That twilight sucks

Dear Pro. . . Thank you for the debate. I really like the idea of the debate. I have also read several Steven king books, all of harry potter, the lord of the rings the hobbit. I have only read the first book of twighlight, but I have recently lost a bet and was forced to watch all three movies. i will reference 1 individual directly for support, joseph cambel and one book 'a billion wicked thoughts`. Along with the books you have forward. Rebuttal #1 Argument from Authority You say the books suck because other authors say it sucks. That’s fine, but there are other authors who say your preferred authors suck. An argument from your preferred authors does not lend weight to your argument. They are experts at writing, in very specific fields, towards very specific target audiences. This does not mean that they are authorities on other forms of writing. I reject your claim of authority as biased and irrelevant until you show how it is. Also can you please provide quotes for your claims? Rebuttal #2 Refuting your claim from actual authority There are 23 general plots in the literary world, dozens of archetypes and millions of variations on each theme. The plot is star crossed lovers from other sides of the track, a play on romeo and juliet. There is the typical reject from 1 party for the safety of other. The father whose sole job is the safety of a community, and the love interests family being a threat. There is the love triangle for tension, there is conflict from without as a minor threat (victoria) and a major threat (NWO dakota team) from belle’s love interest, as well as internal conflicts (pregnancy and ability to have children) and external, constantly being killed from Edwards blood relatives. Coming from a broken home, to an eternal marriage is a central theme. There is a resolution to conflict, questioning of values and judgments. There is also the future predictor, who acts as a moral guide, the quest for truth, the external others, the environment challenges. These are all parts of parts of stories found in Lord of the rings, the hobbit, Steven king books. Joseph Campbell, who actually studies stories (including those listed) lays out plot, character development and something called the HERO’s Journey. Google it and you will find it referencing everything from the LOTR to Twighight. The hero's journey is very clear progression from point a to b. The twilight stories follow it very clearly. http://en.wikipedia.org... He, not your authors is an expert on stories. Rebuttal #3 Argument from false comparison I believe if you’re going to compare apples to apples it should be that, not apples to oranges. You making an argument from false comparison. James patterson is geared toward late teens and audlts who like pop cultural idea and plot. Steven king is a horror writer. Harry potter is for tweens and teens, as well as adults. and Lord of the rings is a biblical tome that sole virtue is its use of language, not plot or character development or moral lessons, in fact it is sexist, mysognistic and slightly preachy. They are books targeted towards different readership. Can you name another book for the target audience that you do approve of? Rebuttal #4 Augment from preference A billion wicked thoughts is an extraordinary book on the difference between men and women. In one chapter it goes in to the preferred writing desired by Men vs Women. The entire language base for women reading books vs visual cues for men is different. That is why many men predominantly do not like the book. Preference by one group does not mean better then another group. http://en.wikipedia.org... Can you define what you mean by one is better than another? Rebuttal #5 Argument from popularity (and slight hypocrisy) The only reason you have presented those books and authors is they are popular. Not catcher in the rye, or Gatsby or even the bible. Your argument is that these popular authors and books are better, but this popular book and writer is not. Can you tell me why it sucks, and PLEASE be specific. . . Thank you for your time.