Review: mixed up 
Sentiment: negative

Review: come closer than anyone could desire to the cheap , graceless , hackneyed sci-fi serials of the '30s and '40s 
Sentiment: negative

Review: despite a quieter middle section , involving aragorn 's dreams of arwen , this is even better than the fellowship . 
Sentiment: positive

Review: charly comes off as emotionally manipulative and sadly imitative of innumerable past love story derisions . 
Sentiment: negative


Review: fails in making this character understandable , in getting under her skin , in exploring motivation ... well before the end