Pinkie Pie Could Exist If She Wanted To

Interpretation of Schrödinger's PonyFirst of all, congratulations to my opponent on such a wonderful play on words for this heading. Second, shame on him for accusing the Equestrian universe of being utterly impossible.Basically, my opponent says that impossible universes can't exist. But what makes a universe impossible? While not likely at all to be created based on the outcomes of what happens here and now, there can still be a universe based on an event long, long ago that could easily have created a universe full of mythical creatures, say if a few squabbles between species altered the very path of natural evolution.That said, these alterations in the path of evolution could have created universes where humans have custard for blood, Hitler is God, or I could be getting anally raped by an elephant with an unfortunate medical condition. To concede that in some universe I'm drinking sperm? I see no reason why not.In short, my opponent, while using some pretty strong words, is only limiting the creation of universes to what outcomes could be starting here and now. But in reality, it is just as likely that the same single-celled organisms eventually evolved into intelligent ponies.Therefore, Equestria is an alternate universe.The Fourth WallMy opponent claims to have explained the difference between breaking the fourth wall and just being cartoony by saying that Pinkie Pie is just "looking at a pony behind the camera", but there's one thing he cannot elaborate on:Where do we draw the line?My opponent has already admitted that Elmer Fudd and Deadpool break the fourth wall. But how do we know that the yellow boxes that Deadpool sees aren't part of his universe (or I guess my opponent prefers "world")? The same for Elmer Fudd. Who's to say that Elmer isn't telling someone behind the camera that he's "huntin' wabbits"?The answer seems to be, because my opponent said so.Furthermore, my opponent wants to include the Equestria Girls phenomenon as just being "part of the world", when the human world Twilight goes to is specifically called an "alternate universe." So how does that remain within the boundary of "being cartoony," though when Deadpoop does it, it's considered "breaking the fourth wall"?Again, because my opponent said so, and nothing more.Call it what you may, but the term is "breaking the fourth wall". And not only does Pinkie Pie do that, she specifically refers to it as "being in an alternate universe" as well.But like my opponent said, breaking the fourth wall does not correlate with entering alternate universes, but in Equestria Girls, Pinkie indeed did prove that she has a connection to alternate universes and, even if she didn't, Equestria Girls proved that Equestria has mirrors that can take people to alternate universes.And if my opponent dismisses it as "it being part of the same universe", consider that for a Pinkie Pie in some universe, it is in fact the ability to travel to different universes. Because, as I said, if you go back far enough, nearly any universe can be created.And then this.My opponent and I can both agree that this is a weak contention, but for formaility's sake, I'll argue it. My opponent claims that if Pinkie could, Pinkie would. Needless to say, he provided no evidence that there is a 100% chance that Pinkie would want to live here. "Anyone farmiliar with the character" would know that she has no knowledge of our world, and therefore can't "want" to live here. Anyone farmiliar with the show would know that only Lyra is aware of our universe, which further asserts that a pony would have the ability to exist here.Extend that there no limits on which universes Pinkie can to to, therefore she can go here.Conclusion:In all reality, my opponent didn't really touch the resolution all that much. A pony universe could easily exist as a result of a different path in evolution, the only difference between the ability to go to new universes and "interacting with one's own" are the perameters my opponent has so generously invented, and other than that, Con has little to say.Pinkie Pie Could Exist If She Wanted To.