Higher Education ought to be private and indiviuals ought to pay for it themselves.

1. Collapse in Germany Improvement of the German economy could be threatened by long-term lack of professionals, especially engineers, showed a study published in the Institute for the German economy. They specified that in the technology companies (from which export depends, therefore improvement of the economy) in July 2010 were missing 36,800 engineers. They said that part of the problem could be solved by "importing" experts. Estimates are that this shortage in the coming months could increase. The problem is more serious if it is known that in the Germany are the lack of students who opt for technical education, which could jeopardize long-German position on the world market. 'The situation with youth is particularly bad in the high-tech industries such as machinery, automobile and chemical industries, which are carriers of the German economic take-off', according in Institute. Per thousand employed engineers comes just 35 graduates. Therefore they are looking for experts from abroad. Economy Minister advises companies to offer a cash award to entice skilled experts from abroad. http://www.automobil-industrie.vogel.de... http://www.onejournal.de... 2. There is always job for those who wants to work I will quote PRO:'For example, a surplus in medical professions might cause a hospital less likely to invest in technology or medical supplies, or other companies might be less likely to invest in technology. (Ex: Software that cause solve mathematical problems, simulators, etc.)' Rebuttal: Every hospital and medical centre (which are financed by state) have constant sum of money for medical research, and that money could not be used for paying workers. So surplus will not affect investing in technology etc. Also, nowhere in the world exist company which will employ more workers than its needed and more workers than can be payed. So there is no dangerous for reduced investments. 3. A loan from bank I'm very interested in this system of loaning and later return, I really don't know how it works for 'educational loan' because that not exist in my country. I saw what PRO said in second round, but I still don't understand some things. Here, when you want to get a loan from a bank you have to mortgage something or to have constant work and payments , and someone still needs to guarantee for you as endorser. What one student can mortgage? What happens if he/she finish University and not get a job? What happens if he/she decide to stop studying? What happens if female stay pregnant? Will bank wait forever? 4. Everyone should have the opportunity Everyone should have opportunity to go to University. Knowledge is not a commodity. Education is not for sale. Of course that rich people have some extra benefits, they can choose between Private and free University, but most important thing is that those who don't have money can be educated. What happens if you don't have free University? A lot of talented people can not go to University because they don't have money! Sad... Education is one of the most important things in people's lives. Every men are born equal and everyone deserve opportunity for better life!