Resolved: The USFG should withdraw the United States Forces of Korea

CX: Never, obviously North Korea has never collapse and no country with nuclear weapons and that is near so many powerhouse countries. Other collapse dont matter because or evidence is specific to North Korea. CP "Their theory is flawed, Like I said it's against the rules to be extra-topical" In no way am i extra topical, im still withdrawing. Whether the troops go to the US or LAtin America it doesnt matter. He has given no reasons why i am extra topical dont let him bring it back up again. " PICS GOOD" Your counterplan isnt a PIC in ANY way. PICS EXCLUDE part of the Aff. You literally do my plan the something else. None of your offense/defense applies because its not a PIC. also i read Plan-Plus bad. You did not respond to this. It was a voter so that means its an automatic voter for the Aff. Extend all Plan Plus bad, they dropped it. Extend my Perm THEY DROPPED IT. I am not extra topical, and perm solves all of their advantages. SKFTA First of all they dropped ALL of my non unique, no link and no impact defense which is all much more recent than the evidence in their first speech. They also dropped the fact that i solve for Prolif through the case flow. Also, SKFAT has absolutlely NOTHING to do with Britain. SKFTA is between South Korea and the US. Britain isnt involved in any way. A. Hisrtorically disproven, no superpowers have attacked upon collapse. too involved in their own issues -this is a horrible argument, North Korea has never collapsed before. Also it is similar to what happened in rome. They collapsed and the barbarians invaded. They only difference is that back then their werent nuclear weapons that could be stolen or used. "B. we answered that nk will go to war/On bandow 03, extend no invasion arguments" -Once again our case has nothing to do with Nk going to war. Extend all of my arguments that SK can win war with NK and other arguments thay state US presence is only driving the conflict. Not to mention that the Nuclear umbrella deters NK. He dropped all of this in his last speech dont let him bring it up again. ">Cronin 12-21 - Like I said there is no proof that superpowers will directly confront now, because they have not in the past" Once again the North Hasnt collapsed in the past. this takes out this entire argument. Extend Cronin 12-21 and Nye 91 which is the Biggest IMPACT in this debate. Its a Nuclear War between Russia, China and the US and Nye indicates that this will lead to extinction. He dropped our other internal link which is that the North has Nuke weapons and if it collapses this will be loose fissile material. This tempts other groups or factions to steal them and use them. Extend Sid-Ahmed 04 that this = extinction. Also 1nc case arguments do not apply, also extend my responces from the subsequent speech, as well as this one. Perm is not severence in any way he has not shown how it is severnce. Im still doing the entirety of my plan plan the troops are going to latin america. Proves the CP is plan plus and he dropped all of my Plan Plus bad theory which is an automatic voter for the PRO side. If you allow Plan Plus and disallow Perm then it kills the aff because the neg can literally steal my plan and add ANY addition to it and claim a net benefit. Also it forces the aff to debate against his own plan which kills debate. Their is no reason why we cant do both the plan and the CP in the same world, and solve back their advantages. Perm is not severance. Case Underview 1.Extend Myers 12-18 that regime collapse is imminent because of a.Leadership transition b.Instability in government c.Korea's Failing Economy 2.This causes a.Civil War between factions in DPRK b.Conflict between China, Russia, South Korea and US-all move in attempting to stabilize c.Uncontrolled nukes in North Korea -Cronin 12/21 and International Crisis Group 9 d. Each of these causes extinction- Nye 91 and Sid-Ahmed 04 3.We solve a.First we have to withdraw our troops because China does not like our presence there b.China and South Korea will go to North Korea and -Denuclearize -Ensure peaceful leadership transition -Reunify c. But we have to withdraw –Nguyen 9 and Onozuka 6