Review: peter jackson and company once again dazzle and delight us , fulfilling practically every expectation either a longtime tolkien fan or a movie-going neophyte could want . 
Sentiment: positive

Review: joan and philip 's repetitive arguments , schemes and treachery 
Sentiment: negative

Review: richly detailed , deftly executed 
Sentiment: positive

Review: a masterpiece -- 
Sentiment: positive


Review: stuttering editing and pompous references to wittgenstein and kirkegaard