# Presentation: 692507

## Dr.

**Dr.**

**Benn Tannenbaum**

## Outline

**Government 101**
**How does one get involved?**
**What did I do?**
**What do I do?**
**What else can you do?**

## Government 101

- The US Federal government has three branches:

- Executive
- Enforces laws

- Judicial
- Interprets laws

- Legislative
- Writes laws

- Executive
- Requests money
- Spends money

- Legislative
- Appropriates money

- Judicial

## Executive Branch 101

- The Executive Branch implements policy set by an administration and laws passed by Congress
- Done through a variety of agencies
- Some have cabinet secretaries as head
- State, Defense, Labor, Energy, Homeland Security, Health and Human Services, etc
- Some do not
- National Science Foundation, Agency for International Development, Office of the US Trade Representative
- Remember  Only one person in the whole EB is elected; everyone else works for him

## Congress 101

- Congress has two Houses (bicameral)
- House
- 435 voting members, ~1 / 500,000 people
- 4 additional non-voting delegates
- District of Columbia
- Guam
- U.S. Virgin Islands
- Puerto Rico
- 232 Republicans, 202 Democrats, 1 Independent
- Senate
- 100 members, two for each state
- 55 Republicans, 44 Democrats, 1 Independent

## Congress 101

- Everything comes down to three things
- Policy
- What we want to do (make laws)
- Politics
- Why we want to do it
- Procedure
- How we do it (rules of House & committees)
- Think about it this way
- Policy = publishing papers
- Politics = theory
- Procedure = building & running experiments

## Making laws

**Making laws**

**House**

**Senate**

**Committee**
**Hearings**

## How does Congress make decisions?

- Relevant Subcommittees and Committees will have hearings
- Hearings generally only last a few hours
- Typically have 1-6 witnesses
- Rarely get more than a handful of Members at a hearing
- So many issues come before a typical Congress that each Member doesn’t have time– or even staff time– to become expert in them all
- Members will specialize in different topics
- They follow each other’s leads on certain topics

## (un)Informed Decision Making

- There is another problem...
- Vast majority of Senators and Representatives are lawyers, not scientists, doctors, or much else
- Further, only few hundred of nearly 10,000 staffers on the Hill have any science or engineering background
-  Neither Members nor staff scientifically sophisticated
- Language a problem
- How scientists and engineers use language often different from how same words used in law

## What can you do?

- Come to Washington: Policy *is* a viable career for scientists
- Spend a sabbatical in DC
- Demand good science from media
- Write letters to editors; get to know local reporters
- Reporters don’t know anything: they’re conduits
- Demand good science from government
- Last year’s Union of Concerned Scientists report on scientific integrity
- Get to know your government
- Call your Congressman! Visit your Senator!
- Lobby through APS or other groups
- But remember, lobbying is a process, not an event

## What can you do?

- Apply to be a Fellow
- Anyone with a Ph.D. in a physics-related topic can apply for the APS and AIP Congressional Science Fellowships (must be US citizen) or any of the AAAS Fellowships
- Prefer recent grads or someone who will work at least 5 more years (*i.e.* not final step to retirement!)
- Prefer at least Associate Professor-level candidates for AIP State Department Fellow

## What’s a Fellow?

- Fellows bring experience or education to an office that has no other way of getting it
- Fellows are often “detailees” from Agency X to Agency Y, or from an Agency to Congress...

## What’s a Fellow?

- There are also American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) Science & Technology Fellows
- 31 year old program; 1700 total Fellows!
- Most recent years have seen ~100 new AAAS Fellows
- All have the highest degree possible in their field
- Some have more than one– there are a couple PhD/JD, PhD/MD, types...
- Vast array of fields represented
- Physical Sciences: Physics, Chemistry, Geology, Materials Science
- Biological Sciences: Biology, Medicine, Food Science, Veterinary Medicine, Agriculture, Primatology
- Social Sciences: Communications, Sociology, Anthropology, Psychology
- Engineering: Electrical, Civil, Mechanical, Nuclear

## So... where do they work?

- ~Thirty of the Fellows are in Congress
- The remaining 70 are scattered throughout the Executive Branch
- Defense
- State
- U.S. Association for International Development
- National Science Foundation
- Education
- National Institutes of Health
- Office of Science and Technology Policy
- Environmental Protection Agency
- There are no Fellows in the Judicial Branch

## How does one get to be a Fellow?

- Applications due in January to AAAS or other sponsoring society
- Two round selection process
- 3 week orientation session in September
- Meet other Fellows
- Learn how government works...

