Review: what 's hard to understand is why anybody picked it up . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: that the lack of linearity is the point of emotional and moral departure for protagonist alice 
Sentiment: negative

Review: 's lost the politics and the social observation and become just another situation romance about a couple of saps stuck in an inarticulate screenplay . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: authentic to the core of his being 
Sentiment: positive


Review: to see samira makhmalbaf as a very distinctive sensibility , working to develop her own film language with conspicuous success