Government in India should set up brothels and amend anti-prostitution laws.

This is kinda sad. My opponent does not understand the importance of citations... Huh... How is this guy a debater, again? Citations maybe important, but only for those where it is really required and there are reasons for the same. I have won all my past 4 debates. Do you know more than the Judges that you claim that I am not a debater? In that case, you will be penalized for defamation, disrespect and insult of Judges. Rebuttal V1: 1. My first source claims there is not a cure for aids. (1) However, I also mentioned that we are very close to find a cure for AIDS. 2. Since my opponent has pointed out a grammatical error I made while awed with the sheer stupidity of his case, allow me to reciprocate. Be my guest and go ahead to prove that I made errors. However, I do not see where you have claimed that I have made a spelling or grammatical mistake. Pls upload a screenshot of my spelling or grammatical mistake taken in MS Word with a red or green wavy line. "By the way, whether they like it or not but in a government brothel they have to go through medical tests." Your word does not peel back my source. You have not refuted my claim that, even when given legal alternatives, illegal prostitution rises when legal prostitution is in affect. If you think that it does not refute the claim or your source remains unchallenged, then I would say that you have not understood my words. I clearly mentioned that illegal prostitution means private brothels and customers won’t choose private brothels to satisfy their lusts for three reasons. 1. First, there is a risk of getting caught by the cops and they may land up in jail. 2. Second, it is costly than government brothels as private brothels may have to bribe the cops and authorities for their business. 3. Third, availing services in private brothels have more chances of getting HIV/AIDS. So, when legal government brothels are available for sexual services, why would any guy go to avail services of an illegal prostitute? Honourable Judges, pls note that Con has committed another error in English as it is “is in effect” and not “is in affect”. 3.Again, even when given legal alternatives, prostitutes still want the illegal option. In your words, are you blind or ignorant? Why would prostitute choose the illegal option in the first place? You have not given me the reason(s) for the same and you are here to debate with me? Being knowledgeable does not mean that you consider baseless, stupid and irrational statements. Now, you will baselessly copy that too in frustration. J 4. Let's look at the causes for high rates of AIDS infection in Africa, shall we? I have found this excerpt from the net -à http://www.medwiser.org... " Cultural factors A large factor preventing people from getting tested and treated for HIV/AIDS is the cultural stigma associated with it. In addition to stigma, there are several other factors medical professionals site as being detrimental to HIV treatment such as male promiscuity and polygamy in some places. One unproven cultural factor consistently mentioned is that the practice of female genital mutilation has led to an increased occurrence of AIDS in Africa. The hypothesis is that intercourse with a circumcised female is conducive to an exchange of blood. Honourable Judges, firstly Con has just recklessly copied and pasted it from the site above. He/She has not taken care that it was wrongly mentioned in the site without an apostrophe ‘s’ as it should be ‘professional’s site’ and not ‘professionals site’. 1. Every country has its culture. 2. Therefore, you agree that it is the culture and mindset of the people by which it gives rise to AIDS in a faster rate than prostitution else countries like Australia, Turkey etc would be topping the list. If prostitution is a threat for increased rate of AIDS cases, then Turkey should be atleast somewhere nearer to these top 10 countries but Turkey ranks way below in 161. 3. Why do we not take this as an example and reverse the effect by starting a new culture of having safe sex? Political factors As stated before, many major African political leaders have denied the link between HIV and AIDS, favoring alternate theories. The general global scientific community considers the evidence that HIV causes AIDS to be conclusive, thus completely rejecting any denial of such as pseudoscience. Still, despite its lack of scientific acceptance, the methodical denial of AIDS has had a significant political impact – especially under the former South African presidency of Thabo Mbeki. 1. If public follows the political leaders blindly, then why do we not in India ask the same political leaders to come infront of the media and preach about safe sex which is opposite to what leaders in Africa are preaching? 