Resolved: The United States should retain Capital Punishment for murder.

Second, third, and fourth round we make rebuttals. Cross Examination is permitted. =Case="A murderer deserves death penalty because he has trespassed against the whole society by killing one of its members. "-unknown. Seeing as I agree with the above quote, I strongly affirm this resolution. I offer the following contentions in support:C1. Capital Punishment saves innocent lives. SPA: Capital Punishment keeps a killer from striking again. There have been many instances in our justice system where a murderer has reoffended, in fact a study from the U. S. Department of Justice finds that of prisoners released in 1994, 1.2% of those convicted of homicide were arrested for another homicide within three years of their release. [1]. There are also many specific examples, such as Kenneth Mcduff. In 1966 a Texas jury ruled for him to die in the electric chair for his brutal murder of two boys and a girl. However his sentence was commuted to Life Imprisonment when the Supreme Court struck down the Death Penalty. Mcduff was later released, and ended up killing at least 9 more people. Thankfully, he was executed by lethal injection in 1998[2]. He will never kill again. Had he been executed the first time at least 9 innocent lives would've been saved. Another example is the recently executed Lee Andrew Taylor. While serving a life sentence for his brutal beating and murder of an elderly couple Taylor fatally stabbed another inmate after a "racial tension" incident occurred[3]. Thankfully, he was executed by Texas in 2011, never to kill again. Yet another example comes from Clarence Ray Allen. Allen was serving a sentence of life without parole for murder, when he conspired with his fellow inmate Billy Hamilton to kill the witnesses for his crime. When paroled, Hamilton tracked down the witnesses and killed one of them, along with two other people[4]. Allen was, thankfully, sentenced to die for this new crime, and executed by the state of California in 2006. These are only some of many examples of murderers who later murdered again. In many cases, anything less than the Death Penalty simply isn't good enough. The recidivism rate for an executed murderer is 0%. SPB: Capital Punishment has a deterrent effect. Many different studies provide many different results, some examples: Studies from Emory University stating that each execution prevents between three and eighteen murders. [5] A 2006 study from the University of Houston, stating that the Illinois moratorium on the Death Penalty led to 150 additional homicides [5] A University of Colorado at Denver study showing that for each execution five muders were prevented. [6]. These are just some of many studies showing the deterrent effect. As Researcher Karl Spence from of Texas A&M University states (speaking about the moratorium on Capital Punishment from 1972-1976): "While some death penalty abolitionists try to face down the results of their disastrous experiment and still argue to the contrary, the. .. [data] concludes that a substantial deterrent effect has been observed. .. In six months, more Americans are murdered than have killed by execution in this entire century. .. Until we begin to fight crime in earnest by using the death penalty, every person who dies at a criminal's hands is a victim of our inaction. "Observation: While the argument that an innocent could be executed is a very compelling one, the murders committed by prior offenders and the deterrent effect of Capital Punishment outweighs this small risk. C2. The Death Penalty is a better punishment than Life without Parole. SPA: Life without parole does not always mean life. If the Death Penalty is abolished, the next thing to go will be life without parole. Already some European countries like Norway, Greece and Spain have abolished it [7]. There is already a movement to abolish life without parole in the United States for juveniles and even for adult offenders! [8][9]. While no one can truly know if these movements will gain traction, the evidence in Europe speaks for itself, sentences for murder in Europe are much lighter than those in the United States. The law can also change, take for example the tragic case of Pamela Moss: "In 1962, James Moore raped and strangled 14-year-old Pamela Moss. Her parents decided to spare Moore the death penalty on the condition that he be sentenced to life in prison without parole. Later on, thanks to a change in sentencing laws in 1982, James Moore is eligible for parole every two years"[10]Laws change, Governors change, sentencing changes, and people forget the past. The only way to truly know if a murderer will not ever be released is to execute them. SPB: Prisoners view the Death Penalty as a harsher punishment than Life without parole. One argument against the Death Penalty is that it does not force criminals to truly pay for their crime. While at first this seems to be a compelling argument, the evidence speaks against it. Criminals have the right to waive the appeals on their death sentence, very very few do. Executions in 2011: 23 so far, 1 waived appeals. Executions in 2010: 46, 1 waiver. Executions in 2009: 52 executions, 2 waivers. Executions in 2008: 37 Executions, 3 waivers. [11]. Nearly 96% of those executed in the past four years have fought to escape their sentence. C3. Capital Punishment is not unconstitutional. There isn't much to be said on this point, so I'll make it brief. The Supreme court has upheld the constitutionality of Capital Punishment many times in the past, most recently in Bazes v. Rees. [12] Also, usage of the Death Penalty is contemplated in the 5th Amendment of the U. S. constitution when it states: "No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury. .. "[13]. Well, that's all I have to say for now. Good luck to my future Opponent, and I urge a Pro vote! =Sources=1. . http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov...2. . http://en.wikipedia.org...3. . http://www.tdcj.state.tx.us...4. . http://www.clarkprosecutor.org...5. . http://www.cbsnews.com...6. . http://www.heritage.org...7. . http://en.wikipedia.org...8. . http://www.huffingtonpost.com...9. . http://www.defenestrator.org...10. . http://www.globalpolitician.com...11. . http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org...12. . http://en.wikipedia.org...13. . http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com...