Abortion

"Alright I'm going to talk about roe v wade first. It's not in the supreme courts power create laws, only say this is what they think. So this Roe v Wade case is invalid. The only people that can make bill which may turn into laws are the congress. the president only signs them. I think Roe v wade should have been a case for congress. So yes if congress can make laws, then its in their right to be in this case, not the supreme court. The courts can look at the law after it has been passed. My Dad was a lawyer so this education helps."- Wow. Just wow. Roe vs Wade is extremely valid especially in accordance to what you said. The Supreme Court decides if laws are constitutional or not. You claimed that abortion goes against the constitution. The Supreme Court decided in Roe vs Wade that the right to an abortion is constitutional. You know nothing about our own constitution if you think that Congress can just make any law. Like I stated before: in the constitution it states that any powers not delegated to the federal government are left to the states. Congress can only write laws concerning certain subjects such as taxes, the military, and commerce. Medical procedures are not something Congress can make a law about. "Also the vegetable thing, yes someone can kill them if needed, but assuming this is after they have had some age means they've already done their potential, whereas a baby hasn't even started. http://goodnews.ws...... this is a picture of a fetus, it isn't just cells."- I know what a fetus looks like thank you. I have already refuted this argument by talking about why I think that fetuses are not people. "I have talked to other women on this topic, and they dislike abortion. Even when a women doesn't want a child, she will usually not abort it because she thinks its morally wrong. And I am not for banning abortion, only for certain cases. If it threatens the woman's life by all means save yourself, but if you are out partying should you not ave consequences for a mistake you did. When you make a mistake I believe you should deal with it, is your problem not the baby's."- Hey guess what? I have talked to other women about abortion and they think it needs to be legal. There is no majority opinion on this issue and even if there were that would not make it more valid. You cannot say that most women think abortion is morally wrong because you do not have even close to a large enough sample of women's opinions to make this valid. So you just admitted that abortion should stay legal? Whether someone is living or not is the only thing that matters in this case? What if an irresponsible woman has unprotected sex but has another condition that would cause he life to be in danger if she were to have the baby, while another woman who had protected sex but still got pregnant(yes this happens) but would most likely not die from complications from pregnancy? The responsible woman's life could be dramatically altered for the worse even though she did everything right and yet the irresponsible woman's does not. The point is that in cases of law you cannot discriminate that way. So what if some women get reinforced for bad behavior? That is a price I am willing to pay to keep young girls lives from being ruined. "I believe that Abortion is against the 8th amendment because it is cruel and unusual. Putting a spatula looking thing up there then throwing the baby in a bio-hazard bad is immoral."- Abortion is certainly not unusual and it is not cruel because the fetus has is not conscience and feels no pain. It has never truly lived since it has never been awake. Secondly, you still have the wrong amendment. The quotes from the Bible have nothing to do with abortion. The Bible has no stance on abortion because abortion did not exist when the Bible was written. It is still very clear that the medical community is not in agreement about whether or not abortion causes breast cancer. I cited this in the last argument. I also showed why abortion should not be illegal even if it does. It is up to the mother to decide whether or not she wants to take the risk. You still have not responded to some of my arguments.