Review: the pretensions -- and disposable story -- sink the movie . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: the film is a confusing melange of tones and styles , one moment a romantic trifle and the next a turgid drama . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: what a great shame that such a talented director as chen kaige has chosen to make his english-language debut with a film so poorly plotted and scripted . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: is a tart , smart breath of fresh air 
Sentiment: positive


Review: share their enthusiasm