# Presentation: 695433

## NIST’s IPsec Web-Based Interoperability Tester (IPsec-WIT)

- Sheila Frankel
- NIST
- Computer Security Division
- sheila.frankel@nist.gov

## Motivation

- Inter-operability of multiple implementations essential for IPsec to succeed
- Existing test modalities
- Interoperability “Bake-offs”
- Pre-planned Web-based interoperability testing
- Needed: spontaneous Web-based testing

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## User-Related Objectives

- Accessible from remote locations
- Available at any time
- Require no modification to the tester’s IPsec implementation
- Allow testers to resume testing later
- Configurable
- Well-documented
- Easy to use

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Implementation Objectives

- Simultaneous access by multiple users
- Rapid, modular implementation
- Easily modified and expanded as IPsec/IKE specifications evolve
- Built around NIST’s IPsec/IKE Reference Implementations, Cerberus and PlutoPlus

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Implementation Objectives(continued)

- Require minimal changes to Cerberus and PlutoPlus
- Operator intervention not required

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## IPsec-WIT Architecture

- <date/time>

***IPsec-WIT Architecture***

## Implementation

- Perl cgi-bin tester
- HTML forms
- Executable test cases
- Output
- PlutoPlus: tracing the IKE negotiation
- Cerberus: dumping the ping packets
-  *expect* command: color-coded output

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Implementation(continued)

- Individual tester files
- Tester-specific parameters
- Tester’s individual output
- Storage and expiration

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Current Capabilities

- Key establishment: manual or                 IKE negotiation
- IKE negotiation: initiator or responder
- Peer authentication: pre-shared secrets
- ISAKMP hash: MD5 or SHA
- ISAKMP encryption: DES or 3DES
- Diffie-Hellman Exchange: First Oakley Group

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Current Capabilities(continued)

- Configurable port for IKE negotiation
- IPsec AH algorithms: HMAC-MD5 or HMAC-SHA1
- IPsec ESP algorithms:
- Encryption: DES, 3DES, IDEA, RC5, Blowfish, or ESP-Null
- Authentication (optional): HMAC-MD5 or HMAC-SHA1
- Variable key length for RC5 and Blowfish

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Current Capabilities(continued)

- IPsec encapsulation mode:              transport or tunnel
- Perfect Forward Secrecy (PFS)
- Verbosity of IKE/IPsec output configurable
- IPsec SA tested using “ping” command
- Transport-mode SA: host-to-host

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Current Capabilities(continued)

- Tunnel-mode SA:host-to-host or          host-to-gateway
- Host-to-gateway SA tests communications with tester’s host behind gateway
- Sample test cases for testers without a working IKE/IPsec implementation
- Current/cumulative test results can be viewed via browser or emailed to tester

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Limitations

- Re-keying
- Crash/disaster recovery
- Complex policy-related scenarios

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Lessons Learned

- Voluntary interoperability testing              is useful and used
- Interoperability tests can also serve as conformance tests
- Stateful protocols can be tested using a Web-based tester
- “Standard” features are more useful than “cutting edge”

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Lessons Learned(continued)

- Some human intervention is required
- Productive and informative multi-protocol interaction is challenging
- Users do the “darnedest” - and most unexpected - things

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Future Horizons - PlutoPlus

- Additional Diffie-Hellman groups
- More complex policy options
- Multiple proposals
- Adjacent SA’s
- Nested SA’s
- Peer authentication: public key
- PKI interaction and certificate exchanges

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Future Horizons - IPsec-WIT

- Test IPsec SA’s with UDP/TCP connections, rather than ICMP
- Better diagnostics from underlying protocols

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Futuristic Horizons

- Negative testing
- Robustness testing

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999

## Contact/Usage Information

- IPsec-WIT: http://ipsec-wit.antd.nist.gov
- Cerberus documentation: http://www.antd.nist.gov/cerberus
- PlutoPlus documentation:
-     http://ipsec-wit.antd.nist.gov/newipsecdoc/pluto.html
- For further information, contact:
- Sheila Frankel: sheila.frankel@nist.gov
- Rob Glenn: rob.glenn@nist.gov

- IPsec99 - Oct. 29, 1999