Review: and pulp melodrama 
Sentiment: negative

Review: poetic , heartbreaking . 
Sentiment: positive

Review: matters because both are just actory concoctions , defined by childlike dimness and a handful of quirks . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: cheats on itself and retreats to comfortable territory 
Sentiment: negative


Review: altogether , this is successful as a film , while at the same time being a most touching reconsideration of the familiar masterpiece .