The user known as 'philosphical' is the same person as the user known as 'GhostWriter.'

Thanks, Phil. 1. ORP MAFIA Suspicion about GW/Phil being the same person arose when he correctly targeted 4/5 people in one mafia on DP1 of RR's game. All 4 of these people were in GW's mafia; Phil was unable to call out anyone from any other mafia (and there were 3). Anyone who has ever played a mafia game knows the extreme unlikelihood of this happening, and can also ration that I would never be so careless as to reveal nearly my entire mafia within the first 10 pages on DP1. Phil has given a gigantic explanation as to how he came to his conclusion though much of it is a straight up lie! For a STEP BY STEP explanation of what happened with DIRECT QUOTES from that day phase, I have provided all of that info here: http://www.debate.org... Now, you'll see that Phil's exact words from R1 were, "Then I ask her why she cared so much about GW and not KRF." In other words, his whole analysis was based on the fact that I did not "care enough" to protect KRF (and that somehow makes the both of us mafia... right. He used terrible logic the whole time). Plus, this is a blatant LIE. On page 5 of that game, a direct quote from me (to Nags) reads, "You've got a point; however, I don't think KRF's comment meant any more than yours did (so I'm defending KRF)... Who would you suggest we lynch and why? Is it still KRF? I'm just asking because I think that's kind of a stretch." In other words, I did indeed defend KRF meaning everything Phil has been saying is complete and utter bullsh!t. Proof: http://www.debate.org... 2. FACEBOOK GW admitted that she lied on DDO about her age, name and profile picture. What incentive did GW have to lie about all of the above while registering? It's more likely that Phil just could not borrow someone's Facebook with those credentials in time when we asked GW to prove via Facebook that she was someone =/= Phil. GW used the Facebook account of Kim Cox of Salt Lake City, UT. She is a 40+ year old paralegal who is Facebook friends (and comments) with a user known as Destiny Gillies: http://i41.tinypic.com... . Destiny Gillies is Facebook friends and RELATED TO none other than Connor Gillies, a.k.a. Philosophical: http://i41.tinypic.com... . Of course Phil claimed to have "no idea" who Kim Cox is lol. We can assume that for a 12 y/o and 40 y/o to be Facebook friends that they're related. Phil admits that he's related to Destiny meaning he's probably related to Kim Cox too. Now, Phil will tell you that this is a "coincidence" but the odds of this obviously suggest otherwise! What are the odds that this mutual friend of his relative's (with a giant age gap) is the person HE IS ACCUSED OF BEING ON DEBATE.ORG? This whole point alone is evidence enough that Phil is lying though I have several more contentions for your own amusement. Moreover, Phil and GW have ANOTHER friend in common: Manola Cox. Obviously he's lying about having no idea who KC is. Also, Kim Cox has mysteriously chosen to delete Vi from her Facebook friends and GW is MIA. 3. BACK TO BACK SIGN-ONS Since it was becoming increasingly obvious to many members that GW and Phil were the same person, I wanted to pay close attention to the times the 2 of them signed on. Not surprisingly, GW is ONLY active on DDO when she is playing in mafia games -- Puck attests to this here: http://www.debate.org... . Additionally, several site members have watched both accounts sign on back to back; Rezz even said he thought "everyone in the community already knew" that GW and Phil were the same person: http://www.debate.org... . Clearly, this suspicion has been widespread for quite some time making it reasonable to assume that people WERE watching the accounts (and noticing patterns). The only thing Phil has to contest this accusation is him saying, "That's not true." However, there are several eye witnesses who can say otherwise. In other words, it's many people's word against 1. Further, I can take a screen shot of my PM to a site member (if necessary) of times where we were acknowledging the back to back switching of Phil and GW. Additionally, I can offer proof of Phil and GW signing on back to back on more than 1 occasion by posting a screen shot of them accepting their mafia roles in Vi's game back to back (Phil @ 7:25 / GW @ 7:28) Proof: http://tinypic.com... / http://tinypic.com... 4. MORE MAFIA CHEATING Alex Hanson mentioned that GW started complaining about the integrity of his game only after the user philosphical found out that he was going to die in the game. Why would a 40+ year old woman feel such contempt at this silly game? And why only after Phil was going to die? Also, in Vi's game Phil was the cop and received information that Ragnar was guilty; however, he was silenced. Because he could not talk during the day phase, he changed his avatar to be the word 'voice' crossed out, and had his alter-ego GW post and call out Ragnar... despite the fact that GhostWriter didn't replace someone until the night before, meaning she wouldn't have known that Phil's intention was to investigate RR anyway. GW frequently posts that she doesn't like reading through entire day phases so what are the odds that she coincidentally knew who Phil was going to investigate? She also seemed to know that Phil was silenced. She pointed out in the DP thread, "Phil's online..." implying that she was going to note the fact that he was online yet probably silenced. In other words, he was going to cheat by revealing his cop investigation and condition using GW. Plus, it was when GW mentioned, "He's online" that I noticed the accounts switching back and forth (one time of many). 5. HIS MISTAKE In noting that Phil and GW were signing on back to back a lot over a few minute period, Vi decided to experiment by asking GhostWriter why she did not vote for herself in her writer's debate with Phil. Obviously debating with Phil was the first debate that GW ever did on this site (and only 1 of 3 in 6 months -- the other debates were jokey debates -- clearly something a grown 40 year old woman would do... right). PHIL responded with, "Because I forfeited." However, PHIL DID NOT FORFEIT - GHOSTWRITER FORFEITED. In other words, he forgot which account he was using and posted as the wrong person. Here's proof (Comments Section) : http://www.debate.org... 6. SPELLING/GRAMMAR Phil uses horrible spelling and grammar; he apparently does not understand the the difference between "your" and "you're." GhostWriter - though she is apparently some brilliant lawyer - seemingly has the same problem. I have screen shots of both Phil and GW making this error though I won't post it due to a lack of character space (I will if requested). Further, both Phil and GW write her name out as two separate words (ghost writer) which I find to be an odd coincidence. Another thing to note is that this grown woman apparently writes using phrases like "kk" and saying "sweet" (as in cool) while talking to Vi; however, the Facebook account we were given depicts the real Kim Cox as having far from such a juvenile vernacular. Even Nags has noted the fact that phil and GW have near identical typing styles as well: http://www.debate.org... 7. IP INFO GhostWriter signed on to DDO Fans using the IP address 69.171.174.67 which is a Cricket Wireless ISP. Cricket works in correspondence with Metropcs and Sprint Nextel. Guess what kind of phone Phil has? Answer: Sprint Nextel. Proof (from the still shot of him making a video with his phone) -- http://img441.imageshack.us... CONCLUSION: I'm out of character space, but I'll say that the number of "coincidences" is far too damning to mount up to "coincidences!"