In fair fight, Qui-Gon Jinn would likely defeat Luke Skywalker

It'll be fun! I will structure my case as follows: first, a critique of Luke Skywalker's abilities; second, an analysis of Qui-Gon's abilities; third, a crystallization of the arguments in the form of a brief comparison of both combatants. LUKE SKYWALKER Luke, at the end of Episode 5, was indeed a skilled fighter; however, there are several critiques we can make of his abilities. Firstly, he was brash and rushed into decisions. After receiving a prophetic vision on Dagobah, Luke left in the middle of his training to fight an opponent (Vader) who was far more skilled than he. Luke demonstrated difficulty in calming himself when channeling the force, as evidence by his issues with telekinesis during his training period with Yoda (clip No.1). Moreover, during Luke's duel with Vader, Luke's lightsaber strokes were blunt and imprecise. His technique lacked refinement, enabling Vader to disarm him at two different junctures. At no point was Vader not fully in control of their duel. Then, we faced with Vader's using of telekinesis to fling objects at him, rather than respond calmly, Luke ineffectively attempted to bat the objects away with his lightsaber (clip No. 2). Finally, Luke lacked training. Consider that by this point, Luke's only formal training in lighstaber combat was with some practice using a remote while en route to Alderaan in Episode 1, and, presumably, during his brief stay on Dagobah with Yoda. In contrast, Qui-Gon had a lifetimes experience beneath his belt, and was far more practiced and confident. QUI-GON JINN "Qui-Gon Jinn was one of the finest swordsman in the Jedi Order, having frequent sparring experience with many of his skilled contemporaries; notably Mace Windu and Anoon Bondara. Jinn was a master of the fourth form of lightsaber combat, Ataru. In combat, his bladework was wide and powerful, marked by heavy, two-handed slashes, and sudden flourishes to cover his flanks. Jinn's mastery of Ataru allowed him to easily defeat blaster wielding opponents despite the forms weakness to blaster fire. Rather than focus on an overall strategy, Jinn preferred to adjust his technique based on the needs of the moment. .. Jinn was also capable of effectively employing unarmed combat strikes into his lightsaber sequences. " [1] We can see a marked difference in skill, elegance, and precision in the clip of Qui-Gon's duel with Maul vice the clip of Luke's duel with Vader. Moreover, Qui-Gon gave Maul a vicious fight and a run for his money. At times throughout the duel Qui-Gon would be on top, clearly pushing Maul to his limits even without Obi-Wan's assistance. Again, at no point did Luke dominate Vader. ANALYSIS Qui-Gon was skilled as a swordsman and in his abilities to deflect blaster blots. In fact, Qui-Gon as one of the best duelist of his time would have clearly dominated the Luke Skywalker from Episode VI. Moreover, Qui-Gon was not likely to act in an irrational manner, and had years of experience on which to draw. Luke, however, clearly lacked to seasoning and clearheadedness of combat Vader effectively. Therefore, this is a no contest. Qui-Gon would crush Luke like a bug. SOURCE . http://starwars.wikia.com... Thanks! Over to Con. .. . http://www.youtube.com... . http://www.youtube.com... . http://www.youtube.com...