Nazi Economics

Like i stated before i will make my final arguements in this round because round 4 is strictly rebuttals. However before i start my arguements i would like to remind my opponent and the voters that the resolution is "Nazi rule over Germany created a better economy" and i stated in the rules that the resolution may not be changed. 1. Work ProgramsThe 25 point plan was a national socialist economic plan that was developed in the 1920's but werent instituted until 1933. The plans points were political, social and economical. The main points of the plan were the nationalize the country and create a system where the government controls the means of production and the production was primarily focused on the war effort. Also that the creation of a welfare state is neccessary ensure equality for all its citizens. (1)2. Non reliance on global macro economicsAlong with the 25 point plan the Germany economy was fully independent of other nations. This created a scenario where even if the economies of other nations fail they wont. For example recently China's economy was taking a bit of a stumble but the effects of their stumble severly hurt US and other european countrie's economies (2)However the Germany economy didnt fail even when the threat of sanctions and cutting off aide became apparent when Germany was aggressive in Europe3. Large Public Work projectsLike ive stated in the previous round the Germans centered their economy around war and public work projects. For example the creation of new buildings, highways and weapons reduced unemployment to a staggering .8 percent! (3). Not only this but public support for Nazi's grew with the creation of these new projects! So not only did the Nazi's increase their economy through projects they also gained support4. The complete lack of interest in paying reparationsIn order to have a fully functioning economy the Germans needed to get out of the Great Depression. However one major things was standing in their way: Reparations. 50 million marks were required (4)! Because Hitler's economic policy was not reliant on other countries the Germans could do what they wanted. However a capitalistic approach would not be able to survive because that requires reliance on other countries. The fasicst/nationalistic approach of Nazi Germany allowed Germany to rebuild its economy at an astonishing rateRebuttalsNazi's unfairly taxed minoritiesMy opponent doesnt explain how this negativley effected the Nazi economy. He seems to be making more of a moral arguement than an economic one. In fact this actually helps me because hauling items from other non germans and distributing the wealth in Germany is actually helpful to the economy. Again i explicitly state we were talking from an economic standpoint and not a moral one. War fueled the economy not just economicsAgain my opponent isnt really making sense here. He is stating that war helped the German economy and not just economic policy. However the resolution clearly states "Nazi rule over germany created a better economy". I did not say "Nazi economics, and only Nazi economics, created a better economy in Germany". So my opponents point about the war effort is null and void. Not only this but fascist economies rely on high military spending and wars. Citizens create weapons and drive the economy by having jobs and supplying the unending military conquest. Centrally planned economyAgain my opponent makes a moral arguements and not a economic one. Why should rights effect the economy and if it does Con has still not explained why they effect the economy. I have made arguements that a centralized government creates a better economy in round 1 already. Private PropertyAgain the morality arguement! Con STILL does not explain why the government taking property away from citizens negatively effects the economyBetter economic policiesAgain the resolution states "Nazi rule over Germany created a better economy". We are not talking about other systems. Con's job was to prove that Nazi rule over Germany negativley effected the economy, not bring up other solutions. My opponent brings up how new things have been invented in a free market economy but the Germans also invented many things as well such as the volkswagon and pionneering large scale highways (5)My opponent also brings up current US economics. Not only does this have nothing to do with the resolution it is completley biased. The economics of WW2 germany should be compared with the economics of WW2 american. However even that is futile since it has nothing to do with the resolution. My opponenet concludes with the fact that FDR got us out of the great depression. And how did he do this? By instating welfare programs. And who pioneered one of the largest welfare states of all time? Thats right! Germany (5)The arguements used in Round 2 of this debate by my opponent have either been promptly rebutted or have nothing to do with the resolution. Sources:(1): . https://en.wikipedia.org...(2): . http://www.telegraph.co.uk...(3): . https://en.wikipedia.org...(4): . https://en.wikipedia.org...(5): . http://listverse.com...