The usual arguments #4: Free will

1) No intervention can't prove God existsDivine intervention can prove God's existence, obviously. Free will is the lack of intervention, the idea that you are free to do anything you want, that your actions are not predetermined. If intervention proves God's existence and free will means the lack of intervention, then free will can't prove God's existence.__________________________________________________________________________________________________I agree with your understanding of free will. You misunderstood how Allah operates. Allah sets the multiple choice before the creation is created. When the creation reaches the question, his free will choices are recorded. He is All-Just for GIVING YOU THE OPTION He is All-Merciful for the wrong option ( if "you" go against your better judgment and accept the wrong) The next question already awaits. The path is already set. As you answer the next question ALREADY awaits. He doesn't answer it for you but chooses your questions. Allah does not "intervene", he has set it to already take place. Quran says Allah merely has to say "Be!" and it is. A Miracle is Allah has set in the BE stage something that happens at IT IS. It might go against your logic but whatever happened is logical. For example, Lets say a guy survived a car crash without a scratch. We consider it a miracle. We ask the guy about it and he responds by saying it was like time slowed down, I saw the telegraph pole go straight pass my face. It is a miracle he survived yes and the guy would also agree. There is however a logical explanation. The true miracle isn't that Allah had to "intervene" (which goes against all logic of free will) but the Allah planned every element in that car, including the pole to go by without scratching the guy. Again to reiterate in the Al-kitab we are told Allah merely has to say "Be" and it is. So Allah isn't changing the IT IS but merely placing the order in BE .....which then becomes. The Al-kitab contains the "BE" we we live in the "it is". Be and it is doesn't mean its something supernatural. It means it was set in place before it was. The Al-kitab was written before time and reaches the ends of space. We are the IT IS living within the pages, recycling. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ 2) Free will doesnt need a source Free will is natural. An organism can't come back to life without divine intervention, but free will can exist without divine intervention, naturally. Microbes have free will, viruses, prokaryotes all have free will. As long as free will is natural, it can't prove God's existence. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ The problem is not free will itself but how did free will come to be. Allah only sets the time of birth and death. In between he says everything is recorded and will be presented to you, (for you to judge yourself on your actions) He never changes free will, merely sets the questions that you will choose to either + or - Microbes, virus, prokaryotes and everything else weren't given the option to live. This option is where you require Allah. Allah creates us just and with good thoughts, with the option to sin. For example if you see a child being raped, you don't need to be of faith to know its wrong. Allowing the goodness to flow from you and prevention (or even understand that it is wrong) is to fight in the way of one of Allah's glorious names Al-Adl (Justice). To allow it to proceed with ignorance is from ones self and is the sin. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ God's existence can only be proven by supernatural phenomenons that can only take place if there is divine intervention. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Nothing is Supernatural. Everything in the Quran agrees to science. After the name of Allah the word "ilm" meaning knowledge/science is the most repeated word in the Quran. Let me show you 6 examples of "miracles" in 4 consecutive ayats. (In the Al-kitab the word "ayat" means both "miracle/signs" and the word in the book, The Quran says the miracle is its truth of the book, not supernatural but the details about the natural.) This ayat is addressed to you "unbelievers" from Allah. Quran 21.30-33 *Do not the unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were a closed-up mass (ratqan), then We clove them asunder (fataqna)? **And We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe? ***And We have made great mountains like pegs in the earth lest it might be convulsed with them, ****and We have made in it wide ways that they may follow a right direction. *****And We have made the heaven a guarded canopy and (yet) they turn aside from its signs. ******And He it is Who created the night and the day and the sun and the moon; all (orbs) travel along swiftly in their celestial spheres. *. The Big bang is explained RATQAN has two distinct meanings. One meaning is 'the coming together of something and the consequent infusion into a single entity' and the second meaning is 'from total darkness'. Both these meanings are significantly applicable. FATAQNA means to be ripped apart, explode, disunite or break. **. Evolution is explained - All living things come from water. ***. Isostasy of mountains are explained ****. Tectonic plates are explained *****. Atmosphere or Van Allen's belt is explained ******. Orbits of celestial entities are explained. Also Watch the video again. I have already explained how Allah and free will can co-exist. Proved it through science as well. 3) I don't even need to read your third question because I answered it clearly in my previous response.