E x i t : P1_E

Searcher        P1
Q1:             4
Q2:             3
Q3:             3
Q4:             C 2
                Z 1
Q5:             C 2
                Z 1
Q6:             C 1
                Z 2
Q7:             Cheshire: Boolean capability, long-short capability.
                Zprise: 2 Windows able to see past decisions in one window.
Q8:             Cheshire: Some query word variants not highlighted
		          after deciding to save a doc have to scroll back
                          up find select button, then save,  then confirm
                          save in another box (This might be necessary if
                          a variety of tasks are to be supported though

                Zprise: SGML format
Q9: ...             

E x i t : P2_E

Searcher        P2
Q1:             4
Q2:             3
Q3:             4
Q4:             Cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprize 1
Q6:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q7:             Liked cheshire's "more like this" feature and viewing options
                also search by headline, author was great but I couldn't get it
                to work
                Like Zprise' ability to view doc in separate window.

Q8:             Disliked Cheshire inability to open up selected documents in
                separate window. Felt locked into UI.
                Zprise was easy to use but too simplistic for advanced search.

Q9:             Might help to answer 7 and 8 above immed. after using the
                engine. I can't remember exactly what other features made
                zprise different.
                8 searches are a bit tiring.

E x i t : P3_E

Searcher        P3
Q1:             4
Q2:             4
Q3:             4
Q4:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q6:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q7:             Cheshire: 1) offered the capability to be more precise (Boolean
                searching on different fields.) 2) unlimited results
                Zprise: Liking this was all about the interface(windows 
                 scrollbars ease of saving a record), I could not 
                 survive long with a search capability that did not allow me to
                 use Boolean operators
Q8:             Cheshire: 1) The interface: scrolling and saving were difficult
                 I think it could be laid out better.
		Zprise: see (other comments on zprise above) plus limit to
                 24 results
Q9:             I don't value the "search for more like this" option, but 
                that may be my deficiency, not that of the capability

E x i t : P4_E

Searcher        P4
Q1:             5
Q2:             4
Q3:             3
Q4:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q6:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q7:             Cheshire: liked the fact that I could hit "return" rather
                 than clicking "search" (one less mouse click)
                Zprise: like the ability to scroll through bib records at the
                 same time as viewing text.
Q8:             Cheshire: easy to lose place in results
                Zprise: difficult to tell which record is being viewed in 
                 full text
Q9:             Was kind of fun, although the topics were very depressing.

E x i t : P5_E

Searcher        P5
Q1:             4
Q2:             3
Q3:             4
Q4:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q6:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q7:             C is obviously more powerful and flexible -- I'd use it for
                serious research. 
                Zprise is kind of "dumbed down", but that's ok for some 
                conditions. I liked the side by side display of summary and
                full text.
Q8:             C II was a little frustrating in that with more search 
                combinations it is less "reassuring".
                Zprise frustrated me that I could only see the top 24 (what is
                in the rest?).
Q9:             Regarding these two applications, I really liked, as I 
                mentioned above, the power of C II. However I was intrigued
                that all I found myself wanting was something "good enough"
                And, that feeling was constantly threatened by C II giving me
                access to all the documents. This stuff is hard to figure out.

E x i t : P6_E

Searcher        P6
Q1:             5
Q2:             5
Q3:             3
Q4:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q5:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q6:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q7:             Zprise - ?
                cheshire - diverse searching option, i.e. combining boolean
Q8:             zprise - visually harder to work with many windows
                cheshire - ?
Q9:             Great experience!

E x i t : P7_E

Searcher        P7
Q1:             4
Q2:             4
Q3:             4
Q4:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q6:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q7:             cheshire: search modification options (rkg, index)
                zprise: separate window for document.
Q8:             cheshire: selecting document after browsing requires backing up
                zprise: limited number of docs retrieved, no help refining 
                 search
Q9:             I was curious to try zprise searches on cheshire, but not
                vice versa. I felt I'd exhausted capabilities of zprise.
                Universally wanted more time on cheshire. Sep window for
                full text and ability to revise saved list w/in view-saved
                window would have helped a lot.

E x i t : P8_E

Searcher        P8
Q1:             4
Q2:             3
Q3:             2
Q4:             cheshire 1
                zprise 2
Q5:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q6:             cheshire 2
                zprise 1
Q7:             cheshire: the search button is quite visible
                zprise: I don't need to use the mouse as much
Q8:             cheshire: The scroll bar!
                zprise: not being able to hide what I have already seen.
Q9:             ...