Belief in a God is rationally justified.

1; That is the definition of argument from ignorance. You are literally saying that because you don't know how something happened that it is untrue. You are not saying that you have evidence that it can't happen, which you don't have, you are saying that you lack information about something so it is not true. 2. I don't think you understand argument from ignorance. It is not saying that you are ignorant so you are wrong, that would be ad hominem. It is saying that you are saying that you lack information about a thing so it is untrue. As to kin selection, I was very clear. There is a selective advantage to a mentality that favors helping one's fellow species or tribe. This is not done in a mechanistic way where an algorithm tells us exactly how to apply it, rather it is embodied as general empathy and caring which then gets extended by our rational minds to be expanded to people and creatures besides those for whom it gives a selective advantage. You could argue that this means the advantage is imperfect, but it is very reasonable to see how an evolved sense of empathy and caring for one's fellow creatures could lead to things like missionary work. That you do not like the explanation because it is defeats your argument does not mean it is not explained. Your rebuttal to my explanation of the eye is another argument from ignorance. You do not understand how these things evolved, so you think it is impossible that they evolved. I do not know all of the intermediate steps in the evolution of an eye, but there are things I could imagine working. For example perhaps there was a failure to inactivate a gene that leads to production of muscle proteins in the cells by these light sensitive cells. That can provide the needed smooth muscle. You do realize that all cells have the information to produce all parts of the body correct? The only reason they develop differently is because of gene inactivation through processes like methylation and acetylation of the DNA/histones. Additionally, you assume that the mutations are useless, but you have no justification for that. Each mutation that permeated probably had some function and over time those functions synergized to form the eye we currently have. We can develop reasonable explanations for the evolution of any particular cell type or organ even if we cannot definitively say that this is definitely how it came to be. This is a common argument from creationists who try to add gods into something that simply does not require them. Even if we had no explanation at all for these things you see as problems, that would not make saying "god did it" a reasonable explanation. Of course a being that can do anything is a sufficient cause for anything, but it is not an explanation because it has no explanatory power. It does not further our understanding of a concept, in fact it stops understanding because accepting that means we have no reason to try to study things to find the cause. As to nonphysical things affecting physical things, math does not cause anything. Our physical brains are able to conceptualize math and then we do work with the understanding we have, but the math itself did nothing. I specifically said that your arguments would not lead to the conclusion of a creator existing outside of time and space, not that they would not lead to a creator. Your arguments could also lead one to conclude that life creating fairies were the cause of evolution or that an immortal witch caused evolution or even a sprite that existed for a millisecond and cast a magic evolution causing spell and then ceased to exist. As to accusing me of an argument from incredulity, I did not say that existence outside of time and space is impossible. I said that it made no sense. This is where you could try to explain it to me, something that I have never seen attempted. People assert that this is possible without demonstrating it. Since it has not been demonstrated to be possible or impossible, the proper stance is to neither believe it is possible nor impossible.