Illegal Immigration: Should we deport all illegal immigrants we find in the U.S.

Hello, I don't see any reason to get them out of the country just as long as their citizens. It would still solve the problem at hand: illegal immigrants inability to properly pay taxes. "your way will do nothing about the ones already here" What? Mine is the one that specifically deals with those who are currently here, turning them into citizens. While yours just throws them out. "Yes they have established life but they have done so illegally" Changing the subject...again. I gave a valid logical argument and you basically said "Yes,...but they still broke in illegally" and then started talking about them immigrating illegaly. Politicians do it all the time. I can see through that. It doesn't matter if it was illegal, the point I was making was that Everybody, even the illegal immigrants wins, with my solution. My solution is compromise. Your's is punishment. I will repeat, most homeless people in America are in poverty fro a reasoncompletely unrelated to illegal immigration. You think all of those poor drunkard bums (no, offense, poor drunkard bums) on the street, are suddenly going to get hired because you deported 5% of the people in the US. Of course not. "there foreign born children would be sent back with them. There american anchor babies should be orphaned and when turn 18 be given the choice of going back to there respective countrys or staying like any dual citizen" Republicanview, that is horrible. 5%. 5% of the people in the US are the people to whom you would deport. Alot of them have children. That is at least 3 million children you are orphaning. "the immigrants get to stay but they are being rewarded for there crime." Soon afterward: "I don't want to deport them out of vengeance" Right...You want to deport them because you're mad at them amd think they "don't deserve" it, yet you are not deporting them from vengeance. Right. Guess what, life isn't always fair. Sometimes we have to transcend what someone "deserves" and realize what is good for the common welfare. I think everyone "deserves" to have a good life. Government is for the good of the people. The people make up the society. The immigrants are deported and thus it hurts the society. Government is there to help society. Sure culture is important, but not in this context. America is supposed to be a MELTING POT, republicanview. We can't suddenly start making it an exclusive club, in which we deport someone because of their culture. That is sick. It is like saying: "WE don't like the foods you eat or the clothes you wear, so...you're gonna have to leave and start life anew in a country surrounded by poverty". "Its the Mexicans culture that made them impoverished" Don't flip-flop on me, republicanview. It's what you said. I missed that you were only specifying your own town. I don't know anything about your town. In austin, Texas, I know lots of hispanics, I don't know any of them to be illegal immigrants. The only person I have known to be an illegal immigrant was from vietnam. You don't need to convince me that illegal immigration is bad. You continuosly complain about it. You should have maybe made the debate header: "illegal immigration is harmful". You didn't though, and we are debating whether we should deport all illegal immigrants.