Review: a collage of clichés and a dim echo of allusions to other films . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: an unusually surreal tone 
Sentiment: positive

Review: is , by itself , deserving of discussion . 
Sentiment: positive

Review: the pianist ( is ) a supremely hopeful cautionary tale of war 's madness remembered that we , today , can prevent its tragic waste of life 
Sentiment: positive


Review: 's really well directed