Minecraft is better than Terraria.

First of all you agreed with me, and consent can be a reason to vote for me, but I believe you were just showing courtesy, and I am letting the voters know that they should not vote on your first line in their RFDs. Let me address all arguments in order of appearance. Definitons. Both of my definitions were agreed to by you, which is good and I appreciate that. The two points of agreement. Because you did not respond to these, you clealry agree that both games are fully modable, and fully enjoyable by anyone. Why agreeing to the two points of agreement is detrimental to you will be examined later. But first your responses.1. Minecraft on the console has a crafting system like Terraria'sThis was basically your assertion. That on the PS4 edition, you can craft with preset recipes, like you can in Terraria. But my response is that the crafting system in Terraria is better not just because of the recipes, but also becasue of the depth. Unlike in Minecraft, the amount of craftable items in Terraria is vast, and far outnumbers Minecraft. Combine that with the recipes that are available, and it is seen Terraria has a better system, and a more in depth system.2. Minecraft is not meant to be advanced in weaponryYour last sentence under this point made little sense, but it should have because the point obviously was incomplete. You are arguing that Terraria is just a more modern tech range. But that is simply not true. You neglect the fact that in vanilla Minecraft, no guns, or futuristic weapons appear in the game. But in vanilla Terraria, guns, futuristic swords and laser guns, and ancient weaponry all make an appearance and use, within the same game. So clearly my point still holds here that Terraria is better.3. The challenge of finding ores in Minecraft makes Minecraft caves betterI disagree (surprising). In Minecraft, let me repeat what I said earlier. Some caves go on for ages, and if you are unlucky, never hold any ore. This is a problem for all those who want to progress in the game at a reasonable pace. Not spend hours of wasted time collecting no ore. In Terraria on the other hand, it is still a challenge to find good ore, but caves are always littered with common ores, meaning that no mining expedition is ever useless. This is a huge benefit to Terraria over Minecraft, because it prove Terraria usefully benefits the player's time.4. You don't ever use all the resources of TerrariaThat is essentially what you argued. A couple problems. First, you conceded that Minecraft has far fewer useful ores, which makes that game less fun. Second, you progress through a tiered ore system in Terraria. If you have ever played the game (I think you have) then you know that mining copper is only the start. As your character gets better, you progress into the level of mining Orichalchum and the like, and by that point you will have dropped copper completely off your concern radar when mining. So while you make think of the hotbar as an inconvenience, I view it as a way to get the most progression out of the game possible. 5. 1.9 Minecraft makes Minecraft combat better than Terraria'sHow is 1.9 Minecraft combat that different from the rest of Minecraft combat before? I mean, what serious difference does spamming or not spamming attacks even make? In Terraria, you spam attacks on ores, blocks, and mobs because that is how you destroy them. If you hit one hit at a time, the game is built to make you lose combat like that. Now why is this better than Minecraft's new one hit system? Because Minecraft has combat that is too simplistic, and clunky. If I shoot a skeleton, then have to wait to do it again a couple seconds later, the combat feels realistic maybe, but not smooth. However Terraria's combat operates like a 2D version of Gungeon. You fire multiple bullets at once, because it is intended to be a fun experience, not a death threatening tedious exercise. Alright now lets examine why exactly agreeing with my second assertion under the agreeable assertions, is so important. I asked you to agree "that both games have the possibility for equivalent enjoyable hours of gameplay, no matter the player. " You agreed. What position does this put you in? It means you agreed that the standard on how we would weigh the word "better" in the resolution, was through whatever tipped the enjoyability factor of either game in its favor through the arguments we presented for each game. So all our arguments must uphold the standard of enjoyability to win in this round. Now after my responses, my arguments of 1, 2, 3, and 5 all clearly uphold a higher enjoyability of Terraria. I still consider whether or not more resources to be enjoyable, up for debate. But the rest I believe have been substantially settled, unless you have good responses to them. I appreciate your willingness to hold a long debate on this topic. This topic honestly has been the talk of the internet for ages, and I finally believe we are doing it some academic justice which is magnificent.