Current LD topic

Since I'm highly limited in characters, this will be very short and I wont be able to go strictly point by point [Values Debate] NC V: Justice 1. He says I dont say how he doesnt link, then he says ignore the definitions debate..... --> Its the definitions that make the link. You cant separate the two. Since justified is not justice, as the definition states, he has no link. 2. America was founded on justice --> No warrant --> America was founded in opposition to Britain, not in the conception of justice At this point you cannot accept my opponents value, and since he puts so much weight on it in the observations, he has no offense coming from the NC NC VC 1. Only ground --> He didnt respond to the ground argument itself. Thus, vote on theory: opponent has skewed the ground of the debate thus violating fairness. AC V: Global Stability 1. Logical fallacy - supposed guide the debate --> Evaluation from an end standpoint doesn't alter the guidance of a round. It simply holds wieght from an utmost consequential view point --> Extend the analogy of safety and such being values used in LD --> Solvency achieves the value. Not hard to understand. 2. End cannot be vague but specific --> Not necessarily. It is an overarching end trying to be achieved through the resolution. *Extend gain all 5 warrants. This value needs to be accepted for having the closest and most relevant scope of the resolution* AC VC: Hegemony 1. No response --> Yes I responded by saying your attack didnt answer the internal links of the Kagan evidence. You took one internal link and said it was wrong. These are clearly extended internal links from the card. 2. Red Scare plus Terror analogy --> New in the 2 *Even if you drop terror from the internal links of Kagan, the ones mentioned above are still being weighed in the round. That maintains the VC link to the V* [AC Contentions] Rakowsky - PMFs necessary for miltiary readiness, and isolated link to Iraq and Afghanistan Stanger and Williams - PMFs needed for specialized operations Rich - the only military airpower industries are PMFs. Hazdra - Air power is necessary for war effectiveness. Airpower necessary in U.S. hegemonic operations Melinger - Airpower is the U.S. unique hegemonic ability. Airpower is key to maintain heg. --> All of these extended pieces of evidence are offense from the AC. They all link to heg as the VC which has a direct link to global stability. [His voters] 1. Values debate --> Refer to top of this. He doesnt have a value linked to the resolution. This mitigates the importance of his abusive VC, but you still should vote off the theory which he dropped 2. No reason to vote aff --> He completely skews the rules of LD and makes his own throughout the round. --> There is clear evidence from the AC which went dropped [My voters] 1. The dropped evidence from the AC links to the dropped internal links of the Kagan evidence. This coupled with the dropped warrants of Global Stability means the evidence links directly to the resolution meaning an Ac ballot 2. Theory. My opponent dropped the theory under his VC 3. [Defensive Voter] No way to vote on anything from the NC. As apparent above, he has absolutely no resolutional link