## How did I find an office?

- AAAS has reception in the Capitol for Fellows & interested offices
- Met interesting people there....
- Decided I wanted to work on homeland security, defense, intelligence, or science in the context of foreign relations
- Dropped off about 20 resumes
- Scored about 10 staff-level interviews
- Got 3 Member interviews (Holt, Markey, Schiff)
- Got 2 offers (Holt, Markey)
- Landed with Rep. Edward J. Markey (D-MA)

## What does a Fellow do?

- 30 Congressional AAAS Fellows in both Houses and on both Member and Committee staff
- Fellows trend towards Democratic offices, but about 1/4 land in Republican offices
- Sometimes get Fellows working for Congressional Research Service
- Work on a vast array of issues
- Space
- Depleted Uranium
- Arms Control
- Health Care
- Role is to understand science or technology of underlying issue & make judgments on that

- Transportation
- Environment
- Science
- Education

## What did I do?

- Mr. Markey sits on the Energy & Commerce, Resources, and Homeland Security committees
- That’s where he does most of his work; has staff to cover those issues. I covered the remainders

- Defense
- Really means “defense appropriations”
- People come hat-in-hand with crazy & not so crazy ideas for military funding requests
- Try to help good constituent ideas get funding
- Also go to military “events” for briefings

- Veterans Affairs
- Mainly answering constituent mail
- Meet with constituents
- Cosponsor bills for constituents
- Casework handled by district office
- Science & Technology
- Meet with constituents
- Sign on to appropriate bills
- Explain science of appropriate bills

## Nonproliferation!
Mr. Markey co-chairs (with Christopher Shays [R-CT]) Bipartisan Task Force on Nonproliferation
Mainly a study group that has briefings for Members & staff
Held briefings on dirty bombs, Iran, North Korea, Biological Weapons Convention, future of arms control, unilateralism versus multilateralism...

- Nonproliferation!
- Mr. Markey co-chairs (with Christopher Shays [R-CT]) Bipartisan Task Force on Nonproliferation
- Mainly a study group that has briefings for Members & staff
- Held briefings on dirty bombs, Iran, North Korea, Biological Weapons Convention, future of arms control, unilateralism versus multilateralism...

- Anything else?

- Follow & work on all legislation dealing with nuclear weapons, nuclear power, international nonproliferation efforts, etc
- Oversight of international nuclear issues

## That’s not physics!

- Yep... had to learn a whole bunch of new stuff...

## Had good set of teachers...

- Rep. Markey has had Fellows since 1980
- Two current Fellows
- Two one former Fellows on staff [one just left for the Center for American Progress]
- Chief of Staff has Law degree
- Legislative Director has Masters degree
- Another has MBA
*That’s rare on the Hill*
- Chief of Staff with Mr. Markey for > 12 years
- Legislative Director there for > 18 years...
*That’s unique on the Hill!*

