochrony the lake malawi species all have the same seven cone opsin genes possessed by their sister group, tilapia. however, the ancestral progression of gene expression has been modified as they adapt to their unique ecologies. two different developmental patterns were identified here. larval malawi rock dwellers express the short wavelength sensitive genes found in young tilapia fry and either retain this larval gene set or slowly shift to the tilapia's juvenile gene set. this neotenic expression pattern enables these species to retain the short wavelength sensitivities found in young tilapia. the malawian sand dwellers, d. compressiceps and t. intermedius, have a different pattern. they express the long wavelength sensitive genes, similar to adult tilapia. however, they do not follow the same complex ontogenetic progression from shorter to longer wavelength sensitivities seen in tilapia. instead, they follow a direct development path and express the long wavelength genes beginning in the larval stages. these changes in developmental program may be an adaptation to the constantly clear waters of lake malawi, which is one of the clearest lakes in the world. fish that inhabit a constant photic environment throughout their life can use the optimal pigment set for those conditions, and may no longer need developmental shifts in visual sensitivity. these developmental changes may also have been driven by the specialized foraging behaviors of these species. most rock-dwelling cichlids are opportunistic zooplanktivores. retaining the larval ultraviolet/violet sensitivities into their adult stages may enable them to feed more efficiently on zooplankton throughout their lives. the sand dwellers studied here are not known for zooplanktivory and, therefore, may not need ultraviolet/violet detection capabilities. role of heterochrony in sensory systems this work documents the differing temporal pattern of opsin gene expression in cichlid fishes. opsin expression can be dynamic, with a progression of different opsin gene combinations from the larval to adult stages. however, lake malawi cichlids have modified the developmental program of their cichlid tilapia-like ancestor. some express the adult gene sets at larval stages while others retain the larval genes into adulthood. these heterochronic shifts cause the large differences in adult sensitivities observed between closely related species. heterochrony is, therefore, a key mechanism by which cichlid visual systems are tuned. these differences have evolved among closely related species which have radiated in lake malawi within the last million years. figure summarizes the cichlid developmental programs within a phylogenetic context including results from lake victoria. the rapid evolution of these expression patterns suggests that regulation of the different opsin genes is coordinated by a developmental program that can be easily modified. studies of additional species are needed to determine how labile these heterochronic shifts are. however, it is clear from this work that evolution can alter early developmental stages to shape adult visual systems. heterochronic shifts in gene expression are a powerful way to modify the senses.  cichlids have diverse visual sensitivities which differ between species. these sensitivities can vary through development, with heterochronic shifts in developmental patterning resulting in alternate adult sensitivities. changes in adult visual sensitivities could have important implications for mate preferences, mate choice and ultimately cichlid speciation. if closely related species differ in visual sensitivities, females with different visual preferences might prefer differently colored males as mates. work is in progress to determine whether closely related species differ in visual sensitivities, how these sensitivities relate to the spectral colors of males, and whether these differences affect female mate preferences. 
in some species, the expressed gene set changes slowly, either retaining the larval pattern or progressing only from larval to juvenile gene sets. in addition to differences in color pattern, lake malawi cichlids also show some of the largest known shifts in visual sensitivity among closely related species. differences in visual sensitivities among species of lake malawi cichlids arise through heterochronic shifts relative to the ontogenetic pattern of the tilapia outgroup. cichlid fishes have radiated into hundreds of species in the great lakes of africa. to test this, we compared the developmental pattern of cone opsin gene expression of the nile tilapia, oreochromis niloticus, with that of several cichlid species from lake malawi. in contrast, lake malawi species showed one of two developmental patterns. in tilapia, quantitative polymerase chain reaction showed that opsin gene expression changes dynamically from a larval gene set through a juvenile set to a final adult set. these shifts result from modulated expression of seven cone opsin genes. in this work, we ask whether these differences might result from changes in developmental patterning of cone opsin genes. we found that altering developmental expression patterns is also an important mechanism for altering sensory systems. strong discrimination by females causes differential male mating success, rapid evolution of male color patterns and, possibly, speciation. heterochrony has previously been shown to be a powerful mechanism for change in morphological evolution.
 cichlid fishes have radiated into hundreds of species in the great lakes of africa. brightly colored males display on leks and vie to be chosen by females as mates. strong discrimination by females causes differential male mating success, rapid evolution of male color patterns and, possibly, speciation. in addition to differences in color pattern, lake malawi cichlids also show some of the largest known shifts in visual sensitivity among closely related species. these shifts result from modulated expression of seven cone opsin genes. however, the mechanisms for this modulated expression are unknown.  in this work, we ask whether these differences might result from changes in developmental patterning of cone opsin genes. to test this, we compared the developmental pattern of cone opsin gene expression of the nile tilapia, oreochromis niloticus, with that of several cichlid species from lake malawi. in tilapia, quantitative polymerase chain reaction showed that opsin gene expression changes dynamically from a larval gene set through a juvenile set to a final adult set. in contrast, lake malawi species showed one of two developmental patterns. in some species, the expressed gene set changes slowly, either retaining the larval pattern or progressing only from larval to juvenile gene sets. in the other species, the same genes are expressed in both larvae and adults but correspond to the tilapia adult genes.  differences in visual sensitivities among species of lake malawi cichlids arise through heterochronic shifts relative to the ontogenetic pattern of the tilapia outgroup. heterochrony has previously been shown to be a powerful mechanism for change in morphological evolution. we found that altering developmental expression patterns is also an important mechanism for altering sensory systems. these resulting sensory shifts will have major impacts on visual communication and could help drive cichlid speciation. 