Star Trek (pro) vs. Star Wars(con) ship-to-ship battle

Note: due to new information, the USS Enterprise only has 10 torpedo launchers, not 12 as stated earlier. While I love both Star Trek and Star Wars, in a ship-to-ship battle the USS Enterprise-E would be victorious over the Imperial Class-I Star Destroyer. .. Mainly because of 3 things, shields, superior design, and engines While both ships have some form of shielding, the USS Enterprise has superior shields. .. 7 shield generators, whereas the Imperial Class-I Star Destroyer has only 2 shield generator domes. And while there is no true measurement of which is stronger, the ISD-72x deflector shield generator is vulnerable to "missile weapons such as concussion missiles or proton torpedoes" and given that Photon Torpedos and Proton Torpedos are similar in size, the shields of the Star Destroyer are vulnerable to the Photon Torpedos aboard the USS Enterprise, and once the shields are down, the ship is easily destroyed. Thus, the USS Enterprise has an obvious advantage over the Star Destroyer in the aspect of shielding. The design of the Imperial Star Destroyer is flawed in two major ways. . A: Shield Positioning If I could add a picture I would show you. But, the positioning of the shield generators is stupid, they protrude from the top of the ship being like "shoot me" Thus, the USS Enterprise would have an easy shot with their photon torpedos and they would be able to easily knock out the Star Destroyer's shields. B: ineffective placement of weaponry "Like with several other Star Destroyer classes, the designers did not take advantage of their wedge shape to give the heavy cannons the ability to focus on targets in the forward firing arc that were level with the ship" So, in simplicity, any ship on a similar level (in reference to the y-axis)with the Imperial Star Destroyer would not receive the full brunt of the weapons onboard. The engine of the USS Enterprise-E has almost instantaneous warp travel and faster warp engines (reaching almost warp 10 in TNG: Encounter at Farpoint) than the Star Destroyer's hyperdrives, using this the Enterprise could easily jump in and out of warp easily evading the Star Destroyer's weapons while dealing severe damage to the Star Destroyer. Basically a run down 1: Enterprise fires photon torpedos at the Star Destroyer's shield generators and easily destroys them because of their poorly designed positioning (reason 1+2) 2: Due to poor designing of the Star Destroyer the USS Enterprise does not receive the brunt of the weapons, but can deal heavy damage (with its 18 phaser arrays and the torpedo launchers) to the Star Destroyer due to the fact the shields are down. 3: If the Enterprise starts taking heavy damage, it can warp away, reload, then warp back in deal significant damage. So, while the Star Destroyer has the weapons and size advantage, the USS Enterprise has the ability to strategically strike the Imperial Class-I Star Destroyer to destroy shields, then without shields the Star Destroyer would be crippled by the USS Enterprise's 18 Phase Arrays and it's photon and quantum torpedos, which the latter can deal twice the energy of a matter-antimatter reaction (which is a lot of energy, good luck surviving a hit from one of those, let alone 150) Source: . http://starwars.wikia.com... Source: . http://starwars.wikia.com... Source:. http://memory-alpha.wikia.com... Just for laughs: