Weak Governments Should Be Overthrown

Yes it is true that Weak Governments affect the people they are ruling over. But a Weak Government is better than no government at all. We cannot overthrow a government that is too weak mainly because it is not politically moral, what good could possibly come out of forcibly depriving an official of government of their power? If we overthrow a government, we might risk poverty and invasion of the country, seeing that there is at the time no government to defend the people. And it is even worse to overthrow and replace a government with another type. An example being Germany Post-WWI, when Germany was run by the Weimer Republic. Everyone hated the government and then an attempted revolution resulted in Adolf Hitler's arrest, and the writing of Mein Kampf. But even besides the point, overthrowing a government can lead to war, higher crime rate, poverty, invasion, Dictatorship, Tyranny and enslavement. I'm not going to state the likelihood of each of these scenarios because I do not find it necessary, but even still, it is true that with no government or a government so weak the people can revolt and win, all of these things can happen post-successful revolt. When Russia faced revolution, many thousands of people died in BOTH revolutions, one being the 1917 revolution, and the other being the 1905 revolution. Revolting against the government is a scary thing that here in America you can be killed for. It is not a bright idea, it causes too much death. The death toll of both Russian Revolutions in the early 1900s were extremely high and rather sickening. 1. Your example of China was somewhat irrelevant. "For example, take the Chinese during the warring states period in time..." You're right, there was no centralized or strong government at the time. But the Emperor taking the throne was not a demonstration of revolting or overthrowing. It was an example of a new leader taking power fairly. China has always been a Market Economy, meaning China makes most of its money from trading. Valuables are traded between China and other countries, which are then used to produce marketing goods that will help produce profit for the country. China works itself half to death to make tons of profit. Working little kids into sweatshops that make shoes and other leather products for the Americans and other foreigners. 2. Nazi Germany? Really? Yes, it is true that the Weimer Republic was a terrible Democracy and possibly the worst Government in Germany so far, but to say that Nazi Germany 'overthrew' the Government is ridiculous! Adolf Hitler, after being arrested and writing Mein Kampf, decided to run for office. President Von Hidenburg won and Hitler lost--but the President granted Hitler the position of Chancellor. After the Reichstag burnt down, Hitler blamed the Communist Party. He was also granted Emergency Service Permissions and instantaneously passed laws allowing him to become the Dictator of Germany. He took full power and locked his political opponents in Camps. Hitler may have raised the economy, power, military and navy, but trust me, there was plenty of revolt, chaos and fear emitting from within the people. No one like Hitler's tyranny except for the Nazis, The Italians and Japanese. To say that Weak Governments should be overthrown is to say we should endanger thousands of lives for no good reason. What would we have to gain out of getting thousands killed? Some people who aren't involved in battle are still caught in the middle of the crossfire and killed. This sort of stuff only ruins a country further.