2. It must be affecting but not to that extent. The article which you copied and pasted does not tell us that to what extent does the political influence affects unsafe sex and spread of HIV/AIDS. Religious factors In Kenya, safe-sex commercials are banned. It maybe banned but not forever. Also, it may have been banned but for this reason that it showed obscenity. If they had shown the same safe sex advertisement in a decent way then they would have allowed it. Also, Kenya has banned leaky condom brand also and below is the site mentioning that. Why would it ban leaky condom if it was against safe sex in general? http://www.panapress.com... In addition, in 2009, the Pope Benedict, on a trip through Africa, banned the use of condoms in general. Even before 2009, i.e. 2008 Swaziland and other African nations topped the list of rates of HIV/AIDS cases. Here is the pdf site to prove it so NOW DO NOT SAY THAT I DID NOT PROVIDE ANY CITATIONS. Honourable Judges also, pls note that I have provided a citation with this website. Pls goto the 5th page of this pdf website which proves my point. http://depts.washington.edu... In 2013 the catholic church renewed banning of condoms in catholic schools. Again, even before 2013 i.e. in 2008 African nations, especially Swaziland topped the list of highest rates of HIV/AIDS found in the nation. Muslim leaders have taken a similar stance in 2008. These are just a few examples demonstrating the significant pressure – and in some cases, condemnation – from both Christian and Muslim religious leaders in regard to AIDS and preventative-care education. Unfortunately, these stances have significantly impeded progress of a variety of safe-sex campaigns. Muslims and Christians are not just in Africa but all around the world. Saudi Arabia is a hardcore Musslim nation but it ranks way below in percentage of HIV cases. Medical Suspicion Suspicions about modern medicine are common throughout the world, and especially in sub-Saharan Africa. Such distrust appears to have an essential impact on utilizing medical services. This distrust is occasionally associated with theories of a “Western Plot” of mass sterilization or reduction in population; thought to be an aftermath of multiple high profile occurrences including Western medical practitioners." (2) Did not understand this point, I would request the site authorities to explain it to me more elaborately. There are more reasons mentioned in the link. Spoiler alert! Prostitution being illegal is not one of the reasons for the high rate of AIDS transmissions. You are just claiming that illegal prostitution is not the reason for high rate of AIDS cases without providing any reason or practical example as proof. However, I gave you statistical data through websites as evidence and therefore I claim that prostitution being illegal is the reason for high rate of HIV/AIDS cases. You simply saying it's a weak argument is not good enough. HPV and other STDs can affet a person regardless if the people are wearing condoms. I don't refute points if they don't have citations backing them up. But, since you asked so nicely, I will. "Rape and prostitution have been compared and contrasted by many in order to make various points about these and other issues. This article primarily attempts to refute theories which ascribe a causal relationship between rape and prostitution." (3) I ask you read the article and see for yourself. Arguments without citations are weak arguments. Rebuttals V2: 1. Reasoning alone does not trump evidence. Evidence trumps any "reasoning" you may present. 2. Trends and behavior are shown through studies where prostitution was legalized before. It shows trends among how prostitutes react when given manditory health checks. It shows many trends regarding legalied prostitution. I have evidence. You have your "reasoning" which is falliable. Again, your word is not God. It does stand in place when you don't have any evidence backing up your claims. You, my good sir, is the person being overconfident. Rebuttals V3: Refer to earlier arguments Again, reasoning does not trump evidence. Rebuttals V4: This guy is an idiot. I take pity in knowing the world has someone like him who actually wants to modify modern society in a way that will harm society because his "reasoning" is absolute. Conclusion Rebuttals: Wha-....Serio-... *sighs* Judges, we all know where this debate is going. He can't provide citations like I have. A lot of my arguments have been dropped. His case is not based on evidence. It is based on opinion. I feel bad knowing there is someone like this in the world. Honourable Judges and my most worthy opponent, I could have debated more till the end but unfortunately there is a prior appointment fixed and I have to go. However, I will reply and debate the remaining part in Round 5 or in the comments and you can go through my comments section for the reply.