superheroes

To begin, I would like to start by defining the terms of the resolution so as to ensure that we are clear on what we are debating. As my opponent has not made it clear as to which Avengers reality he is referring to, I feel like it is same to assume that this debate is operating under the reality of the Avengers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (the MCU); that is, the films produced by Marvel Studios leading up to the 2012 film "The Avengers". With this in mind, we are debating who is superior as an Avenger: Iron Man, as portrayed by Robert Downey Jr., or Thor, as portrayed by Chris Hemsworth. Before we can assess which superhero is a better Avenger, we must first understand what an Avenger is. An Avenger, as defined by Tony Stark in The Avengers (2012) is a member of a group of "Earth's Mightiest Heroes", or a group of super heroes that are part of the Avengers Initiative. More importantly, what makes a super hero an Avenger is the idea that he or she can work with other super heroes for a greater cause. This is highlighted in the Avengers' motto: "Avengers Assemble". With that in mind, I firmly resolve that Iron Man is a superior Avenger as compared to Thor. We already know that in terms of physical prowess, Iron Man and Thor are matched almost perfectly, as illustrated in the iconic stalemated forest battle scene between the two. Therefore, what determines superiority of one Avenger over another is his ability to work in a team of Earth's super heroes. In this category, Tony Stark is clearly far superior for the following reasons: 1. When working as a team in battle, Iron Man consistently shows a stronger ability of being able to fight alongside other members. Iron Man uses other teammates' powers in conjunction with his own in order to mount superior defenses. For example, Iron Man worked well with Captain America in dislodging debris from the Helicarrier in order to get it afloat again. Iron Man also uses Cap's shield to their mutual advantage when disposing of Chitauri in the streets. Conversely, Thor tends to fight on his own terms. 2. Tony Stark is good at recognizing his team members' potential. This is one of the main themes of the Avengers film, and is illustrated best with two very prominent examples. First, Tony was the only Avenger to understand and believe that Bruce Banner could control The Hulk if he changed on his own accord. While the remainder of the Avengers, including Thor, dismissed Dr. Banner as a threat, Tony considered how Dr. Banner could be used as a positive and important member of the team. Secondly, while Tony had initial disagreements with Captain America, he ultimately let Cap take over leadership of the defense against the Chitauri because he understood that that was where Cap's strength lied. Conversely, Thor made no such attempts to play to his team member's strengths. 3. Lastly, Tony is more willing to sacrifice for the greater good. Among Thor's first concerns when he returned to Earth was the safety of his muse, Jane Foster. Tony Stark, however, while still considering her well-being important, prioritized the safety of the world in general. When the nuclear missile was headed towards Manhattan, Iron Man unhesitantly steered it towards the portal, knowing full well that he may not survive the encounter. Thor made no such self sacrifice as an Avenger. For these reasons, I believe that Iron Man is superior of an Avenger when compared to Thor.