Evil proves God does not exist

I am not going to respond to every single claim my opponent has made, but I try to address the fundamental issues My opponents arguments pretty much can all be summarized and interchanged into the following arguments 1) God and evil existing are mutually exclusive 2) Evil exists 3) Therefore God does not exist 1) God and an imperfect world are mutually exclusive 2) An imperfect world exists 3) Therefore God does not exist 1) If God existed God would commit action X 2) God has not committed action X 3) Therefore God does not exist Pro Says "A -> God is good. B -> God has created a universe that destroys people's lives and causes pain for no reason. C -> Pain and death without reason is evil. Therefore, God is evil because he has caused "C" through "B". "A" cannot be true. If "A" is not true, God does not exist. I accept premise A and C, but reject premise B and the conclusion of this argument and I will explain why 1) God is good 2) God creates the universe/a world 3) God creates a universe/world where evil can exist (Notice I didn't say God creates the evil, God creates the possibility for evil existing) 4) Therefore evil exists Pro says "God has created a universe that causes suffering independent of our free will. We do not will earthquakes to occur. Thus, they are results of God's creation. If God created a universe that causes death independent of our choice to inflict death" I find this interesting, Pro is arguing that "evil" should only exist in the context of "chosen" evil. But you see Pro that isn't evil at all, that's justice, which is good. What makes evil so evil, is that it doesn't weight the scales of justice properly, it rewards the guilty, punishes the innocent, what makes evil so evil is just as you said. .. .. "C -> Pain and death without reason is evil. " In a world where evil is allowed to exist, pain and death without reason will exist, since that's the nature and description of evil. Therefore 1) God is good 2) God creates the universe/a world 3) God creates a universe/world where evil can exist 4) Therefore evil exists I would also make the point, that your arguments of Gods non existence is based on evil, both evil existing in the world and God committing acts of evil. Pro says C2: A -> God is all-powerful. B -> Not all people have all the food, water, or shelter they need. C -> It is within God's power to provide these to all people due to "A". Therefore, God should provide these because he can. He doesn't. Therefore, "A" is not true. If "A" is not true, God does not exist. ALSO, if God should provide all people with these goods then he is creating the most good, for the most people. He does not. Therefore, once again, C1 is true and God does not exist. " In this case, he claims that God has not fulfilled some moral duty "Not all people have all the food, water, or shelter they need. " therefore if he has the power is not the good God described But notice without the "moral duty" this argument falls apart, on what basis does Pro claim God has a moral duty ? Clearly Pro must assume that morality exists, and not only that, it must be an objective morality, an objective morality that is alleged that God has not met, and is there fore evil. It must be an objective morality, cause if Pro argues that the existence of evil either in the world or by God is subjective (that is to say what ever you think is morally right or wrong, is morally right or wrong) then all Pro has to do is believe everything is morally right, then evil ceases to exist, and without evils' existence the whole arguments for evil existence and Gods existence being mutual exclusive fall apart. Therefore as I said, Pro must be arguing that evil exists from an objective morality view. But what is the basis of this objective morality that Pro assumes ? I would argue that the basis of this objective morality would have to be found in something uncaused and morally good. These descriptions/properties are the same as found in God My argument is as follows 1) Objective morals can only exist if God exists 2) Objective morals do exist 3) Therefore God exists Both the free will defense, the explanation and nature of evil, and the proving of objective morality refute my opponents claim that "evil proves God does not exist" I look forward to Pros' reply