That twilight sucks

Dear Pro. . . Thank you for the response. I believe stories are important, they define us, who we are and what we think. And in this case, your preference of what is good and sucks (again vampire book called suck chuckles) does not equate. Rebuttal 2.1 You state in r2 1st statement - you did not say twilight is bad because other authors say so. My response is read round 1. It’s exactly what you said. Rebuttal 2.2 Emma, Pride and Prejudice, Hunger Games, my name is Memory, Vampire Academy, Robin hood are damsel in distress, as it the Tempest from Shakespeare. The plot you object to is found in many well acknowledge books that do not suck from old classical to modern books. I do not see how a plot Sucks that is widely acknowledged that it doesn`t. Rebuttal 2.3 You imply that 108 year old vampire and an 18 year old girl is odd. Let’s examine the fiction of this, you object because of the age? Dracula is a lot older in the book with the same name sake. Are you objecting to Dracula on the same grounds? Again Strider is 300 (I do believe) and his love interests range from 18 and 2000 for the elf (I believe). While odd, it’s a story device. Or do you object to a telepath? Have you seen x-men and wheels, sorry Professor X? Its fiction. Rebuttal 2.4 Why does Edward like Bella. Actually I thought about this one for a while long before this debate and I assumed it would come up sooner or later. It must really suck to be Prof X or Shiny Edward. Imagine every thought someone thinks all the random junk you would hear. If any girl I dated could hear my thoughts, I would be dead walking through a mall. Likewise I would hate every women alive (an most men) if I had telepathy. If I had telepathy I would abhor people. Every dirty secret, every indiscriminate slight or annoyance, every ‘wow he looks hot’ by a gf would eventually drive me to hate society. I would like, love and do befriend anyone I couldn’t read. I would be fascinated by the person who could do one thing no one else could, surprize me and keep a secret. Bella has something no one else can offer. Rebuttal 2.5 Again I’ll point to A billion wicked thoughts, not only the preferred language for men vs women when reading, but so is the idea that a girl/woman/damsel has something in her that no other women possess in abundance (virginity, knowledge, Status), and in everything else in spades (like fear, self-conscious, body images). The story is that the love interest is abusive and tamed after the magic kiss or wo-who (sex) puts him in his place. This is part of the female hero story that is found in sade to 50 shades of grey to modern female targeted stories. The idea is that is presented in an authority is that a man or hero is has an aboundence of power, strength or will and the girl has something that can undo it. That is the object of affection that will unmake him and make her into his equal. Which by the way is why its popular to women. Again I`ll ask you of a book for that target audience that you approve of. Your original statement was to address very specific claims, that it suck, and listed a number of reasons why, argument of authority (which you agree is I refuted), argument from popularity (which refuted) and the argument of popular authority. However you haven’t taken up my charges for the rest of my arguments, and presented secondary arguments. Rather than refute my points, you bring up other arguments, all of which my former arguments still refute. However I did address your 2nd round arguments. Thank you for the read. I appreciate your response. Thank you for your patience in my responce.