Persons convicted of a pedophilic crime ought to be treated and not incarcerated in all instances

1)There are those pedophiles who didn"t committed a physical act on a child because they didn"t had a chance to get into a situation where he/she would be alone with a unattended child or was stopped before committing the actual physical act by law enforcement agent. 2)Yes, pedophiles who have not committed a physical act can undergo treatment but if they don"t want to or don"t care for getting a one than it is a failed mission to begin with. 3)Pumping pedophiles with chemical pills against his/her or forcing them to attend treatment circles will does not make them see that pedophilic acts are wrong. Its only suppresses their urges temporarily. 4)According to a reading "Protect child, not pedophile" The Courier Mail (Australia), July 9, 2008 Wednesday, FEATURES; Pg. 31, 773 words, Peter Faris states: "GAMH research shows Pedophilia is a biologically rooted attraction that does not change"". 5)Whether or not the actual physical act was committed is not sufficient evidence in determining that treatment will be effective. 6)When pedophile is released after a forceful chemical treatment it will raise the crime level in the society. When chemical suppressions and/or other forms of treatment stop, there is a chance that it will make the pedophilic urges stronger and perhaps even more violent than before. 7)Incarceration is appropriate to all those pedophiles who don"t care in getting medical treatment in order to suppress their urges and those who simply just don"t care in what happens to their own future lives. 8)In your initial argument you state that:" Individuals who have been charged with a sexual offense of any sort are heavily discriminated and mistreated while incarcerated." Does this means that outside the prison they are not to be discriminated and mistreated? Or that forceful change in their life style after the release is not mistreatment? If we should feel sorry for them inside the prison walls than why not feel sorry for them outside the prison walls? 9)In your initial argument you also state that:" No one chooses to be emotionally and sexually attracted to children or adolescents". In a way you compare pedophiles to Gay people whose sexual orientation preferences cannot be changed by any form of treatment. 10) You also stated "Incarceration does nothing to solve the problem for more serious cases". I disagree because by incarceration you stop further pedophilic crimes by that person which lowers the crime volume in the society. 11)By incarceration of pedophiles we also lower the possible revengeful acts by the victims or their family members. 12) Furthermore, "restorative justice" sounds like a good alternative it is still nothing more than a model which hasn"t been fully executed with this particular population in the United States. 13) If you can show this model to effective with this particular population in the United States then we might be able to consider such an alternative. However, as of now, this model has not be implemented and thus incarceration is the only liable option. 14)The current research shows that there is no way to guarantee that any other form of treatment is effective on pedophiles. 15)Therefore, persons convicted of pedophilic crimes ought to be incarcerated and not treated in all instances.