Review: roman polanski directs the pianist like a surgeon mends a broken heart ; very meticulously but without any passion . 
Sentiment: negative

Review: less the product of loving , well integrated homage and more like a mere excuse for the wan , thinly sketched story 
Sentiment: negative

Review: ingenious and often 
Sentiment: positive

Review: most of the storylines feel like time fillers between surf shots . 
Sentiment: negative


Review: surgeon mends