## Had to learn new jargon

- FNAL

- HASC

**DØ**

**QED**

**Hadron TDC**

**SVX**

**SUSY**

**Tevatron**

**Level 3**

**Squark**

**CDF**

**QCD**

**Gluon**

**P5**

**C++**

**HEPAP**

**CMS**

- Inverse picobarn

- Integrated luminosity

**MDA**

**SASC**

**FAS**

**Adjourn**

**Study Group**

**NMD**

**Groups**

**DCCC**

**DTRA**

**RNEP**

**Recess**

**Move to strike the requisite number of words**

**HPAC**

**UCS**

**MLA**

**Markup**

**Rolled votes**

**Reception**

**Whip**

- OSD

**CERN**

## Started reading new journals

## Example:Nuclear Bunker Busters

- Some claim need nuclear weapons to destroy hardened & deeply buried targets or to destroy chemical & biological weapon stockpiles
- Just a few problems with that
- Nothing can penetrate deep enough have contained nuclear explosion
- 1 kiloton nuke would toss 1 million tons of radioactive debris over several square kilometers
- Doesn’t destroy chemical or biological weapons unless within ~15 feet/ton1/3; just spreads instead
- Many bunkers in densely populated areas
- Suggested weapons are 340 kT and 1 MT weapons
- Military doesn’t want the weapon!

## HPAC: 340 kT weapon on Saddam’s palace

- Typical annual dose is 0.5 rem
- 50% of people die within 30 days of a 200 rem dose

## HPAC: 5 kT weapon on Saddam’s palace

**HPAC: 5 kT weapon on Saddam’s palace**

## Bunker Busters on Floor

- Wrote sign-on letter to HASC on bunker busters
- Got 78 Members to sign (previous year’s had 40)
- Amendment to move money came to floor
- Wrote Dear Colleagues, contacted speakers, etc
- Wrote floor speech, designed props, etc
- 2002 amendment lost 172-243
- 2003 amendment lost 199-226: progress!
- 2004 amendment lost 204-214: even more progress!
- Real battle was during Energy and Water Appropriations: Subcommittee Chairman David Hobson (R-OH) zeroed funding
- After House-Senate conference the _**funding was kept at zero**_!

## After the fellowship...

- I spent a year at the Federation of American Scientists
- I co-wrote a book on science advising
- Helped FAS with Congressional outreach
- Studied nuclear weapons testing & the stockpile stewardship program
- I’ll be speaking on this topic at the April APS meeting
- I am now at AAAS, working more broadly on science & security

## Science & Security: Some History

- During the Cold War, physicists roamed the halls of power and were heard– and were very effective
- Physicists had found ways of killing people more effectively than anyone else
- Physicists also established contacts with Soviet scientists
- Track Two diplomacy
- Post-Cold War, the story is much different
- Other sciences have ‘caught up’
- Far fewer scientists *want* to speak to power
- No monolithic adversary
- Have enormous need!

## History of the Center for Science, Technology & Security Policy

- Planning Workshop at AAAS in April 2003
- Confirmed need for policy hub on S & T and security
- AAAS proposal submitted in September 2003
- Grant received in January 2004
- $2.25M over 3 years
- Part of MacArthur’s Science, Technology and Security Initiative - $50M over 6 years
- Key goals are to develop new cadres of scientists working on security policy issues and to provide useful inputs to national policy formation

## CSTSP CONCEPT

- To serve as a smart, two-way portal between the research on science and security in academic and other policy centers and the Washington policy community
- Provide objective S & T information and advice to Congress and executive branch agencies
- Coordinate efforts among academic centers
- Update centers on Washington issues
- Provide a Washington base for academic visitors
- Help place post-docs, fellows and interns into Washington policy positions
- Goal is to achieve more effective science and technology inputs into US national security policy

## UNDERSTANDING THE CSTSP UNIVERSE

- CSTSP

- Congress

- Executive Branch

- Media

- Public

- MacArthur Centers

- NGO Community

- Scientific Societies

- Other Universities

- National Security Policy

## MacArthur Funded Centers (Domestic)

- Stanford University

- Georgia Tech

- University of Illinois

- Carnegie Mellon University

- University of Maryland

- Cornell University

- University of California, San Diego

- Georgetown University

- Johns Hopkins University

- George Mason University

- George Washington University

- Princeton University

- University of California, Santa Barbara

**MacArthur Funded Centers (Domestic)**

## MacArthur Funded Centers (Int’l)

- King’s College London
- United Kingdom

- Institute of Applied Physics and Computational Mathematics, Beijing, China

- Tsinghua University, Beijing, China

- Center for Policy Studies in Russia, Moscow, Russia

- Analytical Center for Nonproliferation, Sarov, Russia

- Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Moscow, Russia

**MacArthur Funded Centers (Int’l)**

## CONGRESSIONAL ACTIVITIES

- Briefing on hafnium isomer bomb
- Briefing on nuclear waste disposal
- Located expert on flu vaccine manufacture
- Briefing on Pulsed Fast Neutron Analysis
- Briefing of House Science Committee Staff satellite export controls by UMD group
- Working on space weapons briefing series
- Studying dangers of off-shore Liquefied Natural Gas terminals
- Found experts on use of Amtrak to destroy Supreme Court
- Studying radiation portal monitors

