The 11th Doctor is Better Than The 10th Doctor.

Whoops, sorry about that. I don't think anyone can identify with the things the Doctor goes through. Well, a lot of 10th Doctor stories would beg to differ. Sure you can't exactly feel what he's going through but Tennant acts him in a way a human normally does, so it's a bit too easy to indentify what he's going through. With Smith, under that naive skin he has a complex set of things that go over your head, but it's focused on in just the right amount where you don't know what emotion it is exactly, but you know it's there. If the Doctor was just some strange alien and did not have a lot of human characteristics and did not function like some type of human, no one would want to watch the show. I'm not saying that he has to be totally alien, but when you have an alien that's too human, you really sort of lose the point of him being alien. The most interesting thing is how he interacts with his companions, who are the actual humans. Also, Tennant does do the talking thing but I don't think it's as overwhelminingly quick as Smith does it. Tennant has more of a charming fast talking thing. When you watch the tenth Doctor you feel as if you are having an intimate relationship with him of some kind; as if you yourself have traveled with him and he loved you as a friend and you loved hi back that way. His honesty and his warmth make his performances very realistic and compelling and causes an intimacy with the audience unlike any Doctor before in my opinion. I mostly agree with this. What it comes down to, though, is that I really don't want to feel that when I watch Doctor Who. That sounds like the sort of thing I'd watch a sitcom or a talk show for. Rather I'd watch more because I'd want to see what the Doctor does next. This was my original point; when he becomes an actual friend, you almost lose that respect for him, and that mystery that usually shrouds his character. I think this kept him from having many negative human characteristics like arrogance, ignorance, etc. I think he is almost like the perfect human... Maybe those "perfect" qualities make him less human because hardly anyone can achieve those things. Even considering things like this, still, that difference is supposed to put a bit of a gap between the Doctor and a human. Not just physically but character wise. He also loves how every human is greatly different and still similar to one another. I don't think he views us as a "novelty" or he wouldn't come back to Earth all the time, spend so much time saving us personally, and keep having human companions. I always thought that in Doctor cases where he actually chooses his companions (instead of them being lugged onto him) chose them because he thought they were fun. Also, the Doctor has had some human enemies, too. What he likes is the idea of humanity. Over trillions of years, it pushes on and it forces itself to survive. But the "human is greatly different and still similar to one anoher" thing wouldn't be why. When a Doctor regenerates, he becomes a completely different and new person. In the second season, Rose and the Doctor had to begin their relationship all over again Untrue. When Ninth started, they were just companions. We go into the 10th Doctor's run, and right off the bat the love interest has been established. So the relationship isn't "all over again". I believe that throws the entire character development arguement out. Forfeited rounds aside, I honestly did not expect such a strong argument toward Tennant. I thank the CON for the debate.