Review: polanski has found the perfect material with which to address his own world war ii experience in his signature style . 
Sentiment: positive

Review: you expect more from director michael apted ( enigma ) and screenwriter nicholas kazan ( reversal of fortune ) than this cliche pileup . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: ultimately lifeless 
Sentiment: negative

Review: an utterly incompetent conclusion 
Sentiment: negative


Review: that its dying , in this shower of black-and-white psychedelia , is quite beautiful