## CONGRESSIONAL ACTIVITIES

- LANL Director Emeritus Siegfried Hecker spoke on nonproliferation

- Luncheon tutorial on lasers, especially lasers in the military

## CONGRESSIONAL ISSUES

- HOT
- Bankruptcy
- Social Security & Medicare
- Bioshield II (various bills)
- BRAC
- WARM
- Reliable Replacement Warheads
- RNEPs
- Cybersecurity
- Border Control
- Nuclear Testing
- Intelligence Reform
- Port Security
- Force Protection

- Veterans
- Budget
- Terry Schiavo
- Steroids in baseball
- Iraq
- Iran
- North Korea
- Bolton Nomination
- Missile Defense
- Space Weapons
- Expanding CTR
- Biosecurity (Frist)

## LINTON BROOKS ON RNEP (3 MARCH)

## FUTURE PLANS

- Be 1-800-SCIENCE for Congressional staff
- Define best relationship with international centers
- Expand email bulletin and website (www.aaas.org/cstsp)
- Collaborate with scientific societies
- Involve other universities doing science and security work
- Key element is to establish credibility and reputation for responsiveness and reliability

## WEEKLY EMAIL BULLETIN

- Currently 120 subscribers
- Contains upcoming science & security events in Washington, jobs, funding opportunities
- Announced >100 events, >40 grant and 40 fellowship opportunities, >40 internships and >225 jobs in 5 months
- Major news developments

## But enough about me....

- Are there other ways ***you*** can get involved?

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## Here’s a faculty job!

- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies
-  King's College London
- JOB CODE: 10691
- Lecturer or Researcher in War Studies (2-year appointment)
-  The King's College London Centre for Science & Security Studies seeks to appoint a Lecturer or Research Fellow to work on quantitative studies of science related to policy issues in the fields of national and international security. In addition to research and teaching the successful applicant will be expected to help obtain research funding and develop new research. Requirements include a PhD or equivalent terminal degree as a physical scientist (physicist preferred), mathematician or engineer, the ability to work as part of a multi-disciplinary team, as well as interest and experience in at least some of the following research areas: nuclear and biological weapons, space and space arms control, strategic arms control agreements, verification, multilateral arms control agreements. Science and security experience in government or at a major NGO is desirable, the ability to communicate scientific ideas and concepts to a non-specialist is essential. Appointment as Lecturer or as Research Associate/Fellow will depend on the candidate's qualifications and experience. For an informal discussion please contact Professor Peter Zimmerman at peter.zimmerman@kcl.ac.uk. Application forms and details can be obtained from Personnel Department, King's College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, email strand-recruitment@kcl.ac.uk fax 020 7848 1352. The closing date for receipt of applications is 31 March 2005. Please quote Reference A2/DAW/160/04. Equality of opportunity is College policy.

## You can also help me!

- We have been tasked by two Congressmen to study radiation portal monitors to see if they really can detect smuggled fissile material
- It’s unclear, as fissile material tends to be alpha-emitter, not beta or gamma...
- Also have long half-lives, so production of elements that do have more energetic decays is slow
- I am assembling a panel of experts to study the problem
- Could use a particle physicist!

## Final Thoughts...

- We really do get the government we deserve
- We, as scientists, benefit greatly from living and working in the United States
- We, as scientists, have many talents to offer
- Challenge: ***Get Involved!***
- Get to know local reporters
- Get to know your Congressperson & Senators
- Work on a campaign
- Run for elected office
- But remember, politics is a process, not an event